Woman will legally etch a man's eyes - Page 24
| Forum Index > General Forum |
|
TheAntZ
Israel6248 Posts
| ||
|
Patriot.dlk
Sweden5462 Posts
| ||
|
Darksidius
Netherlands52 Posts
Just because the retarded legal system they have in those countries sounds to some acceptable doesn't mean that it is. (with those I mean countries that have Sharia law). This is a inhumane form of law, no matter how much people think the accused deserves the revenge. By the way, the same law-system will hang you if you are gay, or will stone you to death if you are a woman and are raped, or will cut off your hand if you steal. The whole law system (including this verdict) is backwards and retarded. | ||
|
clusen
Germany8702 Posts
On May 14 2011 23:11 Snet wrote: What a wonderful thing. I am a strong supporter of bringing back hangings and the guillotine for violent criminals. If someone commits a violent crime that can be proven without a doubt to be premeditated (like rape, child abuse, beatings, murder), then they should have swift and lethal punishment. The only fault I find in this article is they are going to sedate the man beforehand. She did not have that luxury. She had the luxury of not knowing it beforehand which is an insane psychologically torture. | ||
|
ODKStevez
Ireland1225 Posts
| ||
|
Sanjuro
Indonesia252 Posts
On May 14 2011 23:24 Darksidius wrote: Awefull to see that there are actually people who support this kind of legal system... One would hope that the West has advanced since the Middle Ages, not everyone is happy with this advance it seems. Just because the retarded legal system they have in those countries sounds to some acceptable doesn't mean that it is. (with those I mean countries that have Sharia law). This is a inhumane form of law, no matter how much people think the accused deserves the revenge. By the way, the same law-system will hang you if you are gay, or will stone you to death if you are a woman and are raped, or will cut off your hand if you steal. The whole law system (including this verdict) is backwards and retarded. if it happened to you or someone you care about, and you could give a verdict on the punishment, what would it be? | ||
|
vdale
Germany1173 Posts
On May 14 2011 23:32 Sanjuro wrote: + Show Spoiler + On May 14 2011 23:24 Darksidius wrote: Awefull to see that there are actually people who support this kind of legal system... One would hope that the West has advanced since the Middle Ages, not everyone is happy with this advance it seems. Just because the retarded legal system they have in those countries sounds to some acceptable doesn't mean that it is. (with those I mean countries that have Sharia law). This is a inhumane form of law, no matter how much people think the accused deserves the revenge. By the way, the same law-system will hang you if you are gay, or will stone you to death if you are a woman and are raped, or will cut off your hand if you steal. The whole law system (including this verdict) is backwards and retarded. if it happened to you or someone you care about, and you could give a verdict on the punishment, what would it be? The good thing is that in our legal system the victims aren't the judges. | ||
|
Fleuria
England466 Posts
| ||
|
cujo2k
Canada1044 Posts
The question is, is it better to be burned and have half of your face permanetly disfigured with accompanying blindness, or is it better to be given a quick death? Either way, I don't see anything wrong with the man suffering the same fate in this case. Both of them are going to have really tough lives for a long time. | ||
|
kardinal
Sweden154 Posts
![]() vs dripping a few drops into the eye with sedatives. | ||
|
Darksidius
Netherlands52 Posts
On May 14 2011 23:32 Sanjuro wrote: + Show Spoiler + On May 14 2011 23:24 Darksidius wrote: Awefull to see that there are actually people who support this kind of legal system... One would hope that the West has advanced since the Middle Ages, not everyone is happy with this advance it seems. Just because the retarded legal system they have in those countries sounds to some acceptable doesn't mean that it is. (with those I mean countries that have Sharia law). This is a inhumane form of law, no matter how much people think the accused deserves the revenge. By the way, the same law-system will hang you if you are gay, or will stone you to death if you are a woman and are raped, or will cut off your hand if you steal. The whole law system (including this verdict) is backwards and retarded. if it happened to you or someone you care about, and you could give a verdict on the punishment, what would it be? If someone keyed my car I would like to see them hanged... does that mean that that makes it a suitable punnishment? No, it's retarded. This is retarded, no matter how awefull it is to the woman. | ||
|
mathemagician1986
Germany549 Posts
On May 14 2011 23:24 Darksidius wrote: Awefull to see that there are actually people who support this kind of legal system... One would hope that the West has advanced since the Middle Ages, not everyone is happy with this advance it seems. Just because the retarded legal system they have in those countries sounds to some acceptable doesn't mean that it is. (with those I mean countries that have Sharia law). This is a inhumane form of law, no matter how much people think the accused deserves the revenge. By the way, the same law-system will hang you if you are gay, or will stone you to death if you are a woman and are raped, or will cut off your hand if you steal. The whole law system (including this verdict) is backwards and retarded. I think it's more complicated than that. Laws come from a human's understanding of justice, and a person's understanding of justice comes from their morals. What seems backwards to us, can be totally normal for others. What seems normal for us (porn), can seem highly disgraceful to them. Who are we to say what's "right"? While I agree that this kind of "justice" should not be practised, the more interesting question is, whether there are situations where it still might be the right thing to do. The high court in Iran asked the woman repeatedly to step down from her right, but she refused. If the courts did this out of their general respect for life, it was a great thing to do. I just feel that in Iran a woman is still regarded as an inferiour being than a man, so that's why they don't want her to go through with it. If the woman on the other hand, only wants revenge, she shouldn't get it, because vengeance is not justice, as we all agree. The woman claims however, that she wants to blind the guy, so men will think twice about doing anything like this in the future, which seems a valid point, imo. So you see, blinding the guy might seem barbaric, but might improve the situation of women in Iran, and could potentionally save many women of a similar fate, while not blinding him might be seen as a sign, that men can do whatever they want to women. I think it's very difficult to decide on what should be done. | ||
|
TheHova
United Kingdom2612 Posts
| ||
|
RockIronrod
Australia1369 Posts
On May 14 2011 23:41 TheHova wrote: The path of the righteous man is beset on all sides by the inequities of the selfish and the tyranny of evil men. Blessed is he who, in the name of charity and good will, shepherds the weak through the valley of darkness, for he is truly his brother's keeper and the finder of lost children. also fuck gay people User was temp banned for this post. | ||
|
zeru
8156 Posts
| ||
|
Supamang
United States2298 Posts
On May 14 2011 23:39 mathemagician1986 wrote: I think it's more complicated than that. Laws come from a human's understanding of justice, and a person's understanding of justice comes from their morals. What seems backwards to us, can be totally normal for others. What seems normal for us (porn), can seem highly disgraceful to them. Who are we to say what's "right"? While I agree that this kind of "justice" should not be practised, the more interesting question is, whether there are situations where it still might be the right thing to do. The high court in Iran asked the woman repeatedly to step down from her right, but she refused. If the courts did this out of their general respect for life, it was a great thing to do. I just feel that in Iran a woman is still regarded as an inferiour being than a man, so that's why they don't want her to go through with it. If the woman on the other hand, only wants revenge, she shouldn't get it, because vengeance is not justice, as we all agree. The woman claims however, that she wants to blind the guy, so men will think twice about doing anything like this in the future, which seems a valid point, imo. So you see, blinding the guy might seem barbaric, but might improve the situation of women in Iran, and could potentionally save many women of a similar fate, while not blinding him might be seen as a sign, that men can do whatever they want to women. I think it's very difficult to decide on what should be done. I generally agree with you. For our societies, we have the luxury of having norms that promote equal (for the most part) and civilized treatment of men and women. To think that someone would drip acid into the eyes of another as a legal form of punishment is appalling to us. However, we also dont live in a society where a man would think so lowly of a woman that he thinks he is allowed to throw acid in her face for rejecting him (Cue the guy bringing up a random isolated case of someone doing that in a Western nation. Yea yea I know, but lets consider the general abuse of women in America as compared to in Iran). If a woman is allowed to punish the man in a roughly equal manner as he punished her, it might be a small step towards setting a precedent for gender equality over there. How is that not Justice? And people keep coming in here with their noses in the air chanting "vengeance is not justice" like its a concrete truth and its starting to annoy me. Since when were they mutually exclusive? Give me your definition of justice, then see if vengeance can fall within the same category. | ||
|
TheHova
United Kingdom2612 Posts
wat? | ||
|
Darksidius
Netherlands52 Posts
On May 14 2011 23:39 mathemagician1986 wrote: I think it's more complicated than that. Laws come from a human's understanding of justice, and a person's understanding of justice comes from their morals. What seems backwards to us, can be totally normal for others. What seems normal for us (porn), can seem highly disgraceful to them. Who are we to say what's "right"? While I agree that this kind of "justice" should not be practised, the more interesting question is, whether there are situations where it still might be the right thing to do. The high court in Iran asked the woman repeatedly to step down from her right, but she refused. If the courts did this out of their general respect for life, it was a great thing to do. I just feel that in Iran a woman is still regarded as an inferiour being than a man, so that's why they don't want her to go through with it. If the woman on the other hand, only wants revenge, she shouldn't get it, because vengeance is not justice, as we all agree. The woman claims however, that she wants to blind the guy, so men will think twice about doing anything like this in the future, which seems a valid point, imo. So you see, blinding the guy might seem barbaric, but might improve the situation of women in Iran, and could potentionally save many women of a similar fate, while not blinding him might be seen as a sign, that men can do whatever they want to women. I think it's very difficult to decide on what should be done. I disagree, there are certain clear points where you can say without a single doubt that something is backwards. A legal system based on an eye for an eye is backwards compared to ours. The fact that in some cultures that sort of thing is considered normal doen't make it any less barbaric. The fact that the crime commited was horrible doesn't make it any less barbaric. (Funny you should mention porn, making or assisting in making porn is offcourse punnishable by death in the same country) | ||
|
Blurio
Germany288 Posts
Dude A kills your son. You have all rights to be fucking angry at him, cause he fucked up your whole life. Now you're legally allowed to kill him. That would be an ok judgement, cause he killed your son. Duda A is 18. Now he's dead. Imagine to be in his family. Don't they have the right to kill you now? How can anyone be against things, like murder or this shit, but on the other hand support it in different circumstances? | ||
|
Snet
United States3573 Posts
On May 14 2011 23:53 Blurio wrote: This is retarded. All the people that support this should imagine this situation. Dude A kills your son. You have all rights to be fucking angry at him, cause he fucked up your whole life. Now you're legally allowed to kill him. That would be an ok judgement, cause he killed your son. Duda A is 18. Now he's dead. Imagine to be in his family. Don't they have the right to kill you now? How can anyone be against things, like murder or this shit, but on the other hand support it in different circumstances? No, their son was a murderous criminal. Your son was an innocent victim. | ||
| ||
![[image loading]](http://www.mediafire.com/imgbnc.php/2c28804425437e667800c035e4d40c399c09e2153d1206a3e96cefcec4f406c64g.jpg)