Woman will legally etch a man's eyes - Page 22
| Forum Index > General Forum |
|
RandomAccount#81004
Finland612 Posts
| ||
|
bigbeau
368 Posts
On May 14 2011 19:41 RockIronrod wrote: There is no objectively superior justice system, westerners should stop bragging about our "throw them in a hole and hope they're better for it" way of doing things. It's hardly rehabilitation or justice, any more than an eye for an eye system is. In some countries it's pure vengeance, the holes we throw them in being purposefully dark, dank and rapey. How is a lifetime of rectal bleeding, humiliation, assault and confinement with propagators of the aforementioned and more humane than being blinded? How is a blanket punishment for all crimes any more "fair" than custom punishments suited to each crime? How is rehabilitating a criminal any more just than punishing him? It's not, stop being elitist. That said, I disagree with Sharia law in most instances personally, including this. oh god...despite what you may have heard about jails from tv shows. there is a lot less 'rectal bleeding' than you might think. obviously, it happens but generally you let someone do it to you as 'protection' and thats in the type of high security jail with murderers, which is not what every type of jail is full of. i do agree with some of your points though, and i think our justice system (U.S.) is far from perfect. however, i disagree with the notion that a punishment is to create justice, thats silly and brings up the problem of 'What is justice?' in my mind the sole purpose of a punishment or legal system is to punish crime. the sole purpose of laws is to lay out rules that are to be followed within your specific society. now whether, there is a purpose to prevent future crime is debatable. for example, if a rapist is arrested, sentenced to x amount of years but it is probable that he will rape again. does that mean he should never be let out? or should he just be punished for his crime and that is it? | ||
|
Ropid
Germany3557 Posts
| ||
|
zalz
Netherlands3704 Posts
Your subscription to the belief in "false rape" cases, as if such a thing exists on any scope that needs to be taken seriously. As if "women in the west" all keep a false-rape accusation in the back of their hand, just in case. | ||
|
Cifer
United Kingdom69 Posts
On May 14 2011 19:45 zalz wrote: I think this is by far one of the most offensive things i have seen posted on these forums. ------------- You appeared confused about my statement and i clarified them. Why would you call that a scew-up? I think it would be more appropriate to simply call it what it was, me clarifying an earlier statement. I believe i was very clear in explaining it and never did i make any suggestion that what i said before that was wrong. It was lacking in scope as i said. If i say this is sand and you say, no it's a beach, i am not wrong, i am simply lacking in scope. Your refusal to debate the points you cannot adress will be taken as they always are on the internet, an inabilty to debate them. Is there an anti-ax handle movement? Is there an international group dedicated saving ax handle victims? Are there hundreds of cases where men use ax handles in their atacks? No there is not. Acid-throwing is prevalent and often repeated. It isn't an isolated event, it's an often occuring event. Violence against women is present in every society but even then it differs in degrees. I think you are not taking the plight of muslim women seriously when you try to compare the USA to a country like Pakistan. You will always have thieves, you will always have murderers and you will always have people that engage in violence against women that they feel have wronged them. You cannot create a society in wich that never occurs. But to compare a country like the USA to a country like Pakistan and say the problems are on an equall scale is making light of the suffering of women in these regions. Acid-throwing is a very real thing. It's not a solitary event. This guy didn't just happen to have acid with him. It has been going on for a lot of years now and it's even on the rise in certain countries like Pakistan. This wasn't just a case of violence where acid happened to be the weapon. This was a case of acid throwing. I find it odd that you would once again focus on islam. My entire last post was that these events are grounded in a society having a low regard for women. I followed that up by saying that islamic culture in the middle-east has a very low regard of women and often treats them as inferior to men. The foundation of this problem is discrimination against women. Islam is but one of the many different vehicles in wich such concepts can spread across a nation. A 2003 report on acid atacks in Cambodia marks discrimination against women as one of the major contributing factors: http://www.licadho-cambodia.org/reports/files/41acid report English.pdf You might be suprised at just how much attention goes out to this phenomena. Do you see how many people take this very seriously? They don't disregard it as "just an event" but view it for what it is, a serious problem that can grow if not adressed properly. Read that part. So no Cambodia is not "just an exception" just like these acid atacks aren't just "exceptions". It all gets adressed in the report. The answer in this case is that you simply are wrong. These actions are a result of a general hatred towards women. Knife slashing isn't wide-spread like acid throwing. I urge you to stop making light of this problem by constantly comparing it to other events that have no following. By the same logic countries with lot of gun shootings such as the U.S. can be attributed that culture being inherently corrupt...yes? Also did you even read the thing you linked, didnt say anything about islamic culture anywhere, you keep jumping to different points everytime one of your arguments is shot down. | ||
|
Ghazwan
Netherlands444 Posts
I find it odd that you would once again focus on islam. . I am not the one focusing on Islam. Quite the contrary, I have been saying that Islamic law and culture has nothing in it that promotes acid-throwing to women. So, I disagree with you bringing up the issue of women in Islam in a discussion about an acid-throwing case. You are the one that keeps mentioning Islam after every argument as a basis for acid-throwing, just like: My entire last post was that these events are grounded in a society having a low regard for women. I followed that up by saying that islamic culture in the middle-east has a very low regard of women and often treats them as inferior to men. The list of countries where acid-throwing is a common form of assault against women according to the wiki page you linked is : Cambodia, Afghanistan, India, Bangladesh, Pakistan Yet, you felt it necessary to mention the low regard for women in the Middle East. Do you even know where Middle-East is? None of the countries on that list are in the Middle East. So, what does this have to do with low regard of women in the Middle East? I'll quote Cifer on this, as he put what I am trying to say in a much blunt and clear way: The way you argue you just weave random crap to blame the islamic culture with no factual relevance. | ||
|
RockIronrod
Australia1369 Posts
On May 14 2011 19:52 bigbeau wrote: oh god...despite what you may have heard about jails from tv shows. there is a lot less 'rectal bleeding' than you might think. obviously, it happens but generally you let someone do it to you as 'protection' and thats in the type of high security jail with murderers, which is not what every type of jail is full of. http://forums.somethingawful.com/showthread.php?threadid=3331921 It was linked earlier. Despite what everyone tells you about TV being all bullshit, some of it is based on fact. The rape going on in prison is one of those cases, and it's a serious subject getting ignored because man-on-man rape is fucking hilarious apparently. On May 14 2011 19:52 bigbeau wrote: i do agree with some of your points though, and i think our justice system (U.S.) is far from perfect. however, i disagree with the notion that a punishment is to create justice, thats silly and brings up the problem of 'What is justice?' in my mind the sole purpose of a punishment or legal system is to punish crime. the sole purpose of laws is to lay out rules that are to be followed within your specific society. now whether, there is a purpose to prevent future crime is debatable. for example, if a rapist is arrested, sentenced to x amount of years but it is probable that he will rape again. does that mean he should never be let out? or should he just be punished for his crime and that is it? Good, disagree with it. That's fine and I, for the most part, agree with you. What I don't agree with is blanket statements of "My society is just and right and yours is barbaric and wrong for not being like mine." | ||
|
zalz
Netherlands3704 Posts
On May 14 2011 19:54 Ropid wrote: @zalz: I see that acid-throwing more like a regional phenomenon than Muslim. It basically is India plus countries around India. India is 80 % Hindu and has a population of over one billion people. All the other countries with that problem are much smaller. I adressed this in one of my posts. The suggestion that islam is soley to blame was detailed enough. I believe these acid atacks are a result of an entire culture having a low view of women. The discrimination against women is the #1 cause. I believe a disregard for women spreads in ideas like islam, allowing such things as acid atacks to follow. But a low regard of women can ofcourse also exist without islam but i think we should be honest in adressing the position of women in islam and recognize that it isn't very good. I think islamic culture isn't without discrimination of women and as a result, acid atacks. | ||
|
zalz
Netherlands3704 Posts
I am not the one focusing on Islam. Quite the contrary, I have been saying that Islamic law and culture has nothing in it that promotes acid-throwing to women. So, I disagree with you bringing up the issue of women in Islam in a discussion about an acid-throwing case. You are the one that keeps mentioning Islam after every argument as a basis for acid-throwing, just like: Islam as a basis for the discrimination against women and from that, acid atacks. The list of countries where acid-throwing is a common form of assault against women according to the wiki page you linked is : Cambodia, Afghanistan, India, Bangladesh, Pakistan Yet, you felt it necessary to mention the low regard for women in the Middle East. Do you even know where Middle-East is? None of the countries on that list are in the Middle East. So, what does this have to do with low regard of women in the Middle East? Have you allready forgotten what this topic is about? This event has taken place in Iran. To put this in your words: "Do you even know where Iran is?" I shall spoil the answer, it is the middle-east. I'll quote Cifer on this, as he put what I am trying to say in a much blunt and clear way: You really shouldn't have quoted him. I have actually provided several factual backings for my posts, yet you haven't provided any backing on your posts. You believe it isn't so and therefore, it is not so. You haven't provided any evidence that would suggest otherwise whilst i have done exactly that. I have been using facts in my posts whilst yours have been fully occupied with your opinion. You shouldn't quote people that put it "blunt" but don't actually take my posts into account. | ||
|
Ghazwan
Netherlands444 Posts
On May 14 2011 20:05 zalz wrote: i think we should be honest in adressing the position of women in islam and recognize that it isn't very good. I think islamic culture isn't without discrimination of women and as a result, acid atacks. Thanks for finally making your agenda clear. You just wanted to criticize the position of women in Islam. Unless of course you really want us to agree with the argument that "acid-attacks happen in a variety of countries, including Cambodia and India where the majority of the population isn't even Muslim, yet I believe low regard for women in Islam is a primary reason for acid-attacks." I am sorry to say but that doesn't make any sense. Have you allready forgotten what this topic is about? This event has taken place in Iran. To put this in your words: "Do you even know where Iran is?" I shall spoil the answer, it is the middle-east. Wiki you linked is clear that it is most common in India and nearby countries. So, yeah, your mention of the middle east still is irrelevant. | ||
|
Cifer
United Kingdom69 Posts
On May 14 2011 20:05 zalz wrote: I adressed this in one of my posts. The suggestion that islam is soley to blame was detailed enough. I believe these acid atacks are a result of an entire culture having a low view of women. The discrimination against women is the #1 cause. I believe a disregard for women spreads in ideas like islam, allowing such things as acid atacks to follow. But a low regard of women can ofcourse also exist without islam but i think we should be honest in adressing the position of women in islam and recognize that it isn't very good. I think islamic culture isn't without discrimination of women and as a result, acid atacks. I'm going now show you how dumb that post was, but this time if we were talking about a rape case a western country: I believe these I believe a disregard for women spreads in ideas like But a low regard of women can ofcourse also exist without | ||
|
vetinari
Australia602 Posts
On May 14 2011 19:59 zalz wrote: Your subscription to the belief in "false rape" cases, as if such a thing exists on any scope that needs to be taken seriously. As if "women in the west" all keep a false-rape accusation in the back of their hand, just in case. Uh, false rape accusations are at least 8% of the total, according to the FBI, and that does not include cases where the accusation is withdrawn. Needless to say, including cases where the accusation is withdrawn is highly likely to increase the total proportion of false rape accusations. Repeat: of the cases that resulted in a trial, in 8% of them, the accusation was false. If at least 8% of rape cases are "insignificant" then so is murder, which is much less than 8% of annual deaths. | ||
|
HellRoxYa
Sweden1614 Posts
On May 14 2011 19:59 zalz wrote: Your subscription to the belief in "false rape" cases, as if such a thing exists on any scope that needs to be taken seriously. As if "women in the west" all keep a false-rape accusation in the back of their hand, just in case. Your disbelief in "false rape" cases doesn't mean it doesn't happen. http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,194032,00.html Feel free to open up google and search for more if you want. This was just the first credible article that popped up. And it's definently not the first time I read about it in a major publication. | ||
|
Ropid
Germany3557 Posts
On May 14 2011 20:05 zalz wrote: I adressed this in one of my posts. The suggestion that islam is soley to blame was detailed enough. I believe these acid atacks are a result of an entire culture having a low view of women. The discrimination against women is the #1 cause. I believe a disregard for women spreads in ideas like islam, allowing such things as acid atacks to follow. But a low regard of women can ofcourse also exist without islam but i think we should be honest in adressing the position of women in islam and recognize that it isn't very good. I think islamic culture isn't without discrimination of women and as a result, acid atacks. I agree the problem comes from a low view of women. I imagine this makes it possible to not feel empathy for a female victim as a man, despite being of sound mind and not insane. But problems like this also seem to be everywhere else. There are for example crazy rape statistics in South Africa. I feel it would be more helpful to generally address the idea of women kinda having a subhuman standing in the mind of men in cultures all around the world. Putting energy in singling out Muslims is a bit wasteful and has the chance to piss people off and being harmful to the cause. | ||
|
Fenrax
United States5018 Posts
| ||
|
mcc
Czech Republic4646 Posts
On May 14 2011 19:41 RockIronrod wrote: There is no objectively superior justice system, westerners should stop bragging about our "throw them in a hole and hope they're better for it" way of doing things. It's hardly rehabilitation or justice, any more than an eye for an eye system is. In some countries it's pure vengeance, the holes we throw them in being purposefully dark, dank and rapey. How is a lifetime of rectal bleeding, humiliation, assault and confinement with propagators of the aforementioned and more humane than being blinded? How is a blanket punishment for all crimes any more "fair" than custom punishments suited to each crime? How is rehabilitating a criminal any more just than punishing him? It's not, stop being elitist. That said, I disagree with Sharia law in most instances personally, including this. Actually it is very easy to say sometimes which society is better. If one society has less murders, less rapes, less assaults, .... it is better. It is theoretically possible to say which justice system is better, it is just hard in practice. If you could show that one system leads to lower number of murders, .... ,lower recidivity and has lower number of judicial errors that system would be better. Problem is accounting for all other variables that can have influence on those numbers, that is why I only said it is theoretically possible. But that does not prevent us from having strong indicators about which system is better. Also your examples of mistreatment in prisons are highly US based. US prison system is quite terrible for a 1st world country. But there are countries that limit that mistreatment to much lower amount. If it is possible to rehabilitate a criminal it is pretty clearly better than not to do so as he will not commit any more crimes, he will become productive member of society and society will not have to pay for his future crimes. Of course depends on the cost of rehabilitation and if it is in fact even possible (often it is not). Yes I am elitist and I do not intend to stop. I always wonder why people think labeling someone as elitist is automatically an insult. You are also an elitist, or when you are sick do you go to a butcher instead of a doctor, do you think uneducated people should be allowed to build nuclear power plants ? | ||
|
Mawi
Sweden4365 Posts
| ||
|
Gatsbi
United States1134 Posts
| ||
|
Ropid
Germany3557 Posts
| ||
|
vetinari
Australia602 Posts
On May 14 2011 20:37 Ropid wrote: I guess it is because of car batteries. Nowadays, I only know car batteries that are not supposed to be opened, but before that car batteries could be opened and the acid replaced to repair them instead of throwing them out when they got old. That too. | ||
| ||