|
On May 14 2011 23:57 RockIronrod wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 23:52 TheHova wrote:On May 14 2011 23:45 RockIronrod wrote:On May 14 2011 23:41 TheHova wrote: The path of the righteous man is beset on all sides by the inequities of the selfish and the tyranny of evil men. Blessed is he who, in the name of charity and good will, shepherds the weak through the valley of darkness, for he is truly his brother's keeper and the finder of lost children. also fuck gay people wat? Bible joke. Yes, turn the other cheek, but also women can't speak in church. Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 23:53 Blurio wrote: This is retarded. All the people that support this should imagine this situation. Dude A kills your son. You have all rights to be fucking angry at him, cause he fucked up your whole life. Now you're legally allowed to kill him. That would be an ok judgement, cause he killed your son. Duda A is 18. Now he's dead. Imagine to be in his family. Don't they have the right to kill you now? How can anyone be against things, like murder or this shit, but on the other hand support it in different circumstances? That's like saying that after each criminal serves his time in prison, the victim must also do the same.
I lol'd.
1 = 1
1 = 1 + 1 Crime
1 + 1 = 1 + 1 Justice
1 + 1 + 1 = 1 + 1 You
|
|
|
On May 14 2011 23:57 RockIronrod wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 23:53 Blurio wrote: This is retarded. All the people that support this should imagine this situation. Dude A kills your son. You have all rights to be fucking angry at him, cause he fucked up your whole life. Now you're legally allowed to kill him. That would be an ok judgement, cause he killed your son. Duda A is 18. Now he's dead. Imagine to be in his family. Don't they have the right to kill you now? How can anyone be against things, like murder or this shit, but on the other hand support it in different circumstances? That's like saying that after each criminal serves his time in prison, the victim must also do the same. The difference is a prison sentence is not the same as the crime meaning the crime and the punishment are asymmetric.
|
On May 15 2011 00:02 Bosko wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 23:24 Darksidius wrote: Awefull to see that there are actually people who support this kind of legal system... One would hope that the West has advanced since the Middle Ages, not everyone is happy with this advance it seems.
Just because the retarded legal system they have in those countries sounds to some acceptable doesn't mean that it is. (with those I mean countries that have Sharia law). This is a inhumane form of law, no matter how much people think the accused deserves the revenge.
By the way, the same law-system will hang you if you are gay, or will stone you to death if you are a woman and are raped, or will cut off your hand if you steal.
The whole law system (including this verdict) is backwards and retarded. I don't know why you would say we agree with the whole system when we're just agreeing with this one law in this one instance. If theres a car accident and someone dies, but the driver lives, we wouldn't be saying its a good idea for the driver to get hit by a car as punishment... Our "humane" forms for punishment are why there is so much crime. If people actually feared the repercussions of the crime they're planning to commit they would be more likely to either not do it, or seek mental help to prevent them from doing it. If a rapist would be brutally sodomized, in public, by his victim until she was "satisfied" don't you think there would be less rapes? As it is, they get a few years is jail, with a place warm to sleep and 3 meals a day, which by the way, all come out of your pocket as a taxpayer. Prison just isn't a good enough punishment for some crimes. What you are saying is false. There have been many studies for many decades on this topic and it always ended the same. Harsher punishment has no effect of deterring harder crimes. When maybe 200 years ago the English (I think it was them, not sure) made studies on how to more effectively tackle thiefes they realised that when people were publicly decapitated or hanged for such crimes, at the exact time the rates of those crimes rose drastically. About 25% of all inmates today are in the USA. That's more in total numbers than China. Does it make the US a safer place? I do not think so. Edit: I mean that in a sense of "is the US safer because they have more people locked up than any one else?" Just to clerify^^
By the way the Iranian authorities have put it on hold. They often get a lot of hate but there are actually a lot of people in their government and clerus who try to get away from many of the more cruel forms of punishment.
|
On May 15 2011 00:42 Barrin wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 00:37 Ancient.TL wrote: Rightfully etch ? Can't you use a better word that people know ? Agreed ever since I saw the title. I believe the appropriate word in place of 'rightfully' would be 'lawfully'. I strongly believe it should say may, and not will in the title! Can´t believe after 26 pages people still don´t see that!
|
they society is crap, their legal system is crap, this is disgusting to read
|
Maybe I'm a bit stupid but I really don't see much of a difference between these kinds of punishments and our western ones. We destroy the criminal's life all the same just that in the name of "humane" we also hide them from sight and do not do things WE consider cruel.
This when pretty much all can agree the prison system is a failure in its rehabilitation function, and not only a failure but we keep lying to ourselves that it's the right thing. It's become just a way to hide criminals out of sight and place then in an environment of violence.
In this case the court made the judgement, wasn't the victim's decision alone. Yes, some activities considered criminal there are quite weird and wrong in our society's view. But the punishments for those crimes that are recognized by us also don't seem so extreme when compared to the real prison life, not the idealized one.
|
|
|
On May 15 2011 00:26 Sotamursu wrote: Horrible punishments don't deter horrible crimes.
It is not the harshness, but the certainty, of punishments that deters crime.
If there is to be any fairness at all the victim must not be allowed to have any hand in punishing the perpetrator. There can be no greater bias than the victim's. The "eye for an eye" logic might seem fair, but it is a philosophy which can only propagate hate and violence. I understand the woman's desire for revenge, but she shouldn't be allowed to have revenge. Give her justice instead. And if she does not want justice then give her nothing at all.
|
Seeing the responses to this disgusting system of 'justice' really saddens me. I think this is the furthest from the correct route, the Hammurabi Code needs to stay in history classrooms.
|
|
|
On May 14 2011 11:28 Talin wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 11:10 Mailing wrote:On May 14 2011 11:09 Talin wrote:On May 14 2011 11:02 HowitZer wrote: An eye for an eye makes the world go blind doesn't compute. One eye for one eye and the equation is solved. There's no chaining it to the rest of the population. The victim to the victim may disagree about that (in general terms). In this specific case even, the criminal even gets to walk away after being blinded, so what if the third eye to be taken is actually the girl's life? And then the guy's life? And then the life of girl's relatives? It's not some proverbial saying people throw around. It's a FACT in societies that sported this tradition known as blood feud that many seem to be promoting here. And it can chain over several generations. If in the Nation X, murder resulted in execution 100% of the time, do you think the rate of murder would be as high? y/n? In theory, the rate of murder in such a nation would be lower. In practice, a nation running on such principles if it even existed would likely descend to anarchy or be the most perfect tyrannical state to date (either way, not a very nice place to live). In reality, execution IS murder and a state which commits the same acts that it punishes people for as a general principle isn't realistic or viable. And even if we consider only the simple theoretical consequence (that you kind of based your question around) and it would reduce the murder rate, it would STILL not be an acceptable solution. Because civilized societies do not decide policies based only on efficiency. We'd never have democracies if that was the case.
Execution (via the death penalty for serious crimes) is not the same as murder. In most legal systems murder is a form of unlawful killing of another person. There are also lawful killings like suicide, assisted suicide, the death penalty, killing in a war and defending oneself. The details depend on the legal system. But not every killing is a crime and certainly not every killing is a murder.
|
|
|
You have got to be kidding me. This is 2011. I thought we had moved past the Code of Hammurabi "justice" systems made by five-year-olds.
|
On May 14 2011 13:22 sureshot_ wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 13:01 Tor wrote:On May 14 2011 12:28 Bosu wrote:On May 14 2011 12:22 Tor wrote:On May 14 2011 12:02 Days wrote: For all you people that say an eye for an eye makes everyone blind, let's say your whole family gets slaughtered and your wife gets raped right in front of you while your children are burned alive. Then the murderers somehow are caught and put right in front of your house tied with ropes. I'd like to see how many of you will keep following Gandhi after that. Are you implying that people put in this situation would rape the criminals? Unless incited by a mob mentality I doubt many people in western culture would have it in them to kill or torture the criminals. Most likely they would ask the state to deal with them. Do people really think western law is some mystical force that makes no sense and works only to defend criminals? Do you really think perpetuating a cycle of violence and breeding conditions that force ordinary citizens to make seriously life altering decisions under extraneous circumstances is good for a society or even that citizen? Rape? Maybe not, that is a sexual punishment that many wouldn't get pleasure in doing to the people that raped and murdered your family. Killing the person that raped and murdered your family? I am confident that many people would have no problem doing that. If we were to perpetuate a culture based around retaliation I could agree with you. However in modern societies there is no way the majority could condone an open act of murder or torture regardless of what the criminal did. It would be akin to vigilantism. I personally believe that because of our current culture you would be surprised to see that most people couldn't take action against the criminal. Believe it or not, people aren't all raging psychopaths, frankly I doubt the woman who had acid splashed on her face could personally bring herself to burn her perpetrators face. And if she did, she would likely suffer serious mental anguish afterwards. In any event, your actual argument is: Because most people would react irrationally and cruelly, out of spite and hatred, it is good to be irrational and cruel. Your message is all passion and no thought. I'm confused as for where irrationality is coming from. Sure it's cruel, never is it not, but whether or not you define revenge as a rational act depends on how you define justice. An eye for an eye is just one interpretation of justice. Anger and insanity are two totally different concepts. Take street gangs for example. They're a modern concept of a diluted justice system created by the members of a collective, urban society. How do you bring to justice an opposing gang member who killed a friend of yours? Do you take him to law enforcement. No. You take matters into your own hands because you know that taking his life is the only reasonable punishment for committing such a crime. This example is the same reason why many people are so opposed to the modern prison system in the United States and so supportive of the death penalty; you're paying to house and feed the criminals of your own society.
Irrationality comes from the fact that the crime has already been dealt with. The criminal here would end up going to jail. A working deterrent has been put in place. Now all you're doing is allowing a person to torture someone for no reason beyond self gratification. While the victim may ENJOY torturing or killing the criminal, do you think it is appropriate to ENJOY killing someone? Not even Sharia law allows that. Even the guy who threw acid on her face will be sedated and the acid will be controlled.
You realize you're advocating street justice in your argument? Since when is gang justice a reasonable concept for society? All eye for an eye punishment does in gangs is create gang wars and perpetuate violence.
You need to realize that we have a court system to defend the innocent not the criminals.
By the way, it is MORE expensive to kill someone in the u.s. than to lock them away in jail for life. Do to an appeals system that slightly favors the defendant, why? Because if one innocent person is put to death than the state is responsible for murder.
|
|
|
On May 15 2011 01:08 Vain wrote:Well i first thought it was a bit harsh. Then i saw the picture. You get him girl! + Show Spoiler [Before and after] +http://www.blic.rs/data/images/2011-05-13/142020_ameneh-bahrami_hf.jpg?ver=1305285837
Oh wow No wonder she chose to do the same to him instead of a fine and prison sentence.
|
Its so retarded to mix religion with politics or laws :/
|
On May 15 2011 00:45 luckybeni2 wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 00:02 Bosko wrote:On May 14 2011 23:24 Darksidius wrote: Awefull to see that there are actually people who support this kind of legal system... One would hope that the West has advanced since the Middle Ages, not everyone is happy with this advance it seems.
Just because the retarded legal system they have in those countries sounds to some acceptable doesn't mean that it is. (with those I mean countries that have Sharia law). This is a inhumane form of law, no matter how much people think the accused deserves the revenge.
By the way, the same law-system will hang you if you are gay, or will stone you to death if you are a woman and are raped, or will cut off your hand if you steal.
The whole law system (including this verdict) is backwards and retarded. I don't know why you would say we agree with the whole system when we're just agreeing with this one law in this one instance. If theres a car accident and someone dies, but the driver lives, we wouldn't be saying its a good idea for the driver to get hit by a car as punishment... Our "humane" forms for punishment are why there is so much crime. If people actually feared the repercussions of the crime they're planning to commit they would be more likely to either not do it, or seek mental help to prevent them from doing it. If a rapist would be brutally sodomized, in public, by his victim until she was "satisfied" don't you think there would be less rapes? As it is, they get a few years is jail, with a place warm to sleep and 3 meals a day, which by the way, all come out of your pocket as a taxpayer. Prison just isn't a good enough punishment for some crimes. What you are saying is false. There have been many studies for many decades on this topic and it always ended the same. Harsher punishment has no effect of deterring harder crimes. When maybe 200 years ago the English (I think it was them, not sure) made studies on how to more effectively tackle thiefes they realised that when people were publicly decapitated or hanged for such crimes, at the exact time the rates of those crimes rose drastically. About 25% of all inmates today are in the USA. That's more in total numbers than China. Does it make the US a safer place? I do not think so. Edit: I mean that in a sense of "is the US safer because they have more people locked up than any one else?" Just to clerify^^ By the way the Iranian authorities have put it on hold. They often get a lot of hate but there are actually a lot of people in their government and clerus who try to get away from many of the more cruel forms of punishment. Stop saying "There have been many studies" If you can't post a link. If there have been so many studies, then it should be no problem to find a link. I'm not taking sides, but seriously...Just because you said it's false, doesn't mean it's false. Post a link, or don't waste your time "refuting" at all...You just make yourself look bad.
|
lawful, humane, justice, murder; are all subjective terms. all the people stating this punishment is cruel need to wake the fuck up.
people are marginalized, treated wrong, abused, every single day. to look at this one instance and take the moral high ground is absolutely preposterous. im not saying punishments and jury decisions like the one brought forward by the OP are good or even fair.
the fact of the matter is things like this happen all the time. to call whats going on in iran as barbaric or uncivilized is hypocritical. civilization is a fabrication of collective society. we all have an unstated agreement that laws are some how real, or tangible in some way. people forget they're animals that have the ability to reason and imagine.
maybe one day we can live in a world where pooling unfathomable amounts of resources into federal punishment (and war) wont be necessary. but in this day and age. thit is sadly not the case.
think about all the people you know, what you see on the news, the things you witness when you watch the world and you'll see that instances such as this one happen around you constantly. the only way to work toward eliminating the need for such punishments is to accept that humanity is in fact, very inhumane. then you can start standing up for what you believe in your heart to be right.
or you can continue to deny the fact that the world is entirely fucked up and keep posting about how criminal punishment is wrong, and that an eye for an eye is unproductive. as if your supposed moral superiority will change the world.
TLDR: billions are treated wrong everyday, looking at this one case and saying the punishment is unfit would be an irrelevant view in the scope of human existence, because its a situation akin to countless others. its good to feel that this punishment is wrong, but realize the whole situation is wrong. and a microcosm for society as we know it right now.
|
|
|
|
|
|