The leniency towards criminals that the legal system has developed for the sole purpose of protecting human rights (which I'm not against) seems a bit excessive IMO. I completely agree with the choice of that woman, and wish that the fear of receiving a similar punishment will prevent people from incurring in similar offences in the future.
Woman will legally etch a man's eyes - Page 21
| Forum Index > General Forum |
|
Cr4zyH0r5e
Peru1308 Posts
The leniency towards criminals that the legal system has developed for the sole purpose of protecting human rights (which I'm not against) seems a bit excessive IMO. I completely agree with the choice of that woman, and wish that the fear of receiving a similar punishment will prevent people from incurring in similar offences in the future. | ||
|
Stroggoz
New Zealand79 Posts
| ||
|
Wrath 2.1
Germany880 Posts
| ||
|
emythrel
United Kingdom2599 Posts
On May 14 2011 08:55 Derez wrote: This pretty much proves why victims shouldn't have any say in the punishment of an offender. 'An eye for an eye' isn't justice, it's just retribution. And thats exactly why victims shouldn't ever be asked to speak at parole hearings or the like (except the main trial for giving evidence), a victim can not be an impartial judge of a crime or punshiment. | ||
|
vetinari
Australia602 Posts
On May 14 2011 18:56 Cr4zyH0r5e wrote: Make the punishment harsh enough and no one will commit the offense. The leniency towards criminals that the legal system has developed for the sole purpose of protecting human rights (which I'm not against) seems a bit excessive IMO. I completely agree with the choice of that woman, and wish that the fear of receiving a similar punishment will prevent people from incurring in similar offences in the future. Thats rubbish. There is a reason why "crimes of passion" exist. They will occur no matter how harsh the punishment, because by definition, people aren't actually thinking at all while they commit them. I am only replying to your first sentence, FYI. | ||
|
EmeraldSparks
United States1451 Posts
On May 14 2011 18:56 Cr4zyH0r5e wrote: Make the punishment harsh enough and no one will commit the offense. In the Middle Ages, criminals could be executed by having every single bone in their bodies broken on the wheel with iron hammers and left to die of shock or dehydration over the course of days, and people still committed crimes. I guess they just weren't being "harsh enough." I bet you could make that sort of stuff last weeks, or maybe you could just keep piling on even more unpleasant things. For example, maybe you could sodomize him with a steel bar while force-feeding him his own castrated genitals and have him eaten alive by starving dogs after a day of leaving him out to dry. | ||
|
tyCe
Australia2542 Posts
On May 14 2011 08:55 Derez wrote: This pretty much proves why victims shouldn't have any say in the punishment of an offender. 'An eye for an eye' isn't justice, it's just retribution. You mean like murdering Osama Bin Laden? | ||
|
ULTRAmarine
Sweden47 Posts
i can't disagree with her will for vengeance but such a legal system is obviously dangerous, thus flawed. much surprise, perhaps not. | ||
|
jinnyjinn
United States38 Posts
| ||
|
Ryndika
1489 Posts
On May 14 2011 09:04 aimaimaim wrote: No amount of Civil Justice can bring back what was destroyed by this crazy asshole. Try putting yourself in the woman's position and see if you can just let this man pass after what he has did to you. Also, this will be an example to those other crazy bastards out there. Now, they have to think first before doing something retarded like this. And no amount of pain can bring back what was destroyed by this crazy asshole. In womans situation I would consider killing him but that doesn't mean its necesary or ethical nor does it bring any benefit. I don't think example is going to help much, actually it promotes this kind of barbaric acting. If you were to kill someone or do such things you are in fiercy mode and do not think about 'hmm.. wait a second I consider how many years I'm going to get from doing this'.. If you are not in fiercy mode you are psycopath or serial killer most likely. | ||
|
Cifer
United Kingdom69 Posts
On May 14 2011 18:27 zalz wrote: I think refuting is overstating it. I would argue that my comment was lacking in scope. An utter disregard for the position of women, of wich islamic culture is filled. The anti-feminism within islamic culture creates an environment where such extreme actions can take hold and spread. Nobody is saying that all muslims are throwing acid in people's faces but it doesn't exactly have to be a majority for it to be a problem. I don't think the victims of these atacks will sleep any better when you tell them that there are only several hundred atacks like this each year. The victims are pretty much always female. The hatred for women is very clear in this act. It's not just a violent act that anyone will use, it's the result of cultures that consider women inferior. So the problem is cultures that consider women lower then men and since Islam in the middle-east generally favors that, i consider it responsible. So you somehow know without a doubt that this is hate crime against women? or you're saying any crime against women in that country is hate crime because its muslim? How is this not generalisation... The way argue you just weave random crap to blame the islamic culture with no factual relevence. What if the same crime happened in the U.S. (I bet you it has)?, guess what you wouldnt blame islam...and that my friend is the epitome of bigotry. Also even if you are correct in saying that its prodominant theme in islamic countries (its not, i have lived in many islamic countries with not even hearing of such incident) even that doesnt give you the right to attribute it to islam, since most aspects in those cultures are actually not religous but social. | ||
|
nOia.pod
Hungary263 Posts
On May 14 2011 18:51 KaiserJohan wrote: Right, I'm fairly sure their prison system probably is not as nice as you think. Still. Is it justice to lock up somebody for being a huge dick and destroy somebody's life? Is it ENOUGH punishment? Would you say the same if you or somebody close to you would be the victim? | ||
|
W2
United States1177 Posts
This way, everyone wins. The woman gets satisfaction from her retribution, nobody gets harmed, and the cover-up acts still acts as a deterrent. | ||
|
RockIronrod
Australia1369 Posts
How is a lifetime of rectal bleeding, humiliation, assault and confinement with propagators of the aforementioned and more humane than being blinded? How is a blanket punishment for all crimes any more "fair" than custom punishments suited to each crime? How is rehabilitating a criminal any more just than punishing him? It's not, stop being elitist. That said, I disagree with Sharia law in most instances personally, including this. | ||
|
RockIronrod
Australia1369 Posts
On May 14 2011 19:39 W2 wrote: If I were one of the assistants at the "etching retribution" I would switcheroo the acid with water, tell the offender to fake it, and once it all blows over, send him overseas where my friend will give him a job while keeping an eye on him for misbehavior. This way, everyone wins. The woman gets satisfaction from her retribution, nobody gets harmed, and the cover-up acts still acts as a deterrent. And a criminal goes rewarded for throwing acid in peoples faces. I think you're too blinded by bias against the people defending the punishments to realise HE THREW ACID IN SOMEONES FACE FOR SHITS AND GIGGLES. | ||
|
nOia.pod
Hungary263 Posts
Check those pics, and think about again. Those women are fucked for their entire life, because some random guy cannot control his brutality and cannot think racionally. | ||
|
zalz
Netherlands3704 Posts
Of course the victim's almost always female. Spurned lovers that turn to violence are almost always male, no matter the country. Especially in western countries, as a matter of fact, since women in civilised lands have different ways to exact vengeance (aka the false rape accusation.) I think this is by far one of the most offensive things i have seen posted on these forums. ------------- @ Zalz I am not gonna argue with all the points in your last post as you are now deflecting from your initial screw-up in reasoning. You appeared confused about my statement and i clarified them. Why would you call that a scew-up? I think it would be more appropriate to simply call it what it was, me clarifying an earlier statement. I believe i was very clear in explaining it and never did i make any suggestion that what i said before that was wrong. It was lacking in scope as i said. If i say this is sand and you say, no it's a beach, i am not wrong, i am simply lacking in scope. Your refusal to debate the points you cannot adress will be taken as they always are on the internet, an inabilty to debate them. So an assault on a woman in a Muslim country signals a deep sociological problem for which the religion of that country is responsible, yet the attacks on women in other countries (like the assault on a woman by an ax handle in US I linked in my first post) is what exactly? Just moments of rage? You are being subjective and seeing what you want to see. Is there an anti-ax handle movement? Is there an international group dedicated saving ax handle victims? Are there hundreds of cases where men use ax handles in their atacks? No there is not. Acid-throwing is prevalent and often repeated. It isn't an isolated event, it's an often occuring event. Violence against women is present in every society but even then it differs in degrees. I think you are not taking the plight of muslim women seriously when you try to compare the USA to a country like Pakistan. You will always have thieves, you will always have murderers and you will always have people that engage in violence against women that they feel have wronged them. You cannot create a society in wich that never occurs. But to compare a country like the USA to a country like Pakistan and say the problems are on an equall scale is making light of the suffering of women in these regions. Acid-throwing is a very real thing. It's not a solitary event. This guy didn't just happen to have acid with him. It has been going on for a lot of years now and it's even on the rise in certain countries like Pakistan. This wasn't just a case of violence where acid happened to be the weapon. This was a case of acid throwing. The wiki page lists Cambodia as one of the countries where acid attacks are common. Yet, Cambodia is majority Buddhist with Muslim and Christian minority. So, Cambodia is just an exception then? I find it odd that you would once again focus on islam. My entire last post was that these events are grounded in a society having a low regard for women. I followed that up by saying that islamic culture in the middle-east has a very low regard of women and often treats them as inferior to men. The foundation of this problem is discrimination against women. Islam is but one of the many different vehicles in wich such concepts can spread across a nation. A 2003 report on acid atacks in Cambodia marks discrimination against women as one of the major contributing factors: http://www.licadho-cambodia.org/reports/files/41acid report English.pdf You might be suprised at just how much attention goes out to this phenomena. Do you see how many people take this very seriously? They don't disregard it as "just an event" but view it for what it is, a serious problem that can grow if not adressed properly. How big is the problem, and why does it happen? Read that part. So no Cambodia is not "just an exception" just like these acid atacks aren't just "exceptions". Once again you are seeing what you want to see. Disfiguring a woman's face is nothing special for Islam nor for this geography. There are quite many cases where a man knifed or slashed a woman's face in the West. (just google, an example: http://daily-journal.com/archives/dj/display.php?id=473130) The motive for these disgusting acts is simply to take away the beauty of a woman and does not necessarily indicate a general hatred towards women in that culture. It all gets adressed in the report. The answer in this case is that you simply are wrong. These actions are a result of a general hatred towards women. Knife slashing isn't wide-spread like acid throwing. I urge you to stop making light of this problem by constantly comparing it to other events that have no following. | ||
|
KinosJourney2
Sweden1811 Posts
On May 14 2011 08:59 1Eris1 wrote: Good. Permananetely crippling someones body does not equal=an assualt or whatever's worth of time in prison I agree, anyone throwing fucking acid on someone and destroys their face should get either a similar punishment or death penalty. What if someone threw acid in your face and made you look like her? Basically he ruined her life for no reason at all. He should be happy that he'll get sedated to begin with. | ||
|
vetinari
Australia602 Posts
On May 14 2011 19:45 zalz wrote: I think this is by far one of the most offensive things i have seen posted on these forums. ------------- Facts are offensive? | ||
|
Kinshuk
India116 Posts
On May 14 2011 19:09 EmeraldSparks wrote: In the Middle Ages, criminals could be executed by having every single bone in their bodies broken on the wheel with iron hammers and left to die of shock or dehydration over the course of days, and people still committed crimes. I guess they just weren't being "harsh enough." I bet you could make that sort of stuff last weeks, or maybe you could just keep piling on even more unpleasant things. For example, maybe you could sodomize him with a steel bar while force-feeding him his own castrated genitals and have him eaten alive by starving dogs after a day of leaving him out to dry. Thats some scary imagination you got there | ||
| ||