|
On May 14 2011 09:57 Talin wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 09:30 Thermia wrote: While a few assholes who deserve it might suffer, in the long run everyone else benefits. They're not assholes, they are human beings. There are reasons why we don't use such logic in civilized societies. In civilized societies there are such things as laws and justice system so we don't have to depend on primitive emotions and hatred to make decisions. There is nothing even remotely good or positive about this. I'm shocked by the reactions in this thread, although I suppose I shouldn't be, after that thread about caning recently. Do you guys even understand what humanity is all about? Just because the world didn't turn out to be the nicest fluffy place imaginable doesn't mean that devising some sick rationale and descending even further into cruelty and barbarism will somehow magically fix it by making everyone scared. You're only making it worse.
Come talk here when you eye is blinded by someone by acid completaly unrightfully.
I am not supporthing this but your "civilization" won't help you when you are in that women's condition.
|
I dont see this guy as a human. When a dog is so out of control it bites a human it gets put down like the crazed animal it is. When a dog acts normal, and doesnt bite anyone its treated with respect and love. When a human being throws acid into another humans face over something as petty as jealousy then he's not acting like a human he's acting like an animal, and will be treated as such. He waived his right to sympathy when he made the consious decision to solve his problems with a face full of acid. Its not exactly the healthiest way for this woman to cope with her trauma but she's the one with the disfigured face, so its rightfully her call.
Besides maybe selling some Pay-per-view tickets can help raise a lil money towards our national debt O.o you never know
|
"An eye for an eye makes the whole world blind." -Ghandi (If everyone doesn't already know that quote)
Not really much to say other than that because of the simple fact that revenge is a dead end and there isn't really going to be anything positive coming out of this. The whole situation is terrible because this innocent girl had her life absolutely ruined by what he did. He absolutely deserves it but acting revenge isn't the correct moral decision.
|
Is disfigurement by acid a big problem? That's horrible.
|
I like this system better than the system that gave a man only 9 years for raping his 14 year old daughter.
|
Everyone just think of it as this, you get acid thrown at your face, just the pain from the acid melting your face away would be unbearable, some of you are telling me that if you had the option to get payback you wouldnt? You wouldn't want them to feel the pain you felt? Its like the countries where you steal shit you get your hand chopped off. If someone threw acid at my face I would want my payback, and for all of you who don't think you would do it, trust me you would change your mind if it actually happened to you.
eye for an eye is the correct term here, ghandi was a peace activist, sure he did good things, but his "the whole world would be blind" doesn't seem to fit for every single thing out there.
|
Any legal system that is based on personal revenge is useless to organized society. Ofcourse I have zero sympathy with the retard who gets the punishment.
In a sensible legal system he gets jail and is forced to pay or some reasonable punishment. She still has all the options in the world to exact revenge and throw acid in his eyes when he comes out of jail and then she gets time in prison too. As it should be.
It is ridiculous that a state should be offering the tools of vengeance to people, it is not in the interest of the state. Why should government spend money to let her recommit his crime but under legal amnsesty?
Sure take revenge if you want I don't care. But states should not have the duty of helping people exact revenge on others.
|
I can't condone the punishment, and I would not want this kind of law governing me. That said, I completely understand why the woman would make this choice and have no sympathy for the poor SOB who's getting an acid face punishment either. With any luck any other idiots out there will think twice before they decide to do such a disfiguring crime.
|
On May 14 2011 08:47 jstar wrote: I like that legal system. I think you can tell a lot about a person when they condone the inhumane way people are "punished" in dictatorships and totalitarian governments. Very inferior, in my opinion.
I understand the woman's choice in some ways but I sure as hell wouldn't want my government to perform those kinds of punishments (or anything even remotely close) with my tax money. That's disgusting. Many people need to realize that we don't live in the dark ages anymore. Maybe you do, but I don't.
|
On May 14 2011 08:47 jstar wrote: I like that legal system.
http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2011/may/13/iran-blind-criminal-acid
Iranian media have reported that Movahedi will be blinded in both eyes but Bahrami, in an interview in 2009, said that the man would be blinded only in one eye because "each man is worth two women" under Iranian law.
|
i really hope she goes through with it.
and hes lucky thats all he gets
|
You people sicken me
Sometimes i wish that all the people who want to hurt each other and enact their constant revenge game would just group up together and leave the rest of the world alone
Buddism teaches us that when people break the rules that we have in our head of them, we feel anger and hate. We cannot directly control what other people feel about us, only what we feel for others. By showing compassion, we bring ourselves to better society. We create the justice system to rehabilitate criminals as part of a civilized society.
Enacting violent punishment of this manner simply does not solve anything, but only brings more anger and hate onto the world.
|
On May 14 2011 10:19 Djzapz wrote:I think you can tell a lot about a person when they condone the inhumane way people are "punished" in dictatorships and totalitarian governments. Very inferior, in my opinion. I think you can tell alot about a person when they let someone who commit inhumance acts on other people and only live in jail for a few years where he'll be fed and housed on the taxpayer's money. Very unproductive, in my opinion. I bet you paymore tax dollars that go to feeding criminals then your children's christmas presents. So tell me, you're paying more towards criminals than your children's happiness. Does that make sense?
|
On May 14 2011 10:23 Blasterion wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 10:19 Djzapz wrote:On May 14 2011 08:47 jstar wrote: I like that legal system. I think you can tell a lot about a person when they condone the inhumane way people are "punished" in dictatorships and totalitarian governments. Very inferior, in my opinion. I think you can tell alot about a person when they let someone who commit inhumance acts on other people and only live in jail for a few years where he'll be fed and housed on the taxpayer's money. Very unproductive, in my opinion As opposed to mutilating them and letting them roam freely in society? Pathetic. Unproductive? This is unproductive as hell.
This thread is going to be filled with (relatively) civilized people like myself being outraged about people who are fine with barbaric and medieval inhumane BS. You people are sickening.
|
The state is the people, and the interests of the state are the interest of the people, and if the interests of the people are to get back at this sub-human ass hole then they have a right to do it.
Beside our justice system is really bad as it is. At best its faulty, slow and weak. Its obviously way better than sharia but lets be serious here. Does anyone here actually believe that if this happened in america this guy would even get half of what he deserves? haha no he wouldn't. He would probably get a few years TOPS, while she goes the rest of her natural life blind.
|
I don't understand why you could have sympathy for this guy. I disregard his right to happiness because he gave up that right by dissolving half the face of a woman. Now let him get half his face off for his rash act. They felt the same exact emotion, anger for what just happened. Boom.
|
Justice != Vengeance
itt, concrete examples of why and how the world froths around in an unquenchable rage.
|
On May 14 2011 10:26 Djzapz wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 10:23 Blasterion wrote:On May 14 2011 10:19 Djzapz wrote:On May 14 2011 08:47 jstar wrote: I like that legal system. I think you can tell a lot about a person when they condone the inhumane way people are "punished" in dictatorships and totalitarian governments. Very inferior, in my opinion. I think you can tell alot about a person when they let someone who commit inhumance acts on other people and only live in jail for a few years where he'll be fed and housed on the taxpayer's money. Very unproductive, in my opinion As opposed to mutilating them and letting them roam freely in society? Pathetic. Unproductive? This is unproductive as hell. As opposed to letting him get away and able to hurt other people hell yeah it's productive. Instead of housing him and feeding him with taxpaper money? Pathetic
|
sometimes something so outrageous happens I am left more curious than shocked. What was going through his mind when he chose such a crazy unconventional way to attack her? What was going through the mind of the people passing judgement? When things go this crazy, everybody walks away worse for wear. I hope she finds a better way to make peace with this tragedy.
|
On May 14 2011 10:22 BrTarolg wrote: You people sicken me
Sometimes i wish that all the people who want to hurt each other and enact their constant revenge game would just group up together and leave the rest of the world alone
Buddism teaches us that when people break the rules that we have in our head of them, we feel anger and hate. We cannot directly control what other people feel about us, only what we feel for others. By showing compassion, we bring ourselves to better society. We create the justice system to rehabilitate criminals as part of a civilized society.
Enacting violent punishment of this manner simply does not solve anything, but only brings more anger and hate onto the world.
Except society is not as civilized as any of us hope it to be. What message should be condoned then? I am Buddhist too, but spiritually I may have died a while ago. What can we do to teach people that doing such things are wrong? And if they know it's wrong and are just laughing at us, what can we do to make them stop?
It's moving for sure when people forgive others. But I'm sure without this sentence, this man would never have learned. He would have been praised by other people in jail. A simple petty fine would not do ANY sort of justice. As I suggested earlier, let this man be her workhorse. If he doesn't kill her that is.
|
|
|
|
|
|