On May 14 2011 09:23 Reaper9 wrote: In this case, I am a United States born American. I am critiquing the fallacies of Justice both in our own system, and that of other countries. Our prison system and punishment simply extends the length of misery as well.
Cool story, but it has jack shit to do with the topic at hand. Here's what happens in virtually every thread on General:
Hey here's this story about something in (X country), what do you guys think? Pretty terrible huh?
Yeah that's pretty terrible, but you know who else is terrible? The U.S.
You're right, let's spend the rest of the thread talking about how shitty America is
Good thing the mods don't seem to care about this sort of thing. We know America has problems but stop turning every goddamn thread into a discussion about them.
On May 14 2011 09:02 Parnage wrote: The hell is wrong with you people?
How can you condone this? This is no better then removing the hand of a pickpocket or forcing a woman to be blinded due to looking at another man.
This isn't justice, this is disgustingly barbaric and you can't stand for this without standing for all the other terrible things Sharia law allows.
No amount of acid is going to take back the pain, nor is it going to make her feel better to hear some bastard screaming bloody murder as acid is poured into his eye. Would you feel better? Would you really feel better taking that revenge as you watched someone else go through the pain and horror she experienced again?
I can't believe anyone could ever condone this. Ignoring all of this. Money can be used for plastic surgery to help restore a sense of normalcy which is the point of justice it's to restore things to normalcy not.. not this. This is just barbaric in the truest sense of the word.
RETRIBUTION M.FER!!!! Good god this didn't happen in America because the worst thing that's going to happen to the criminal would be some jail time.
On May 14 2011 08:54 itzme_petey wrote: Turns out the victim's heart is as black as the criminals. Sad turn of events.
While I don't necessarily agree with it, the guy made an unprovoked premeditated attack on an innocent who is now blind and disfigured for the rest of her life. She's merely getting revenge in-kind. Massive difference in "hearts" there.
The decision certainly appeals to the barbaric and vindictive side of the human nature no doubt.
Two wrongs don't make a right. More suffering never leads to less suffering. No pain can undo past pain. The punishment of a crime has very little to do with how many people do the crime. Increasing the severity of a punishment does not lead to less crime. Studies show this over and over again.
Clearly this type of justice is archaic and doesn't have a place in modern society.
Having said that if this was done to my girlfriend or any of my loved ones, some acid in his eye would be the least of his worries. If I put myself in her or her familes shoes I'd want to destroy the guy. I have no sympathy for these deviants.
To all the idiots crying out "THIS IS RETRIBUTION" and inhumane or whatever, are you serious? Sure, it might be somewhat retribution on the woman's part, but the effect of punishments like that is that would-be offenders think a lot more seriously before they commit crimes, which leads to a lot less incidents like this happening overall. While a few assholes who deserve it might suffer, in the long run everyone else benefits. Being put in prison where you are fed, clothed, etc. for years isn't anything for a criminal to be afraid of compared to permanent damage (which, from the sounds of things, won't even be as severe for him as it was for the woman).
She should have struck a deal with the judge where by the man thinks she is going to have her vengeance extracted, but she just lets them sedate him and put him under. Let him feel the remorse and fear of knowing he is going to wake up blind, but instead wakes up in jail. That would be the most appropriate punishment to me.
On May 14 2011 09:30 gameguard wrote: people keep saying "acid throwers." Is this a common enough occurrence in Iran or something ? ..;
It is also prevalent in India. In college, there is the foreign study program for the summer. My friend's class asked one of my/his Indian Professors why he did not organize trips to his hometown. His answer was because in his neighborhood, there are men waiting to throw acid at random women in the streets (and then they run away like the spineless devils they are). He says because he is a man, he would not have this problem. But these fiends have absolutely no regret when throwing it at ANY woman.
"Don't do to others what you wouldn't want done to yourself". The idealist in me has always held this belief close and I honestly can't summon any pity or compassion for the man.
Iran practices public execution. Women get hung by the neck for sometimes trivial crimes. This is the society the article is referring to. So complaining about this case is pretty, pretty, pretty trivial. Eye-for-an-eye isn't that far-off from the justice system used in every country in the world, and in Iran's case, it's a drastic improvement.
In America, this guy would be put in prison for X years, but would most likely end up getting beaten, raped, and quite possibly killed in the process. We accept this as "prison justice" for violence against women and children, and kind of shrug it off.
So Iran, which is an extremely chauvinistic society, is granting a female victim an extraordinary choice over the fate of the man who assaulted her, and the punishment, while violent, is actually not any worse than what happened to the victim (he won't feel the pain the way she did).
Sounds like progress to me. Justice isn't sterile. It's about deterring people from crimes. That, in effect, makes justice very much a thing of retribution.
How many years of "freedom", or how much money does a man have to pay to disfigure and mangle his ex-girlfriend's face? Some people will make those kind of cold decisions, when they're in a time of stress. Some punishments just need to fit the crime.
On May 14 2011 08:46 Airship wrote: An eye for an eye.
...makes the whole world blind -gandhi
Then there shall be equality.
On May 14 2011 09:32 Tosho wrote: She should of struck a deal with the judge where by the man thinks she is going to have her vengeance extracted, but she just lets them sedate him and put him under. Let him feel the remorse and fear of knowing he is going to wake up blind, but instead wakes up in jail. That would be the most appropriate punishment to me.
Think about the relief he would feel after he woke. He doesn't deserve that.
Couldn't she just extract money from the guy in payment? They do have mechanical eyes now, at least in research.
On May 14 2011 09:16 Reaper9 wrote: @ Parnage. Yet there was the thread about the man who was tortured for 28 years in our fabulous American prison system. Justice indeed.
He killed like 3 people with one being a prison guard... he was dangerous to the people who worked their, too, and locked him away with 4 years being solitary and the other 24 in a normal jail cell...