|
On May 14 2011 15:17 mathershop wrote: People who just blindly assume that eye for an eye is a good way to deal with criminals don't even remotely think about its complications. In such a system a person who murdered in the heat of the moment (aka 3rd degree murder/manslaughter in Canada) will have to be punished by a capital punishment. Is this justified? What about euthanasia? a doctor who assisted someone with painless suicide to end suffering of a terminal disease? is the doctor needs to be punished in the way he committed the murder? There are prisons for a reason, the main one is to institutionalize the criminals for correctional purposes. If you don't give a chance for a person to improve upon his crimes you will have the most tyrannical government.
No one argued that this rule should be general, nor do I think it is in Iran. We are talking about this specific case, In which it is probably not in the heat of the moment and has nothing to do with euthanasia. Not that im saying that its right, but I can respect the opinions of people who do.
|
I like this strawman that equates "I do not agree with this form of justice" with "I will let criminals like this go".
|
On May 14 2011 15:31 Cifer wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 15:17 mathershop wrote: People who just blindly assume that eye for an eye is a good way to deal with criminals don't even remotely think about its complications. In such a system a person who murdered in the heat of the moment (aka 3rd degree murder/manslaughter in Canada) will have to be punished by a capital punishment. Is this justified? What about euthanasia? a doctor who assisted someone with painless suicide to end suffering of a terminal disease? is the doctor needs to be punished in the way he committed the murder? There are prisons for a reason, the main one is to institutionalize the criminals for correctional purposes. If you don't give a chance for a person to improve upon his crimes you will have the most tyrannical government. No one argued that this rule should be general, nor do I think it is in Iran. We are talking about this specific case, In which it is probably not in the heat of the moment and has nothing to do with euthanasia. Not that im saying that its right, but I can respect the opinions of people who do. It is still a precedent which makes it wrong
|
On May 14 2011 15:34 mathershop wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 15:31 Cifer wrote:On May 14 2011 15:17 mathershop wrote: People who just blindly assume that eye for an eye is a good way to deal with criminals don't even remotely think about its complications. In such a system a person who murdered in the heat of the moment (aka 3rd degree murder/manslaughter in Canada) will have to be punished by a capital punishment. Is this justified? What about euthanasia? a doctor who assisted someone with painless suicide to end suffering of a terminal disease? is the doctor needs to be punished in the way he committed the murder? There are prisons for a reason, the main one is to institutionalize the criminals for correctional purposes. If you don't give a chance for a person to improve upon his crimes you will have the most tyrannical government. No one argued that this rule should be general, nor do I think it is in Iran. We are talking about this specific case, In which it is probably not in the heat of the moment and has nothing to do with euthanasia. Not that im saying that its right, but I can respect the opinions of people who do. It is still a precedent which makes it wrong I can't see how this can be a precedent for euthanasia?! Its in completely different circumstances.
|
Guy gets no sympathy from me. In my opinion, he deserves what ever he gets.
For "an eye for an eye" as a justice system, however, I'm on the fence. Some punishments would be cruel (should we punish a rapist with rape?) but others, it makes sense. Of course, there'll always be people who take it to an extreme, like cutting someone's hand off for stealing. That's not an eye for an eye. An eye for an eye would be returning what was stolen and then taking that value in money from the criminal. I'll have to think about it some more.
|
If I were in the man's position, I think I would rather just die.
|
Guy deserves it, but under no circumstances can I condone the decision. It undermines everything modern democracy and progressive justice systems stand for. You can't say you think it shouldn't be a general rule, and still endorse it in this single case. We should be above that, and the fact that the option was even on the table as a punishment shows how ill-equipped religious law is to operate in the modern world.
|
This makes me happy. Good for her, hope she enjoys and savors it
|
On May 14 2011 15:39 Cifer wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 15:34 mathershop wrote:On May 14 2011 15:31 Cifer wrote:On May 14 2011 15:17 mathershop wrote: People who just blindly assume that eye for an eye is a good way to deal with criminals don't even remotely think about its complications. In such a system a person who murdered in the heat of the moment (aka 3rd degree murder/manslaughter in Canada) will have to be punished by a capital punishment. Is this justified? What about euthanasia? a doctor who assisted someone with painless suicide to end suffering of a terminal disease? is the doctor needs to be punished in the way he committed the murder? There are prisons for a reason, the main one is to institutionalize the criminals for correctional purposes. If you don't give a chance for a person to improve upon his crimes you will have the most tyrannical government. No one argued that this rule should be general, nor do I think it is in Iran. We are talking about this specific case, In which it is probably not in the heat of the moment and has nothing to do with euthanasia. Not that im saying that its right, but I can respect the opinions of people who do. It is still a precedent which makes it wrong I can't see how this can be a precedent for euthanasia?! Its in completely different circumstances. precendent for similar cases in which the punishment might not be justifiable My point is that letting your emotions affect your decision in legal cases is not the most civilized and correct way to do it.
|
You know this story reminds me of the overarching plot of Naruto. This plot revolves around the concept of revenge, hatred, and war and can someone go about ending such things. Hatred and revenge breed only more hatred and revenge. In order to end this vicious cycle someone has to refuse to give into hatred and revenge. We can learn more from the victims that forgive than we can from those that seek revenge. Revenge stops people from understanding each other/helping people change for the better.
|
On May 14 2011 08:46 Airship wrote: An eye for an eye.
Makes the world blind.
|
Sounds like justice will be served. The western society is far too lenient on sadistic or deranged criminals.
|
Ehh... Very bad decision from side of Woman... Revenge isn't the best choice... We have to fight with good against bad
|
On May 14 2011 15:53 mathershop wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 15:39 Cifer wrote:On May 14 2011 15:34 mathershop wrote:On May 14 2011 15:31 Cifer wrote:On May 14 2011 15:17 mathershop wrote: People who just blindly assume that eye for an eye is a good way to deal with criminals don't even remotely think about its complications. In such a system a person who murdered in the heat of the moment (aka 3rd degree murder/manslaughter in Canada) will have to be punished by a capital punishment. Is this justified? What about euthanasia? a doctor who assisted someone with painless suicide to end suffering of a terminal disease? is the doctor needs to be punished in the way he committed the murder? There are prisons for a reason, the main one is to institutionalize the criminals for correctional purposes. If you don't give a chance for a person to improve upon his crimes you will have the most tyrannical government. No one argued that this rule should be general, nor do I think it is in Iran. We are talking about this specific case, In which it is probably not in the heat of the moment and has nothing to do with euthanasia. Not that im saying that its right, but I can respect the opinions of people who do. It is still a precedent which makes it wrong I can't see how this can be a precedent for euthanasia?! Its in completely different circumstances. precendent for similar cases in which the punishment might not be justifiable My point is that letting your emotions affect your decision in legal cases is not the most civilized and correct way to do it. Yeah but you used euthanasia as an example. Being used as a precedent is a completely different issue, as it will come down to how the system uses it. If thats the case about emotion then no one is civilised since, in countries with jury systems the lawyers main goal is for them to gain sympathy with their client. Emotion being used in law is inevitable, we are humans after all. I don't agree that we have to be robots in order to be civilized. And I don't think there is such a thing as one "Correct way" to do it, and if there is then we will never be able to achieve it.
|
On May 14 2011 16:02 Kickboxer wrote: Sounds like justice will be served. The western society is far too lenient on sadistic or deranged criminals.
Revenge and justice are far from the same thing. As plenty of people have already stated in this thread, an eye for an eye makes us all blind.
|
Cool stuff, that woman deserves her revenge imo. What that guy did is just terrible! I wouldnt like this kind of justicesystem, however i do think she deserves to get back. This is even better than the death penalty, now the guy will know and feel how it is.
|
On May 14 2011 15:57 NEOtheONE wrote: You know this story reminds me of the overarching plot of Naruto. This plot revolves around the concept of revenge, hatred, and war and can someone go about ending such things. Hatred and revenge breed only more hatred and revenge. In order to end this vicious cycle someone has to refuse to give into hatred and revenge. We can learn more from the victims that forgive than we can from those that seek revenge. Revenge stops people from understanding each other/helping people change for the better. I don't think this applies to psychopaths which you can't even reason with, eventually naruto will have to stop Madara forcefully, be it revenge or not. Also, how do you distinguish punishment from revenge? isn't throwing someone away in jail for the rest of their lives revenge? Should we just forgive people and let them run rampant? Also, how do you know what the women is thinking, maybe she stripped her self out of emotion, and is doing this just to teach him a lesson. In theory although unlikely it could still be a not vengeful act.
|
On May 14 2011 16:09 Cifer wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 15:53 mathershop wrote:On May 14 2011 15:39 Cifer wrote:On May 14 2011 15:34 mathershop wrote:On May 14 2011 15:31 Cifer wrote:On May 14 2011 15:17 mathershop wrote: People who just blindly assume that eye for an eye is a good way to deal with criminals don't even remotely think about its complications. In such a system a person who murdered in the heat of the moment (aka 3rd degree murder/manslaughter in Canada) will have to be punished by a capital punishment. Is this justified? What about euthanasia? a doctor who assisted someone with painless suicide to end suffering of a terminal disease? is the doctor needs to be punished in the way he committed the murder? There are prisons for a reason, the main one is to institutionalize the criminals for correctional purposes. If you don't give a chance for a person to improve upon his crimes you will have the most tyrannical government. No one argued that this rule should be general, nor do I think it is in Iran. We are talking about this specific case, In which it is probably not in the heat of the moment and has nothing to do with euthanasia. Not that im saying that its right, but I can respect the opinions of people who do. It is still a precedent which makes it wrong I can't see how this can be a precedent for euthanasia?! Its in completely different circumstances. precendent for similar cases in which the punishment might not be justifiable My point is that letting your emotions affect your decision in legal cases is not the most civilized and correct way to do it. Yeah but you used euthanasia as an example. Being used as a precedent is a completely different issue, as it will come down to how the system uses it. If thats the case about emotion then no one is civilised since, in countries with jury systems the lawyers main goal is for them to gain sympathy with their client. Emotion being used in law is inevitable, we are humans after all. I don't agree that we have to be robots in order to be civilized. And I don't think there is such a thing as one "Correct way" to do it, and if there is then we will never be able to achieve it. My example of euthanasia was related to the topic of eye for an eye and tooth for a tooth type of punishments in general, not for this case specifically. The jury's job is to provide the general public opinion of the "standard reasonable man" not the "emotional sympathetic man". And no, lawyers don't rely on emotion when they work on criminal cases, they rely on evidence and the positive law. There is a "Correct way" however, the law is not static as you assume it is, it's a "chain novel", it's a work in progress. I didn't say that we will be able to achieve the best correct way but some ways are better than others and every civilized legal system striving for improvement.
|
Well.... this is... strange. To say the least. Her face was really horrible damn..
|
On May 14 2011 11:32 deesee wrote: If prison as a deterrent and rehabilitation as a justice system worked, we wouldn't have as many crimes committed.
Absolute nonsense. You could make that statement if *any* amount of crimes would be committed.
Also, how do you distinguish punishment from revenge? isn't throwing someone away in jail for the rest of their lives revenge?
The purpose of prison is, and should not be revenge. It should be keeping dangerous people. Off the streets. After they have committed a crime. Can't exactly jail them before the fact.
|
|
|
|
|
|