|
On August 02 2011 04:16 enecateReAP wrote: Im from UK, and I support the death penalty, Im not in favor of government money looking after rapists and murderers, just kill them, they deserve it. If they inflict pain on someone else, they deserve everything that comes to them.
And if the person is accused wrongly of their crimes?
|
I feel really sorry for the woman in this case, however I think that exacting this kind of revenge against the criminal is only going to make things worse for her in the long run. She can never get back her former beauty and now by doing this to the man she will lose all her moral superiority. Not only will her face have been marred but her soul as well. If she can forgive the man and just have him sent to jail I think it will be better for her psychologically, her beauty will be gone but she will have cultivated inner beauty to replace it.
|
On August 02 2011 04:25 JeanLuc wrote:
I feel really sorry for the woman in this case, however I think that exacting this kind of revenge against the criminal is only going to make things worse for her in the long run. She can never get back her former beauty and now by doing this to the man she will lose all her moral superiority. Not only will her face have been marred but her soul as well. If she can forgive the man and just have him sent to jail I think it will be better for her psychologically, her beauty will be gone but she will have cultivated inner beauty to replace it.
Some people don't think like you. I'd be much more at peace by pouring acid on that guy. At the same time, she doesn't lose any "moral superiority" that you claim from your own biased standpoint. To her, isn't she just following her religion?
|
On August 02 2011 04:25 JeanLuc wrote:
I feel really sorry for the woman in this case, however I think that exacting this kind of revenge against the criminal is only going to make things worse for her in the long run. She can never get back her former beauty and now by doing this to the man she will lose all her moral superiority. Not only will her face have been marred but her soul as well. If she can forgive the man and just have him sent to jail I think it will be better for her psychologically, her beauty will be gone but she will have cultivated inner beauty to replace it.
I don't think that etching the mans face is right either, but i can't imagine how she can forgive him after he has done something like that ... i mean she doesn't have to forgive him and she won't get anything out of it ,in my opinion he deserves to be punished but not eye for eye , tooth for tooth
|
Easy to say when it's not your life which has been fubar'ed. Would you be speaking of inner beauty JeanLuc if you were a fugly blind man after some stupid bitch doused you with acid because you turned her down?
No, you'd be mad with rage at having a great deal of your life taken away from you. The idiot needs to be taught a lesson - you can't go fucking douse people who reject you with acid.
And more importantly, like-minded idiots need to be warned and scared so as to avoid anything similar from happening again.
Kind of like cutting one hand from a thief if ever caught stolen. Great dissuasive material.
Does anyone know if the punishment has been executed already?
|
On August 02 2011 04:27 FabledIntegral wrote:+ Show Spoiler +On August 02 2011 04:25 JeanLuc wrote:
I feel really sorry for the woman in this case, however I think that exacting this kind of revenge against the criminal is only going to make things worse for her in the long run. She can never get back her former beauty and now by doing this to the man she will lose all her moral superiority. Not only will her face have been marred but her soul as well. If she can forgive the man and just have him sent to jail I think it will be better for her psychologically, her beauty will be gone but she will have cultivated inner beauty to replace it. Some people don't think like you. I'd be much more at peace by pouring acid on that guy. At the same time, she doesn't lose any "moral superiority" that you claim from your own biased standpoint. To her, isn't she just following her religion?
In an attempt to not turn this into a religion debate, I am going to simply say that using "she's just following her religion" as a reason for this sort of revenge is not justified as all of the anti-female extremists are simply following their religion as well.
On August 02 2011 04:30 Suvorov wrote:+ Show Spoiler + Easy to say when it's not your life which has been fubar'ed. Would you be speaking of inner beauty JeanLuc if you were a fugly blind man after some stupid bitch doused you with acid because you turned her down?
No, you'd be mad with rage at having a great deal of your life taken away from you. The idiot needs to be taught a lesson - you can't go fucking douse people who reject you with acid.
And more importantly, like-minded idiots need to be warned and scared so as to avoid anything similar from happening again.
Kind of like cutting one hand from a thief if ever caught stolen. Great dissuasive material.
Does anyone know if the punishment has been executed already?
Of course most people are going to want revenge immediately after words, but they are not in a position to be making that call anyways. Hell, I want to hurt someone after a frustrating game of starcraft but a minute later I'm perfectly calm. People need time to accept what has happened, but exacting revenge is not going to help her feel any better about her losses. And a society should never be enforced through the means of fear, it just doesn't work.
|
On August 02 2011 04:23 MrDudeMan wrote:Show nested quote +On August 02 2011 03:56 pyrogenetix wrote: I'm really surprised so many of you are saying that she shouldn't do it because it's not right etc.
Women get treated like vermin in Iran. Girls that go to school are attacked with acid all the time because their culture think that only boys should go and girls should stay at home doing housework and cooking. As a woman, the only thing going for you is your attractive looks. Having that taken away is almost like cutting off a man's penis and cutting off his hands so he cannot make money.
It's a little sickening to me how many of you sit comfortably in your air conditioned rooms with fast internet and three hot meals a day and say that "hurr durr this is wrong bla bla we should be the better man".
Get the fuck out.
If your girlfriend/wife or mother were attacked and ended up looking like a fucking ghoul, never to be able to hold their head high in public, never able to sexually arouse another male, you wouldn't let it go either. I know I wouldn't.
Until there exists scientific evidence that having such a revenge system doesn't lower the acid attacks on women, I don't see any fucking reason at all to stop this. How exactly will revenge help her? I think a lot of people have forgotten that the point of a prison system it to serve as both punishment and rehabilitation. An eye for an eye will not suddenly make the men view the women as being equal, if anything it will cause further hate between them. It helps her because she is a human and as humans we are driven by emotion. If she gets a certain satisfaction in doing that then she should. Who are you to say otherwise?
I do realize that she decided to spare him, but still that was her choice. If someone cut off your penis and testicles, you wouldn't be having this whole "oh well, you know, he was a little upset and should just be taken to jail and rehabilitated" attitude.
Yes crazy monsters exist in the world. They should be met with proportionate force because that is the only thing they understand. They already fail to see what is wrong with throwing acid into someone's face why would you think talking to them is of any use? If your country was being invaded by an army, would you simply go out and talk with them?
If you want to go deeper into the issue we could be here forever. Backwards cultural traditions, economic instability, social acceptance of degrading women etc etc. All these issues take decades if not centuries to solve. What would be your plan to fix all this?
|
On August 02 2011 04:24 ZeritoN wrote:Show nested quote +On August 02 2011 04:16 enecateReAP wrote: Im from UK, and I support the death penalty, Im not in favor of government money looking after rapists and murderers, just kill them, they deserve it. If they inflict pain on someone else, they deserve everything that comes to them. And if the person is accused wrongly of their crimes?
That is a breakdown in the legal system...not in the punishment handed out for a crime. Simple rules like murder = death sentence make sense to me. The fear of our legal system getting a verdit wrong should not change the punishment for a crime.
|
On August 02 2011 04:30 MrDudeMan wrote:Show nested quote +On August 02 2011 04:27 FabledIntegral wrote:+ Show Spoiler +On August 02 2011 04:25 JeanLuc wrote:
I feel really sorry for the woman in this case, however I think that exacting this kind of revenge against the criminal is only going to make things worse for her in the long run. She can never get back her former beauty and now by doing this to the man she will lose all her moral superiority. Not only will her face have been marred but her soul as well. If she can forgive the man and just have him sent to jail I think it will be better for her psychologically, her beauty will be gone but she will have cultivated inner beauty to replace it. Some people don't think like you. I'd be much more at peace by pouring acid on that guy. At the same time, she doesn't lose any "moral superiority" that you claim from your own biased standpoint. To her, isn't she just following her religion? In an attempt to not turn this into a religion debate, I am going to simply say that using "she's just following her religion" as a reason for this sort of revenge is not justified as all of the anti-female extremists are simply following their religion as well.
Yeah, and they seem in most part to be fine with it. Ok, your point doesn't mean much to me. Do I think it's morally wrong from my perspective? Yes. But it's not relevant to how they feel about it, thus there's no reason to suggest them taking some "moral high ground." And if it is relevant, it's clearly less relevant.
|
On August 02 2011 04:47 Khaymus wrote:Show nested quote +On August 02 2011 04:24 ZeritoN wrote:On August 02 2011 04:16 enecateReAP wrote: Im from UK, and I support the death penalty, Im not in favor of government money looking after rapists and murderers, just kill them, they deserve it. If they inflict pain on someone else, they deserve everything that comes to them. And if the person is accused wrongly of their crimes? That is a breakdown in the legal system...not in the punishment handed out for a crime. Simple rules like murder = death sentence make sense to me. The fear of our legal system getting a verdit wrong should not change the punishment for a crime. It's disgusting to read that people approve the death penalty. Absolutely no one has the right to take someone elses life, no matter what they did. An eye for an eye? Welcome uncivilized world.
|
On August 02 2011 04:41 pyrogenetix wrote:+ Show Spoiler + It helps her because she is a human and as humans we are driven by emotion. If she gets a certain satisfaction in doing that then she should. Who are you to say otherwise?
I do realize that she decided to spare him, but still that was her choice. If someone cut off your penis and testicles, you wouldn't be having this whole "oh well, you know, he was a little upset and should just be taken to jail and rehabilitated" attitude.
Yes crazy monsters exist in the world. They should be met with proportionate force because that is the only thing they understand. They already fail to see what is wrong with throwing acid into someone's face why would you think talking to them is of any use? If your country was being invaded by an army, would you simply go out and talk with them?
If you want to go deeper into the issue we could be here forever. Backwards cultural traditions, economic instability, social acceptance of degrading women etc etc. All these issues take decades if not centuries to solve. What would be your plan to fix all this?
Are you seriously suggesting we should act based on our emotions instead of logical rationale? Harsh punishments (such as capital punishment) never reduce crime rates, here is a comparison of crime rates in states with the death penalty and without. I'm going to paraphrase day9 and say that emotions are the result of chemical reactions in your body, they should not be what a justice system is based off. And my plan to solving the social problems in Iran is to step away from religion, but this is not an appropriate place to discuss that.
|
|
|
On August 02 2011 04:55 Pulzlulz wrote:Show nested quote +On August 02 2011 04:47 Khaymus wrote:On August 02 2011 04:24 ZeritoN wrote:On August 02 2011 04:16 enecateReAP wrote: Im from UK, and I support the death penalty, Im not in favor of government money looking after rapists and murderers, just kill them, they deserve it. If they inflict pain on someone else, they deserve everything that comes to them. And if the person is accused wrongly of their crimes? That is a breakdown in the legal system...not in the punishment handed out for a crime. Simple rules like murder = death sentence make sense to me. The fear of our legal system getting a verdit wrong should not change the punishment for a crime. It's disgusting to read that people approve the death penalty. Absolutely no one has the right to take someone elses life, no matter what they did. An eye for an eye? Welcome uncivilized world. No "one" has the right to take someone else's life. But Society has the right to take someones' life for the sake of preventing harm to it's members
|
On August 02 2011 04:55 Pulzlulz wrote:Show nested quote +On August 02 2011 04:47 Khaymus wrote:On August 02 2011 04:24 ZeritoN wrote:On August 02 2011 04:16 enecateReAP wrote: Im from UK, and I support the death penalty, Im not in favor of government money looking after rapists and murderers, just kill them, they deserve it. If they inflict pain on someone else, they deserve everything that comes to them. And if the person is accused wrongly of their crimes? That is a breakdown in the legal system...not in the punishment handed out for a crime. Simple rules like murder = death sentence make sense to me. The fear of our legal system getting a verdit wrong should not change the punishment for a crime. It's disgusting to read that people approve the death penalty. Absolutely no one has the right to take someone elses life, no matter what they did. An eye for an eye? Welcome uncivilized world.
Yeah, I don't see any basis behind that. I disagree 100%. You mass murder, you forfeit your right to life. You consider my ways barbaric, I consider yours ridiculous. Whatever.
I also fail to see how life in prison is any less barbaric.
|
On August 02 2011 04:55 Pulzlulz wrote:Show nested quote +On August 02 2011 04:47 Khaymus wrote:On August 02 2011 04:24 ZeritoN wrote:On August 02 2011 04:16 enecateReAP wrote: Im from UK, and I support the death penalty, Im not in favor of government money looking after rapists and murderers, just kill them, they deserve it. If they inflict pain on someone else, they deserve everything that comes to them. And if the person is accused wrongly of their crimes? That is a breakdown in the legal system...not in the punishment handed out for a crime. Simple rules like murder = death sentence make sense to me. The fear of our legal system getting a verdit wrong should not change the punishment for a crime. It's disgusting to read that people approve the death penalty. Absolutely no one has the right to take someone elses life, no matter what they did. An eye for an eye? Welcome uncivilized world.
Uncivilized world in my opinion is someone who can go on a killing spree and end up getting free shelter and food for the rest of their life paid for by the relatives of his victims.
|
On August 02 2011 04:58 Blasterion wrote:Show nested quote +On August 02 2011 04:55 Pulzlulz wrote:On August 02 2011 04:47 Khaymus wrote:On August 02 2011 04:24 ZeritoN wrote:On August 02 2011 04:16 enecateReAP wrote: Im from UK, and I support the death penalty, Im not in favor of government money looking after rapists and murderers, just kill them, they deserve it. If they inflict pain on someone else, they deserve everything that comes to them. And if the person is accused wrongly of their crimes? That is a breakdown in the legal system...not in the punishment handed out for a crime. Simple rules like murder = death sentence make sense to me. The fear of our legal system getting a verdit wrong should not change the punishment for a crime. It's disgusting to read that people approve the death penalty. Absolutely no one has the right to take someone elses life, no matter what they did. An eye for an eye? Welcome uncivilized world. No "one" has the right to take someone else's life. But Society has the right to take someones' life for the sake of preventing harm to it's members Then society is a bunch of uneducated apes. Imagine you are the doctor injecting the poison. You are a murderer and did the same crime as the person you just killed. No, you are even worse because you think your action was righteous.
|
On August 02 2011 04:59 Khaymus wrote:Show nested quote +On August 02 2011 04:55 Pulzlulz wrote:On August 02 2011 04:47 Khaymus wrote:On August 02 2011 04:24 ZeritoN wrote:On August 02 2011 04:16 enecateReAP wrote: Im from UK, and I support the death penalty, Im not in favor of government money looking after rapists and murderers, just kill them, they deserve it. If they inflict pain on someone else, they deserve everything that comes to them. And if the person is accused wrongly of their crimes? That is a breakdown in the legal system...not in the punishment handed out for a crime. Simple rules like murder = death sentence make sense to me. The fear of our legal system getting a verdit wrong should not change the punishment for a crime. It's disgusting to read that people approve the death penalty. Absolutely no one has the right to take someone elses life, no matter what they did. An eye for an eye? Welcome uncivilized world. Uncivilized world in my opinion is someone who can go on a killing spree and end up getting free shelter and food for the rest of their life paid for by the relatives of his victims. Doesn't that sound real familiar?
|
On August 02 2011 05:01 Pulzlulz wrote:Show nested quote +On August 02 2011 04:58 Blasterion wrote:On August 02 2011 04:55 Pulzlulz wrote:On August 02 2011 04:47 Khaymus wrote:On August 02 2011 04:24 ZeritoN wrote:On August 02 2011 04:16 enecateReAP wrote: Im from UK, and I support the death penalty, Im not in favor of government money looking after rapists and murderers, just kill them, they deserve it. If they inflict pain on someone else, they deserve everything that comes to them. And if the person is accused wrongly of their crimes? That is a breakdown in the legal system...not in the punishment handed out for a crime. Simple rules like murder = death sentence make sense to me. The fear of our legal system getting a verdit wrong should not change the punishment for a crime. It's disgusting to read that people approve the death penalty. Absolutely no one has the right to take someone elses life, no matter what they did. An eye for an eye? Welcome uncivilized world. No "one" has the right to take someone else's life. But Society has the right to take someones' life for the sake of preventing harm to it's members Then society is a bunch of uneducated apes. Imagine you are the doctor injecting the poison. You are a murderer and did the same crime as the person you just killed. No, you are even worse because you think your action was righteous. Yes I am righteous because I put down a criminal that was a threat to the society that I live in
|
On August 02 2011 05:01 Pulzlulz wrote:Show nested quote +On August 02 2011 04:58 Blasterion wrote:On August 02 2011 04:55 Pulzlulz wrote:On August 02 2011 04:47 Khaymus wrote:On August 02 2011 04:24 ZeritoN wrote:On August 02 2011 04:16 enecateReAP wrote: Im from UK, and I support the death penalty, Im not in favor of government money looking after rapists and murderers, just kill them, they deserve it. If they inflict pain on someone else, they deserve everything that comes to them. And if the person is accused wrongly of their crimes? That is a breakdown in the legal system...not in the punishment handed out for a crime. Simple rules like murder = death sentence make sense to me. The fear of our legal system getting a verdit wrong should not change the punishment for a crime. It's disgusting to read that people approve the death penalty. Absolutely no one has the right to take someone elses life, no matter what they did. An eye for an eye? Welcome uncivilized world. No "one" has the right to take someone else's life. But Society has the right to take someones' life for the sake of preventing harm to it's members Then society is a bunch of uneducated apes. Imagine you are the doctor injecting the poison. You are a murderer and did the same crime as the person you just killed. No, you are even worse because you think your action was righteous.
This argument is so stupid. No, it's not even the definition of murder. You did not do the same thing, you did not commit any crime. The logic honestly makes me laugh in my seat. You're trying to tell me you think an executioner who puts down a mass murderer is worse than the murderer himself? LOL.
|
On August 02 2011 04:59 Khaymus wrote:Show nested quote +On August 02 2011 04:55 Pulzlulz wrote:On August 02 2011 04:47 Khaymus wrote:On August 02 2011 04:24 ZeritoN wrote:On August 02 2011 04:16 enecateReAP wrote: Im from UK, and I support the death penalty, Im not in favor of government money looking after rapists and murderers, just kill them, they deserve it. If they inflict pain on someone else, they deserve everything that comes to them. And if the person is accused wrongly of their crimes? That is a breakdown in the legal system...not in the punishment handed out for a crime. Simple rules like murder = death sentence make sense to me. The fear of our legal system getting a verdit wrong should not change the punishment for a crime. It's disgusting to read that people approve the death penalty. Absolutely no one has the right to take someone elses life, no matter what they did. An eye for an eye? Welcome uncivilized world. Uncivilized world in my opinion is someone who can go on a killing spree and end up getting free shelter and food for the rest of their life paid for by the relatives of his victims. This person is punished by being excluded of society for the rest of their lives.
|
|
|
|
|
|