1/ just revenge and retribution 2/ but also punishment that is directly proportional to the crime
While 1/ is cleraly not a good part of a justice system 2/ is a great part of a deterrent justice system, it makes for a harsh justice; but in a country that is rife with crime it's probably the appropriate policy, as reducing crime rates becomes more important than reintegrating the criminals. The proportionality of a punishment to a crime is extremely important for instance in my country, corruption is thriving, because the corrupted get bribed 1 000 000 and then, IF they get caught they have to pay a fine of something like 200 000; so it works more like a corruption tax than a punishment - a justice system gone wrong.
On May 14 2011 15:17 mathershop wrote: People who just blindly assume that eye for an eye is a good way to deal with criminals don't even remotely think about its complications. In such a system a person who murdered in the heat of the moment (aka 3rd degree murder/manslaughter in Canada) will have to be punished by a capital punishment. Is this justified? What about euthanasia? a doctor who assisted someone with painless suicide to end suffering of a terminal disease? is the doctor needs to be punished in the way he committed the murder? There are prisons for a reason, the main one is to institutionalize the criminals for correctional purposes. If you don't give a chance for a person to improve upon his crimes you will have the most tyrannical government.
No one argued that this rule should be general, nor do I think it is in Iran. We are talking about this specific case, In which it is probably not in the heat of the moment and has nothing to do with euthanasia. Not that im saying that its right, but I can respect the opinions of people who do.
It is still a precedent which makes it wrong
I can't see how this can be a precedent for euthanasia?! Its in completely different circumstances.
precendent for similar cases in which the punishment might not be justifiable My point is that letting your emotions affect your decision in legal cases is not the most civilized and correct way to do it.
Yeah but you used euthanasia as an example. Being used as a precedent is a completely different issue, as it will come down to how the system uses it. If thats the case about emotion then no one is civilised since, in countries with jury systems the lawyers main goal is for them to gain sympathy with their client. Emotion being used in law is inevitable, we are humans after all. I don't agree that we have to be robots in order to be civilized. And I don't think there is such a thing as one "Correct way" to do it, and if there is then we will never be able to achieve it.
My example of euthanasia was related to the topic of eye for an eye and tooth for a tooth type of punishments in general, not for this case specifically. The jury's job is to provide the general public opinion of the "standard reasonable man" not the "emotional sympathetic man". And no, lawyers don't rely on emotion when they work on criminal cases, they rely on evidence and the positive law. There is a "Correct way" however, the law is not static as you assume it is, it's a "chain novel", it's a work in progress. I didn't say that we will be able to achieve the best correct way but some ways are better than others and every civilized legal system striving for improvement.
What you're saying is how it should be, not what happens in practice. You say its better, which it could be, but you have provided no valid argument to suggest that relating to this specific case.
On May 14 2011 15:17 mathershop wrote: People who just blindly assume that eye for an eye is a good way to deal with criminals don't even remotely think about its complications. In such a system a person who murdered in the heat of the moment (aka 3rd degree murder/manslaughter in Canada) will have to be punished by a capital punishment. Is this justified? What about euthanasia? a doctor who assisted someone with painless suicide to end suffering of a terminal disease? is the doctor needs to be punished in the way he committed the murder? There are prisons for a reason, the main one is to institutionalize the criminals for correctional purposes. If you don't give a chance for a person to improve upon his crimes you will have the most tyrannical government.
No one argued that this rule should be general, nor do I think it is in Iran. We are talking about this specific case, In which it is probably not in the heat of the moment and has nothing to do with euthanasia. Not that im saying that its right, but I can respect the opinions of people who do.
It is still a precedent which makes it wrong
I can't see how this can be a precedent for euthanasia?! Its in completely different circumstances.
precendent for similar cases in which the punishment might not be justifiable My point is that letting your emotions affect your decision in legal cases is not the most civilized and correct way to do it.
Yeah but you used euthanasia as an example. Being used as a precedent is a completely different issue, as it will come down to how the system uses it. If thats the case about emotion then no one is civilised since, in countries with jury systems the lawyers main goal is for them to gain sympathy with their client. Emotion being used in law is inevitable, we are humans after all. I don't agree that we have to be robots in order to be civilized. And I don't think there is such a thing as one "Correct way" to do it, and if there is then we will never be able to achieve it.
My example of euthanasia was related to the topic of eye for an eye and tooth for a tooth type of punishments in general, not for this case specifically. The jury's job is to provide the general public opinion of the "standard reasonable man" not the "emotional sympathetic man". And no, lawyers don't rely on emotion when they work on criminal cases, they rely on evidence and the positive law. There is a "Correct way" however, the law is not static as you assume it is, it's a "chain novel", it's a work in progress. I didn't say that we will be able to achieve the best correct way but some ways are better than others and every civilized legal system striving for improvement.
What you're saying is how it should be, not what happens in practice. You say its better, which it could be, but you have provided no valid argument to suggest that relating to this specific case.
I am saying exactly what happens in practice in western societies. I can guarantee you that if this case was taking place in north america, nobody would have thought about melting the guys' face with acid during the trial.
On May 14 2011 15:50 Daimai wrote: This makes me happy. Good for her, hope she enjoys and savors it
She got acid thrown in her face because off a culture drenched in Islamic tradition and sharia law.
You can call it justice (i would not) that she can now dump acid in his eyes via sharia law but had she been born in a civilised country she wouldn't have gotten acid in her face in the first place.
The islamic culture is what contributed to her situation in the first place. To then make use of it for revenge and call it good seems strange at best. The culture of "women are property" is what got her in this mess in the first place.
In the end it's not right, it's not justice and it's not as it should be. The middle-east should strive for a world where this doesn't happen in the first place. Not rejoice in barbaric revenge for a barbaric act.
Also, how do you distinguish punishment from revenge? isn't throwing someone away in jail for the rest of their lives revenge?
The purpose of prison is, and should not be revenge. It should be keeping dangerous people. Off the streets. After they have committed a crime. Can't exactly jail them before the fact.
That's factually incorrect, if its just a form of containment that we should see more life sentences, why would you let a dangerous person back out? and why should the time scale with the crime? It's because they have done their "punishment" regardless of you truly think they have rehabilitated or not.
Why is it uncivilised or barbaric to do back to him what he did to her, just because that's not how we run things in our civilised society? Is this not merely a logical consequence for his actions?
Personally I have no problem whatsoever with revenge or retribution.
On May 14 2011 16:36 Phenny wrote: Why is it uncivilised or barbaric to do back to him what he did to her, just because that's not how we run things in our civilised society? Is this not merely a logical consequence for his actions?
Personally I have no problem whatsoever with revenge or retribution.
It is barbaric because it's the most primitive and ancient solution to this case. Cutting thief's hand for stealing bread is logical as well, not ethical.
On May 14 2011 15:50 Daimai wrote: This makes me happy. Good for her, hope she enjoys and savors it
She got acid thrown in her face because off a culture drenched in Islamic tradition and sharia law.
You can call it justice (i would not) that she can now dump acid in his eyes via sharia law but had she been born in a civilised country she wouldn't have gotten acid in her face in the first place.
The islamic culture is what contributed to her situation in the first place. To then make use of it for revenge and call it good seems strange at best. The culture of "women are property" is what got her in this mess in the first place.
In the end it's not right, it's not justice and it's not as it should be. The middle-east should strive for a world where this doesn't happen in the first place. Not rejoice in barbaric revenge for a barbaric act.
Crimes happen everywhere, you are definitely assuming too much here. There is no acid throwing culture rituals as far as I know. And if there was they thought it was right, wouldn't be punishing it. If anything this is women empowerment to an extreme. You are just plugging in your opinion on a completely unrelated matter here.
On May 14 2011 15:50 Daimai wrote: This makes me happy. Good for her, hope she enjoys and savors it
She got acid thrown in her face because off a culture drenched in Islamic tradition and sharia law.
You can call it justice (i would not) that she can now dump acid in his eyes via sharia law but had she been born in a civilised country she wouldn't have gotten acid in her face in the first place.
The islamic culture is what contributed to her situation in the first place. To then make use of it for revenge and call it good seems strange at best. The culture of "women are property" is what got her in this mess in the first place.
In the end it's not right, it's not justice and it's not as it should be. The middle-east should strive for a world where this doesn't happen in the first place. Not rejoice in barbaric revenge for a barbaric act.
God..Look at what Wilders is doing to this country....
There is absolutely nothing in Islamic culture that justifies a man throwing acid to a woman's face. Stop trying to look for reasons to blame everything wrong on Islam.
I did a google search "woman assaulted by her lover" and clicked on the first link:
even though it seems kinda brutal, i agree with her decision. i mean she got etched and wants to exact revenge by doing the same thing. an eye for an eye or whatever you might want to call it. plus the judge has also agreed with her decision. so i say justice has been served.
On May 14 2011 08:48 aimaimaim wrote: The man was crazy. The woman had the right to exact revenge Humanitarians can sometimes be really stupid.
You go girl
On May 14 2011 08:47 daytrippers wrote: will there be a stream? how much is HD pass
The man will be sedated .. Theres no fun in that but would still love to see it though
Everything about this is just terrible.
The fuck is wrong with you?
This is bullshit TL, You guys are warning people for supporting this trial but letting people like him go.
This is a starcraft forum, who is to say what is wrong/right, and justice
There is so much western subjectivism in here
I think I am able to say what is wrong/right exactly because it is a starcraft forum (my starcraft forum) and not a court room. Thanks though.
On a more serious note, we don't catch everything and just because somebody wasn't caught does not mean its right. That much should be obvious. This situation is so ugly yet so morally complicated and sad. And that is what makes it so interesting.
On May 14 2011 16:36 Phenny wrote: Why is it uncivilised or barbaric to do back to him what he did to her, just because that's not how we run things in our civilised society?.
On May 14 2011 16:36 Phenny wrote: Why is it uncivilised or barbaric to do back to him what he did to her, just because that's not how we run things in our civilised society?.
You already answered your own question
What I meant was what makes it "civilised" to do it our way? Is it just because for some reason our society thinks it is more morally acceptable or is there a more reasonable and logical reason?
On May 14 2011 12:24 unichan wrote: Why would he do that to someone he loves ~_~ real angry
for the 'ed' conjugation
He "loved" her... as in past tense... or not present... something in him changed...
If it were possible, giving him 20000 hours of community service would be just as good...( 8760 hours/year and he can work 12hours/day for ~4-5 years... ) It'd rehabilitate him and still give him some human interaction.
On May 14 2011 16:36 Phenny wrote: Why is it uncivilised or barbaric to do back to him what he did to her, just because that's not how we run things in our civilised society?.
You already answered your own question
What I meant was what makes it "civilised" to do it our way? Is it just because for some reason our society thinks it is more morally acceptable or is there a more reasonable and logical reason?
If it was uncivilized/barbaric when it was done to the woman, it will be so when it will be done to the man. Perhaps even more so, since the act would have their legal system supporting it, and apparently acceptance from some people.
On May 14 2011 15:50 Daimai wrote: This makes me happy. Good for her, hope she enjoys and savors it
She got acid thrown in her face because off a culture drenched in Islamic tradition and sharia law.
You can call it justice (i would not) that she can now dump acid in his eyes via sharia law but had she been born in a civilised country she wouldn't have gotten acid in her face in the first place.
The islamic culture is what contributed to her situation in the first place. To then make use of it for revenge and call it good seems strange at best. The culture of "women are property" is what got her in this mess in the first place.
In the end it's not right, it's not justice and it's not as it should be. The middle-east should strive for a world where this doesn't happen in the first place. Not rejoice in barbaric revenge for a barbaric act.
God..Look at what Wilders is doing to this country....
There is absolutely nothing in Islamic culture that justifies a man throwing acid to a woman's face. Stop trying to look for reasons to blame everything wrong on Islam.
I did a google search "woman assaulted by her lover" and clicked on the first link:
A woman assaulted by her boyfriend in US with an axe handle. Are we to blame this now on the American culture? No...
Lovers getting over-jealous and doing disgusting things in a moment of rage happens everywhere in the world.
What can I say some people just think that they are all-knowing to a degree that they can attribute any unrelated crime to a mind-set of a culture or a religion they know nothing about. Its just blatant discrimination and generalization. I gotta say people zalz to extent ruin TL for me.
On May 14 2011 16:36 Phenny wrote: Why is it uncivilised or barbaric to do back to him what he did to her, just because that's not how we run things in our civilised society?.
You already answered your own question
What I meant was what makes it "civilised" to do it our way? Is it just because for some reason our society thinks it is more morally acceptable or is there a more reasonable and logical reason?
Seriously? Do you not understand how it is uncivilized to sedate a man and pour acid on his face for a crime that he comitted? I think some of you guys need to come live in a country that has a working legal system that does not rely upon vengeance. Funny how the countries with the most 'humane' treatment of criminals also has the lowest crime rates in the world.