|
On May 14 2011 13:08 EmeraldSparks wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 13:06 Mailing wrote:On May 14 2011 13:04 lluke9 wrote: Oh my... this is a good example of why humans should never trust their own morals... they'll just be going around creating justice systems like these...
And here we have people arguing that their morals are superior to those of other people. We have to use... logic! Logically, the "eye for an eye" system is flawed, because it is not beneficial to the human race as a whole. It only serves to make the victim feel better. Although, I'm willing to acknowledge that people believe a harsher punishment MAY lower the frequency of said crime. Or it may not, because the threat of life in prison may be just as frightening as retribution.
So, in the end, I am thoroughly confused as to which side is more justified, like many other controversial issues I decide to take on.
I guess none of us are really qualified to judge other people's judgement or morals. It's really what makes the majority of the people happy. In their case, shariah law. Can't say for sure if the majority of the people there are quite happy with it, though. The majority of people in the US do not seem to be happy with that fact that their taxes pay for rapists and murderers to have a relativity comfortable life in prison compared to some third world countries. The majority of people in the United States are actually pretty happy with the way that prisons are run as calls for prison reform either way are being steadfastly ignored, and of those that are being heeded, the most often listened to are the ones claiming that life in prison are too harsh. In addition, if you gave most prisoners in for life a chance to live out the rest of their lives as free people in third world countries, the vast majority of them would go for it. Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 13:08 lluke9 wrote: Indeed. We should change that. Lots of money going into those prisons, I hear. We could kill them all and let God sort them out. I wouldnt say they are happy with the way prisons run. I would say they are apathetic to how their prisons are run, and probably a majority of the people do not know how the prisons are run at all.
I personally don't care in the slightest, I got more problems than worrying about how we deal with criminals.
|
Teaches motherfuckers a lesson. You think that nasty piece of scum will ever pull some shit like that again? Not fucking likely.
|
On May 14 2011 13:12 TwoPac wrote: Teaches motherfuckers a lesson. You think that nasty piece of scum will ever pull some shit like that again? Not fucking likely. Yeah, I can't imagine that somebody who had his own eyes burned out with acid would ever try and pull some shit like trying to burn someone else's eyes out with acid.
That's illogical.
On May 14 2011 11:28 Aelip wrote:Show nested quote +[B]On May 14 2011 11:26 aimaimaim wrote: But the new murders to come will decrease. Gradually, if thinking of long term goals, the murders will decrease  oh and PPV would be awesome. George Carlin would be proud!  If this system is in function and i kill someone in a fit of rage og during temporary insanity, i know i'm gonna die. So what do i do? I kill every fucker that ever hurt me or my family, the punishment wouldn't scale anyway. The only reason you don't think the punishment can scale is because you aren't considering the fact that the justice system can mete out a variety of punishments worse than death.
|
On May 14 2011 12:06 turdburgler wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 12:02 Days wrote: For all you people that say an eye for an eye makes everyone blind, let's say your whole family gets slaughtered and your wife gets raped right in front of you while your children are burned alive. Then the murderers somehow are caught and put right in front of your house tied with ropes. I'd like to see how many of you will keep following Gandhi after that. i dont know how to reply to this. its like, you just dont get it. its not even that, you are so far from getting it, that i dont think you could ever be explained the basic concepts of how the western justice system works. this is the whole reason we DONT let the victims choose the punishment. keeping a sensible, detached perspective is a cornerstone of our society. letting people emotionally involved in a situation make the judgements is basically the dumbest thing anyone can do, in any field.
Another interesting part of the western justice system is that (it atleast in my country) you always assume that the perpetrator is mentally ill, as if you're mentally fine, you don't go around raping/ killing people.
Also vengeance feeds vengeance, meaning that if you kill the perpatrator, someone in his/ her family might come after you, and when you die, someone in your family might come after your murderer etc etc. Interestingly enough, this is a major part of how terrorist recruitment works. A family gets slaughtered and raped by American troops, and then they get asked by X terrorist organization to join the resistance.
|
On May 14 2011 13:12 TwoPac wrote: Teaches motherfuckers a lesson. You think that nasty piece of scum will ever pull some shit like that again? Not fucking likely. Then why did the crime happen in the first place? Do you think he didn't know what the punishment was? He probably did, but he did it anyway.
|
Au contraire, an eye for an eye is a valid definition of justice. Maybe it's just not the one you like. And btw, retribution is punishment that is morally justified (i.e. just punishment).
|
On May 14 2011 13:01 Tor wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 12:28 Bosu wrote:On May 14 2011 12:22 Tor wrote:On May 14 2011 12:02 Days wrote: For all you people that say an eye for an eye makes everyone blind, let's say your whole family gets slaughtered and your wife gets raped right in front of you while your children are burned alive. Then the murderers somehow are caught and put right in front of your house tied with ropes. I'd like to see how many of you will keep following Gandhi after that. Are you implying that people put in this situation would rape the criminals? Unless incited by a mob mentality I doubt many people in western culture would have it in them to kill or torture the criminals. Most likely they would ask the state to deal with them. Do people really think western law is some mystical force that makes no sense and works only to defend criminals? Do you really think perpetuating a cycle of violence and breeding conditions that force ordinary citizens to make seriously life altering decisions under extraneous circumstances is good for a society or even that citizen? Rape? Maybe not, that is a sexual punishment that many wouldn't get pleasure in doing to the people that raped and murdered your family. Killing the person that raped and murdered your family? I am confident that many people would have no problem doing that. If we were to perpetuate a culture based around retaliation I could agree with you. However in modern societies there is no way the majority could condone an open act of murder or torture regardless of what the criminal did. It would be akin to vigilantism. I personally believe that because of our current culture you would be surprised to see that most people couldn't take action against the criminal. Believe it or not, people aren't all raging psychopaths, frankly I doubt the woman who had acid splashed on her face could personally bring herself to burn her perpetrators face. And if she did, she would likely suffer serious mental anguish afterwards. In any event, your actual argument is: Because most people would react irrationally and cruelly, out of spite and hatred, it is good to be irrational and cruel. Your message is all passion and no thought.
I'm confused as for where irrationality is coming from. Sure it's cruel, never is it not, but whether or not you define revenge as a rational act depends on how you define justice. An eye for an eye is just one interpretation of justice. Anger and insanity are two totally different concepts.
Take street gangs for example. They're a modern concept of a diluted justice system created by the members of a collective, urban society. How do you bring to justice an opposing gang member who killed a friend of yours? Do you take him to law enforcement. No. You take matters into your own hands because you know that taking his life is the only reasonable punishment for committing such a crime.
This example is the same reason why many people are so opposed to the modern prison system in the United States and so supportive of the death penalty; you're paying to house and feed the criminals of your own society.
|
if this were a man and another man it would be a whole other story,
i think that because it is a women that got hurt it is why we as Americans are more on the lenient side
|
On May 14 2011 13:23 MarkBolinder3 wrote: if this were a man and another man it would be a whole other story,
i think that because it is a women that got hurt it is why we as Americans are more on the lenient side
if it were a man and another man they would both be being put to death for being homosexuals, this is IRAN we are talking about
|
On May 14 2011 13:22 sureshot_ wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 13:01 Tor wrote:On May 14 2011 12:28 Bosu wrote:On May 14 2011 12:22 Tor wrote:On May 14 2011 12:02 Days wrote: For all you people that say an eye for an eye makes everyone blind, let's say your whole family gets slaughtered and your wife gets raped right in front of you while your children are burned alive. Then the murderers somehow are caught and put right in front of your house tied with ropes. I'd like to see how many of you will keep following Gandhi after that. Are you implying that people put in this situation would rape the criminals? Unless incited by a mob mentality I doubt many people in western culture would have it in them to kill or torture the criminals. Most likely they would ask the state to deal with them. Do people really think western law is some mystical force that makes no sense and works only to defend criminals? Do you really think perpetuating a cycle of violence and breeding conditions that force ordinary citizens to make seriously life altering decisions under extraneous circumstances is good for a society or even that citizen? Rape? Maybe not, that is a sexual punishment that many wouldn't get pleasure in doing to the people that raped and murdered your family. Killing the person that raped and murdered your family? I am confident that many people would have no problem doing that. If we were to perpetuate a culture based around retaliation I could agree with you. However in modern societies there is no way the majority could condone an open act of murder or torture regardless of what the criminal did. It would be akin to vigilantism. I personally believe that because of our current culture you would be surprised to see that most people couldn't take action against the criminal. Believe it or not, people aren't all raging psychopaths, frankly I doubt the woman who had acid splashed on her face could personally bring herself to burn her perpetrators face. And if she did, she would likely suffer serious mental anguish afterwards. In any event, your actual argument is: Because most people would react irrationally and cruelly, out of spite and hatred, it is good to be irrational and cruel. Your message is all passion and no thought. I'm confused as for where irrationality is coming from. Sure it's cruel, never is it not, but whether or not you define revenge as a rational act depends on how you define justice. An eye for an eye is just one interpretation of justice. Anger and insanity are two totally different concepts. Take street gangs for example. They're a modern concept of a diluted justice system created by the members of a collective, urban society. How do you bring to justice an opposing gang member who killed a friend of yours? Do you take him to law enforcement. No. You take matters into your own hands because you know that taking his life is the only reasonable punishment for committing such a crime. The type of justice meted out by gangs would be an unfathomably shitty way to actually run civil society.
|
On May 14 2011 13:25 EmeraldSparks wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 13:22 sureshot_ wrote:On May 14 2011 13:01 Tor wrote:On May 14 2011 12:28 Bosu wrote:On May 14 2011 12:22 Tor wrote:On May 14 2011 12:02 Days wrote: For all you people that say an eye for an eye makes everyone blind, let's say your whole family gets slaughtered and your wife gets raped right in front of you while your children are burned alive. Then the murderers somehow are caught and put right in front of your house tied with ropes. I'd like to see how many of you will keep following Gandhi after that. Are you implying that people put in this situation would rape the criminals? Unless incited by a mob mentality I doubt many people in western culture would have it in them to kill or torture the criminals. Most likely they would ask the state to deal with them. Do people really think western law is some mystical force that makes no sense and works only to defend criminals? Do you really think perpetuating a cycle of violence and breeding conditions that force ordinary citizens to make seriously life altering decisions under extraneous circumstances is good for a society or even that citizen? Rape? Maybe not, that is a sexual punishment that many wouldn't get pleasure in doing to the people that raped and murdered your family. Killing the person that raped and murdered your family? I am confident that many people would have no problem doing that. If we were to perpetuate a culture based around retaliation I could agree with you. However in modern societies there is no way the majority could condone an open act of murder or torture regardless of what the criminal did. It would be akin to vigilantism. I personally believe that because of our current culture you would be surprised to see that most people couldn't take action against the criminal. Believe it or not, people aren't all raging psychopaths, frankly I doubt the woman who had acid splashed on her face could personally bring herself to burn her perpetrators face. And if she did, she would likely suffer serious mental anguish afterwards. In any event, your actual argument is: Because most people would react irrationally and cruelly, out of spite and hatred, it is good to be irrational and cruel. Your message is all passion and no thought. I'm confused as for where irrationality is coming from. Sure it's cruel, never is it not, but whether or not you define revenge as a rational act depends on how you define justice. An eye for an eye is just one interpretation of justice. Anger and insanity are two totally different concepts. Take street gangs for example. They're a modern concept of a diluted justice system created by the members of a collective, urban society. How do you bring to justice an opposing gang member who killed a friend of yours? Do you take him to law enforcement. No. You take matters into your own hands because you know that taking his life is the only reasonable punishment for committing such a crime. The type of justice meted out by gangs would be an unfathomably shitty way to actually run civil society.
The point wasn't to try and present a reasonable justice system, although I do agree with you. 
|
On May 14 2011 13:23 MarkBolinder3 wrote: if this were a man and another man it would be a whole other story,
i think that because it is a women that got hurt it is why we as Americans are more on the lenient side
If a man did this to another man, we would call him barbaric. Since it's a woman doing it to a man, we call her liberated.
|
On May 14 2011 13:28 SevenBunnies wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 13:23 MarkBolinder3 wrote: if this were a man and another man it would be a whole other story,
i think that because it is a women that got hurt it is why we as Americans are more on the lenient side If a man did this to another man, we would call him barbaric. Since it's a woman doing it to a man, we call her liberated. Maybe you would, but please, speak for yourself.
|
On May 14 2011 13:22 sureshot_ wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 13:01 Tor wrote:On May 14 2011 12:28 Bosu wrote:On May 14 2011 12:22 Tor wrote:On May 14 2011 12:02 Days wrote: For all you people that say an eye for an eye makes everyone blind, let's say your whole family gets slaughtered and your wife gets raped right in front of you while your children are burned alive. Then the murderers somehow are caught and put right in front of your house tied with ropes. I'd like to see how many of you will keep following Gandhi after that. Are you implying that people put in this situation would rape the criminals? Unless incited by a mob mentality I doubt many people in western culture would have it in them to kill or torture the criminals. Most likely they would ask the state to deal with them. Do people really think western law is some mystical force that makes no sense and works only to defend criminals? Do you really think perpetuating a cycle of violence and breeding conditions that force ordinary citizens to make seriously life altering decisions under extraneous circumstances is good for a society or even that citizen? Rape? Maybe not, that is a sexual punishment that many wouldn't get pleasure in doing to the people that raped and murdered your family. Killing the person that raped and murdered your family? I am confident that many people would have no problem doing that. If we were to perpetuate a culture based around retaliation I could agree with you. However in modern societies there is no way the majority could condone an open act of murder or torture regardless of what the criminal did. It would be akin to vigilantism. I personally believe that because of our current culture you would be surprised to see that most people couldn't take action against the criminal. Believe it or not, people aren't all raging psychopaths, frankly I doubt the woman who had acid splashed on her face could personally bring herself to burn her perpetrators face. And if she did, she would likely suffer serious mental anguish afterwards. In any event, your actual argument is: Because most people would react irrationally and cruelly, out of spite and hatred, it is good to be irrational and cruel. Your message is all passion and no thought. I'm confused as for where irrationality is coming from. Sure it's cruel, never is it not, but whether or not you define revenge as a rational act depends on how you define justice. An eye for an eye is just one interpretation of justice. Anger and insanity are two totally different concepts. Take street gangs for example. They're a modern concept of a diluted justice system created by the members of a collective, urban society. How do you bring to justice an opposing gang member who killed a friend of yours? Do you take him to law enforcement. No. You take matters into your own hands because you know that taking his life is the only reasonable punishment for committing such a crime. This example is the same reason why many people are so opposed to the modern prison system in the United States and so supportive of the death penalty; you're paying to house and feed the criminals of your own society.
Yeah, but the world would be a lot nicer if people tried to be more compassionate rather than spreading pain and suffering.
|
On May 14 2011 13:25 EmeraldSparks wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 13:22 sureshot_ wrote:On May 14 2011 13:01 Tor wrote:On May 14 2011 12:28 Bosu wrote:On May 14 2011 12:22 Tor wrote:On May 14 2011 12:02 Days wrote: For all you people that say an eye for an eye makes everyone blind, let's say your whole family gets slaughtered and your wife gets raped right in front of you while your children are burned alive. Then the murderers somehow are caught and put right in front of your house tied with ropes. I'd like to see how many of you will keep following Gandhi after that. Are you implying that people put in this situation would rape the criminals? Unless incited by a mob mentality I doubt many people in western culture would have it in them to kill or torture the criminals. Most likely they would ask the state to deal with them. Do people really think western law is some mystical force that makes no sense and works only to defend criminals? Do you really think perpetuating a cycle of violence and breeding conditions that force ordinary citizens to make seriously life altering decisions under extraneous circumstances is good for a society or even that citizen? Rape? Maybe not, that is a sexual punishment that many wouldn't get pleasure in doing to the people that raped and murdered your family. Killing the person that raped and murdered your family? I am confident that many people would have no problem doing that. If we were to perpetuate a culture based around retaliation I could agree with you. However in modern societies there is no way the majority could condone an open act of murder or torture regardless of what the criminal did. It would be akin to vigilantism. I personally believe that because of our current culture you would be surprised to see that most people couldn't take action against the criminal. Believe it or not, people aren't all raging psychopaths, frankly I doubt the woman who had acid splashed on her face could personally bring herself to burn her perpetrators face. And if she did, she would likely suffer serious mental anguish afterwards. In any event, your actual argument is: Because most people would react irrationally and cruelly, out of spite and hatred, it is good to be irrational and cruel. Your message is all passion and no thought. I'm confused as for where irrationality is coming from. Sure it's cruel, never is it not, but whether or not you define revenge as a rational act depends on how you define justice. An eye for an eye is just one interpretation of justice. Anger and insanity are two totally different concepts. Take street gangs for example. They're a modern concept of a diluted justice system created by the members of a collective, urban society. How do you bring to justice an opposing gang member who killed a friend of yours? Do you take him to law enforcement. No. You take matters into your own hands because you know that taking his life is the only reasonable punishment for committing such a crime. The type of justice meted out by gangs would be an unfathomably shitty way to actually run civil society.
the mafia qualify as a gang, and their set of rules and justice, is suprisingly reasonable for street justice
|
While I can see why some people think this would not be justice, but I have heard worse things happening as punishment for criminals.
I can't say that this is barbaric or any less civil than the western world. Saying that our values or justice system is better than theirs somewhat negates civility as a whole. Well, it's their law and sovereignty, even though I disagree with choices of the punishments.
|
On May 14 2011 13:30 Pleiades wrote: While I can see why some people think this would not be justice, but I have heard worse things happening as punishment for criminals.
I can't say that this is barbaric or any less civil than the western world. Saying that our values or justice system is better than theirs somewhat negates civility as a whole. Well, it's their law and sovereignty, even though I disagree with choices of the punishments. I can totally make such judgments about different justice systems. Like this one:
Executing people for engaging in homosexual relations is barbaric.
|
Good for her. That's what the asshole gets. It's sickening seeing people get away with things like this with just prison time. It's actually LOL worthy. Oh, you disfigured someone's face and now their blind for the rest of their life? LOL, I'll go to prison and get fed food every day. At least I can see. I never really understood that.
|
On May 14 2011 13:29 EmeraldSparks wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 13:28 SevenBunnies wrote:On May 14 2011 13:23 MarkBolinder3 wrote: if this were a man and another man it would be a whole other story,
i think that because it is a women that got hurt it is why we as Americans are more on the lenient side If a man did this to another man, we would call him barbaric. Since it's a woman doing it to a man, we call her liberated. Maybe you would, but please, speak for yourself. On second thought, I can easily see a lot of opinions changing if a woman had thrown acid into a man's face because he went out and messed with some other girls, and in response the man initiated a judicial process that culminated in the state burning out her eyes. My initial reaction to the situation was different.
How intriguing.
On May 14 2011 13:33 Joementum wrote: Good for her. That's what the asshole gets. It's sickening seeing people get away with things like this with just prison time. It's actually LOL worthy. Oh, you disfigured someone's face and now their blind for the rest of their life? LOL, I'll go to prison and get fed food every day. At least I can see. I never really understood that. You don't understand the principle behind the Eighth Amendment? (Assuming you're American.)
|
Here's two stories that are almost identical.
Story A. A man and a woman get in some sort of domestic dispute involving the woman cheating, and one day while the woman is watching the television the man throws a beaker of acid into her face, disfiguring her and causing permanent vision damage.
Story B A woman and a man get in some sort of domestic dispute involving the man cheating, and one day while the man is watching the television the woman throws a beaker of acid into his face, disfiguring him and causing permanent vision damage.
Poll: Were your initial impressions of the two perpetrators different?No. (22) 79% Yes. (6) 21% 28 total votes Your vote: Were your initial impressions of the two perpetrators different? (Vote): Yes. (Vote): No.
|
|
|
|
|
|