|
On August 02 2011 05:41 TheGlassface wrote: Lol @ "Have you seen American History X?" It's a movie. A movie is not reality.
That being said, I agree. Prison is for rehabilitation, not revenge or spot removal/isolation.
It's so strange how many people come out the wood work in times like this and demand "justice!" in the form of reciprocal violence. Especially, if you're from the US, considering how many cases a year we have of "guilty" people being found that they've been kept in jail for a crime they didn't commit and the evidence gets looked into YEARS after the fact.
But that is an issue with the judicial system, Getting the right verdict is the judge's job, doesn't have to conflict with the punishment
|
On August 02 2011 05:29 tdynasty wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 09:02 Parnage wrote: The hell is wrong with you people?
How can you condone this? This is no better then removing the hand of a pickpocket or forcing a woman to be blinded due to looking at another man.
This isn't justice, this is disgustingly barbaric and you can't stand for this without standing for all the other terrible things Sharia law allows.
No amount of acid is going to take back the pain, nor is it going to make her feel better to hear some bastard screaming bloody murder as acid is poured into his eye. Would you feel better? Would you really feel better taking that revenge as you watched someone else go through the pain and horror she experienced again?
I can't believe anyone could ever condone this. Ignoring all of this. Money can be used for plastic surgery to help restore a sense of normalcy which is the point of justice it's to restore things to normalcy not.. not this. This is just barbaric in the truest sense of the word. I find it interesting how you view this. I'm just trying to put myself in that man's shoes. To do what he did, must have caused him great satisfaction. To have the will to disfigure a woman you wanted to marry because she does not accept you. And now, you he gets to feel the feeling of counter attack. He gets to share in her pain of being disfigured and blinded. I do agree that acid throwing is just pure madness and in my opinion is much more tragic then what is going to happen to this piece of shit. In a Hypothetical situation, my sister is the victim. Can you imagine the pure impulse of retrebution from me, my father, my brother? I think less people condonde this then you think. But I will say that tere needs to be retaliation to this acid throwing .... For that is the true barbaric behavior. Hate only creates more hate. Pain only creates the need to cause more pain. Simple as that. Emotional decisions are rarely good ones, especially if those emotions are negative ones. Rationality should always be the goal, no matter how hard it is.
|
How about a Penal system that makes the Prisoner work off his....ugh...debts? For basic food healthcare stuff but no pay just work for X years to earn freedom? This way we don't just have them sleeping around all day, They make productive work. and goes in to pay for rehab.
Efficiency is key of course
|
On August 02 2011 05:41 Pulzlulz wrote:Show nested quote +On August 02 2011 05:29 Blasterion wrote:On August 02 2011 05:26 Pulzlulz wrote:On August 02 2011 05:11 Blasterion wrote:On August 02 2011 05:10 MrDudeMan wrote: shelter, safety and food should be basic human rights. The fact that people do not have it is a problem, not the fact that in certain countries everyone has it. Do mass murderers have human rights? No, he gave it up the moment he took it away from those victims What do you base this on? Lights thoughts from Death Note? Because human rights exist because it is observed by the society you live in. Murder is attack on members of society, without a valid reason it can be interpreted as a treason to the society and there for society chooses to no longer observe the rights of that person. Congratulations, you think like babylonians from 2000BC. He stole my bread? I'm gonna cut off his hands. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Code_of_HammurabiPlease don't talk to me anymore, my brain is full of fuck right now. Btw, I'm sorry I can't write longer answers then I do right now, my English skills aren't sufficient to write in a fast speed without using online dictionaries.
Your argument is awful and is only working against you.You're using some petty theft crime with a massive punishment as an analogy. Please, stop trying to make it sound as if every poster that disagrees with you in this thread is the ignorant, or that you are "better" than them. If you're going to call me barbaric because I think someone like Osama deserved to be assassinated, then so be it, I really couldn't care less. Or that you think Hitler wouldn't have deserved execution despite the mass execution of the Jews and essentially causing WW2. Honestly, I'm happy not to have your mentality.
|
On August 02 2011 05:49 Blasterion wrote: How about a Penal system that makes the Prisoner work off his....ugh...debts? For basic food healthcare stuff but no pay just work for X years to earn freedom? This way we don't just have them sleeping around all day, They make productive work. and goes in to pay for rehab.
Efficiency is key of course
Or just rehabilitate them.. Prisoners are almost always mentally ill. The offending rate of war criminals for instance is huge, as they learn to murder anyone without hesitation while in combat, and are drilled for years, and when they come home they still have the same instincts.
Either you A: put the guy in prison and let him out in thirty years when he's even more aggressive or B: you let the guy get the treatment he deserves, and show him some respect and let him come back into society, as he's as much of a human being as everyone else.
|
On August 02 2011 05:49 Blasterion wrote: How about a Penal system that makes the Prisoner work off his....ugh...debts? For basic food healthcare stuff but no pay just work for X years to earn freedom? This way we don't just have them sleeping around all day, They make productive work. and goes in to pay for rehab.
Efficiency is key of course Working prisoners is a norm in Europe. Many even study and get their Bachelors to be able to work after their time in prison.
|
On August 02 2011 05:54 FabledIntegral wrote:Show nested quote +On August 02 2011 05:41 Pulzlulz wrote:On August 02 2011 05:29 Blasterion wrote:On August 02 2011 05:26 Pulzlulz wrote:On August 02 2011 05:11 Blasterion wrote:On August 02 2011 05:10 MrDudeMan wrote: shelter, safety and food should be basic human rights. The fact that people do not have it is a problem, not the fact that in certain countries everyone has it. Do mass murderers have human rights? No, he gave it up the moment he took it away from those victims What do you base this on? Lights thoughts from Death Note? Because human rights exist because it is observed by the society you live in. Murder is attack on members of society, without a valid reason it can be interpreted as a treason to the society and there for society chooses to no longer observe the rights of that person. Congratulations, you think like babylonians from 2000BC. He stole my bread? I'm gonna cut off his hands. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Code_of_HammurabiPlease don't talk to me anymore, my brain is full of fuck right now. Btw, I'm sorry I can't write longer answers then I do right now, my English skills aren't sufficient to write in a fast speed without using online dictionaries. Your argument is awful and is only working against you.You're using some petty theft crime with a massive punishment as an analogy. Please, stop trying to make it sound as if every poster that disagrees with you in this thread is the ignorant, or that you are "better" than them. If you're going to call me barbaric because I think someone like Osama deserved to be assassinated, then so be it, I really couldn't care less. Or that you think Hitler wouldn't have deserved execution despite the mass execution of the Jews and essentially causing WW2. Honestly, I'm happy not to have your mentality. Care to explain, where the difference lies between an Osama in prison and a dead Osama?
I don't see the problem with my analogy. How do you even decide, when the death penalty should be used? When he killed 10 people? If below 10, cut his eyes out or what?
|
On August 02 2011 05:59 Pulzlulz wrote:Show nested quote +On August 02 2011 05:54 FabledIntegral wrote:On August 02 2011 05:41 Pulzlulz wrote:On August 02 2011 05:29 Blasterion wrote:On August 02 2011 05:26 Pulzlulz wrote:On August 02 2011 05:11 Blasterion wrote:On August 02 2011 05:10 MrDudeMan wrote: shelter, safety and food should be basic human rights. The fact that people do not have it is a problem, not the fact that in certain countries everyone has it. Do mass murderers have human rights? No, he gave it up the moment he took it away from those victims What do you base this on? Lights thoughts from Death Note? Because human rights exist because it is observed by the society you live in. Murder is attack on members of society, without a valid reason it can be interpreted as a treason to the society and there for society chooses to no longer observe the rights of that person. Congratulations, you think like babylonians from 2000BC. He stole my bread? I'm gonna cut off his hands. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Code_of_HammurabiPlease don't talk to me anymore, my brain is full of fuck right now. Btw, I'm sorry I can't write longer answers then I do right now, my English skills aren't sufficient to write in a fast speed without using online dictionaries. Your argument is awful and is only working against you.You're using some petty theft crime with a massive punishment as an analogy. Please, stop trying to make it sound as if every poster that disagrees with you in this thread is the ignorant, or that you are "better" than them. If you're going to call me barbaric because I think someone like Osama deserved to be assassinated, then so be it, I really couldn't care less. Or that you think Hitler wouldn't have deserved execution despite the mass execution of the Jews and essentially causing WW2. Honestly, I'm happy not to have your mentality. Care to explain, where the difference lies between an Osama in prison and a dead Osama? Depends on how good the prison is. I guess a Dead Osama is just a safety measure
|
On August 02 2011 05:54 FabledIntegral wrote: Your argument is awful and is only working against you.You're using some petty theft crime with a massive punishment as an analogy. Please, stop trying to make it sound as if every poster that disagrees with you in this thread is the ignorant, or that you are "better" than them. If you're going to call me barbaric because I think someone like Osama deserved to be assassinated, then so be it, I really couldn't care less. Or that you think Hitler wouldn't have deserved execution despite the mass execution of the Jews and essentially causing WW2. Honestly, I'm happy not to have your mentality.
The problem with setting up this kind of law in a justice system is that it sets a bad example. Justice systems are based on what the society deems as acceptable, there is no doubt about that. But there is a reason certain human rights exist. Justifying murder by stating that the person was not worthy of life (because that is what you are claiming, they lost their opportunity to live) sets an awful example because being worthy of life is an opinionated matter. In hitlers eyes jews were not worthy of life, and in extremist muslim culture, women are not worthy of the same things as men. If we go by your logic, then the prejudice that occurs in certain societies is acceptable because it is the norm of that society. This is why it is important to set certain rights that every human being is worthy of no matter what.
|
On August 02 2011 05:59 Pulzlulz wrote:Show nested quote +On August 02 2011 05:54 FabledIntegral wrote:On August 02 2011 05:41 Pulzlulz wrote:On August 02 2011 05:29 Blasterion wrote:On August 02 2011 05:26 Pulzlulz wrote:On August 02 2011 05:11 Blasterion wrote:On August 02 2011 05:10 MrDudeMan wrote: shelter, safety and food should be basic human rights. The fact that people do not have it is a problem, not the fact that in certain countries everyone has it. Do mass murderers have human rights? No, he gave it up the moment he took it away from those victims What do you base this on? Lights thoughts from Death Note? Because human rights exist because it is observed by the society you live in. Murder is attack on members of society, without a valid reason it can be interpreted as a treason to the society and there for society chooses to no longer observe the rights of that person. Congratulations, you think like babylonians from 2000BC. He stole my bread? I'm gonna cut off his hands. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Code_of_HammurabiPlease don't talk to me anymore, my brain is full of fuck right now. Btw, I'm sorry I can't write longer answers then I do right now, my English skills aren't sufficient to write in a fast speed without using online dictionaries. Your argument is awful and is only working against you.You're using some petty theft crime with a massive punishment as an analogy. Please, stop trying to make it sound as if every poster that disagrees with you in this thread is the ignorant, or that you are "better" than them. If you're going to call me barbaric because I think someone like Osama deserved to be assassinated, then so be it, I really couldn't care less. Or that you think Hitler wouldn't have deserved execution despite the mass execution of the Jews and essentially causing WW2. Honestly, I'm happy not to have your mentality. Care to explain, where the difference lies between an Osama in prison and a dead Osama? The threat of many innocent, American lives being killed by a drone-like martyr to save the cause of agenda. Care to think how many terrorist acts would be carried out on America holding a Osama in prison?
You seem so dense on your beliefs that they are the only true, correct train of thought and we are all barbarians. Can you please quit the name calling though, no need to be a kid over the subject.
On August 02 2011 06:02 MrDudeMan wrote:Show nested quote +On August 02 2011 05:54 FabledIntegral wrote: Your argument is awful and is only working against you.You're using some petty theft crime with a massive punishment as an analogy. Please, stop trying to make it sound as if every poster that disagrees with you in this thread is the ignorant, or that you are "better" than them. If you're going to call me barbaric because I think someone like Osama deserved to be assassinated, then so be it, I really couldn't care less. Or that you think Hitler wouldn't have deserved execution despite the mass execution of the Jews and essentially causing WW2. Honestly, I'm happy not to have your mentality. The problem with setting up this kind of law in a justice system is that it sets a bad example. Justice systems are based on what the society deems as acceptable, there is no doubt about that. But there is a reason certain human rights exist. Justifying murder by stating that the person was not worthy of life (because that is what you are claiming, they lost their opportunity to live) sets an awful example because being worthy of life is an opinionated matter. In hitlers eyes jews were not worthy of life, and in extremist muslim culture, women are not worthy of the same things as men. If we go by your logic, then the prejudice that occurs in certain societies is acceptable because it is the norm of that society. This is why it is important to set certain rights that every human being is worthy of no matter what.
How would you go about value-ing life when the person whom committed act, admittitdly and willing, whom also subjects himself as a drone to a political idea, whom only value to himself as a tool to spread a voice. Where do we values these people? These terrorists that we argue about. I kinda fail to see how Hitler is in any way related to a terrorist, think about the idea and how hitler and a terrorist value themselves.
|
On August 02 2011 06:01 Blasterion wrote:Show nested quote +On August 02 2011 05:59 Pulzlulz wrote:On August 02 2011 05:54 FabledIntegral wrote:On August 02 2011 05:41 Pulzlulz wrote:On August 02 2011 05:29 Blasterion wrote:On August 02 2011 05:26 Pulzlulz wrote:On August 02 2011 05:11 Blasterion wrote:On August 02 2011 05:10 MrDudeMan wrote: shelter, safety and food should be basic human rights. The fact that people do not have it is a problem, not the fact that in certain countries everyone has it. Do mass murderers have human rights? No, he gave it up the moment he took it away from those victims What do you base this on? Lights thoughts from Death Note? Because human rights exist because it is observed by the society you live in. Murder is attack on members of society, without a valid reason it can be interpreted as a treason to the society and there for society chooses to no longer observe the rights of that person. Congratulations, you think like babylonians from 2000BC. He stole my bread? I'm gonna cut off his hands. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Code_of_HammurabiPlease don't talk to me anymore, my brain is full of fuck right now. Btw, I'm sorry I can't write longer answers then I do right now, my English skills aren't sufficient to write in a fast speed without using online dictionaries. Your argument is awful and is only working against you.You're using some petty theft crime with a massive punishment as an analogy. Please, stop trying to make it sound as if every poster that disagrees with you in this thread is the ignorant, or that you are "better" than them. If you're going to call me barbaric because I think someone like Osama deserved to be assassinated, then so be it, I really couldn't care less. Or that you think Hitler wouldn't have deserved execution despite the mass execution of the Jews and essentially causing WW2. Honestly, I'm happy not to have your mentality. Care to explain, where the difference lies between an Osama in prison and a dead Osama? Depends on how good the prison is. I guess a Dead Osama is just a safety measure That's a good point but still does not justify his death.
The threat of many innocent, American lives being killed by a drone-like martyr to save the cause of agenda. Care to think how many terrorist acts would be carried out on America holding a Osama in prison?
You seem so dense on your beliefs that they are the only true, correct train of thought and we are all barbarians. Can you please quit the name calling though, no need to be a kid over the subject. Name calling? Where? This babylonian thing?
That doesn't make sense to me though. America KILLED Osama, there shouldve been at least 10 attacks by now by your logic, unless I missunderstand you and you mean the same as Blasterion. I believe, it is possible to keep someone's location secret.
|
On August 02 2011 06:03 Pulzlulz wrote:Show nested quote +On August 02 2011 06:01 Blasterion wrote:On August 02 2011 05:59 Pulzlulz wrote:On August 02 2011 05:54 FabledIntegral wrote:On August 02 2011 05:41 Pulzlulz wrote:On August 02 2011 05:29 Blasterion wrote:On August 02 2011 05:26 Pulzlulz wrote:On August 02 2011 05:11 Blasterion wrote:On August 02 2011 05:10 MrDudeMan wrote: shelter, safety and food should be basic human rights. The fact that people do not have it is a problem, not the fact that in certain countries everyone has it. Do mass murderers have human rights? No, he gave it up the moment he took it away from those victims What do you base this on? Lights thoughts from Death Note? Because human rights exist because it is observed by the society you live in. Murder is attack on members of society, without a valid reason it can be interpreted as a treason to the society and there for society chooses to no longer observe the rights of that person. Congratulations, you think like babylonians from 2000BC. He stole my bread? I'm gonna cut off his hands. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Code_of_HammurabiPlease don't talk to me anymore, my brain is full of fuck right now. Btw, I'm sorry I can't write longer answers then I do right now, my English skills aren't sufficient to write in a fast speed without using online dictionaries. Your argument is awful and is only working against you.You're using some petty theft crime with a massive punishment as an analogy. Please, stop trying to make it sound as if every poster that disagrees with you in this thread is the ignorant, or that you are "better" than them. If you're going to call me barbaric because I think someone like Osama deserved to be assassinated, then so be it, I really couldn't care less. Or that you think Hitler wouldn't have deserved execution despite the mass execution of the Jews and essentially causing WW2. Honestly, I'm happy not to have your mentality. Care to explain, where the difference lies between an Osama in prison and a dead Osama? Depends on how good the prison is. I guess a Dead Osama is just a safety measure That's a good point but still does not justify his death. I don't know if it's something we should pride ourselves on but, We Chinese don't really like to justify everything, just gotta do what has to be done.
|
On August 02 2011 06:05 Blasterion wrote:Show nested quote +On August 02 2011 06:03 Pulzlulz wrote:On August 02 2011 06:01 Blasterion wrote:On August 02 2011 05:59 Pulzlulz wrote:On August 02 2011 05:54 FabledIntegral wrote:On August 02 2011 05:41 Pulzlulz wrote:On August 02 2011 05:29 Blasterion wrote:On August 02 2011 05:26 Pulzlulz wrote:On August 02 2011 05:11 Blasterion wrote:On August 02 2011 05:10 MrDudeMan wrote: shelter, safety and food should be basic human rights. The fact that people do not have it is a problem, not the fact that in certain countries everyone has it. Do mass murderers have human rights? No, he gave it up the moment he took it away from those victims What do you base this on? Lights thoughts from Death Note? Because human rights exist because it is observed by the society you live in. Murder is attack on members of society, without a valid reason it can be interpreted as a treason to the society and there for society chooses to no longer observe the rights of that person. Congratulations, you think like babylonians from 2000BC. He stole my bread? I'm gonna cut off his hands. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Code_of_HammurabiPlease don't talk to me anymore, my brain is full of fuck right now. Btw, I'm sorry I can't write longer answers then I do right now, my English skills aren't sufficient to write in a fast speed without using online dictionaries. Your argument is awful and is only working against you.You're using some petty theft crime with a massive punishment as an analogy. Please, stop trying to make it sound as if every poster that disagrees with you in this thread is the ignorant, or that you are "better" than them. If you're going to call me barbaric because I think someone like Osama deserved to be assassinated, then so be it, I really couldn't care less. Or that you think Hitler wouldn't have deserved execution despite the mass execution of the Jews and essentially causing WW2. Honestly, I'm happy not to have your mentality. Care to explain, where the difference lies between an Osama in prison and a dead Osama? Depends on how good the prison is. I guess a Dead Osama is just a safety measure That's a good point but still does not justify his death. I don't know if it's something we should pride ourselves on but, We Chinese don't really like to justify everything, just gotta do what has to be done. It's not like I hate China or America, Europe has a lot of faults too (bombing in Kundus, Afghanistan) but this is what I believe in, which I consider a sustainable belief.
|
On August 02 2011 06:03 Snackysnacks wrote:Show nested quote +On August 02 2011 05:59 Pulzlulz wrote:On August 02 2011 05:54 FabledIntegral wrote:On August 02 2011 05:41 Pulzlulz wrote:On August 02 2011 05:29 Blasterion wrote:On August 02 2011 05:26 Pulzlulz wrote:On August 02 2011 05:11 Blasterion wrote:On August 02 2011 05:10 MrDudeMan wrote: shelter, safety and food should be basic human rights. The fact that people do not have it is a problem, not the fact that in certain countries everyone has it. Do mass murderers have human rights? No, he gave it up the moment he took it away from those victims What do you base this on? Lights thoughts from Death Note? Because human rights exist because it is observed by the society you live in. Murder is attack on members of society, without a valid reason it can be interpreted as a treason to the society and there for society chooses to no longer observe the rights of that person. Congratulations, you think like babylonians from 2000BC. He stole my bread? I'm gonna cut off his hands. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Code_of_HammurabiPlease don't talk to me anymore, my brain is full of fuck right now. Btw, I'm sorry I can't write longer answers then I do right now, my English skills aren't sufficient to write in a fast speed without using online dictionaries. Your argument is awful and is only working against you.You're using some petty theft crime with a massive punishment as an analogy. Please, stop trying to make it sound as if every poster that disagrees with you in this thread is the ignorant, or that you are "better" than them. If you're going to call me barbaric because I think someone like Osama deserved to be assassinated, then so be it, I really couldn't care less. Or that you think Hitler wouldn't have deserved execution despite the mass execution of the Jews and essentially causing WW2. Honestly, I'm happy not to have your mentality. Care to explain, where the difference lies between an Osama in prison and a dead Osama? The threat of many innocent, American lives being killed by a drone-like martyr to save the cause of agenda. Care to think how many terrorist acts would be carried out on America holding a Osama in prison? You seem so dense on your beliefs that they are the only true, correct train of thought and we are all barbarians. Can you please quit the name calling though, no need to be a kid over the subject. Terrorist attacks on the US because of holding Osama captive? If you're really afraid of that, the terrorists have already won. It's exactly what they want. They want people to fear them.
|
On August 02 2011 03:44 maartendq wrote:Show nested quote +On August 02 2011 02:08 tayscrim wrote:On May 14 2011 08:55 Derez wrote: This pretty much proves why victims shouldn't have any say in the punishment of an offender.
'An eye for an eye' isn't justice, it's just retribution. And what is wrong with retribution? She doesn't deserve this after what he has done to her? Something is wrong with you. Retribution does not solve anything. That's what's wrong with it. It does not bring your eyesight back, it does not bring murdered relatives back from the dead, it does nothing. It's highly irrational.
true
|
On August 02 2011 06:05 Blasterion wrote:Show nested quote +On August 02 2011 06:03 Pulzlulz wrote:On August 02 2011 06:01 Blasterion wrote:On August 02 2011 05:59 Pulzlulz wrote:On August 02 2011 05:54 FabledIntegral wrote:On August 02 2011 05:41 Pulzlulz wrote:On August 02 2011 05:29 Blasterion wrote:On August 02 2011 05:26 Pulzlulz wrote:On August 02 2011 05:11 Blasterion wrote:On August 02 2011 05:10 MrDudeMan wrote: shelter, safety and food should be basic human rights. The fact that people do not have it is a problem, not the fact that in certain countries everyone has it. Do mass murderers have human rights? No, he gave it up the moment he took it away from those victims What do you base this on? Lights thoughts from Death Note? Because human rights exist because it is observed by the society you live in. Murder is attack on members of society, without a valid reason it can be interpreted as a treason to the society and there for society chooses to no longer observe the rights of that person. Congratulations, you think like babylonians from 2000BC. He stole my bread? I'm gonna cut off his hands. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Code_of_HammurabiPlease don't talk to me anymore, my brain is full of fuck right now. Btw, I'm sorry I can't write longer answers then I do right now, my English skills aren't sufficient to write in a fast speed without using online dictionaries. Your argument is awful and is only working against you.You're using some petty theft crime with a massive punishment as an analogy. Please, stop trying to make it sound as if every poster that disagrees with you in this thread is the ignorant, or that you are "better" than them. If you're going to call me barbaric because I think someone like Osama deserved to be assassinated, then so be it, I really couldn't care less. Or that you think Hitler wouldn't have deserved execution despite the mass execution of the Jews and essentially causing WW2. Honestly, I'm happy not to have your mentality. Care to explain, where the difference lies between an Osama in prison and a dead Osama? Depends on how good the prison is. I guess a Dead Osama is just a safety measure That's a good point but still does not justify his death. I don't know if it's something we should pride ourselves on but, We Chinese don't really like to justify everything, just gotta do what has to be done. Well, you're not exactly living in a democracy, so I can understand your train of thought. However, in the western world, we expect people to be able to justify their every action.
Who defines "what needs to be done" anyway?
|
On August 02 2011 06:20 maartendq wrote:Show nested quote +On August 02 2011 06:05 Blasterion wrote:On August 02 2011 06:03 Pulzlulz wrote:On August 02 2011 06:01 Blasterion wrote:On August 02 2011 05:59 Pulzlulz wrote:On August 02 2011 05:54 FabledIntegral wrote:On August 02 2011 05:41 Pulzlulz wrote:On August 02 2011 05:29 Blasterion wrote:On August 02 2011 05:26 Pulzlulz wrote:On August 02 2011 05:11 Blasterion wrote: [quote] Do mass murderers have human rights? No, he gave it up the moment he took it away from those victims What do you base this on? Lights thoughts from Death Note? Because human rights exist because it is observed by the society you live in. Murder is attack on members of society, without a valid reason it can be interpreted as a treason to the society and there for society chooses to no longer observe the rights of that person. Congratulations, you think like babylonians from 2000BC. He stole my bread? I'm gonna cut off his hands. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Code_of_HammurabiPlease don't talk to me anymore, my brain is full of fuck right now. Btw, I'm sorry I can't write longer answers then I do right now, my English skills aren't sufficient to write in a fast speed without using online dictionaries. Your argument is awful and is only working against you.You're using some petty theft crime with a massive punishment as an analogy. Please, stop trying to make it sound as if every poster that disagrees with you in this thread is the ignorant, or that you are "better" than them. If you're going to call me barbaric because I think someone like Osama deserved to be assassinated, then so be it, I really couldn't care less. Or that you think Hitler wouldn't have deserved execution despite the mass execution of the Jews and essentially causing WW2. Honestly, I'm happy not to have your mentality. Care to explain, where the difference lies between an Osama in prison and a dead Osama? Depends on how good the prison is. I guess a Dead Osama is just a safety measure That's a good point but still does not justify his death. I don't know if it's something we should pride ourselves on but, We Chinese don't really like to justify everything, just gotta do what has to be done. Well, you're not exactly living in a democracy, so I can understand your train of thought. However, in the western world, we expect people to be able to justify their every action. Who defines "what needs to be done" anyway? Tell who defines what needs to be done in your country? Do the people actually define what needs to be done?
and I don't really like your tone of speaking, intentional or not
|
On August 02 2011 06:23 Blasterion wrote:Show nested quote +On August 02 2011 06:20 maartendq wrote:On August 02 2011 06:05 Blasterion wrote:On August 02 2011 06:03 Pulzlulz wrote:On August 02 2011 06:01 Blasterion wrote:On August 02 2011 05:59 Pulzlulz wrote:On August 02 2011 05:54 FabledIntegral wrote:On August 02 2011 05:41 Pulzlulz wrote:On August 02 2011 05:29 Blasterion wrote:On August 02 2011 05:26 Pulzlulz wrote: [quote] What do you base this on? Lights thoughts from Death Note? Because human rights exist because it is observed by the society you live in. Murder is attack on members of society, without a valid reason it can be interpreted as a treason to the society and there for society chooses to no longer observe the rights of that person. Congratulations, you think like babylonians from 2000BC. He stole my bread? I'm gonna cut off his hands. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Code_of_HammurabiPlease don't talk to me anymore, my brain is full of fuck right now. Btw, I'm sorry I can't write longer answers then I do right now, my English skills aren't sufficient to write in a fast speed without using online dictionaries. Your argument is awful and is only working against you.You're using some petty theft crime with a massive punishment as an analogy. Please, stop trying to make it sound as if every poster that disagrees with you in this thread is the ignorant, or that you are "better" than them. If you're going to call me barbaric because I think someone like Osama deserved to be assassinated, then so be it, I really couldn't care less. Or that you think Hitler wouldn't have deserved execution despite the mass execution of the Jews and essentially causing WW2. Honestly, I'm happy not to have your mentality. Care to explain, where the difference lies between an Osama in prison and a dead Osama? Depends on how good the prison is. I guess a Dead Osama is just a safety measure That's a good point but still does not justify his death. I don't know if it's something we should pride ourselves on but, We Chinese don't really like to justify everything, just gotta do what has to be done. Well, you're not exactly living in a democracy, so I can understand your train of thought. However, in the western world, we expect people to be able to justify their every action. Who defines "what needs to be done" anyway? Tell who defines what needs to be done in your country? Do the people actually define what needs to be done? and I don't really like your tone of speaking, intentional or not It was intentional. I'm usually rather harsh on people who blindly do what others think that "needs to be done." Don't ever do something unless you know why and you agree with that explanation.
If you say that chinese people don't really seek explanations and just do "what needs to be done" I just cannot help but think and fear that you guys are living in some kind of dictatorship (which you kind of are, considering there's only one party in your country and it's not exactly a party that appreciates people not agreeing with them; to put it more bluntly, they're extremely repressive towards dissidents).
Here in Europe members of parliament must, in theory, be able to give a thorough explanation for their decisions. They have to answer to the people who voted for them. If they can't do that, they won't be elected again and/or get ridiculed/criticized in the press.
|
On August 02 2011 06:37 maartendq wrote:Show nested quote +On August 02 2011 06:23 Blasterion wrote:On August 02 2011 06:20 maartendq wrote:On August 02 2011 06:05 Blasterion wrote:On August 02 2011 06:03 Pulzlulz wrote:On August 02 2011 06:01 Blasterion wrote:On August 02 2011 05:59 Pulzlulz wrote:On August 02 2011 05:54 FabledIntegral wrote:On August 02 2011 05:41 Pulzlulz wrote:On August 02 2011 05:29 Blasterion wrote: [quote] Because human rights exist because it is observed by the society you live in. Murder is attack on members of society, without a valid reason it can be interpreted as a treason to the society and there for society chooses to no longer observe the rights of that person. Congratulations, you think like babylonians from 2000BC. He stole my bread? I'm gonna cut off his hands. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Code_of_HammurabiPlease don't talk to me anymore, my brain is full of fuck right now. Btw, I'm sorry I can't write longer answers then I do right now, my English skills aren't sufficient to write in a fast speed without using online dictionaries. Your argument is awful and is only working against you.You're using some petty theft crime with a massive punishment as an analogy. Please, stop trying to make it sound as if every poster that disagrees with you in this thread is the ignorant, or that you are "better" than them. If you're going to call me barbaric because I think someone like Osama deserved to be assassinated, then so be it, I really couldn't care less. Or that you think Hitler wouldn't have deserved execution despite the mass execution of the Jews and essentially causing WW2. Honestly, I'm happy not to have your mentality. Care to explain, where the difference lies between an Osama in prison and a dead Osama? Depends on how good the prison is. I guess a Dead Osama is just a safety measure That's a good point but still does not justify his death. I don't know if it's something we should pride ourselves on but, We Chinese don't really like to justify everything, just gotta do what has to be done. Well, you're not exactly living in a democracy, so I can understand your train of thought. However, in the western world, we expect people to be able to justify their every action. Who defines "what needs to be done" anyway? Tell who defines what needs to be done in your country? Do the people actually define what needs to be done? and I don't really like your tone of speaking, intentional or not It was intentional. I'm usually rather harsh on people who blindly do what others think that "needs to be done." Don't ever do something unless you know why and you agree with that explanation. If you say that chinese people don't really seek explanations and just do "what needs to be done" I just cannot help but think and fear that you guys are living in some kind of dictatorship (which you kind of are, considering there's only one party in your country and it's not exactly a party that appreciates people not agreeing with them; to put it more bluntly, they're extremely repressive towards dissidents). You seem to be dodging my question, Do the people actually defines what needs to be done in your country? or does your government do it?
Edit: To answer your edit, I think it's simple enough to say what needs to be done, improve national economy, security, and promoting life quality. which I think China is doing a decent job. You seem fixed on that Chinese hate their life and you look down on others because their lives are of lower quality. When it's simply not the case
|
On August 02 2011 06:02 MrDudeMan wrote:Show nested quote +On August 02 2011 05:54 FabledIntegral wrote: Your argument is awful and is only working against you.You're using some petty theft crime with a massive punishment as an analogy. Please, stop trying to make it sound as if every poster that disagrees with you in this thread is the ignorant, or that you are "better" than them. If you're going to call me barbaric because I think someone like Osama deserved to be assassinated, then so be it, I really couldn't care less. Or that you think Hitler wouldn't have deserved execution despite the mass execution of the Jews and essentially causing WW2. Honestly, I'm happy not to have your mentality. The problem with setting up this kind of law in a justice system is that it sets a bad example. Justice systems are based on what the society deems as acceptable, there is no doubt about that. But there is a reason certain human rights exist. Justifying murder by stating that the person was not worthy of life (because that is what you are claiming, they lost their opportunity to live) sets an awful example because being worthy of life is an opinionated matter. In hitlers eyes jews were not worthy of life, and in extremist muslim culture, women are not worthy of the same things as men. If we go by your logic, then the prejudice that occurs in certain societies is acceptable because it is the norm of that society. This is why it is important to set certain rights that every human being is worthy of no matter what.
Can we stop using the term murder when it clearly doesn't apply? You can say killing someone, but it doesn't make it murder. And I simply disagree with the notion that every human being is worthy no matter what. Some simply aren't, and I think it's ridiculous to assume otherwise. Where do we draw the line on this supposed slippery slope? It's hard, but it can be done, just like with a million other things in the world you need to draw lines for.
However I'd personally have us not utilize the death penalty simply because our system makes it so hard to actually execute the prisoner that it's not worth it. I'd rather have them sit in jail forever. And if "pursuit of happiness" (someone else quoted it earlier, not you) is a human right, how is prison not denying that?
|
|
|
|
|
|