|
I somehow have the feeling once the justice is enacted by the woman, she will probably commit suicide.
It's easy to go and say "an eye for an eye makes the world blind" when it's not you who has had their faced burned and disfigured for life. Not to mention she is basically blind. This form of "justice" that she chose is the "purest" because you make the offender feel what you felt when they performed some crime against you.
Hopefully her decision will deter future actions by people such as these acid attacks.
In reality ask yourself, what punishment is equal to having lost your eye sight and being disfigured for the rest of your life?
|
If only they knew the more excellent way.
|
|
|
Cayman Islands24199 Posts
retributive punishment should go. people are to be managed like cargo. it is preferable that this is done distributively though, so religious humanism for everyone. yay?
|
On May 14 2011 11:51 Hinanawi wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 11:46 Talin wrote:On May 14 2011 11:24 Hinanawi wrote:On May 14 2011 11:17 Talin wrote:On May 14 2011 11:06 Hinanawi wrote:On May 14 2011 11:03 Talin wrote:On May 14 2011 10:51 Hinanawi wrote:On May 14 2011 10:27 koreasilver wrote: Justice != Vengeance
itt, concrete examples of why and how the world froths around in an unquenchable rage. Vengeance is justice. I don't know where you all are getting the idea that it isn't, they're practically synonyms. Are you going to make an effort to prove that exact statement, or do you expect us to take your word for it? jus·tice/ˈjəstis/Noun 1. Just behavior or treatment. 2. The quality of being fair and reasonable. According to you, vengeance is synonymous to being fair and reasonable. Tell me, what does it mean 99.99% of the time when you hear that someone has been 'brought to justice'? Does it mean they got 'rehabilitated'? I'm also waiting on a response to my hypothetical scenario with the mind-reading machine. Vengeance is at least part of justice, and always has been. It may not mean they got "rehabilitated", but it means they were given a chance, and it means the state did not condone and commit cruelty that it punishes people for (in this specific example it's actually the EXACT same crime on both sides, except the latter case is state sanctioned crime). You can't punish somebody for committing an act you define as crime, and then commit that very same act and expect such a system to actually work out. This is silly. The exact same crime on both sides? Imagine someone kidnaps another person and makes them stay in a cell for a year. If you really believe what you said earlier, then you could say that the government is acting unjust by sending this man to jail, because they're 'just doing to him what he did to the other person' (locking him up in a cell). That analogy is awful (most analogies are). Jail is the "default" punishment for most serious crimes - because something has got to be. Claiming that it's analogous to deliberate retribution just because the crime happens to coincide exactly with what a pre-determined punishment is way off the mark. If that traditional "default" punishment for crimes would be sipping acid into the criminal's eye, it would actually be "better" (and I use better very liberally here, it's still inhuman) - if only because it doesn't promote the concept of vengeance. On May 14 2011 11:24 Hinanawi wrote: I have a feeling you're not being serious here. You can't really think that she's on the same moral level as him for making this decision? You can argue that it would be BETTER if she didn't do it, but she's really on the SAME level as him? You don't really believe this and calling it 'state-sanctioned crime' is borderline trolling. There's no need to have the feeling I'm not being serious. It's 4:30 AM and I'm posting in a thread which is literally painful to read. I can assure you that I'm dead serious, so there's no need to add redundant and pointless comments to your post. Just write your damn answer. I'm not saying she is on the same level with him - just like no two murders are "morally" on the exact same level either and for each individual case there are circumstances that might make it more or less understandable to do something. It's certainly easy to understand her decision, but the act is still the same - causing harm to another human being, and in a pretty cruel way at that, and in her case, state sanctioned. I'm not even bothered by her decision so much. I'm bothered by the laws that give her the right to make that decision and I'm bothered by the state that will strip people off their basic human rights as a punishment. As I said, in our part of the world (Europe and North America for the most part), people have guaranteed human rights that you can't legally suspend at will. If you disagree with this, then I'm afraid our problem is mostly the cultural differences - maybe you should consider moving to a culture that suits your preferences more. We don't even disagree that neither of us would want these laws in Europe or North America. Iran is not the same ballgame. You can't just paste Sweden's laws onto Iran and expect it to work. This is a gradual process, and this is a step up from before where men would do this shit and just get a slap on the wrist. I'm not even trying to pull a 'moral relativism' card here. I hope that one day Iran doesn't need to have laws like this, but for NOW, this is progress. You (and I don't mean YOU in particular, just everyone in this thread) can't sit comfy in your 1st-world country sipping tea talking about how those savages in the Middle East should just adopt our civilized legal system already. It doesn't work like that.
What? I never argued that we should copy Sweden paste Iran at all, or anything similar.
To me it seemed that a lot of people in this thread are arguing the opposite (in this specific case) - copy Iran paste Sweden (and everywhere else). Now admittedly I'm not reading the IDs of everyone I reply to, I mostly read just the post, so I can't put you in that lot - but there have been more than a few posts from various people hailing the fairness of this punishment and comparing it to the "inefficiency" of dealing with crime in the west.
|
On May 14 2011 11:54 BeJe77 wrote: I somehow have the feeling once the justice is enacted by the woman, she will probably commit suicide.
It's easy to go and say "an eye for an eye makes the world blind" when it's not you who has had their faced burned and disfigured for life. Not to mention she is basically blind. This form of "justice" that she chose is the "purest" because you make the offender feel what you felt when they performed some crime against you.
Hopefully her decision will deter future actions by people such as these acid attacks.
In reality ask yourself, what punishment is equal to having lost your eye sight and being disfigured for the rest of your life? I think it's better for someone not involved in the crime to make judgements on punishment and justice, because then it is an unbiased judgement. The woman is obviously biased and cannot be trusted to make a clear objective decision if she was the victim of the crime in question.
|
For all you people that say an eye for an eye makes everyone blind, let's say your whole family gets slaughtered and your wife gets raped right in front of you while your children are burned alive. Then the murderers somehow are caught and put right in front of your house tied with ropes. I'd like to see how many of you will keep following Gandhi after that.
|
On May 14 2011 11:59 Talin wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 11:51 Hinanawi wrote:On May 14 2011 11:46 Talin wrote:On May 14 2011 11:24 Hinanawi wrote:On May 14 2011 11:17 Talin wrote:On May 14 2011 11:06 Hinanawi wrote:On May 14 2011 11:03 Talin wrote:On May 14 2011 10:51 Hinanawi wrote:On May 14 2011 10:27 koreasilver wrote: Justice != Vengeance
itt, concrete examples of why and how the world froths around in an unquenchable rage. Vengeance is justice. I don't know where you all are getting the idea that it isn't, they're practically synonyms. Are you going to make an effort to prove that exact statement, or do you expect us to take your word for it? jus·tice/ˈjəstis/Noun 1. Just behavior or treatment. 2. The quality of being fair and reasonable. According to you, vengeance is synonymous to being fair and reasonable. Tell me, what does it mean 99.99% of the time when you hear that someone has been 'brought to justice'? Does it mean they got 'rehabilitated'? I'm also waiting on a response to my hypothetical scenario with the mind-reading machine. Vengeance is at least part of justice, and always has been. It may not mean they got "rehabilitated", but it means they were given a chance, and it means the state did not condone and commit cruelty that it punishes people for (in this specific example it's actually the EXACT same crime on both sides, except the latter case is state sanctioned crime). You can't punish somebody for committing an act you define as crime, and then commit that very same act and expect such a system to actually work out. This is silly. The exact same crime on both sides? Imagine someone kidnaps another person and makes them stay in a cell for a year. If you really believe what you said earlier, then you could say that the government is acting unjust by sending this man to jail, because they're 'just doing to him what he did to the other person' (locking him up in a cell). That analogy is awful (most analogies are). Jail is the "default" punishment for most serious crimes - because something has got to be. Claiming that it's analogous to deliberate retribution just because the crime happens to coincide exactly with what a pre-determined punishment is way off the mark. If that traditional "default" punishment for crimes would be sipping acid into the criminal's eye, it would actually be "better" (and I use better very liberally here, it's still inhuman) - if only because it doesn't promote the concept of vengeance. On May 14 2011 11:24 Hinanawi wrote: I have a feeling you're not being serious here. You can't really think that she's on the same moral level as him for making this decision? You can argue that it would be BETTER if she didn't do it, but she's really on the SAME level as him? You don't really believe this and calling it 'state-sanctioned crime' is borderline trolling. There's no need to have the feeling I'm not being serious. It's 4:30 AM and I'm posting in a thread which is literally painful to read. I can assure you that I'm dead serious, so there's no need to add redundant and pointless comments to your post. Just write your damn answer. I'm not saying she is on the same level with him - just like no two murders are "morally" on the exact same level either and for each individual case there are circumstances that might make it more or less understandable to do something. It's certainly easy to understand her decision, but the act is still the same - causing harm to another human being, and in a pretty cruel way at that, and in her case, state sanctioned. I'm not even bothered by her decision so much. I'm bothered by the laws that give her the right to make that decision and I'm bothered by the state that will strip people off their basic human rights as a punishment. As I said, in our part of the world (Europe and North America for the most part), people have guaranteed human rights that you can't legally suspend at will. If you disagree with this, then I'm afraid our problem is mostly the cultural differences - maybe you should consider moving to a culture that suits your preferences more. We don't even disagree that neither of us would want these laws in Europe or North America. Iran is not the same ballgame. You can't just paste Sweden's laws onto Iran and expect it to work. This is a gradual process, and this is a step up from before where men would do this shit and just get a slap on the wrist. I'm not even trying to pull a 'moral relativism' card here. I hope that one day Iran doesn't need to have laws like this, but for NOW, this is progress. You (and I don't mean YOU in particular, just everyone in this thread) can't sit comfy in your 1st-world country sipping tea talking about how those savages in the Middle East should just adopt our civilized legal system already. It doesn't work like that. What? I never argued that we should copy Sweden paste Iran at all, or anything similar. To me it seemed that a lot of people in this thread are arguing the opposite (in this specific case) - copy Iran paste Sweden (and everywhere else). Now admittedly I'm not reading the IDs of everyone I reply to, I mostly read just the post, so I can't put you in that lot - but there have been more than a few posts from various people hailing the fairness of this punishment and comparing it to the "inefficiency" of dealing with crime in the west.
We agree on this. I think our disagreement was on whether vengeance can be a part of justice, and I maintain that it can be.
|
Destroying a person's face with the intention of making the victim so disfigured that they will never find a new live partner again is a terrible crime. Similar in scale to rape or murder imo. Looks are important to people and this man was so jealous or spiteful that this woman would leave him that he felt it necessary to make sure she would never be attractive to someone again.
Al tough I do not agree with the punishment method of ''a eye for a eye'', I can understand the motives behind this woman's decision to let him go trough the same pain as he inflicted to her. If the punishment for this man would have been a lifelong prison sentence or the death penalty then I would find that the best solution but I suspect that this man would have been released again from prison after a certain amount of years under the sharia law, and that is why this woman chose this solution instead.
|
On May 14 2011 12:02 Days wrote: For all you people that say an eye for an eye makes everyone blind, let's say your whole family gets slaughtered and your wife gets raped right in front of you while your children are burned alive. Then the murderers somehow are caught and put right in front of your house tied with ropes. I'd like to see how many of you will keep following Gandhi after that.
i dont know how to reply to this. its like, you just dont get it. its not even that, you are so far from getting it, that i dont think you could ever be explained the basic concepts of how the western justice system works.
this is the whole reason we DONT let the victims choose the punishment. keeping a sensible, detached perspective is a cornerstone of our society. letting people emotionally involved in a situation make the judgements is basically the dumbest thing anyone can do, in any field.
|
On May 14 2011 12:02 Days wrote: For all you people that say an eye for an eye makes everyone blind, let's say your whole family gets slaughtered and your wife gets raped right in front of you while your children are burned alive. Then the murderers somehow are caught and put right in front of your house tied with ropes. I'd like to see how many of you will keep following Gandhi after that. No one is disputing that. That is why the jurisdiction shouldn't be handled by the victims. Retribution is not a good basis for a justice system.
|
The modern rejection of retribution isn't noble, its just pathetic. I would kill the man in her position.
|
Are people actually supporting an eye for an eye rofl? Two wrongs don't make a right. A negative number plus a negative number gives you a.. more negative number. Both parties end up worse off.
On May 14 2011 12:02 Days wrote: For all you people that say an eye for an eye makes everyone blind, let's say your whole family gets slaughtered and your wife gets raped right in front of you while your children are burned alive. Then the murderers somehow are caught and put right in front of your house tied with ropes. I'd like to see how many of you will keep following Gandhi after that. It's no secret that people's good judgement deteriorates in stressful situations. That's why we say things objectively now. To hope that we don't make the mistakes we might later on or that other people are there to stop us.
On May 14 2011 12:09 smokeyhoodoo wrote: The modern rejection of retribution isn't noble, its just pathetic. I would kill the man in her position. Though I guess some people might reside in a perpetual state of bad judgement:
|
On May 14 2011 12:09 smokeyhoodoo wrote: The modern rejection of retribution isn't noble, its just pathetic. I would kill the man in her position. That doesn't mean it should be done.
|
On May 14 2011 08:49 kerpal wrote:...makes the whole world blind -gandhi
Indeed. They have a justice system that was modern in the bronze age.
Edit. It's also interesting from a religious perspective, as most religious people are very much so into retribution, whereas every religious book in the world speaks of forgiveness.
|
On May 14 2011 12:10 Enervate wrote:Are people actually supporting an eye for an eye rofl? Two wrongs don't make a right. A negative number plus a negative number gives you a.. more negative number. Both parties end up worse off. Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 12:02 Days wrote: For all you people that say an eye for an eye makes everyone blind, let's say your whole family gets slaughtered and your wife gets raped right in front of you while your children are burned alive. Then the murderers somehow are caught and put right in front of your house tied with ropes. I'd like to see how many of you will keep following Gandhi after that. It's no secret that people's good judgement deteriorates in stressful situations. That's why we say things objectively now. To hope that we don't make the mistakes we might later on or that other people are there to stop us. Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 12:09 smokeyhoodoo wrote: The modern rejection of retribution isn't noble, its just pathetic. I would kill the man in her position. Though I guess some people might reside in a perpetual state of bad judgement:
It's in Iran, their justice system is already retarded. She already can only burn one of his eyes because a womans life is not worth as much as a mans there.
Let the woman have her retribution and be done with it. Only one additional person here is hurt, and it's the person who deserves it.
|
On May 14 2011 12:10 relyt wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 12:09 smokeyhoodoo wrote: The modern rejection of retribution isn't noble, its just pathetic. I would kill the man in her position. That doesn't mean it should be done.
What does that even mean? Seriously, I'm just baffled by this.
|
On May 14 2011 12:10 Enervate wrote: Are people actually supporting an eye for an eye rofl? Two wrongs don't make a right. A negative number plus a negative number gives you a.. more negative number. Both parties end up worse off.
On May 14 2011 12:14 Mailing wrote: Only one additional person here is hurt, and it's the person who deserves it.
Agreed, there are no two negatives in this scenario, just a victim and a perpetrator.
|
It may not be right, but I would have no problem whatsoever pouring acid in the face of somebody who did it to me. I actually think people who say they wouldn't exact revenge are the weirdos.
That being said, I am not sure it is a good practice to follow or not.
|
On May 14 2011 12:02 Days wrote: For all you people that say an eye for an eye makes everyone blind, let's say your whole family gets slaughtered and your wife gets raped right in front of you while your children are burned alive. Then the murderers somehow are caught and put right in front of your house tied with ropes. I'd like to see how many of you will keep following Gandhi after that.
Are you implying that people put in this situation would rape the criminals? Unless incited by a mob mentality I doubt many people in western culture would have it in them to kill or torture the criminals. Most likely they would ask the state to deal with them.
Do people really think western law is some mystical force that makes no sense and works only to defend criminals? Do you really think perpetuating a cycle of violence and breeding conditions that force ordinary citizens to make seriously life altering decisions under extraneous circumstances is good for a society or even that citizen?
|
|
|
|
|
|