|
Netherlands45349 Posts
On May 14 2011 09:36 nalgene wrote:Urine---> Extract WP ---> use WP on guy... Couldn't she just extract money from the guy in payment? They do have mechanical eyes now, at least in research. Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 09:16 Reaper9 wrote: @ Parnage. Yet there was the thread about the man who was tortured for 28 years in our fabulous American prison system. Justice indeed. He killed like 3 people with one being a prison guard... he was dangerous to the people who worked their, too, and locked him away with 4 years being solitary and the other 24 in a normal jail cell...
He can't pay it, The OP refers to this.
|
Not sure what to think of this..
|
Retribution doesn't make it better!
Stop trying to change the topic to how flawed my nations system of justice is just for a moment and try to understand the point I am trying to get across.
You can't condone this, and then ignore everything else that goes with this style of justice. It's not imposing my world view if I feel that hey you should not throw acid into a guy's eyes even if he did it to someone else. It should be common sense that this isn't a good way to hand out justice. You can't bring back that persons sight of remove her disfigurement by doing this, she gets this and then nothing. Is it worth it?
Victims need to be compensated and have a sense of normalcy restored I don't think you are quite understanding this. If you had a choice of torturing a guy who hurts you or just never being hurt which one would you choose? This isn't justice guys this is just retribution and retribution only hurts more people. It doesn't make things better, it doesn't stop it from happening(as has been stated already) and it just feels like a short term solution.
|
On May 14 2011 09:33 Drium wrote: Crimes against women like this happen all the time in Iran and go unpunished, and the western world doesn't notice.
Now finally something is being done to punish them, and the western world is outraged?
Give me a break, there is certainly a humanitarian crisis here, but it's not the punishment. Harsher punishments are a band-aid solution. We don't have laws like this and we don't have the sort of violence found in the middle east. It's the culture that has to change.
I feel no sympathy for the man and I can't really condemn the decision of the woman; regardless, I feel as though it is a barbaric law that should be abolished.
|
This is a difficult situation to try and defend/condone. I am sure she is only exacting this punishment as a deterrent to other men who think this is an acceptable response to rejection. Do i think its just though? Well i cant decide. Lets say it happened in my country, i guess the offender would recieve a punishment of <5 years in a cell with a playstation, tv, mobile phone, meals worth 5x the value of a school meal. Is this just? I am more certain that this isnt.
|
On May 14 2011 09:29 crms wrote: Clearly this type of justice is archaic and doesn't have a place in modern society.
Having said that if this was done to my girlfriend or any of my loved ones, some acid in his eye would be the least of his worries. If I put myself in her or her familes shoes I'd want to destroy the guy. I have no sympathy for these deviants. Acid to just the eyes? psh.... Have him take an acid bath. Fire burns? have him burnt at the stake. Stabbed someone once? Get stabbed 10 times.
Retribution, Eye for an eye has no place in this world. Retribution should be swift, brutal, and painfully felt.
|
Well I always used to think the justice system should be about simply protecting society from dangerous people and preventing them from harming people, but I have to say there is part of me that enjoys people wrongly done being allowed to commit the same act to the person who did the wrongdoing. I think the nebulous and hard-to-define word 'justice' could be in some ways equated to 'fairness' which could in some ways be equated to 'revenge'.
|
|
|
On May 14 2011 09:36 nalgene wrote:Urine---> Extract WP ---> use WP on guy... Couldn't she just extract money from the guy in payment? They do have mechanical eyes now, at least in research. Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 09:16 Reaper9 wrote: @ Parnage. Yet there was the thread about the man who was tortured for 28 years in our fabulous American prison system. Justice indeed. He killed like 3 people with one being a prison guard... he was dangerous to the people who worked their, too, and locked him away with 4 years being solitary and the other 24 in a normal jail cell...
But still, this is the sort of justice system that we have. It does not differ greatly, just the type of punishment. But the misery is also present, and while what he did was a heinous crime, then if people are advocating our system, please explain the following. Why was this man not allowed even a bit of less light for sleep. He has vision problems. Why is this man locked in such a small space that cluster phobia developed? He can't even speak properly anymore, due to his isolation from other humans. (This is observations from the other thread.)
Therefore, my conclusion with that thread along with this one, is that Justice does come in different forms. There are people arguing that this would never be allowed in the United States. Yes, specifically not acid throwing. However, our alternatives are often just as barbaric.
|
I don't see the problem with retribution being a form of justice. Otherwise the criminals get too pampered.
|
On May 14 2011 09:32 Tosho wrote: She should have struck a deal with the judge where by the man thinks she is going to have her vengeance extracted, but she just lets them sedate him and put him under. Let him feel the remorse and fear of knowing he is going to wake up blind, but instead wakes up in jail. That would be the most appropriate punishment to me.
God, learn your language...
As for the case and guys saying stuff like 'two wrongs don't make a right', 'His pain won't ease her pain':
You are not in her position, and while I (like many others) don't condone her actions, I can fully understand where she's coming from. Maybe she can't ease her physical pain, but I am sure that this (potentially) could be satisfying her in a psychological way, and ease her in that she'll forever after know that the guy who did that to her now runs around like her.
I don't know about you, but it would give me some satisfaction at least.
|
He dumped acid on a woman's eye. He will have acid dumped on his eye. She was horribly disfigured and can barely see so this is the ultimate form of equality, punishment, and empathy. Good for her.
The fucker deserved it, make it hurt
|
On May 14 2011 09:39 Parnage wrote: Retribution doesn't make it better!
Stop trying to change the topic to how flawed my nations system of justice is just for a moment and try to understand the point I am trying to get across.
You can't condone this, and then ignore everything else that goes with this style of justice. It's not imposing my world view if I feel that hey you should not throw acid into a guy's eyes even if he did it to someone else. It should be common sense that this isn't a good way to hand out justice. You can't bring back that persons sight of remove her disfigurement by doing this, she gets this and then nothing. Is it worth it?
Victims need to be compensated and have a sense of normalcy restored I don't think you are quite understanding this. If you had a choice of torturing a guy who hurts you or just never being hurt which one would you choose? This isn't justice guys this is just retribution and retribution only hurts more people. It doesn't make things better, it doesn't stop it from happening(as has been stated already) and it just feels like a short term solution.
Normally I don't particularly agree with these kind of punishments, but I don't think it applies in a scenario where the society has come to tolerate such actions. There needs to be severe action taken to make everyone understand that what they are doing is incredibly wrong, and this punishment may be the proper deterrent.
Also, the soon-to-be-blinded man will no longer be able to properly aim and throw acid at more women, so it's like a nice preventative measure against his actions.
Honestly, I'm having a hard time being unbiased here though, because this kind of behavior is really disgusting.
|
The one thing I don't understand, is if this is supposed to be a fair punishment back on the man, why is he going to be sedated? She didn't have that lovely benefit when he destroyed her life, why should he?
|
On May 14 2011 09:39 Parnage wrote: Retribution doesn't make it better!
Stop trying to change the topic to how flawed my nations system of justice is just for a moment and try to understand the point I am trying to get across.
You can't condone this, and then ignore everything else that goes with this style of justice. It's not imposing my world view if I feel that hey you should not throw acid into a guy's eyes even if he did it to someone else. It should be common sense that this isn't a good way to hand out justice. You can't bring back that persons sight of remove her disfigurement by doing this, she gets this and then nothing. Is it worth it?
Victims need to be compensated and have a sense of normalcy restored I don't think you are quite understanding this. If you had a choice of torturing a guy who hurts you or just never being hurt which one would you choose? This isn't justice guys this is just retribution and retribution only hurts more people. It doesn't make things better, it doesn't stop it from happening(as has been stated already) and it just feels like a short term solution. But the hurt is done, are you saying you can go back in time and make the incident avoidable? What's done is done. And retribution must be dealt. Normalcy. what normalcy can be restored? tell the woman to get a new face? hahahaha, It doesn't stop things from happening? Sure it does.They do it because they can get away. If you punish them accordingly. then the problem will be reduced. Why? cuz they won't think it's worth it.
|
This is revolting. Shows just how 'civilized' Sharia law is, and why we don't want it in the west.
|
On May 14 2011 09:48 PITN wrote: This is revolting. Shows just how 'civilized' Sharia law is, and why we don't want it in the west. If civilized means having criminals living a life off my tax dollars that I spent my hour earning, I don't want to be civilized. Prefer to just bury them in a pit somewhere, then aleast you don't have to feed them. It's like being supply capped with useless units. What do you do? get rid of supply. Criminals are just dead weights to society. Fuck them. Actually.... I take that back, cuz Killing them takes money. Like paying the guys that dig the pit. Make them slave off time. At least then they're some what productive
|
Whilst barbaric, probably a good thing this part of the world wakes and treats women like equals. As cruel as it is this will should help them in the long run.
Retribution it might be, but in this case I think it and justice are not mutually exclusive.
|
On May 14 2011 08:49 kerpal wrote:...makes the whole world blind -gandhi
Gandhi also beat his wife. I don't really take his quotes too seriously, sorry.
|
Have we learned nothing from Park Chan-wook's Vengence trilogy?
|
|
|
|
|
|