|
On August 02 2011 06:44 Blasterion wrote:Show nested quote +On August 02 2011 06:37 maartendq wrote:On August 02 2011 06:23 Blasterion wrote:On August 02 2011 06:20 maartendq wrote:On August 02 2011 06:05 Blasterion wrote:On August 02 2011 06:03 Pulzlulz wrote:On August 02 2011 06:01 Blasterion wrote:On August 02 2011 05:59 Pulzlulz wrote:On August 02 2011 05:54 FabledIntegral wrote:On August 02 2011 05:41 Pulzlulz wrote:[quote] Congratulations, you think like babylonians from 2000BC. He stole my bread? I'm gonna cut off his hands. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Code_of_HammurabiPlease don't talk to me anymore, my brain is full of fuck right now. Btw, I'm sorry I can't write longer answers then I do right now, my English skills aren't sufficient to write in a fast speed without using online dictionaries. Your argument is awful and is only working against you.You're using some petty theft crime with a massive punishment as an analogy. Please, stop trying to make it sound as if every poster that disagrees with you in this thread is the ignorant, or that you are "better" than them. If you're going to call me barbaric because I think someone like Osama deserved to be assassinated, then so be it, I really couldn't care less. Or that you think Hitler wouldn't have deserved execution despite the mass execution of the Jews and essentially causing WW2. Honestly, I'm happy not to have your mentality. Care to explain, where the difference lies between an Osama in prison and a dead Osama? Depends on how good the prison is. I guess a Dead Osama is just a safety measure That's a good point but still does not justify his death. I don't know if it's something we should pride ourselves on but, We Chinese don't really like to justify everything, just gotta do what has to be done. Well, you're not exactly living in a democracy, so I can understand your train of thought. However, in the western world, we expect people to be able to justify their every action. Who defines "what needs to be done" anyway? Tell who defines what needs to be done in your country? Do the people actually define what needs to be done? and I don't really like your tone of speaking, intentional or not It was intentional. I'm usually rather harsh on people who blindly do what others think that "needs to be done." Don't ever do something unless you know why and you agree with that explanation. If you say that chinese people don't really seek explanations and just do "what needs to be done" I just cannot help but think and fear that you guys are living in some kind of dictatorship (which you kind of are, considering there's only one party in your country and it's not exactly a party that appreciates people not agreeing with them; to put it more bluntly, they're extremely repressive towards dissidents). You seem to be dodging my question, Do the people actually defines what needs to be done in your country? or does your government do it? The difference between China and most of the western world is that we live in a democracy, where we choose the government we believe will do their best job for their country and the world, basically we, the people, have the souvereignty.
|
On August 02 2011 06:51 FabledIntegral wrote: And if "pursuit of happiness" (someone else quoted it earlier, not you) is a human right, how is prison not denying that? Because they are free to do almost whatever they want in prison. Of course it is cut down, but still acceptable.
|
On August 02 2011 06:52 Pulzlulz wrote:Show nested quote +On August 02 2011 06:44 Blasterion wrote:On August 02 2011 06:37 maartendq wrote:On August 02 2011 06:23 Blasterion wrote:On August 02 2011 06:20 maartendq wrote:On August 02 2011 06:05 Blasterion wrote:On August 02 2011 06:03 Pulzlulz wrote:On August 02 2011 06:01 Blasterion wrote:On August 02 2011 05:59 Pulzlulz wrote:On August 02 2011 05:54 FabledIntegral wrote: [quote]
Your argument is awful and is only working against you.You're using some petty theft crime with a massive punishment as an analogy. Please, stop trying to make it sound as if every poster that disagrees with you in this thread is the ignorant, or that you are "better" than them. If you're going to call me barbaric because I think someone like Osama deserved to be assassinated, then so be it, I really couldn't care less. Or that you think Hitler wouldn't have deserved execution despite the mass execution of the Jews and essentially causing WW2. Honestly, I'm happy not to have your mentality. Care to explain, where the difference lies between an Osama in prison and a dead Osama? Depends on how good the prison is. I guess a Dead Osama is just a safety measure That's a good point but still does not justify his death. I don't know if it's something we should pride ourselves on but, We Chinese don't really like to justify everything, just gotta do what has to be done. Well, you're not exactly living in a democracy, so I can understand your train of thought. However, in the western world, we expect people to be able to justify their every action. Who defines "what needs to be done" anyway? Tell who defines what needs to be done in your country? Do the people actually define what needs to be done? and I don't really like your tone of speaking, intentional or not It was intentional. I'm usually rather harsh on people who blindly do what others think that "needs to be done." Don't ever do something unless you know why and you agree with that explanation. If you say that chinese people don't really seek explanations and just do "what needs to be done" I just cannot help but think and fear that you guys are living in some kind of dictatorship (which you kind of are, considering there's only one party in your country and it's not exactly a party that appreciates people not agreeing with them; to put it more bluntly, they're extremely repressive towards dissidents). You seem to be dodging my question, Do the people actually defines what needs to be done in your country? or does your government do it? The difference between China and most of the western world is that we live in a democracy, where we choose the government we believe will do their best job for their country and the world, basically we, the people, have the souvereignty. But you really don't because the government still make decisions, you can say that the people make the decision but that's just retrospective. You can fire government officials but only after the decision they made
|
On August 02 2011 06:54 Pulzlulz wrote:Show nested quote +On August 02 2011 06:51 FabledIntegral wrote: And if "pursuit of happiness" (someone else quoted it earlier, not you) is a human right, how is prison not denying that? Because they are free to do almost whatever they want in prison. Of course it is cut down, but still acceptable.
They're pursuit of happiness is definitely being denied due to being detained. Would you not agree they consequently forfeit part of that right when they commit a crime? To pursue happiness as they see fit? Of course, this is assuming pursuit of happiness is an inalienable right.
|
On August 02 2011 06:56 Blasterion wrote:Show nested quote +On August 02 2011 06:52 Pulzlulz wrote:On August 02 2011 06:44 Blasterion wrote:On August 02 2011 06:37 maartendq wrote:On August 02 2011 06:23 Blasterion wrote:On August 02 2011 06:20 maartendq wrote:On August 02 2011 06:05 Blasterion wrote:On August 02 2011 06:03 Pulzlulz wrote:On August 02 2011 06:01 Blasterion wrote:On August 02 2011 05:59 Pulzlulz wrote: [quote] Care to explain, where the difference lies between an Osama in prison and a dead Osama? Depends on how good the prison is. I guess a Dead Osama is just a safety measure That's a good point but still does not justify his death. I don't know if it's something we should pride ourselves on but, We Chinese don't really like to justify everything, just gotta do what has to be done. Well, you're not exactly living in a democracy, so I can understand your train of thought. However, in the western world, we expect people to be able to justify their every action. Who defines "what needs to be done" anyway? Tell who defines what needs to be done in your country? Do the people actually define what needs to be done? and I don't really like your tone of speaking, intentional or not It was intentional. I'm usually rather harsh on people who blindly do what others think that "needs to be done." Don't ever do something unless you know why and you agree with that explanation. If you say that chinese people don't really seek explanations and just do "what needs to be done" I just cannot help but think and fear that you guys are living in some kind of dictatorship (which you kind of are, considering there's only one party in your country and it's not exactly a party that appreciates people not agreeing with them; to put it more bluntly, they're extremely repressive towards dissidents). You seem to be dodging my question, Do the people actually defines what needs to be done in your country? or does your government do it? The difference between China and most of the western world is that we live in a democracy, where we choose the government we believe will do their best job for their country and the world, basically we, the people, have the souvereignty. But you really don't because the government still make decisions, you can say that the people make the decision but that's just retrospective. You can fire government officials but only after the decision they made Not exactly. In Germany we have the "Bundesverfassungsgericht", a court, whose job is to check every bill for their validity with the law. Democracies have seperated powers, which control each other and therefore bringt out the best results.
This is why the proposed internet censorship rule and the storage of internet user files by internet providers have been abolished.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Separation_of_powers
They're pursuit of happiness is definitely being denied due to being detained. Would you not agree they consequently forfeit part of that right when they commit a crime? To pursue happiness as they see fit? Of course, this is assuming pursuit of happiness is an inalienable right. I don't see the problem in my argumentation. Someone's hapiness CAN be cut down in prison (what I think is perfectly acceptable, even though I wish better conditions in certain countries for certain crimes), but someone dead is dead.
|
But you really don't because the government still make decisions, you can say that the people make the decision but that's just retrospective. You can fire government officials but only after the decision they made
But what you just said makes absolutely no sense because the definition of democracy is not "prevent officials you elected from doing things you don't like" and it is not just "vote for your leaders and if you do not like what they do you can vote them out."
It is the latter and the rule of law, which as far as government goes, means "laws restricting the government's behavior in favor of the rights of individuals that the government cannot change." And it also means the government can't hide information that reflects badly on the government from you.
In China there are no decisions that government officials cannot make regardless of the rights of the individual (most of which China's shitty government doesn't even recognize anyway) and no way to fire them. unlike in the West. In China any time the government is embarrassed there's a media/internet crackdown on discussion of the embarrassing topic. In the West the local government might harass your food kiosk in the town square by making you spend lots of time, money, and effort to have every I dotted and T crossed. In China, local bureaucrats demand kickbacks and generally treat you like dirt and if you don't like it they beat you to death right on the street. But at least if you're a pregnant woman, they don't kill you. Presumably.
Sorry, your country is an authoritarian den of corruption and boots on the faces of the little people, Mr. Chinese Nationalist E-Warrior.
|
On August 02 2011 06:44 Blasterion wrote:Show nested quote +On August 02 2011 06:37 maartendq wrote:On August 02 2011 06:23 Blasterion wrote:On August 02 2011 06:20 maartendq wrote:On August 02 2011 06:05 Blasterion wrote:On August 02 2011 06:03 Pulzlulz wrote:On August 02 2011 06:01 Blasterion wrote:On August 02 2011 05:59 Pulzlulz wrote:On August 02 2011 05:54 FabledIntegral wrote:On August 02 2011 05:41 Pulzlulz wrote:[quote] Congratulations, you think like babylonians from 2000BC. He stole my bread? I'm gonna cut off his hands. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Code_of_HammurabiPlease don't talk to me anymore, my brain is full of fuck right now. Btw, I'm sorry I can't write longer answers then I do right now, my English skills aren't sufficient to write in a fast speed without using online dictionaries. Your argument is awful and is only working against you.You're using some petty theft crime with a massive punishment as an analogy. Please, stop trying to make it sound as if every poster that disagrees with you in this thread is the ignorant, or that you are "better" than them. If you're going to call me barbaric because I think someone like Osama deserved to be assassinated, then so be it, I really couldn't care less. Or that you think Hitler wouldn't have deserved execution despite the mass execution of the Jews and essentially causing WW2. Honestly, I'm happy not to have your mentality. Care to explain, where the difference lies between an Osama in prison and a dead Osama? Depends on how good the prison is. I guess a Dead Osama is just a safety measure That's a good point but still does not justify his death. I don't know if it's something we should pride ourselves on but, We Chinese don't really like to justify everything, just gotta do what has to be done. Well, you're not exactly living in a democracy, so I can understand your train of thought. However, in the western world, we expect people to be able to justify their every action. Who defines "what needs to be done" anyway? Tell who defines what needs to be done in your country? Do the people actually define what needs to be done? and I don't really like your tone of speaking, intentional or not It was intentional. I'm usually rather harsh on people who blindly do what others think that "needs to be done." Don't ever do something unless you know why and you agree with that explanation. If you say that chinese people don't really seek explanations and just do "what needs to be done" I just cannot help but think and fear that you guys are living in some kind of dictatorship (which you kind of are, considering there's only one party in your country and it's not exactly a party that appreciates people not agreeing with them; to put it more bluntly, they're extremely repressive towards dissidents). You seem to be dodging my question, Do the people actually defines what needs to be done in your country? or does your government do it? Edit: To answer your edit, I think it's simple enough to say what needs to be done, improve national economy, security, and promoting life quality. which I think China is doing a decent job. You seem fixed on that Chinese hate their life and you look down on others because their lives are of lower quality. When it's simply not the case No, I'm not fixed on the fact that the Chinese hate their life. As a matter of fact, most Chinese tourists I see where I live (and there are quite a lot of chinese tourists here) look really happy. I'm mainly fixed on the fact that Europeans have way more freedom than Chinese do. We can actually openly protest against our government without being arrested. We can ridicule it, mock it, etc. and the government can't do anything about it.
We, the people, decide what needs to be done. Our MP's (members of parliament) represent the opinions of different groups of people. If the people find that an MP no longer acts in the interest of those who voted for him/her, he doesn't get elected in the next term. The last thing I want is a government telling me what I should believe in, what I should do and how I should it.
There's no denying that China has been a rich, affluent country for most of the past 2500 years. However, the way this economic growth was achieved has always been authoritarian. It's a recurring theme in Chinese history. Respect for the individual citizen is something they did not care about back then and probably don't care about right now, which is one of the nastier side-effects of communism.
@Deepelemblues: there's no reason to get rude here. I can sum up as many faults about the American libertarian ideals as I can about the Chinese' way of doing things. You're actually as nationalist as he is.
|
On August 02 2011 05:41 Pulzlulz wrote:Show nested quote +On August 02 2011 05:54 FabledIntegral wrote:
They're pursuit of happiness is definitely being denied due to being detained. Would you not agree they consequently forfeit part of that right when they commit a crime? To pursue happiness as they see fit? Of course, this is assuming pursuit of happiness is an inalienable right. I don't see the problem in my argumentation. Someone's hapiness CAN be cut down in prison (what I think is perfectly acceptable, even though I wish better conditions in certain countries for certain crimes), but someone dead is dead.
Someone dead is dead, we can agree on that. You suggest this is violating their right to life if they are executed (I disagree, but not the point here). I'm suggesting that by giving someone a life sentence, they are consequently denied their ability to pursue happiness. What if the only way they can have happiness is to not be detained in the same place, but be free to wander wherever? All I'm saying is that you can forfeit your rights in certain situations by the actions you make.
|
On August 02 2011 07:11 FabledIntegral wrote:Show nested quote +On August 02 2011 05:41 Pulzlulz wrote:On August 02 2011 05:54 FabledIntegral wrote:
They're pursuit of happiness is definitely being denied due to being detained. Would you not agree they consequently forfeit part of that right when they commit a crime? To pursue happiness as they see fit? Of course, this is assuming pursuit of happiness is an inalienable right. I don't see the problem in my argumentation. Someone's hapiness CAN be cut down in prison (what I think is perfectly acceptable, even though I wish better conditions in certain countries for certain crimes), but someone dead is dead. Someone dead is dead, we can agree on that. You suggest this is violating their right to life if they are executed (I disagree, but not the point here). I'm suggesting that by giving someone a life sentence, they are consequently denied their ability to pursue happiness. What if the only way they can have happiness is to not be detained in the same place, but be free to wander wherever? All I'm saying is that you can forfeit your rights in certain situations by the actions you make. To a certain extent you are correct. To be honest I haven't looked and read into this issue to such an extent that I could argue with you. Maybe someone else will be able to jump in my position.
|
On August 02 2011 07:11 FabledIntegral wrote:Show nested quote +On August 02 2011 05:41 Pulzlulz wrote:On August 02 2011 05:54 FabledIntegral wrote:
They're pursuit of happiness is definitely being denied due to being detained. Would you not agree they consequently forfeit part of that right when they commit a crime? To pursue happiness as they see fit? Of course, this is assuming pursuit of happiness is an inalienable right. I don't see the problem in my argumentation. Someone's hapiness CAN be cut down in prison (what I think is perfectly acceptable, even though I wish better conditions in certain countries for certain crimes), but someone dead is dead. Someone dead is dead, we can agree on that. You suggest this is violating their right to life if they are executed (I disagree, but not the point here). I'm suggesting that by giving someone a life sentence, they are consequently denied their ability to pursue happiness. What if the only way they can have happiness is to not be detained in the same place, but be free to wander wherever? All I'm saying is that you can forfeit your rights in certain situations by the actions you make.
Most life sentences are not actually for a persons entire life. And if a prison is setup to be more of a rehabilitation than a punishment, this pursuit of freedom can be achieved eventually. The american prison system in general serves more as a punishment than a prison system should in theory.
|
The mission of a prison is to resocialize the prisoner to send him back to society as a righteous person. Of course it is very difficult to achieve this, but I guess we could learn from Cesar Millan.
|
|
|
If she does this, how are she better than him? Because it's legal? I don't get it
|
On August 02 2011 07:11 FabledIntegral wrote:Show nested quote +On August 02 2011 05:41 Pulzlulz wrote:On August 02 2011 05:54 FabledIntegral wrote:
They're pursuit of happiness is definitely being denied due to being detained. Would you not agree they consequently forfeit part of that right when they commit a crime? To pursue happiness as they see fit? Of course, this is assuming pursuit of happiness is an inalienable right. I don't see the problem in my argumentation. Someone's hapiness CAN be cut down in prison (what I think is perfectly acceptable, even though I wish better conditions in certain countries for certain crimes), but someone dead is dead. Someone dead is dead, we can agree on that. You suggest this is violating their right to life if they are executed (I disagree, but not the point here). I'm suggesting that by giving someone a life sentence, they are consequently denied their ability to pursue happiness. What if the only way they can have happiness is to not be detained in the same place, but be free to wander wherever? All I'm saying is that you can forfeit your rights in certain situations by the actions you make. There's a difference between forfeiting one's rights as a civilian (which is actually an existing sentence in Belgium) and outright killing someone because of a murder he/she commited. When one commits a serious crime, it's all but logical that (some of) his/her rights be temporarily denied. I do not, however, find it logical that a murderer should be put to death just because he murdered someone. You do not want to sink to the same depths as the purpetrator.
The main idea behind imprisonment is temporarily or permanently removing harmful people from society. You don't have to kill people to remove them. Some people may actually come to regret what they have done and be succesfully rehabillitated into society. Other are obviously best kept away from society as far as possible. Again, this does not mean that you should just kill them outright.
|
We're mainly talking about retaliation and its connection to death sentences and "doing what must be done."
|
On August 01 2011 23:01 MiraMax wrote:Show nested quote +On August 01 2011 22:39 sigma_x wrote:On August 01 2011 22:06 sleepingdog wrote:On August 01 2011 21:44 targ wrote: Although throwing acid in his eyes will not bring back the woman's eyesight, I would like some statistics in the coming years on whether the occurrences of such incidents drop in the future in Iran. Me too. That's the problem of nowadays screwed society. That doing terrible, abominable things may prevent even more terrible, abominable things in the future. In Iran, there's apparently a good amount of people who think it's cool to throw acid in the eye of women who reject them. I've read many articles on this, these are NOT isolated cases. It happens dreadfully often. Make no mistake, I am 100% against allowing her to do the same to him, since it's against everything I believe in both as a legal scholar and as a human being. Nevertheless the question remains: what if this really is the only way to prevent those "brainsick-degenerated-sorry-excuses-for-human-beings" to do this to women? What if, in Iran, this really is the only way to make sure men don't throw acid into women's eyes? It is a shame, I think, that legal systems give the guilty the primacy of attention, when it is the victim who needs it most. It is giving the accused the pedestal while the victim is forgotten. It is, to me, the subtler manifestation of 'blaming the victim'. In respect of the current case, the fact that justice was brought into the hands of the victim herself is a good thing. If she spares him, which she has, it shows her humanity and her ability to step above the fray and the notion of revenge. It is the ultimate victory of the victim. If she does not spare him, then she gets her vengeance and feels that justice is served. The public may disagree with her position, but I find it hard to believe that there would be much vitriol given everything she would have gone through. If she chooses to refrain from making a decision, then she was at least afforded an opportunity to play a major role in the system. In all matters, it is about the victim. The subject matter of the penal system becomes the heroism of the victim (or lack of it in another's eyes). The fact that so much time is given towards the guilty instead of the victim is, in my opinion, very unfortunate. I think that quite to the contrary such a legal system enforces exactly what it tries to prevent. If you give this much power to a victim, you actually turn the victim into an offender. You basically say: A person can do something so grave to another person that justice is only served, if the offender is killed/ blinded / mutilated / etc. This in effect endorses the "means" and merely criticizes the "end". From that it is only a small step for any individual to conclude that since what has been done to him "hurts so horribly" in their eyes, it merits such an "otherwise completely acceptable" punishment. "Honour crimes" are no normal crimes. These people actually think that by spraying acid into some women's face, they restore justice. I think the more effective path to prevent these cruelties is to condemn the means. No person "deserves" to be killed / blinded / mutilated / etc. whatever the deed and there is nothing good coming out of this kind of retribution. The act itself is barbarous. The more people in a society understand that, the less likely it is to occur.
I appreciate that that is the general sentiment in this thread, but it is not quite what I was saying. All I am saying is that the legal system treats everyone with care and respect, except the one person who needs it most. The victim is ignored, her input into what the appropriate remedy should be is somewhat unbelievably dismissed as 'biased', the prosecutor acts on behalf of the state ignoring what the victim has to say. I find that to be a sad state of affairs.
As to whether the effect endorses the 'means', all that I am suggesting is that the victim should be heard and not silenced in respect of the severity of the punishment.
|
On August 02 2011 07:34 maartendq wrote:Show nested quote +On August 02 2011 07:11 FabledIntegral wrote:On August 02 2011 05:41 Pulzlulz wrote:On August 02 2011 05:54 FabledIntegral wrote:
They're pursuit of happiness is definitely being denied due to being detained. Would you not agree they consequently forfeit part of that right when they commit a crime? To pursue happiness as they see fit? Of course, this is assuming pursuit of happiness is an inalienable right. I don't see the problem in my argumentation. Someone's hapiness CAN be cut down in prison (what I think is perfectly acceptable, even though I wish better conditions in certain countries for certain crimes), but someone dead is dead. Someone dead is dead, we can agree on that. You suggest this is violating their right to life if they are executed (I disagree, but not the point here). I'm suggesting that by giving someone a life sentence, they are consequently denied their ability to pursue happiness. What if the only way they can have happiness is to not be detained in the same place, but be free to wander wherever? All I'm saying is that you can forfeit your rights in certain situations by the actions you make. There's a difference between forfeiting one's rights as a civilian (which is actually an existing sentence in Belgium) and outright killing someone because of a murder he/she commited. When one commits a serious crime, it's all but logical that (some of) his/her rights be temporarily denied. I do not, however, find it logical that a murderer should be put to death just because he murdered someone. You do not want to sink to the same depths as the purpetrator. The main idea behind imprisonment is temporarily or permanently removing harmful people from society. You don't have to kill people to remove them. Some people may actually come to regret what they have done and be succesfully rehabillitated into society. Other are obviously best kept away from society as far as possible. Again, this does not mean that you should just kill them outright.
But see, this is what we differ. I find it completely logical that a murderer should be put to death "just" because he murdered someone. I find the word "just" almost offensive in this case. And you're flat out against the death penalty, meaning that it wouldn't matter even if the person was able to nuke Canada by some odd measure, that person "just" nuked you guys, they shouldn't be put to death.
I have never, ever bought to the "sinking to the same depths" argument. I don't believe retaliation is almost ever sinking to the same level. For example, someone punches you in the race randomly. Are you sinking to their level by punching them back? No, you're simply retaliating against some asshole who randomly punched you - you never would have punched him if he didn't first.
|
On August 02 2011 10:20 FabledIntegral wrote:Show nested quote +On August 02 2011 07:34 maartendq wrote:On August 02 2011 07:11 FabledIntegral wrote:On August 02 2011 05:41 Pulzlulz wrote:On August 02 2011 05:54 FabledIntegral wrote:
They're pursuit of happiness is definitely being denied due to being detained. Would you not agree they consequently forfeit part of that right when they commit a crime? To pursue happiness as they see fit? Of course, this is assuming pursuit of happiness is an inalienable right. I don't see the problem in my argumentation. Someone's hapiness CAN be cut down in prison (what I think is perfectly acceptable, even though I wish better conditions in certain countries for certain crimes), but someone dead is dead. Someone dead is dead, we can agree on that. You suggest this is violating their right to life if they are executed (I disagree, but not the point here). I'm suggesting that by giving someone a life sentence, they are consequently denied their ability to pursue happiness. What if the only way they can have happiness is to not be detained in the same place, but be free to wander wherever? All I'm saying is that you can forfeit your rights in certain situations by the actions you make. There's a difference between forfeiting one's rights as a civilian (which is actually an existing sentence in Belgium) and outright killing someone because of a murder he/she commited. When one commits a serious crime, it's all but logical that (some of) his/her rights be temporarily denied. I do not, however, find it logical that a murderer should be put to death just because he murdered someone. You do not want to sink to the same depths as the purpetrator. The main idea behind imprisonment is temporarily or permanently removing harmful people from society. You don't have to kill people to remove them. Some people may actually come to regret what they have done and be succesfully rehabillitated into society. Other are obviously best kept away from society as far as possible. Again, this does not mean that you should just kill them outright. But see, this is what we differ. I find it completely logical that a murderer should be put to death "just" because he murdered someone. I find the word "just" almost offensive in this case. And you're flat out against the death penalty, meaning that it wouldn't matter even if the person was able to nuke Canada by some odd measure, that person "just" nuked you guys, they shouldn't be put to death. I have never, ever bought to the "sinking to the same depths" argument. I don't believe retaliation is almost ever sinking to the same level. For example, someone punches you in the race randomly. Are you sinking to their level by punching them back? No, you're simply retaliating against some asshole who randomly punched you - you never would have punched him if he didn't first.
FabledIntegral, I don't even know why you bother arguing with this guy. I completely agree with you for the record. The thing I've realized about some TL posters is that they will go to incredible lengths to take the high moral ground in anything, even if it makes them delusional to reality.
It reminds me of arguing with a religious zealot. There's no point to it
|
On August 02 2011 10:40 SweetNJoshSauce wrote:Show nested quote +On August 02 2011 10:20 FabledIntegral wrote:On August 02 2011 07:34 maartendq wrote:On August 02 2011 07:11 FabledIntegral wrote:On August 02 2011 05:41 Pulzlulz wrote:On August 02 2011 05:54 FabledIntegral wrote:
They're pursuit of happiness is definitely being denied due to being detained. Would you not agree they consequently forfeit part of that right when they commit a crime? To pursue happiness as they see fit? Of course, this is assuming pursuit of happiness is an inalienable right. I don't see the problem in my argumentation. Someone's hapiness CAN be cut down in prison (what I think is perfectly acceptable, even though I wish better conditions in certain countries for certain crimes), but someone dead is dead. Someone dead is dead, we can agree on that. You suggest this is violating their right to life if they are executed (I disagree, but not the point here). I'm suggesting that by giving someone a life sentence, they are consequently denied their ability to pursue happiness. What if the only way they can have happiness is to not be detained in the same place, but be free to wander wherever? All I'm saying is that you can forfeit your rights in certain situations by the actions you make. There's a difference between forfeiting one's rights as a civilian (which is actually an existing sentence in Belgium) and outright killing someone because of a murder he/she commited. When one commits a serious crime, it's all but logical that (some of) his/her rights be temporarily denied. I do not, however, find it logical that a murderer should be put to death just because he murdered someone. You do not want to sink to the same depths as the purpetrator. The main idea behind imprisonment is temporarily or permanently removing harmful people from society. You don't have to kill people to remove them. Some people may actually come to regret what they have done and be succesfully rehabillitated into society. Other are obviously best kept away from society as far as possible. Again, this does not mean that you should just kill them outright. But see, this is what we differ. I find it completely logical that a murderer should be put to death "just" because he murdered someone. I find the word "just" almost offensive in this case. And you're flat out against the death penalty, meaning that it wouldn't matter even if the person was able to nuke Canada by some odd measure, that person "just" nuked you guys, they shouldn't be put to death. I have never, ever bought to the "sinking to the same depths" argument. I don't believe retaliation is almost ever sinking to the same level. For example, someone punches you in the race randomly. Are you sinking to their level by punching them back? No, you're simply retaliating against some asshole who randomly punched you - you never would have punched him if he didn't first. FabledIntegral, I don't even know why you bother arguing with this guy. I completely agree with you for the record. The thing I've realized about some TL posters is that they will go to incredible lengths to take the high moral ground in anything, even if it makes them delusional to reality. It reminds me of arguing with a religious zealot. There's no point to it Yeah, it's easier to stay ignorant to other people's opinions.
But see, this is what we differ. I find it completely logical that a murderer should be put to death "just" because he murdered someone. I find the word "just" almost offensive in this case. And you're flat out against the death penalty, meaning that it wouldn't matter even if the person was able to nuke Canada by some odd measure, that person "just" nuked you guys, they shouldn't be put to death. I think neither sides can argue using this argument because I could throw in whether you would kill someone, who stole a PS3 from a store.
I have never, ever bought to the "sinking to the same depths" argument. I don't believe retaliation is almost ever sinking to the same level. For example, someone punches you in the race randomly. Are you sinking to their level by punching them back? No, you're simply retaliating against some asshole who randomly punched you - you never would have punched him if he didn't first. Im not sure if I understand you correctly.
The problem is that you are acting out of self-defence as he might continue to attack you. You are allowed to kill out of self-defence but not as a third person. I don't like victims acting out of revenge as this prohibits enforced judgement by the law. Then a third person has to perform the "kill" (seems people don't like the word murder), who is in no way involved except being part of the same society. What right does this person have to inject poison or whatever you do in the US?
|
Lol, the examples people use to justify the death penalty are ridiculous. Also it's more then just a moral issue, the death penalty does not reduce crime rates as you are basically stating as a society that murder is acceptable under certain terms.
|
|
|
|
|
|