Woman will legally etch a man's eyes - Page 27
| Forum Index > General Forum |
|
synapse
China13814 Posts
| ||
|
Mawi
Sweden4365 Posts
if you seen the before and after pictures you wont feel bad and you will think " omg poor her no wonder she wants to do it" To answer the guy above it was mentioned that someone will help her"place her hand next to his eye so she knows where to spill the acid altho i dont know if anyone really wants to do that also as some people already mentioned its Law ,Sharia means Law People confuse middle eastern things so easy for example Allah muslims they worship the same god as Christians but they dont worship a god named Allah, "Allah" means God. | ||
|
dakalro
Romania525 Posts
On May 15 2011 00:55 Stijx wrote: Seeing the responses to this disgusting system of 'justice' really saddens me. I think this is the furthest from the correct route, the Hammurabi Code needs to stay in history classrooms. What is justice? Where is the justice in giving the criminal a place in a jail where the only thing most of them get is better training is their criminal skills, mistreatment, violence. Justice should be punishment and correction. The reality of punishment is it's more cruel that we want to think and correction is ignored by everyone. We're just lying to ourselves that our all mighty justice system is fair, which it is, in theory. But the reality is jails are a complete failure in most places. It's the difference between what the public considers should be just and the reality that nobody cares what happens to the criminals as long as they're hidden out of sight. At least those people in Iran or w/e don't lie to themselves that they're being nice to the criminals or that they're helping a criminal. Their whole system is done so that others will be deterred. Our is saying it's punishing criminals and helping them become good citizens in a non cruel way. Isn't there enough proof already that this failed. It costs too much to even hold all the criminals let alone having working programs for rehabilitation. And if ever anyone says they want to give more money to the correction system all the taxpayers jump in anger. Whenever anyone shows mistreatment in jails, all the taxpayers jump in anger. Are we so eager to just fool ourselves and pretend it's all paradise when it's common knowledge our system is a failure? Do we have the right to take the moral high ground when we've failed in our own system? True, some of the things Sharia considers as crimes are unacceptable from our point of view but for the crimes both systems recognize is theirs really that wrong? When our own reality is so much worse than what we would so love to believe. I guess it's a lot easier to turn a blind eye rather than look reality in the eye. | ||
|
zeru
8156 Posts
| ||
|
mcc
Czech Republic4646 Posts
On May 14 2011 20:39 RockIronrod wrote: Murder numbers will show which is better for preventing murder. Not what is a better society, because "better" is subjective. A tyrannical dictatorship like North Korea would have absurdly low crime rates because the masses are brainwashed. Is that a better society? That was why I put the three dots at the end of the list to convey that the list goes on. And of course when doing such comparisons you imply the disclaimer "All other things being equal". As for "better" is subjective, I do not subscribe to any moral relativism so if my defintion of "better" is valid for most (meaning nearly all) people on the planet it is objective enough for me. On May 14 2011 20:39 RockIronrod wrote: I agree. Keyword here being "I." It was bad wording on my part, yeah. Nationalistic would've been better. Ah, that makes more sense. Well that is nationalistic only if your argument for why one is better and the other is worse is based in some nationalistic feeling. If you have sensible, objective criteria I do not see the point of calling it nationalistic. It still might fit the definition, but not the intended meaning. | ||
|
teekesselchen
Germany886 Posts
Actually I don't really know about the role of vengeance in Islam? All I know is that vengeance has been forbidden by both the old and especially new testamony, means for jews and christians (even though the old testamony definition is quite racist, because it only says not to take revenge on other people of your nation...) | ||
|
Tor
Canada231 Posts
On May 15 2011 01:24 Sporadic44 wrote: lawful, humane, justice, murder; are all subjective terms. all the people stating this punishment is cruel need to wake the fuck up. people are marginalized, treated wrong, abused, every single day. to look at this one instance and take the moral high ground is absolutely preposterous. im not saying punishments and jury decisions like the one brought forward by the OP are good or even fair. the fact of the matter is things like this happen all the time. to call whats going on in iran as barbaric or uncivilized is hypocritical. civilization is a fabrication of collective society. we all have an unstated agreement that laws are some how real, or tangible in some way. people forget they're animals that have the ability to reason and imagine. maybe one day we can live in a world where pooling unfathomable amounts of resources into federal punishment (and war) wont be necessary. but in this day and age. thit is sadly not the case. think about all the people you know, what you see on the news, the things you witness when you watch the world and you'll see that instances such as this one happen around you constantly. the only way to work toward eliminating the need for such punishments is to accept that humanity is in fact, very inhumane. then you can start standing up for what you believe in your heart to be right. or you can continue to deny the fact that the world is entirely fucked up and keep posting about how criminal punishment is wrong, and that an eye for an eye is unproductive. as if your supposed moral superiority will change the world. TLDR: billions are treated wrong everyday, looking at this one case and saying the punishment is unfit would be an irrelevant view in the scope of human existence, because its a situation akin to countless others. its good to feel that this punishment is wrong, but realize the whole situation is wrong. and a microcosm for society as we know it right now. One should always take the moral high ground. Just because many things are wrong, you should accept them? | ||
|
HoldenR
Netherlands256 Posts
| ||
|
Sporadic44
United States533 Posts
On May 15 2011 01:47 Tor wrote: One should always take the moral high ground. Just because many things are wrong, you should accept them? no thats not what i am trying to say. what i mean is the moral high ground is subjective. people have different morals. its a matter of finding equality between all those places. not assuming you are more just than another individual. because in the end we're all animals looking to self preserve. we're designed that way. i'm not automatically better than you because i disagree with how you think. and i think accepting that ideal is pivotal in understanding eachother and growing as a global community. take the nazis for example, they saw themselves as morally superior. were they right in that assumption? or religion. the crusades were based on moral beliefs. and now islamic fundamentalists think they're morally superior to christians, and vica versa. who has the high ground? | ||
|
Phenny
Australia1435 Posts
"This isn't how my country works / what the law is in my country so therefore this is wrong". Or "I disagree with this because personally I think this is morally wrong and if I think it's wrong then god damnit it's wrong"? Don't get me wrong I believe Sharia law is probably the most disgusting thing in existence but in this specific case I can't help but feel it's perfectly acceptable. | ||
|
BuddhiBadougi
Germany2 Posts
1) He threw acid into her face, so nobody ever wants to look at her again forever 2) What better way is there to learn, that you shouldn't do to others, what you wouldn't want to be done to you either? I don't get the critique on "an eye for eye" and Gandhi's "the world would be blind then". If people just wouldn't do things to others, they wouldn't want to be done to themselves, how would everybody be blinded exactly? | ||
|
zeru
8156 Posts
| ||
|
Nevy
Canada169 Posts
| ||
|
Greatness
United States450 Posts
On May 15 2011 02:06 zeru wrote: So basically. What he did is completely inhumane and wrong, lets show him how wrong it was and show how to be a better human being by doing the same thing to him. I don't think i'll ever get that logic. If he doesn't know throwing acid in someones face is wrong in the first place. Good riddance, make him blind in my opinion. He's a sick individual and deserves the worst punishment. Too bad it's only at his eyes, and not his entire face. | ||
|
zeru
8156 Posts
| ||
|
HoldenR
Netherlands256 Posts
On May 15 2011 02:06 zeru wrote: So basically. What he did is completely inhumane and wrong, lets show him how wrong it was and show how to be a better human being by doing the same thing to him. I don't think i'll ever get that logic. You know how, as a child, when your mother told you not to do something dangerous because it might hurt(like holding your finger in a flame), you were more tempted to try it anyway? Then you burned your finger, depending on your age you might have cried about it, and then you never did it again. Well some people never fucking learn until they get hurt. And it's a pretty safe bet that this guy will definitely learn. | ||
|
Deadlyfish
Denmark1980 Posts
If you've just been blinded by acid thrown in your face, and disfigured completely, you would probably want whoever did that dead. This is not about teaching this dude right and wrong, it's just 100% pure justice. Yes, if you want to prevent this sort of thing from happening, and make society a better place to live then this might not be the best punishment. But if all you're looking for is justice, then it's a good one, and a straight to the point one. I do not blame the woman, and I think that that guy has to pay the consequences. It's easy to sit in your chair at home and think "what a terrible punishment, this sounds barbaric!!", but if this actually happened to you i'm sure you'd feel differently. | ||
|
Greatness
United States450 Posts
On May 15 2011 02:11 zeru wrote: Stealing is also wrong and everyone knows that, do we take all the things a person owns if they steal something? Raping is also wrong and everyone knows that, do we go and rape rapists to show them its wrong? Like i said, ill never understand that logic. Stealing is not a good example, some people steal to survive. Being a rapist is such a broad term. Maybe if both people were drunk, but the guy got charged with rape, etc. It's a bad example, unless you refer to the serial rapists, that can't control themselves, that is why, they are targeted in prison. Throwing acid, is not excusable in any situation. How are you going to punish a person like this? 5 years in jail, a fine? That's nothing, make it a lifetime punishment, as it will be a lifetime disability for her. | ||
|
zeru
8156 Posts
| ||
|
Greatness
United States450 Posts
On May 15 2011 02:25 zeru wrote: I don't see how straight up forced violent rape is less known to be wrong than throwing acid in someones face. There's no way anyone can think either one is right in any way. So what makes it right to throw acid in someones face who did that to someone, but not to rape a rapist as punishment? What in your opinion would be a better punishment? I'm all for cutting off his hands. | ||
| ||