|
Crimes happen everywhere, you are definitely assuming too much here. There is no acid throwing culture rituals as far as I know. And if there was they thought it was right, wouldn't be punishing it. If anything this is women empowerment to an extreme. You are just plugging in your opinion on a completely unrelated matter here.
This goes for you and all the others with similar complaints that i am generalising.
This man did not invent acid throwing, this man did not just want to hurt his ex and decided a bottle of acid just happened to be near him at the time. Acid throwing is something that happens reguraly.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Acid_throwing
It's easy to rush and accuse me of things that i clearly am not. Read up and educate yourself on the matter. Acid throwing is something entirely in and of itself.
You can't seriously say that it's not inherent to a culture when it happens so often in certain countries whilst absolutely never in others. There are entire groups aimed at helping victims of acid throwing.
It's not just a guy that happened to use acid because it was available. He sought out acid and used it, following in a line of people that went before him that established acid throwing as an aspect of a culture.
I think it's not fair to the victims to try and pretend like acid throwing isn't something in and of itself.
|
On May 14 2011 08:55 Derez wrote: This pretty much proves why victims shouldn't have any say in the punishment of an offender.
'An eye for an eye' isn't justice, it's just retribution. Im afraid thats how the world is run. Look at the US killing Usama for example. That wasnt justice but pure vengance. Not saying I dont think it was the correct thing to do though.
|
On May 14 2011 17:15 BloodDrunK wrote: plus the judge has also agreed with her decision. so i say justice has been served. The judge never agreed to her decision, he tried to convince her of not doing it. He is just legally bound to accept it, he still found it the wrong thing to do (it's written in the interview with her linked in the OP)
€ There are also other things mentioned in the article that might interest some people. She is seeking revenge and wants to set an example, after she took revenge she is going to go the attention whore-route and will be visiting tv-shows(which is also a way of making money, and kind of a contradiction imo).
Depending on the interest in her, how much she is going to make off of it and if her claims that the offender does not have much money are true she might be better of monetarily this way than with accepting the money+jail-option.
|
Why do we want to just lock somebody into a prison for X amount of time on the money of taxpaying ppl? You commit something terrible, you got locked in, you have food, you can educate yourself etc etc. Basically you sacrifice some of your time but that poor woman's entire life is destroyed. Is this justice?
Yes it's barbaric to just etch somebody's eye, even if it is justified by the law, but fuck, why would this man deserve less suffering then the woman who got crippled by him?
|
On May 14 2011 18:06 zalz wrote:Show nested quote +Crimes happen everywhere, you are definitely assuming too much here. There is no acid throwing culture rituals as far as I know. And if there was they thought it was right, wouldn't be punishing it. If anything this is women empowerment to an extreme. You are just plugging in your opinion on a completely unrelated matter here. This goes for you and all the others with similar complaints that i am generalising. This man did not invent acid throwing, this man did not just want to hurt his ex and decided a bottle of acid just happened to be near him at the time. Acid throwing is something that happens reguraly. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Acid_throwingIt's easy to rush and accuse me of things that i clearly am not. Read up and educate yourself on the matter. Acid throwing is something entirely in and of itself. You can't seriously say that it's not inherent to a culture when it happens so often in certain countries whilst absolutely never in others. There are entire groups aimed at helping victims of acid throwing. It's not just a guy that happened to use acid because it was available. He sought out acid and used it, following in a line of people that went before him that established acid throwing as an aspect of a culture. I think it's not fair to the victims to try and pretend like acid throwing isn't something in and of itself.
You just refuted your initial argument, which was:
"The islamic culture is what contributed to her situation in the first place."
Now you are linking to a wiki page about acid throwing that states the following:
"These attacks are most common in Cambodia,[7] Afghanistan,[8] India,[9] Bangladesh,[4][5] Pakistan[4] and other nearby countries."
Not all the countries in that list are Muslim. I'd say their common part is geography more than anything else. Yet, you somehow decided that it was Islam's fault. And, also the fact that there are dozens of other Islamic countries not on that list brings me to my first point: Stop trying to generalize and pin everything on Islam.
|
On May 14 2011 18:04 iTzAnglory wrote: It is news like these that make me glad I am living in the United States. Wait a minute, didn't you guys just kill someone a week ago? I kind of heard it on the news..
User was warned for this post
|
It's scary that people claim this to be just. The basis of law should not be to punish, but prevent. Physical mutilation will not stop people from committing crimes of passion or neccessity. Taking the eyes of this criminal will not cause the victim to get hers back, or prevent any crimes from happening again.
|
On May 14 2011 18:18 superjoppe wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 18:04 iTzAnglory wrote: It is news like these that make me glad I am living in the United States. Wait a minute, didn't you guys just kill someone a week ago? I kind of heard it on the news..
Yeah, in Pakistan. That's why he is glad he is living in the U.S.
|
You just refuted your initial argument, which was:
"The islamic culture is what contributed to her situation in the first place."
Now you are linking to a wiki page about acid throwing that states the following:
"These attacks are most common in Cambodia,[7] Afghanistan,[8] India,[9] Bangladesh,[4][5] Pakistan[4] and other nearby countries."
I think refuting is overstating it. I would argue that my comment was lacking in scope. An utter disregard for the position of women, of wich islamic culture is filled.
The anti-feminism within islamic culture creates an environment where such extreme actions can take hold and spread. Nobody is saying that all muslims are throwing acid in people's faces but it doesn't exactly have to be a majority for it to be a problem.
I don't think the victims of these atacks will sleep any better when you tell them that there are only several hundred atacks like this each year.
Not all the countries in that list are Muslim. I'd say their common part is geography more than anything else. Yet, you somehow decided that it was Islam's fault. And, also the fact that there are dozens of other Islamic countries not on that list brings me to my first point: Stop trying to generalize and pin everything on Islam.
As stated above Islamic culture was perhaps lacking in scope. It is the ever present anti-feminism and disregard for the position of women that leads to things like this. Islam is filled with that so ofcourse like any other heavily anti-feminist idea it can lead to things like this.
The victims are pretty much always female. The hatred for women is very clear in this act. It's not just a violent act that anyone will use, it's the result of cultures that consider women inferior. So the problem is cultures that consider women lower then men and since Islam in the middle-east generally favors that, i consider it responsible.
That such a medieval practice spreads geographically only makes sense but to suggest that that is the primary factor seems ludicrous. There are plenty of countries in those regions that don't have acid throwing as a serious problem.
|
Well everyone, here's Sharia. I'm curious to how they're going to work this out in Sweden within 20 years.
|
I guess and eye-for-an-eye does make the whole world blind...
|
I'm surprised the man was even convicted, give their government some props!
|
On May 14 2011 09:02 Parnage wrote: The hell is wrong with you people?
How can you condone this? This is no better then removing the hand of a pickpocket or forcing a woman to be blinded due to looking at another man.
Really? It's no different? Blinding someone for a heinous crime is the exact same as blinding someone for something that isn't even a crime in most countries? If only I had known I could make up random analogies to argue with I would have told my parents that grounding me for staying up late to play starcraft is no different than castrating a man for being gay.
|
On May 14 2011 16:35 Cifer wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 16:24 Nightfall.589 wrote:On May 14 2011 11:32 deesee wrote: If prison as a deterrent and rehabilitation as a justice system worked, we wouldn't have as many crimes committed. Absolute nonsense. You could make that statement if *any* amount of crimes would be committed. Also, how do you distinguish punishment from revenge? isn't throwing someone away in jail for the rest of their lives revenge? The purpose of prison is, and should not be revenge. It should be keeping dangerous people. Off the streets. After they have committed a crime. Can't exactly jail them before the fact. That's factually incorrect, if its just a form of containment that we should see more life sentences, why would you let a dangerous person back out? and why should the time scale with the crime? It's because they have done their "punishment" regardless of you truly think they have rehabilitated or not.
This is exactly correct. Criminal justice, in general, serves a variety of purposes - the most important of which is definitely retributive. Most modern liberal democracies now outlaw capital/corporal punishment, but this only goes to the humanity of the penalty, not the purpose of the penalty. In fact, although I don't have the figures off the top of my head, I could dig up a bunch of papers done by criminologists showing that prison does not reform or rehabilitate criminals. And all governments know this. Sociologically, punishment is important because it reinforces the normative patterns in any given society and draws a clear line between what behavior is acceptable and what behavior isn't. So, the punishment in this case is probably uncalled for, but nevertheless, punishment, whether in the form of prison or capital punishment, ultimately serves a similar purpose.
|
Criminals are a cancer on society. Cancer can't be reasoned with and learn from its mistakes and then politely asked not to destroy the body its in.... you have to nuke it with chemicals or cut it out or it spreads and destroys everything.
For society to survive criminals should be treated the same.... and prison isn't cutting them out or nuking em.
I know it might sound harsh to people who still believe in the "justice" system. But its not a justice system in the western world. Its a legal system. And it doesn't give a hoot about justice.
In the womans position I could not think of a more fitting consequence for the man to pay for his actions with. And anyone foolish enough to think a time out in a jail will help alter his view is naive to say the least.
|
On May 14 2011 17:56 Bergys wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 17:26 Phenny wrote:On May 14 2011 17:21 ChApFoU wrote:On May 14 2011 16:36 Phenny wrote: Why is it uncivilised or barbaric to do back to him what he did to her, just because that's not how we run things in our civilised society?. You already answered your own question  What I meant was what makes it "civilised" to do it our way? Is it just because for some reason our society thinks it is more morally acceptable or is there a more reasonable and logical reason? Seriously? Do you not understand how it is uncivilized to sedate a man and pour acid on his face for a crime that he comitted? I think some of you guys need to come live in a country that has a working legal system that does not rely upon vengeance. Funny how the countries with the most 'humane' treatment of criminals also has the lowest crime rates in the world.
I just think it's kind of subservient and complicit for people to just support the states method of dealing with criminals regardless of what it might be because the state did it so it must be ~right~.
Whereas if it's carried out on a personal level it must be inherently bad.
EDIT: Don't get me wrong I'm not advocating everyone pursue their own justice or revenge even though it kinda sounds like it lol.
|
On May 14 2011 18:27 zalz wrote:Show nested quote +You just refuted your initial argument, which was:
"The islamic culture is what contributed to her situation in the first place."
Now you are linking to a wiki page about acid throwing that states the following:
"These attacks are most common in Cambodia,[7] Afghanistan,[8] India,[9] Bangladesh,[4][5] Pakistan[4] and other nearby countries." I think refuting is overstating it. I would argue that my comment was lacking in scope. An utter disregard for the position of women, of wich islamic culture is filled. The anti-feminism within islamic culture creates an environment where such extreme actions can take hold and spread. Nobody is saying that all muslims are throwing acid in people's faces but it doesn't exactly have to be a majority for it to be a problem. I don't think the victims of these atacks will sleep any better when you tell them that there are only several hundred atacks like this each year. Show nested quote +Not all the countries in that list are Muslim. I'd say their common part is geography more than anything else. Yet, you somehow decided that it was Islam's fault. And, also the fact that there are dozens of other Islamic countries not on that list brings me to my first point: Stop trying to generalize and pin everything on Islam. As stated above Islamic culture was perhaps lacking in scope. It is the ever present anti-feminism and disregard for the position of women that leads to things like this. Islam is filled with that so ofcourse like any other heavily anti-feminist idea it can lead to things like this. The victims are pretty much always female. The hatred for women is very clear in this act. It's not just a violent act that anyone will use, it's the result of cultures that consider women inferior. So the problem is cultures that consider women lower then men and since Islam in the middle-east generally favors that, i consider it responsible. That such a medieval practice spreads geographically only makes sense but to suggest that that is the primary factor seems ludicrous. There are plenty of countries in those regions that don't have acid throwing as a serious problem.
Of course the victim's almost always female. Spurned lovers that turn to violence are almost always male, no matter the country. Especially in western countries, as a matter of fact, since women in civilised lands have different ways to exact vengeance (aka the false rape accusation.)
|
On May 14 2011 18:09 nOia.pod wrote: Why do we want to just lock somebody into a prison for X amount of time on the money of taxpaying ppl? You commit something terrible, you got locked in, you have food, you can educate yourself etc etc. Basically you sacrifice some of your time but that poor woman's entire life is destroyed. Is this justice?
Yes it's barbaric to just etch somebody's eye, even if it is justified by the law, but fuck, why would this man deserve less suffering then the woman who got crippled by him?
Right, I'm fairly sure their prison system probably is not as nice as you think.
|
@ Zalz I am not gonna argue with all the points in your last post as you are now deflecting from your initial screw-up in reasoning.
The anti-feminism within islamic culture creates an environment where such extreme actions can take hold and spread....As stated above Islamic culture was perhaps lacking in scope. It is the ever present anti-feminism and disregard for the position of women that leads to things like this.
So an assault on a woman in a Muslim country signals a deep sociological problem for which the religion of that country is responsible, yet the attacks on women in other countries (like the assault on a woman by an ax handle in US I linked in my first post) is what exactly? Just moments of rage? You are being subjective and seeing what you want to see.
The wiki page lists Cambodia as one of the countries where acid attacks are common. Yet, Cambodia is majority Buddhist with Muslim and Christian minority. So, Cambodia is just an exception then?
The victims are pretty much always female. The hatred for women is very clear in this act. It's not just a violent act that anyone will use, it's the result of cultures that consider women inferior.
Once again you are seeing what you want to see. Disfiguring a woman's face is nothing special for Islam nor for this geography. There are quite many cases where a man knifed or slashed a woman's face in the West. (just google, an example: http://daily-journal.com/archives/dj/display.php?id=473130) The motive for these disgusting acts is simply to take away the beauty of a woman and does not necessarily indicate a general hatred towards women in that culture.
|
On May 14 2011 08:52 Jerubaal wrote: There's a big difference between justice and retribution.
Perspective?
Of the two, justice is a far more subjective term. Retribution gets a bad rap since the dawn of the politically correct age and post non-violent movements, but ignoring results + Show Spoiler +On May 14 2011 08:45 Zephy wrote:...This should also serve as an example for any similar cases, she thinks. According to the judges, the sole judgement has already awed a statistically significant amount of possible perpetrators, that there has been a noticeable decline in this crimesector...
is somewhat naive is it not?
I think we've seen what the Ghandi approach has done for women in some parts of the world, and I'm glad to hear about a change for the better. If in this case comes at the cost of one man's eyesight, so be it. Particularly a man who has proven that he is part of the problem.
He's going to be sedated and whatnot and I think it is fairly safe to say that it would take less than one fewer women being assaulted/raped/murdered to make it an overall good trade for reducing human suffering on a whole. Objectively.
...I had a feeling this would be one of those posts I was nervous to click the 'Post' button on.
|
|
|
|
|
|