|
On May 14 2011 12:44 hypercube wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 12:28 smokeyhoodoo wrote:On May 14 2011 12:10 Enervate wrote:Are people actually supporting an eye for an eye rofl? Two wrongs don't make a right. A negative number plus a negative number gives you a.. more negative number. Both parties end up worse off. On May 14 2011 12:02 Days wrote: For all you people that say an eye for an eye makes everyone blind, let's say your whole family gets slaughtered and your wife gets raped right in front of you while your children are burned alive. Then the murderers somehow are caught and put right in front of your house tied with ropes. I'd like to see how many of you will keep following Gandhi after that. It's no secret that people's good judgement deteriorates in stressful situations. That's why we say things objectively now. To hope that we don't make the mistakes we might later on or that other people are there to stop us. On May 14 2011 12:09 smokeyhoodoo wrote: The modern rejection of retribution isn't noble, its just pathetic. I would kill the man in her position. Though I guess some people might reside in a perpetual state of bad judgement: It must be coddled environments that breed this kind of thinking. Anything but tit for tat is bad judgement. Study some game theory. Also try backing up personal attacks with at least something. You're trying to convince people that your right by presenting it as the "normal" view. Please don't do this. There's no way to prove an eye for an eye is ideal using game theory. You're making stuff up and claiming it's backed by some sort of rational analysis, when it's not.
Actually it demonstrates that strategies lacking revenge end up getting used.
|
Holy shit picture made me sick!~
|
Systems of punishment based on retribution are fantastic and should be implemented more often.
On May 14 2011 12:50 smokeyhoodoo wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 12:44 hypercube wrote:On May 14 2011 12:28 smokeyhoodoo wrote:On May 14 2011 12:10 Enervate wrote:Are people actually supporting an eye for an eye rofl? Two wrongs don't make a right. A negative number plus a negative number gives you a.. more negative number. Both parties end up worse off. On May 14 2011 12:02 Days wrote: For all you people that say an eye for an eye makes everyone blind, let's say your whole family gets slaughtered and your wife gets raped right in front of you while your children are burned alive. Then the murderers somehow are caught and put right in front of your house tied with ropes. I'd like to see how many of you will keep following Gandhi after that. It's no secret that people's good judgement deteriorates in stressful situations. That's why we say things objectively now. To hope that we don't make the mistakes we might later on or that other people are there to stop us. On May 14 2011 12:09 smokeyhoodoo wrote: The modern rejection of retribution isn't noble, its just pathetic. I would kill the man in her position. Though I guess some people might reside in a perpetual state of bad judgement: It must be coddled environments that breed this kind of thinking. Anything but tit for tat is bad judgement. Study some game theory. Also try backing up personal attacks with at least something. You're trying to convince people that your right by presenting it as the "normal" view. Please don't do this. There's no way to prove an eye for an eye is ideal using game theory. You're making stuff up and claiming it's backed by some sort of rational analysis, when it's not. Actually it demonstrates that strategies lacking revenge end up getting used. That analysis only holds in the repeated game, which this isn't.
|
On May 14 2011 12:44 hypercube wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 12:28 smokeyhoodoo wrote:On May 14 2011 12:10 Enervate wrote:Are people actually supporting an eye for an eye rofl? Two wrongs don't make a right. A negative number plus a negative number gives you a.. more negative number. Both parties end up worse off. On May 14 2011 12:02 Days wrote: For all you people that say an eye for an eye makes everyone blind, let's say your whole family gets slaughtered and your wife gets raped right in front of you while your children are burned alive. Then the murderers somehow are caught and put right in front of your house tied with ropes. I'd like to see how many of you will keep following Gandhi after that. It's no secret that people's good judgement deteriorates in stressful situations. That's why we say things objectively now. To hope that we don't make the mistakes we might later on or that other people are there to stop us. On May 14 2011 12:09 smokeyhoodoo wrote: The modern rejection of retribution isn't noble, its just pathetic. I would kill the man in her position. Though I guess some people might reside in a perpetual state of bad judgement: It must be coddled environments that breed this kind of thinking. Anything but tit for tat is bad judgement. Study some game theory. Also try backing up personal attacks with at least something. You're trying to convince people that your right by presenting it as the "normal" view. Please don't do this. There's no way to prove an eye for an eye is ideal using game theory. You're making stuff up and claiming it's backed by some sort of rational analysis, when it's not.
Its just as, if not more, rational as the American or European form of punishment. Deterrence and Retribution are the two main theories behind the justice system as it is.
|
On May 14 2011 12:52 cLutZ wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 12:44 hypercube wrote:On May 14 2011 12:28 smokeyhoodoo wrote:On May 14 2011 12:10 Enervate wrote:Are people actually supporting an eye for an eye rofl? Two wrongs don't make a right. A negative number plus a negative number gives you a.. more negative number. Both parties end up worse off. On May 14 2011 12:02 Days wrote: For all you people that say an eye for an eye makes everyone blind, let's say your whole family gets slaughtered and your wife gets raped right in front of you while your children are burned alive. Then the murderers somehow are caught and put right in front of your house tied with ropes. I'd like to see how many of you will keep following Gandhi after that. It's no secret that people's good judgement deteriorates in stressful situations. That's why we say things objectively now. To hope that we don't make the mistakes we might later on or that other people are there to stop us. On May 14 2011 12:09 smokeyhoodoo wrote: The modern rejection of retribution isn't noble, its just pathetic. I would kill the man in her position. Though I guess some people might reside in a perpetual state of bad judgement: It must be coddled environments that breed this kind of thinking. Anything but tit for tat is bad judgement. Study some game theory. Also try backing up personal attacks with at least something. You're trying to convince people that your right by presenting it as the "normal" view. Please don't do this. There's no way to prove an eye for an eye is ideal using game theory. You're making stuff up and claiming it's backed by some sort of rational analysis, when it's not. Its just as, if not more, rational as the American or European form of punishment. Deterrence and Retribution are the two main theories behind the justice system as it is. Rehabilitation and Justice called, they want back into Western society.
|
On May 14 2011 09:02 Parnage wrote: The hell is wrong with you people?
How can you condone this? This is no better then removing the hand of a pickpocket or forcing a woman to be blinded due to looking at another man.
This isn't justice, this is disgustingly barbaric and you can't stand for this without standing for all the other terrible things Sharia law allows.
No amount of acid is going to take back the pain, nor is it going to make her feel better to hear some bastard screaming bloody murder as acid is poured into his eye. Would you feel better? Would you really feel better taking that revenge as you watched someone else go through the pain and horror she experienced again?
I can't believe anyone could ever condone this. Ignoring all of this. Money can be used for plastic surgery to help restore a sense of normalcy which is the point of justice it's to restore things to normalcy not.. not this. This is just barbaric in the truest sense of the word. Completely agree with you. Can't believe how many people think different in this thread.
|
On May 14 2011 09:02 Parnage wrote: The hell is wrong with you people?
How can you condone this? This is no better then removing the hand of a pickpocket or forcing a woman to be blinded due to looking at another man. That's punishment disproportionate to the crime.
A better example would be pickpocketing a pickpocket, or having the looker looked at.
On May 14 2011 09:02 Parnage wrote: No amount of acid is going to take back the pain, nor is it going to make her feel better to hear some bastard screaming bloody murder as acid is poured into his eye. Would you feel better? Would you really feel better taking that revenge as you watched someone else go through the pain and horror she experienced again? I'm pretty sure she's going to feel pretty good about it.
|
On May 14 2011 08:54 itzme_petey wrote: Turns out the victim's heart is as black as the criminals. Sad turn of events.
Hardly. You may as well be saying sending someone to jail who was innocent is as wrong as sending someone who commited a crime to jail.
The man did this to an innocent woman. The woman did it to a cold blooded man.
Shooting Nazis who just killed your family and shooting babies in their cribs aren't exactly the same thing.
If anything the law is too bloody lenient. He should get the jailtime AND the eye for an eye, it hardly seems fair someone who did nothing wrong gets the same punishment as someone who hurts innocent people.
I think the idea of a criminal being punished less than an innocent. (ie. a bit in jail and some stupid fine vs permanent injury and blindness) is absolutely ludicrous. How anyone can even CONSIDER that fair is beyond me.
|
On May 14 2011 12:49 relyt wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 12:45 Defeat wrote:On May 14 2011 12:42 mathershop wrote: eye for an eye and tooth for a tooth is a primitive way of serving a punishment it's a circle of revenge that never ends It will end. People will see that they can't get away with it. Glad justice is being served instead of him being fined/thrown in jail for a short time. You do realize that they have been using that system of justice for centuries. It never ends no matter what the punishment is, people will always make mistake and do stupid things.
No, no, really, it does end. Afterall there are no murders in US states which have the death penalty, so obviously it works.
|
On May 14 2011 09:02 Parnage wrote: How can you condone this? This is no better then removing the hand of a pickpocket or forcing a woman to be blinded due to looking at another man.
Cut the hand off a pickpocket, and he will never steal again. As for the looking at another man, that is not as severe and you are using mixed arguments.
On May 14 2011 09:02 Parnage wrote: This isn't justice, this is disgustingly barbaric and you can't stand for this without standing for all the other terrible things Sharia law allows.
No amount of acid is going to take back the pain, nor is it going to make her feel better to hear some bastard screaming bloody murder as acid is poured into his eye. Would you feel better? Would you really feel better taking that revenge as you watched someone else go through the pain and horror she experienced again?
No amount of jail/prison is going to take back the pain. Not only that, but the man would be asleep and sedated during the act, oblivious to the pain he inflicted. As for the second part, yes. I ABSOLUTELY would feel better after retribution of being wronged.
On May 14 2011 09:02 Parnage wrote:I can't believe anyone could ever condone this. Ignoring all of this. Money can be used for plastic surgery to help restore a sense of normalcy which is the point of justice it's to restore things to normalcy not.. not this. This is just barbaric in the truest sense of the word.
She is blind, her loss can never be restored.
|
On May 14 2011 12:59 Mailing wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 09:02 Parnage wrote: How can you condone this? This is no better then removing the hand of a pickpocket or forcing a woman to be blinded due to looking at another man. Cut the hand off a pickpocket, and he will never steal again. As for the looking at another man, that is not as severe and you are using mixed arguments. I'm pretty sure pickpocketing is also less severe than amputation.
I would much rather have my wallet taken than my hand.
That's just me, though.
|
On May 14 2011 12:28 Bosu wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 12:22 Tor wrote:On May 14 2011 12:02 Days wrote: For all you people that say an eye for an eye makes everyone blind, let's say your whole family gets slaughtered and your wife gets raped right in front of you while your children are burned alive. Then the murderers somehow are caught and put right in front of your house tied with ropes. I'd like to see how many of you will keep following Gandhi after that. Are you implying that people put in this situation would rape the criminals? Unless incited by a mob mentality I doubt many people in western culture would have it in them to kill or torture the criminals. Most likely they would ask the state to deal with them. Do people really think western law is some mystical force that makes no sense and works only to defend criminals? Do you really think perpetuating a cycle of violence and breeding conditions that force ordinary citizens to make seriously life altering decisions under extraneous circumstances is good for a society or even that citizen? Rape? Maybe not, that is a sexual punishment that many wouldn't get pleasure in doing to the people that raped and murdered your family. Killing the person that raped and murdered your family? I am confident that many people would have no problem doing that.
If we were to perpetuate a culture based around retaliation I could agree with you. However in modern societies there is no way the majority could condone an open act of murder or torture regardless of what the criminal did. It would be akin to vigilantism. I personally believe that because of our current culture you would be surprised to see that most people couldn't take action against the criminal. Believe it or not, people aren't all raging psychopaths, frankly I doubt the woman who had acid splashed on her face could personally bring herself to burn her perpetrators face. And if she did, she would likely suffer serious mental anguish afterwards.
In any event, your actual argument is: Because most people would react irrationally and cruelly, out of spite and hatred, it is good to be irrational and cruel. Your message is all passion and no thought.
|
while not an expert on middle eastern culture, these sorts of things have happened before, though the women generally choose the jailtime+money option, which is why this is a big deal there.
On May 14 2011 08:55 Derez wrote: This pretty much proves why victims shouldn't have any say in the punishment of an offender.
'An eye for an eye' isn't justice, it's just retribution.
philosophically isn't justice merely society enacting moderated vengence for an act against what society as a whole declared as RIGHT?
and victims/victims families do have a chance here in the US to influence the punishment against the offender during sentancing hearings by telling/showing the judge what the offender cost them.
On May 14 2011 09:02 Parnage wrote: The hell is wrong with you people?
How can you condone this? This is no better then removing the hand of a pickpocket or forcing a woman to be blinded due to looking at another man.
This isn't justice, this is disgustingly barbaric and you can't stand for this without standing for all the other terrible things Sharia law allows.
No amount of acid is going to take back the pain, nor is it going to make her feel better to hear some bastard screaming bloody murder as acid is poured into his eye. Would you feel better? Would you really feel better taking that revenge as you watched someone else go through the pain and horror she experienced again?
I can't believe anyone could ever condone this. Ignoring all of this. Money can be used for plastic surgery to help restore a sense of normalcy which is the point of justice it's to restore things to normalcy not.. not this. This is just barbaric in the truest sense of the word.
1. yes actually it would make me feel better to know that they had to experience even a phantom of the pain and suffering they put me through.
2.plastic surgery won't restore her eyesight 3. sharia law is actually relatively fair. and before i hear about the stoning for adultery thing, men get stoned for it too, the catch is there must be 2 independent witness or proof to bring claim of adultery to either side
|
Oh my... this is a good example of why humans should never trust their own morals... they'll just be going around creating justice systems like these...
And here we have people arguing that their morals are superior to those of other people. We have to use... logic! Logically, the "eye for an eye" system is flawed, because it is not beneficial to the human race as a whole. It only serves to make the victim feel better. Although, I'm willing to acknowledge that people believe a harsher punishment MAY lower the frequency of said crime. Or it may not, because the threat of life in prison may be just as frightening as retribution.
So, in the end, I am thoroughly confused as to which side is more justified, like many other controversial issues I decide to take on.
I guess none of us are really qualified to judge other people's judgement or morals. It's really what makes the majority of the people happy. In their case, shariah law. Can't say for sure if the majority of the people there are quite happy with it, though.
Off-Topic: polysciguy, your signature quote is just epic. Did you make it up yourself?
|
On May 14 2011 13:01 Tor wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 12:28 Bosu wrote:On May 14 2011 12:22 Tor wrote:On May 14 2011 12:02 Days wrote: For all you people that say an eye for an eye makes everyone blind, let's say your whole family gets slaughtered and your wife gets raped right in front of you while your children are burned alive. Then the murderers somehow are caught and put right in front of your house tied with ropes. I'd like to see how many of you will keep following Gandhi after that. Are you implying that people put in this situation would rape the criminals? Unless incited by a mob mentality I doubt many people in western culture would have it in them to kill or torture the criminals. Most likely they would ask the state to deal with them. Do people really think western law is some mystical force that makes no sense and works only to defend criminals? Do you really think perpetuating a cycle of violence and breeding conditions that force ordinary citizens to make seriously life altering decisions under extraneous circumstances is good for a society or even that citizen? Rape? Maybe not, that is a sexual punishment that many wouldn't get pleasure in doing to the people that raped and murdered your family. Killing the person that raped and murdered your family? I am confident that many people would have no problem doing that. If we were to perpetuate a culture based around retaliation I could agree with you. However in modern societies there is no way the majority could condone an open act of murder or torture regardless of what the criminal did. It would be akin to vigilantism. I personally believe that because of our current culture you would be surprised to see that most people couldn't take action against the criminal. You are correct; most victims, given the chance to exact punishment on their perpetrators, will probably show some form of mercy rather than attempting to deliver the worst possible punishment.
On May 14 2011 13:01 Tor wrote: Believe it or not, people aren't all raging psychopaths, frankly I doubt the woman who had acid splashed on her face could personally bring herself to burn her perpetrators face. And if she did, she would likely suffer serious mental anguish afterwards. I'm sure the amount of mental anguish involved would be small compared to having your own eyes burned out with acid.
On May 14 2011 13:01 Tor wrote: In any event, your actual argument is: Because most people would react irrationally and cruelly, out of spite and hatred, it is good to be irrational and cruel. Your message is all passion and no thought. Cruel, but not irrational.
|
On May 14 2011 12:50 smokeyhoodoo wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 12:44 hypercube wrote:On May 14 2011 12:28 smokeyhoodoo wrote:On May 14 2011 12:10 Enervate wrote:Are people actually supporting an eye for an eye rofl? Two wrongs don't make a right. A negative number plus a negative number gives you a.. more negative number. Both parties end up worse off. On May 14 2011 12:02 Days wrote: For all you people that say an eye for an eye makes everyone blind, let's say your whole family gets slaughtered and your wife gets raped right in front of you while your children are burned alive. Then the murderers somehow are caught and put right in front of your house tied with ropes. I'd like to see how many of you will keep following Gandhi after that. It's no secret that people's good judgement deteriorates in stressful situations. That's why we say things objectively now. To hope that we don't make the mistakes we might later on or that other people are there to stop us. On May 14 2011 12:09 smokeyhoodoo wrote: The modern rejection of retribution isn't noble, its just pathetic. I would kill the man in her position. Though I guess some people might reside in a perpetual state of bad judgement: It must be coddled environments that breed this kind of thinking. Anything but tit for tat is bad judgement. Study some game theory. Also try backing up personal attacks with at least something. You're trying to convince people that your right by presenting it as the "normal" view. Please don't do this. There's no way to prove an eye for an eye is ideal using game theory. You're making stuff up and claiming it's backed by some sort of rational analysis, when it's not. Actually it demonstrates that strategies lacking revenge end up getting used.
That's very different from "Anything but tit for tat is bad judgement."
Also revenge is used differently in common speech than in your statement.
|
On May 14 2011 13:04 lluke9 wrote: Oh my... this is a good example of why humans should never trust their own morals... they'll just be going around creating justice systems like these...
And here we have people arguing that their morals are superior to those of other people. We have to use... logic! Logically, the "eye for an eye" system is flawed, because it is not beneficial to the human race as a whole. It only serves to make the victim feel better. Although, I'm willing to acknowledge that people believe a harsher punishment MAY lower the frequency of said crime. Or it may not, because the threat of life in prison may be just as frightening as retribution.
So, in the end, I am thoroughly confused as to which side is more justified, like many other controversial issues I decide to take on.
I guess none of us are really qualified to judge other people's judgement or morals. It's really what makes the majority of the people happy. In their case, shariah law. Can't say for sure if the majority of the people there are quite happy with it, though.
The majority of people in the US do not seem to be happy with that fact that their taxes pay for rapists and murderers to have a relativity comfortable life in prison compared to some third world countries.
|
Nothing wrong with retribution m8s. Me fucking someone over who previously fucked me or people close to me over is simply the logical consequence imo.
|
On May 14 2011 13:06 Mailing wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 13:04 lluke9 wrote: Oh my... this is a good example of why humans should never trust their own morals... they'll just be going around creating justice systems like these...
And here we have people arguing that their morals are superior to those of other people. We have to use... logic! Logically, the "eye for an eye" system is flawed, because it is not beneficial to the human race as a whole. It only serves to make the victim feel better. Although, I'm willing to acknowledge that people believe a harsher punishment MAY lower the frequency of said crime. Or it may not, because the threat of life in prison may be just as frightening as retribution.
So, in the end, I am thoroughly confused as to which side is more justified, like many other controversial issues I decide to take on.
I guess none of us are really qualified to judge other people's judgement or morals. It's really what makes the majority of the people happy. In their case, shariah law. Can't say for sure if the majority of the people there are quite happy with it, though. The majority of people in the US do not seem to be happy with that fact that their taxes pay for rapists and murderers to have a relativity comfortable life in prison compared to some third world countries.
Indeed. We should change that. Lots of money going into those prisons, I hear.
|
On May 14 2011 13:06 Mailing wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 13:04 lluke9 wrote: Oh my... this is a good example of why humans should never trust their own morals... they'll just be going around creating justice systems like these...
And here we have people arguing that their morals are superior to those of other people. We have to use... logic! Logically, the "eye for an eye" system is flawed, because it is not beneficial to the human race as a whole. It only serves to make the victim feel better. Although, I'm willing to acknowledge that people believe a harsher punishment MAY lower the frequency of said crime. Or it may not, because the threat of life in prison may be just as frightening as retribution.
So, in the end, I am thoroughly confused as to which side is more justified, like many other controversial issues I decide to take on.
I guess none of us are really qualified to judge other people's judgement or morals. It's really what makes the majority of the people happy. In their case, shariah law. Can't say for sure if the majority of the people there are quite happy with it, though. The majority of people in the US do not seem to be happy with that fact that their taxes pay for rapists and murderers to have a relativity comfortable life in prison compared to some third world countries. The majority of people in the United States are actually pretty happy with the way that prisons are run as calls for prison reform either way are being steadfastly ignored, and of those that are being heeded, the most often listened to are the ones claiming that life in prison are too harsh. In addition, if you gave most prisoners in for life a chance to live out the rest of their lives as free people in third world countries, the vast majority of them would go for it.
On May 14 2011 13:08 lluke9 wrote: Indeed. We should change that. Lots of money going into those prisons, I hear. We could kill them all and let God sort them out.
|
|
|
|
|
|