|
On May 14 2011 11:10 Mailing wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 11:09 Talin wrote:On May 14 2011 11:02 HowitZer wrote: An eye for an eye makes the world go blind doesn't compute. One eye for one eye and the equation is solved. There's no chaining it to the rest of the population. The victim to the victim may disagree about that (in general terms). In this specific case even, the criminal even gets to walk away after being blinded, so what if the third eye to be taken is actually the girl's life? And then the guy's life? And then the life of girl's relatives? It's not some proverbial saying people throw around. It's a FACT in societies that sported this tradition known as blood feud that many seem to be promoting here. And it can chain over several generations. If in the Nation X, murder resulted in execution 100% of the time, do you think the rate of murder would be as high? y/n? That would be one additional murder per murderer. So, higher.
|
living in canada im sick of how little criminals get for what they do.
Those who decide they are above the law should not be protected by the law
|
Edit: Changed my mind. I'd rather not say silly stuff.
|
On May 14 2011 08:55 Hinanawi wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 08:49 kerpal wrote:On May 14 2011 08:46 Airship wrote: An eye for an eye. ...makes the whole world blind -gandhi In this case it actually only makes men who throw acid on women's faces blind, which I'm fine with to be honest.
Yes, but apply a system of revenge to a population, and the next thing you have is a warmongering nation. For every offence against the country, the population will want their righteous revenge. This may seem justified because what the criminal did was so horrid and unnecessary, but it shows just how immoral both parties are.
|
On May 14 2011 11:17 Talin wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 11:06 Hinanawi wrote:On May 14 2011 11:03 Talin wrote:On May 14 2011 10:51 Hinanawi wrote:On May 14 2011 10:27 koreasilver wrote: Justice != Vengeance
itt, concrete examples of why and how the world froths around in an unquenchable rage. Vengeance is justice. I don't know where you all are getting the idea that it isn't, they're practically synonyms. Are you going to make an effort to prove that exact statement, or do you expect us to take your word for it? jus·tice/ˈjəstis/Noun 1. Just behavior or treatment. 2. The quality of being fair and reasonable. According to you, vengeance is synonymous to being fair and reasonable. Tell me, what does it mean 99.99% of the time when you hear that someone has been 'brought to justice'? Does it mean they got 'rehabilitated'? I'm also waiting on a response to my hypothetical scenario with the mind-reading machine. Vengeance is at least part of justice, and always has been. It may not mean they got "rehabilitated", but it means they were given a chance, and it means the state did not condone and commit cruelty that it punishes people for (in this specific example it's actually the EXACT same crime on both sides, except the latter case is state sanctioned crime). You can't punish somebody for committing an act you define as crime, and then commit that very same act and expect such a system to actually work out.
This is silly. The exact same crime on both sides? Imagine someone kidnaps another person and makes them stay in a cell for a year. If you really believe what you said earlier, then you could say that the government is acting unjust by sending this man to jail, because they're 'just doing to him what he did to the other person' (locking him up in a cell).
I have a feeling you're not being serious here. You can't really think that she's on the same moral level as him for making this decision? You can argue that it would be BETTER if she didn't do it, but she's really on the SAME level as him? You don't really believe this and calling it 'state-sanctioned crime' is borderline trolling.
|
That's disgusting. Creeps me out thinking someone would would get pleasure from pouring acid in someones eye, no matter what they did.
|
On May 14 2011 11:18 Djzapz wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 11:10 Mailing wrote:On May 14 2011 11:09 Talin wrote:On May 14 2011 11:02 HowitZer wrote: An eye for an eye makes the world go blind doesn't compute. One eye for one eye and the equation is solved. There's no chaining it to the rest of the population. The victim to the victim may disagree about that (in general terms). In this specific case even, the criminal even gets to walk away after being blinded, so what if the third eye to be taken is actually the girl's life? And then the guy's life? And then the life of girl's relatives? It's not some proverbial saying people throw around. It's a FACT in societies that sported this tradition known as blood feud that many seem to be promoting here. And it can chain over several generations. If in the Nation X, murder resulted in execution 100% of the time, do you think the rate of murder would be as high? y/n? That would be one additional murder per murderer. So, higher.
But the new murders to come will decrease. Gradually, if thinking of long term goals, the murders will decrease 
oh and PPV would be awesome. George Carlin would be proud!
|
On May 14 2011 11:10 Mailing wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 11:09 Talin wrote:On May 14 2011 11:02 HowitZer wrote: An eye for an eye makes the world go blind doesn't compute. One eye for one eye and the equation is solved. There's no chaining it to the rest of the population. The victim to the victim may disagree about that (in general terms). In this specific case even, the criminal even gets to walk away after being blinded, so what if the third eye to be taken is actually the girl's life? And then the guy's life? And then the life of girl's relatives? It's not some proverbial saying people throw around. It's a FACT in societies that sported this tradition known as blood feud that many seem to be promoting here. And it can chain over several generations. If in the Nation X, murder resulted in execution 100% of the time, do you think the rate of murder would be as high? y/n?
In theory, the rate of murder in such a nation would be lower.
In practice, a nation running on such principles if it even existed would likely descend to anarchy or be the most perfect tyrannical state to date (either way, not a very nice place to live).
In reality, execution IS murder and a state which commits the same acts that it punishes people for as a general principle isn't realistic or viable.
And even if we consider only the simple theoretical consequence (that you kind of based your question around) and it would reduce the murder rate, it would STILL not be an acceptable solution. Because civilized societies do not decide policies based only on efficiency. We'd never have democracies if that was the case.
|
[B]On May 14 2011 11:26 aimaimaim wrote: But the new murders to come will decrease. Gradually, if thinking of long term goals, the murders will decrease  oh and PPV would be awesome. George Carlin would be proud! 
If this system is in function and i kill someone in a fit of rage og during temporary insanity, i know i'm gonna die. So what do i do? I kill every fucker that ever hurt me or my family, the punishment wouldn't scale anyway.
Seriously, this is a stupid idea and only something people would do in places like that. Chances are she won't feel better, quite possibly worse, and so will everyone watching it take place. No matter how sedated it'll be a gruesome thing to watch and i don't see any reason to scar people with stuff like that. Throw him in jail for 5 years, done and done.
|
On May 14 2011 11:24 Hinanawi wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 11:17 Talin wrote:On May 14 2011 11:06 Hinanawi wrote:On May 14 2011 11:03 Talin wrote:On May 14 2011 10:51 Hinanawi wrote:On May 14 2011 10:27 koreasilver wrote: Justice != Vengeance
itt, concrete examples of why and how the world froths around in an unquenchable rage. Vengeance is justice. I don't know where you all are getting the idea that it isn't, they're practically synonyms. Are you going to make an effort to prove that exact statement, or do you expect us to take your word for it? jus·tice/ˈjəstis/Noun 1. Just behavior or treatment. 2. The quality of being fair and reasonable. According to you, vengeance is synonymous to being fair and reasonable. Tell me, what does it mean 99.99% of the time when you hear that someone has been 'brought to justice'? Does it mean they got 'rehabilitated'? I'm also waiting on a response to my hypothetical scenario with the mind-reading machine. Vengeance is at least part of justice, and always has been. It may not mean they got "rehabilitated", but it means they were given a chance, and it means the state did not condone and commit cruelty that it punishes people for (in this specific example it's actually the EXACT same crime on both sides, except the latter case is state sanctioned crime). You can't punish somebody for committing an act you define as crime, and then commit that very same act and expect such a system to actually work out.
This is silly. The exact same crime on both sides? Imagine someone kidnaps another person and makes them stay in a cell for a year. If you really believe what you said earlier, then you could say that the government is acting unjust by sending this man to jail, because they're 'just doing to him what he did to the other person' (locking him up in a cell).
I have a feeling you're not being serious here. You can't really think that she's on the same moral level as him for making this decision? You can argue that it would be BETTER if she didn't do it, but she's really on the SAME level as him? You don't really believe this and calling it 'state-sanctioned crime' is borderline trolling.
On May 14 2011 11:23 Tdelamay wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 08:55 Hinanawi wrote:On May 14 2011 08:49 kerpal wrote:On May 14 2011 08:46 Airship wrote: An eye for an eye. ...makes the whole world blind -gandhi In this case it actually only makes men who throw acid on women's faces blind, which I'm fine with to be honest. Yes, but apply a system of revenge to a population, and the next thing you have is a warmongering nation. For every offence against the country, the population will want their righteous revenge. This may seem justified because what the criminal did was so horrid and unnecessary, but it shows just how immoral both parties are.
This just doesn't follow. The only way this would follow is if people had no faith in the justice system, and thought that most people being punished were actually innocent. If for example my friend did something terrible like this to a woman and he had to have the same done to him, I would be very sad but I wouldn't seek vengeance on them, if my friend (ex-friend at this point) really did such a thing then he deserves it.
What you're basically saying is "Our civilized country doesn't do this, and see, it works just fine here!" The Middle East is not Canada. Sweden is not the United States. Did the chicken come first, or the egg? Do you have lenient criminal justice systems because of low crime, or low crime because of lenient criminal justice systems?
Are you naive enough to think that you could just apply the laws of a country like Sweden to every country in the world and it would just work everywhere?
|
I don't think punishment cause crime rates to lower. The chance of being caught does.
|
On May 14 2011 11:28 Aelip wrote:Show nested quote +[B]On May 14 2011 11:26 aimaimaim wrote: But the new murders to come will decrease. Gradually, if thinking of long term goals, the murders will decrease  oh and PPV would be awesome. George Carlin would be proud!  If this system is in function and i kill someone in a fit of rage og during temporary insanity, i know i'm gonna die. So what do i do? I kill every fucker that ever hurt me or my family, the punishment wouldn't scale anyway. Seriously, this is a stupid idea and only something people would do in places like that. Chances are she won't feel better, quite possibly worse, and so will everyone watching it take place. No matter how sedated it'll be a gruesome thing to watch and i don't see any reason to scar people with stuff like that. Throw him in jail for 5 years, done and done.
i would hardly call it temporary if that were the case
|
On May 14 2011 11:26 aimaimaim wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 11:18 Djzapz wrote:On May 14 2011 11:10 Mailing wrote:On May 14 2011 11:09 Talin wrote:On May 14 2011 11:02 HowitZer wrote: An eye for an eye makes the world go blind doesn't compute. One eye for one eye and the equation is solved. There's no chaining it to the rest of the population. The victim to the victim may disagree about that (in general terms). In this specific case even, the criminal even gets to walk away after being blinded, so what if the third eye to be taken is actually the girl's life? And then the guy's life? And then the life of girl's relatives? It's not some proverbial saying people throw around. It's a FACT in societies that sported this tradition known as blood feud that many seem to be promoting here. And it can chain over several generations. If in the Nation X, murder resulted in execution 100% of the time, do you think the rate of murder would be as high? y/n? That would be one additional murder per murderer. So, higher. But the new murders to come will decrease. Gradually, if thinking of long term goals, the murders will decrease  oh and PPV would be awesome. George Carlin would be proud!  Would it counterbalance it? Would it really work? I don't think it would, first off. Plus, that punishment is such a bad thing...
I mean, you could also kill the criminal's family and then crime would become nearly inexistent... Cool, but you live in barbaric nation... Not worth it IMO.
|
i like this
"what happened to to your face?"
"i threw acid on a woman who rejected me so she did it back"
"oic"
|
Hmm, I don't know what to think about this, personally, i would've taken the money, seeing as retaliation brings me no personal gain.
On a semi related note i like how Hammurabi's code is famous for the "eye for an eye" philosophy, yet i think one of the first laws in it says that if you steal a goat, than you must give the goat back... then die.
|
Interesting how people continue to spew out "retribution is not justice" here. In many cases youre right, but in this case it is exactly justice. It might not be the best course of action and of course its not humanitarian in any way, but its balance aka justice. If a guy kills someone with intent, are you saying that he doesnt deserve the exact same thing that he dished out? He denied someone the right to life, how is it not "justice" that he is also denied the right to life? The man in the OP blinded the woman out of spite, why should he have the right to clear vision?
Yeah yeah, all of the carebears will come out and say that its wrong or amoral. Im not arguing that. Im saying that justice is balance. An eye for an eye is balance. It may be cruel and I agree that we should not go down that primitive path, but dont deny that this is justice. We have a better justice system in that we take the high road and look to the good of society, but how can you say that a man being blinded for deliberately blinding someone else is not justice?
|
If prison as a deterrent and rehabilitation as a justice system worked, we wouldn't have as many crimes committed. If this kind of sentencing actually did cause a noticeable decline in related crimes then it's clear that a system can be achieved to lower crime further than just "go to prison".
If an ideal, lowest-crime world isn't what you'd argue for, then you must be arguing for justice.
Is justice completely divorced from the suffering of victims? What are we "making right" then? Fixing a broken gear in the machine of our local society? How is that fair or reasonable? It's utopian.
That's where my personal feelings differ, at least. If somebody took my eyesight and ruined my face for the rest of my life, you can bet that the government whisking them away into a cell to be fed and looked after wouldn't satisfy me. They are removed from my life and confined - that is all. If I was going to want that, I'd have wanted it before they disfigured me. Afterwards I want to witness justice, and hey, to me that's have somebody do it to my attacker.
Going by the definition fair or reasonable? Justice is subjective.
|
On May 14 2011 11:26 aimaimaim wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 11:18 Djzapz wrote:On May 14 2011 11:10 Mailing wrote:On May 14 2011 11:09 Talin wrote:On May 14 2011 11:02 HowitZer wrote: An eye for an eye makes the world go blind doesn't compute. One eye for one eye and the equation is solved. There's no chaining it to the rest of the population. The victim to the victim may disagree about that (in general terms). In this specific case even, the criminal even gets to walk away after being blinded, so what if the third eye to be taken is actually the girl's life? And then the guy's life? And then the life of girl's relatives? It's not some proverbial saying people throw around. It's a FACT in societies that sported this tradition known as blood feud that many seem to be promoting here. And it can chain over several generations. If in the Nation X, murder resulted in execution 100% of the time, do you think the rate of murder would be as high? y/n? That would be one additional murder per murderer. So, higher. But the new murders to come will decrease. Gradually, if thinking of long term goals, the murders will decrease  oh and PPV would be awesome. George Carlin would be proud! 
Except actually no, not really.
There's a soft limit on where increasing the punishment further doesn't really do any good. Even if you put the death penalty on every crime you would only see a slight decrease in most of them. At least until you've executed all the "baddies" (most of the population).
Take this in to consideration before responding:
On May 14 2011 11:30 relyt wrote: I don't think punishment cause crime rates to lower. The chance of being caught does.
|
On May 14 2011 11:30 Kyuukyuu wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 11:28 Aelip wrote:[B]On May 14 2011 11:26 aimaimaim wrote: But the new murders to come will decrease. Gradually, if thinking of long term goals, the murders will decrease  oh and PPV would be awesome. George Carlin would be proud!  If this system is in function and i kill someone in a fit of rage og during temporary insanity, i know i'm gonna die. So what do i do? I kill every fucker that ever hurt me or my family, the punishment wouldn't scale anyway. Seriously, this is a stupid idea and only something people would do in places like that. Chances are she won't feel better, quite possibly worse, and so will everyone watching it take place. No matter how sedated it'll be a gruesome thing to watch and i don't see any reason to scar people with stuff like that. Throw him in jail for 5 years, done and done. i would hardly call it temporary if that were the case
It would be temporary insanity, the rest would be rational thinking.
Though hardly the point of my post~
Unrelated note: Imagine if she missed due to being blind, that'd be bloody hilarious.
|
Degenerative middle aged justice system. I'm not religious but I feel strongly that this isn't the right punishment and will only lead to more problems.
|
|
|
|
|
|