|
On May 14 2011 10:27 Blasterion wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 10:26 Djzapz wrote:On May 14 2011 10:23 Blasterion wrote:On May 14 2011 10:19 Djzapz wrote:On May 14 2011 08:47 jstar wrote: I like that legal system. I think you can tell a lot about a person when they condone the inhumane way people are "punished" in dictatorships and totalitarian governments. Very inferior, in my opinion. I think you can tell alot about a person when they let someone who commit inhumance acts on other people and only live in jail for a few years where he'll be fed and housed on the taxpayer's money. Very unproductive, in my opinion As opposed to mutilating them and letting them roam freely in society? Pathetic. Unproductive? This is unproductive as hell. As opposed to letting him get away and able to hurt other people hell yeah it's productive. Instead of housing him and feeding him with taxpaper money? Pathetic Are you feeling OK or is nonsense just the way your brain works? Prison, especially in those islamic countries, isn't a field day - it sucks big time. Also it keeps them from hurting anybody. Pretty sure he keeps his ability to hurt people if he's not incarcerated. Not that you would care, I guess. You just like your gore.
|
I have to say, one of the oddest things from this thread is people who seem to use some variant of the following line of reasoning:
- Acid in eye system might be a deterrent - System in country X might not be - Therefore acid in eye system is the solution
Just because some system somewhere sucks, doesn't mean a terrible system is therefore a good thing. It just means that if you're correct about the penal system in country X not being good enough, then maybe both systems need changing. It should in no way be a basis for supporting barbarism.
|
On May 14 2011 10:30 Djzapz wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 10:27 Blasterion wrote:On May 14 2011 10:26 Djzapz wrote:On May 14 2011 10:23 Blasterion wrote:On May 14 2011 10:19 Djzapz wrote:On May 14 2011 08:47 jstar wrote: I like that legal system. I think you can tell a lot about a person when they condone the inhumane way people are "punished" in dictatorships and totalitarian governments. Very inferior, in my opinion. I think you can tell alot about a person when they let someone who commit inhumance acts on other people and only live in jail for a few years where he'll be fed and housed on the taxpayer's money. Very unproductive, in my opinion As opposed to mutilating them and letting them roam freely in society? Pathetic. Unproductive? This is unproductive as hell. As opposed to letting him get away and able to hurt other people hell yeah it's productive. Instead of housing him and feeding him with taxpaper money? Pathetic Are you feeling OK or is nonsense just the way your brain works? Prison, especially in those islamic countries, isn't a field day - it sucks big time. Also it keeps them from hurting anybody. Pretty sure he keeps his ability to hurt people if he's not incarcerated. Not that you would care, I guess. You just like your gore. Like I said, this is a meh solution. If you read and quoted my entire post I said the most productive solution is to have them to unwanted and unpaid labor. So they contribute shit for shit they did.
|
On May 14 2011 10:30 Iyerbeth wrote: I have to say, one of the oddest things from this thread is people who seem to use some variant of the following line of logic:
- Acid in eye system might be a deterrent - System in country X might not be - Therefore acid in eye system is the solution
Just because some system somewhere sucks, doesn't mean a terrible system is therefore a good thing. It just means that if you're correct about the penal system in country X not being good enough, then maybe both systems need changing. It should in no way be a basis for supporting barbarism. Seriously though, that's not logic. That's some form of reasoning if you want to call it that, but not logic.
|
They're not assholes, they are human beings. There are reasons why we don't use such logic in civilized societies. In civilized societies there are such things as laws and justice system so we don't have to depend on primitive emotions and hatred to make decisions.
There is nothing even remotely good or positive about this. I'm shocked by the reactions in this thread, although I suppose I shouldn't be, after that thread about caning recently.
Look on the bright side, in cases of conviction, the guilty party has the right of appeal to the victim's "primitive emotions" for clemency. It basically permits the victimised party vast judicial powers over those who are found guilty of having wronged them. The majority of the Middle East (and Asia, for that matter,) depend on people more than institutions, and this is not even a very radical representation of that.
For a contemporary whiff of something equally daunting in our own society, look at the prodigious volume of child and spousal abuse in East Asian families, even among immigrants in North America. Now when have you last heard of a Chinese-American get arrested for abusing his wife or kids? Neither of them will whisper a peep to any authority beyond close confidants; for what goes on in the tribe, is resolved in the tribe.
|
hell knows no fury like a woman scorned.
|
On May 14 2011 10:34 Djzapz wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 10:30 Iyerbeth wrote: I have to say, one of the oddest things from this thread is people who seem to use some variant of the following line of logic:
- Acid in eye system might be a deterrent - System in country X might not be - Therefore acid in eye system is the solution
Just because some system somewhere sucks, doesn't mean a terrible system is therefore a good thing. It just means that if you're correct about the penal system in country X not being good enough, then maybe both systems need changing. It should in no way be a basis for supporting barbarism. Seriously though, that's not logic. That's some form of reasoning if you want to call it that, but not logic.
It's half two in the morning so yeah...fair point. I know what I meant though. 
Edit: Also, yeah fixed it.
|
I like the solution and looking at her pictures, she looks absolutely AWFUL afterwards, to the point where the rest of her entire life is likely to be ruined (and possibly depressed). If I could, I'd choose the acid route as well.
|
On May 14 2011 10:01 Blasterion wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 09:56 PITN wrote:On May 14 2011 09:49 Blasterion wrote:On May 14 2011 09:48 PITN wrote: This is revolting. Shows just how 'civilized' Sharia law is, and why we don't want it in the west. If civilized means having criminals living a life off my tax dollars that I spent my hour earning, I don't want to be civilized. Prefer to just bury them in a pit somewhere, then aleast you don't have to feed them. It's like being supply capped with useless units. What do you do? get rid of supply. Criminals are just dead weights to society. Fuck them. Actually.... I take that back, cuz Killing them takes money. Like paying the guys that dig the pit. Make them slave off time. At least then they're some what productive Yeah, lets just blind the criminals like she is doing, then he'll be a productive member of society. typical right-wing bullshit here, with no plausible real solution, nothing new to see. Much more productive than he has been. He's just a dead weight, tell me. What can a criminal, a danger to society. Contribute? He'll go around acid other women. And hurt society more. Like I said, from an economic view it's not a good idea. But it's still good to set an example
You assume that people cannot be rehabilitated, that they cannot learn that their destructive behaviour is not good for society, or them. Setting examples through punitive measures does not work, and has never worked. The death penalty is a pretty good example. The US is the only country in the West that has the death penalty, and yet it still has a homicide rate far above other western nations. From an economic point of view, it is better to try an rehabilitate people and NOT lock them up for the rest of their lives, because they can then become a productive member of society. Your view on criminals is bizarre.
|
Those who are saying that this is completely barbaric, I agree completely. But we are finally making progress. Most cases like this resulted in the man going free. However, that still does not make the sentence right.
|
On May 14 2011 10:12 Armut wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 09:57 Talin wrote:On May 14 2011 09:30 Thermia wrote: While a few assholes who deserve it might suffer, in the long run everyone else benefits. They're not assholes, they are human beings. There are reasons why we don't use such logic in civilized societies. In civilized societies there are such things as laws and justice system so we don't have to depend on primitive emotions and hatred to make decisions. There is nothing even remotely good or positive about this. I'm shocked by the reactions in this thread, although I suppose I shouldn't be, after that thread about caning recently. Do you guys even understand what humanity is all about? Just because the world didn't turn out to be the nicest fluffy place imaginable doesn't mean that devising some sick rationale and descending even further into cruelty and barbarism will somehow magically fix it by making everyone scared. You're only making it worse. Come talk here when you eye is blinded by someone by acid completaly unrightfully. I am not supporthing this but your "civilization" won't help you when you are in that women's condition.
Why are you making it so personal, though? I mean, what is saying "come talk when it happens to YOU" really supposed to accomplish? You're trying to force the subject to a more emotional and personal level, which is IMO the wrong way to look at it.
Sure I'd get emotional and obviously a lot more angry and vindictive if it happened to me or somebody close to me. But that would only mean my judgement would be clouded under such circumstances and that the state court should most definitely NOT ask me to be the judge in the case.
I do sympathize with victims as much as the next guy, but not to the point where I would condone cruelty (effectively the same thing victims suffered in the first place - except now there are two victims instead of one), and inhumane ideology that is even worse than the cruelty itself (that has been promoted in a few posts in this thread).
|
It's good to see we haven't intellectually or culturally surpassed wanton bloodshed, violence and retribution for the enjoyment for all to watch.
Bring back the Colosseum and throw the poor in there to fight to the death. Winner gets free healthcare for a month.
|
The deterrent argument is ridiculous. Why don't we kill the next person who steals? You'd surely see a drop in thefts. Doesn't mean it's the right course of action. This doesn't make her any better than the perpetrator, not that I particularly feel sorry for him.
|
On May 14 2011 10:34 Djzapz wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 10:30 Iyerbeth wrote: I have to say, one of the oddest things from this thread is people who seem to use some variant of the following line of logic:
- Acid in eye system might be a deterrent - System in country X might not be - Therefore acid in eye system is the solution
Just because some system somewhere sucks, doesn't mean a terrible system is therefore a good thing. It just means that if you're correct about the penal system in country X not being good enough, then maybe both systems need changing. It should in no way be a basis for supporting barbarism. Seriously though, that's not logic. That's some form of reasoning if you want to call it that, but not logic.
Logic is a structure system, it doesn't have to do with the contents of a statement, literally speaking. Logical validity and soundness are different things.
|
On May 14 2011 10:43 Talin wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 10:12 Armut wrote:On May 14 2011 09:57 Talin wrote:On May 14 2011 09:30 Thermia wrote: While a few assholes who deserve it might suffer, in the long run everyone else benefits. They're not assholes, they are human beings. There are reasons why we don't use such logic in civilized societies. In civilized societies there are such things as laws and justice system so we don't have to depend on primitive emotions and hatred to make decisions. There is nothing even remotely good or positive about this. I'm shocked by the reactions in this thread, although I suppose I shouldn't be, after that thread about caning recently. Do you guys even understand what humanity is all about? Just because the world didn't turn out to be the nicest fluffy place imaginable doesn't mean that devising some sick rationale and descending even further into cruelty and barbarism will somehow magically fix it by making everyone scared. You're only making it worse. Come talk here when you eye is blinded by someone by acid completaly unrightfully. I am not supporthing this but your "civilization" won't help you when you are in that women's condition. Sure I'd get emotional and obviously a lot more angry and vindictive if it happened to me or somebody close to me. But that would only mean my judgement would be clouded under such circumstances and that the state court should most definitely NOT ask me to be the judge in the case. I absolutely agree. The government shouldn't "avenge" people. Justice and vengeance are very different. I can't condemn her for picking that option, personally. I think the government just can't offer something like that.
|
I'm sure he deserves it. If he can pay nothing, she gains nothing from sending him to jail. If she blinds him, she does. It may not be monetary, but I'm sure she'll be fairly satisfied.
|
Imagine how the guy must feel. The impending doom of knowing you're going blind in a few hours.
The woman will now share the same guilt her assailant does for the reminder of her life. And how will she get through with it? I can't possibly imagine someone dropping 20 drops of acid in someone else's eyes keeping a straight face on. Things will get nasty and gory. She's got to be very deranged.
|
So many Canadians thinking that way...
I'm ashamed right now. How can I share this landmass with you?
|
An eye for an eye is justice. You can call it many things, but you can't say it's not just.
|
On May 14 2011 10:27 koreasilver wrote: Justice != Vengeance
itt, concrete examples of why and how the world froths around in an unquenchable rage.
Vengeance is justice. I don't know where you all are getting the idea that it isn't, they're practically synonyms.
You could argue that she would 'be the better person' by forgiving him (and I would certainly be very moved by such forgiveness), but that's called compassion and forgiveness, not justice. Justice is exactly what she's going to do here, and I'm not going to cry about it.
I also find the line a bit blurry here. Sending someone to prison isn't vengeance? Yes it is. Don't believe me? Imagine there was a machine that could read someone's mind and see if they were 'rehabilitated' (i.e. wouldn't commit a crime again). If someone threw acid on a woman's face like this, and he regretted it afterwards and the machine proved that he would never do it again, EVERY SINGLE COUNTRY would still send him to jail for at least some time. Yes Swedes, even your country.
|
|
|
|
|
|