|
On August 01 2011 05:11 bluQ wrote:Show nested quote +On August 01 2011 04:08 Grenadieris wrote:On August 01 2011 03:12 Gamegene wrote:On August 01 2011 02:47 Stratos_speAr wrote: Why is it wrong to do this to him though? That's the question. He (arguably) deserves it for completely ruining this woman's life. This sounds naive, foolish and possibly even idealistic: Because it's not right. It's not right to do that action, regardless of the reason. Do you send a rapist to get raped? Do you let drunk drivers get hit by drunk drivers? We live in the 21st fucking century. There's 5000+ years of despicable cruel and unusual punishment all under this simple (and dumb) idea that it's okay because it's an "eye for an eye". Let's try to grow up a little bit as a society. I don't get how 5000 years of wrong punishments is connected to "eye for an eye". People got their fingers/hands cut off for stealing, clearly that's going over the top. Some got beheaded for treason, that doesn't seem like "eye for an eye" neither. Actually yeah, I do think rapists should get raped and etc., maybe that would actually achieve some results. As we can observe rapists who leave prison often rape again. Of course I'm exaggerating, but there is no prison that would do justice enough to this man. It's simple as that. Sometimes animals need to put down. You do know you will create an infinity loop? I first giggled when i recon that but then got sad that we would have a world full of rapist
I'm actually in favor of flat out death penalty for violent criminals, at least when their crimes result in permanent harm to their victims.
Its not a matter of cruelty, or of punishing them. Its simply that their behavior is not tolerable in society, they are defective. The cost of rehabilitating them, combined with their potential to backslide, is greater than their potential value to society. The only rational course of action is to dispose of such waste.
There are two ways you can look at a violent criminal. Either he cannot be made well again, in which case ending his life is the only way to prevent relapse, or he CAN be made well again, in which case he will be wracked with guilt over his past actions, and killing him is a mercy.
Cruelty doesn't factor into this, nor does punishment. Its the only logical solution.
|
I think that the woman lacked money so she hoped to gain some for abstaining from this judgement.
On August 01 2011 05:11 bluQ wrote:Show nested quote +On August 01 2011 04:08 Grenadieris wrote:On August 01 2011 03:12 Gamegene wrote:On August 01 2011 02:47 Stratos_speAr wrote: Why is it wrong to do this to him though? That's the question. He (arguably) deserves it for completely ruining this woman's life. This sounds naive, foolish and possibly even idealistic: Because it's not right. It's not right to do that action, regardless of the reason. Do you send a rapist to get raped? Do you let drunk drivers get hit by drunk drivers? We live in the 21st fucking century. There's 5000+ years of despicable cruel and unusual punishment all under this simple (and dumb) idea that it's okay because it's an "eye for an eye". Let's try to grow up a little bit as a society. I don't get how 5000 years of wrong punishments is connected to "eye for an eye". People got their fingers/hands cut off for stealing, clearly that's going over the top. Some got beheaded for treason, that doesn't seem like "eye for an eye" neither. Actually yeah, I do think rapists should get raped and etc., maybe that would actually achieve some results. As we can observe rapists who leave prison often rape again. Of course I'm exaggerating, but there is no prison that would do justice enough to this man. It's simple as that. Sometimes animals need to put down. You do know you will create an infinity loop? I first giggled when i recon that but then got sad that we would have a world full of rapist No, it would end in gay relationships.
|
"In Iran..." OK now everything makes sense.
But seriously in some countries (mostly chaotic ones) the "system of law and justice" if you consider it to exist bears the ideology of retribution and "eye for an eye" as stated in past posts.
|
On August 01 2011 05:20 Horst wrote:Show nested quote +On August 01 2011 05:11 bluQ wrote:On August 01 2011 04:08 Grenadieris wrote:On August 01 2011 03:12 Gamegene wrote:On August 01 2011 02:47 Stratos_speAr wrote: Why is it wrong to do this to him though? That's the question. He (arguably) deserves it for completely ruining this woman's life. This sounds naive, foolish and possibly even idealistic: Because it's not right. It's not right to do that action, regardless of the reason. Do you send a rapist to get raped? Do you let drunk drivers get hit by drunk drivers? We live in the 21st fucking century. There's 5000+ years of despicable cruel and unusual punishment all under this simple (and dumb) idea that it's okay because it's an "eye for an eye". Let's try to grow up a little bit as a society. I don't get how 5000 years of wrong punishments is connected to "eye for an eye". People got their fingers/hands cut off for stealing, clearly that's going over the top. Some got beheaded for treason, that doesn't seem like "eye for an eye" neither. Actually yeah, I do think rapists should get raped and etc., maybe that would actually achieve some results. As we can observe rapists who leave prison often rape again. Of course I'm exaggerating, but there is no prison that would do justice enough to this man. It's simple as that. Sometimes animals need to put down. You do know you will create an infinity loop? I first giggled when i recon that but then got sad that we would have a world full of rapist I'm actually in favor of flat out death penalty for violent criminals, at least when their crimes result in permanent harm to their victims. Its not a matter of cruelty, or of punishing them. Its simply that their behavior is not tolerable in society, they are defective. The cost of rehabilitating them, combined with their potential to backslide, is greater than their potential value to society. The only rational course of action is to dispose of such waste. There are two ways you can look at a violent criminal. Either he cannot be made well again, in which case ending his life is the only way to prevent relapse, or he CAN be made well again, in which case he will be wracked with guilt over his past actions, and killing him is a mercy. Cruelty doesn't factor into this, nor does punishment. Its the only logical solution.
Your 'logic' is flawed. If the person is rehabilitated, sure they will be wracked with guilt, but do you REALLY think that they will feel so guilty they want to die? hahaha. Irrational 'rationality' ftw.
|
On August 01 2011 05:20 Horst wrote:Show nested quote +On August 01 2011 05:11 bluQ wrote:On August 01 2011 04:08 Grenadieris wrote:On August 01 2011 03:12 Gamegene wrote:On August 01 2011 02:47 Stratos_speAr wrote: Why is it wrong to do this to him though? That's the question. He (arguably) deserves it for completely ruining this woman's life. This sounds naive, foolish and possibly even idealistic: Because it's not right. It's not right to do that action, regardless of the reason. Do you send a rapist to get raped? Do you let drunk drivers get hit by drunk drivers? We live in the 21st fucking century. There's 5000+ years of despicable cruel and unusual punishment all under this simple (and dumb) idea that it's okay because it's an "eye for an eye". Let's try to grow up a little bit as a society. I don't get how 5000 years of wrong punishments is connected to "eye for an eye". People got their fingers/hands cut off for stealing, clearly that's going over the top. Some got beheaded for treason, that doesn't seem like "eye for an eye" neither. Actually yeah, I do think rapists should get raped and etc., maybe that would actually achieve some results. As we can observe rapists who leave prison often rape again. Of course I'm exaggerating, but there is no prison that would do justice enough to this man. It's simple as that. Sometimes animals need to put down. You do know you will create an infinity loop? I first giggled when i recon that but then got sad that we would have a world full of rapist I'm actually in favor of flat out death penalty for violent criminals, at least when their crimes result in permanent harm to their victims. Its not a matter of cruelty, or of punishing them. Its simply that their behavior is not tolerable in society, they are defective. The cost of rehabilitating them, combined with their potential to backslide, is greater than their potential value to society. The only rational course of action is to dispose of such waste. There are two ways you can look at a violent criminal. Either he cannot be made well again, in which case ending his life is the only way to prevent relapse, or he CAN be made well again, in which case he will be wracked with guilt over his past actions, and killing him is a mercy. Cruelty doesn't factor into this, nor does punishment. Its the only logical solution.
Logic? What logic is there in you deciding what people would and wouldn't feel en masse? How can you so easily write off lives with such a pathetically simple template?
Where is the humanity in your response?
"killing him is a mercy"
Read what you wrote, look past the petty logic and absorb what you are saying. When is ripping someone's soul from their body not cruel?
|
This kind of thing is not really a black and white issue, it's a grey and grey morality spectrum. So I don't expect to convince anybody at all, I expect pretty much the opposite.
Maybe it's because I was raised in the United States, where for the most part we (judicially) classify eye for an eye punishments as cruel and unusual.
But I don't understand- No I understand completely. I don't accept. I don't accept this notion that it's okay to do wrong if someone else does wrong. For me, two lefts do not make a right, it only veers us further from the correct path.
...I'm not an especially religious person, but I think this pretty much sums it up:
"All they that take the sword shall perish with the sword."
We have to be better than this. We, as a people, as a society have to be better than pouring acid into another persons eyes.
And I would love to see who would want this implemented in their own home countries. I seriously doubt anybody would enjoy any of the legal implications involved with such a barbaric idea.
|
On August 01 2011 05:20 Horst wrote:Show nested quote +On August 01 2011 05:11 bluQ wrote:On August 01 2011 04:08 Grenadieris wrote:On August 01 2011 03:12 Gamegene wrote:On August 01 2011 02:47 Stratos_speAr wrote: Why is it wrong to do this to him though? That's the question. He (arguably) deserves it for completely ruining this woman's life. This sounds naive, foolish and possibly even idealistic: Because it's not right. It's not right to do that action, regardless of the reason. Do you send a rapist to get raped? Do you let drunk drivers get hit by drunk drivers? We live in the 21st fucking century. There's 5000+ years of despicable cruel and unusual punishment all under this simple (and dumb) idea that it's okay because it's an "eye for an eye". Let's try to grow up a little bit as a society. I don't get how 5000 years of wrong punishments is connected to "eye for an eye". People got their fingers/hands cut off for stealing, clearly that's going over the top. Some got beheaded for treason, that doesn't seem like "eye for an eye" neither. Actually yeah, I do think rapists should get raped and etc., maybe that would actually achieve some results. As we can observe rapists who leave prison often rape again. Of course I'm exaggerating, but there is no prison that would do justice enough to this man. It's simple as that. Sometimes animals need to put down. You do know you will create an infinity loop? I first giggled when i recon that but then got sad that we would have a world full of rapist I'm actually in favor of flat out death penalty for violent criminals, at least when their crimes result in permanent harm to their victims. Its not a matter of cruelty, or of punishing them. Its simply that their behavior is not tolerable in society, they are defective. The cost of rehabilitating them, combined with their potential to backslide, is greater than their potential value to society. The only rational course of action is to dispose of such waste. There are two ways you can look at a violent criminal. Either he cannot be made well again, in which case ending his life is the only way to prevent relapse, or he CAN be made well again, in which case he will be wracked with guilt over his past actions, and killing him is a mercy. Cruelty doesn't factor into this, nor does punishment. Its the only logical solution.
Above from the 2 post after yours which already point out the flaws and inadequacies of your post, I have another point to add. Or rather a question:
So what have you done that deserves severe punishment????
The reason I ask is cause you seem to be so educated in terms of psychology of offenders after full or partial rehabilitation. Now if you are NOT educated on it, than you base your judgement to end peoples lives on assumptions or similar unstable arguments. Now if THAT is the case, you should be put to rest based on your own "logic" cause you decided to end peoples lives based on invalid or or arbitrary information or judgments.
On subject: I would venture a guess the woman let him off in favour of substantial monetary compensation. Back when the etching was supposed to happen (around original fiirst post) in an interview I heard her say she forfeited the money in favour of punishing him. Hence my assumption of her being talked into taking the cash.
|
That`s the Middle East for you.
User was temp banned for this post.
|
The offenders obviously will never feel remorse. I find this pain with pain world a sorry place to live in, but at this point I can see the justice behind it, given that fairness was always based on a society's judgement.
offenders dont expect to have the same thing happen to them. The best time to punish an offense is immediately and in the same manner. The offender stops being antisocial completely after becoming a victim of their own act. its actually damn effective.
|
On August 01 2011 18:54 BlizzrdSlave wrote:Show nested quote + The offenders obviously will never feel remorse. I find this pain with pain world a sorry place to live in, but at this point I can see the justice behind it, given that fairness was always based on a society's judgement.
offenders dont expect to have the same thing happen to them. The best time to punish an offense is immediately and in the same manner. The offender stops being antisocial completely after becoming a victim of their own act. its actually damn effective.
Yes, this will work for smaller crimes. When you get to crimes which either ends live or severly hampers it (for instance..etching someones eyes out..) then the offender will not be able to learn from his actions, as he wont be able to function normally.
|
On August 01 2011 05:55 sorrowptoss wrote: But seriously in some countries (mostly chaotic ones) the "system of law and justice" if you consider it to exist bears the ideology of retribution and "eye for an eye" as stated in past posts. In other countries the "system of law and justice" has the one with the most money winning simply because he can afford the best lawyers. Most systems of law in "western civilized countries" have lawyers (and judges) using the letter of the law to defeat the spirit of the law. So "us westerners" cant really complain about the Iranian system, because our laws arent perfect either because the punishments dont prevent criminals from their illegal deeds.
"Eye for an eye" literally is a bad way to go and there are always alternatives which are deterring as well without crippling another human being.
|
Although throwing acid in his eyes will not bring back the woman's eyesight, I would like some statistics in the coming years on whether the occurrences of such incidents drop in the future in Iran.
|
On August 01 2011 06:04 ShatterZer0 wrote:Show nested quote +On August 01 2011 05:20 Horst wrote:On August 01 2011 05:11 bluQ wrote:On August 01 2011 04:08 Grenadieris wrote:On August 01 2011 03:12 Gamegene wrote:On August 01 2011 02:47 Stratos_speAr wrote: Why is it wrong to do this to him though? That's the question. He (arguably) deserves it for completely ruining this woman's life. This sounds naive, foolish and possibly even idealistic: Because it's not right. It's not right to do that action, regardless of the reason. Do you send a rapist to get raped? Do you let drunk drivers get hit by drunk drivers? We live in the 21st fucking century. There's 5000+ years of despicable cruel and unusual punishment all under this simple (and dumb) idea that it's okay because it's an "eye for an eye". Let's try to grow up a little bit as a society. I don't get how 5000 years of wrong punishments is connected to "eye for an eye". People got their fingers/hands cut off for stealing, clearly that's going over the top. Some got beheaded for treason, that doesn't seem like "eye for an eye" neither. Actually yeah, I do think rapists should get raped and etc., maybe that would actually achieve some results. As we can observe rapists who leave prison often rape again. Of course I'm exaggerating, but there is no prison that would do justice enough to this man. It's simple as that. Sometimes animals need to put down. You do know you will create an infinity loop? I first giggled when i recon that but then got sad that we would have a world full of rapist I'm actually in favor of flat out death penalty for violent criminals, at least when their crimes result in permanent harm to their victims. Its not a matter of cruelty, or of punishing them. Its simply that their behavior is not tolerable in society, they are defective. The cost of rehabilitating them, combined with their potential to backslide, is greater than their potential value to society. The only rational course of action is to dispose of such waste. There are two ways you can look at a violent criminal. Either he cannot be made well again, in which case ending his life is the only way to prevent relapse, or he CAN be made well again, in which case he will be wracked with guilt over his past actions, and killing him is a mercy. Cruelty doesn't factor into this, nor does punishment. Its the only logical solution. Logic? What logic is there in you deciding what people would and wouldn't feel en masse? How can you so easily write off lives with such a pathetically simple template? Where is the humanity in your response? "killing him is a mercy" Read what you wrote, look past the petty logic and absorb what you are saying. When is ripping someone's soul from their body not cruel?
When they "rip someones soul from someone elses body". I agree killing him is not mercy, but rather retribution. It bothers me to this day that everyone is instilled with right and wrong at birth but we dont always believe in things i think are obvious, like eye for an eye or cash, which is pretty legit imo.
Does it spawn from people not wanting to die? That in itself is in false logic because if someone killed others, self preservation would force you to lock them up forever or kill them. I'm in favor of the latter, because why should the already mispent tax dollars keep that asshole alive?
|
On May 14 2011 08:49 kerpal wrote:...makes the whole world blind -gandhi
At least he will not have an advantage over me.
I say... An eye for the head.
|
Good news. Sadly this judge gave him something that is given once in a million.. you know... fair punishment.
|
On August 01 2011 21:44 targ wrote: Although throwing acid in his eyes will not bring back the woman's eyesight, I would like some statistics in the coming years on whether the occurrences of such incidents drop in the future in Iran.
Me too.
That's the problem of nowadays screwed society. That doing terrible, abominable things may prevent even more terrible, abominable things in the future. In Iran, there's apparently a good amount of people who think it's cool to throw acid in the eye of women who reject them. I've read many articles on this, these are NOT isolated cases. It happens dreadfully often.
Make no mistake, I am 100% against allowing her to do the same to him, since it's against everything I believe in both as a legal scholar and as a human being. Nevertheless the question remains: what if this really is the only way to prevent those "brainsick-degenerated-sorry-excuses-for-human-beings" to do this to women? What if, in Iran, this really is the only way to make sure men don't throw acid into women's eyes?
|
On August 01 2011 05:20 Horst wrote:Show nested quote +On August 01 2011 05:11 bluQ wrote:On August 01 2011 04:08 Grenadieris wrote:On August 01 2011 03:12 Gamegene wrote:On August 01 2011 02:47 Stratos_speAr wrote: Why is it wrong to do this to him though? That's the question. He (arguably) deserves it for completely ruining this woman's life. This sounds naive, foolish and possibly even idealistic: Because it's not right. It's not right to do that action, regardless of the reason. Do you send a rapist to get raped? Do you let drunk drivers get hit by drunk drivers? We live in the 21st fucking century. There's 5000+ years of despicable cruel and unusual punishment all under this simple (and dumb) idea that it's okay because it's an "eye for an eye". Let's try to grow up a little bit as a society. I don't get how 5000 years of wrong punishments is connected to "eye for an eye". People got their fingers/hands cut off for stealing, clearly that's going over the top. Some got beheaded for treason, that doesn't seem like "eye for an eye" neither. Actually yeah, I do think rapists should get raped and etc., maybe that would actually achieve some results. As we can observe rapists who leave prison often rape again. Of course I'm exaggerating, but there is no prison that would do justice enough to this man. It's simple as that. Sometimes animals need to put down. You do know you will create an infinity loop? I first giggled when i recon that but then got sad that we would have a world full of rapist I'm actually in favor of flat out death penalty for violent criminals, at least when their crimes result in permanent harm to their victims. Its not a matter of cruelty, or of punishing them. Its simply that their behavior is not tolerable in society, they are defective. The cost of rehabilitating them, combined with their potential to backslide, is greater than their potential value to society. The only rational course of action is to dispose of such waste. There are two ways you can look at a violent criminal. Either he cannot be made well again, in which case ending his life is the only way to prevent relapse, or he CAN be made well again, in which case he will be wracked with guilt over his past actions, and killing him is a mercy. Cruelty doesn't factor into this, nor does punishment. Its the only logical solution. Do you, by chance, watch way too many movies or anime series? Because seriously, that's not how reality works. People can live with guilt without being suicidal, you know.
|
On August 01 2011 22:06 sleepingdog wrote:Show nested quote +On August 01 2011 21:44 targ wrote: Although throwing acid in his eyes will not bring back the woman's eyesight, I would like some statistics in the coming years on whether the occurrences of such incidents drop in the future in Iran. Me too. That's the problem of nowadays screwed society. That doing terrible, abominable things may prevent even more terrible, abominable things in the future. In Iran, there's apparently a good amount of people who think it's cool to throw acid in the eye of women who reject them. I've read many articles on this, these are NOT isolated cases. It happens dreadfully often. Make no mistake, I am 100% against allowing her to do the same to him, since it's against everything I believe in both as a legal scholar and as a human being. Nevertheless the question remains: what if this really is the only way to prevent those "brainsick-degenerated-sorry-excuses-for-human-beings" to do this to women? What if, in Iran, this really is the only way to make sure men don't throw acid into women's eyes?
It is a shame, I think, that legal systems give the guilty the primacy of attention, when it is the victim who needs it most. It is giving the accused the pedestal while the victim is forgotten. It is, to me, the subtler manifestation of 'blaming the victim'. In respect of the current case, the fact that justice was brought into the hands of the victim herself is a good thing. If she spares him, which she has, it shows her humanity and her ability to step above the fray and the notion of revenge. It is the ultimate victory of the victim. If she does not spare him, then she gets her vengeance and feels that justice is served. The public may disagree with her position, but I find it hard to believe that there would be much vitriol given everything she would have gone through. If she chooses to refrain from making a decision, then she was at least afforded an opportunity to play a major role in the system. In all matters, it is about the victim. The subject matter of the penal system becomes the heroism of the victim (or lack of it in another's eyes). The fact that so much time is given towards the guilty instead of the victim is, in my opinion, very unfortunate.
|
United Kingdom16710 Posts
Picture of the victim (not for the faint-hearted): + Show Spoiler +
I was initially against this kind of eye for an eye retribution as a form of justice, but after seeing her and imagining what she must've gone through, I'm not so sure anymore. Maybe the guy should've been made an example of to show everyone that you shouldn't commit these kinds of acts if you do not wish it upon yourself. I do believe that ultimately, more violence isn't the answer to violence but history has shown us that it can be an effective form of deterrent.
|
On August 01 2011 22:39 sigma_x wrote:Show nested quote +On August 01 2011 22:06 sleepingdog wrote:On August 01 2011 21:44 targ wrote: Although throwing acid in his eyes will not bring back the woman's eyesight, I would like some statistics in the coming years on whether the occurrences of such incidents drop in the future in Iran. Me too. That's the problem of nowadays screwed society. That doing terrible, abominable things may prevent even more terrible, abominable things in the future. In Iran, there's apparently a good amount of people who think it's cool to throw acid in the eye of women who reject them. I've read many articles on this, these are NOT isolated cases. It happens dreadfully often. Make no mistake, I am 100% against allowing her to do the same to him, since it's against everything I believe in both as a legal scholar and as a human being. Nevertheless the question remains: what if this really is the only way to prevent those "brainsick-degenerated-sorry-excuses-for-human-beings" to do this to women? What if, in Iran, this really is the only way to make sure men don't throw acid into women's eyes? It is a shame, I think, that legal systems give the guilty the primacy of attention, when it is the victim who needs it most. It is giving the accused the pedestal while the victim is forgotten. It is, to me, the subtler manifestation of 'blaming the victim'. In respect of the current case, the fact that justice was brought into the hands of the victim herself is a good thing. If she spares him, which she has, it shows her humanity and her ability to step above the fray and the notion of revenge. It is the ultimate victory of the victim. If she does not spare him, then she gets her vengeance and feels that justice is served. The public may disagree with her position, but I find it hard to believe that there would be much vitriol given everything she would have gone through. If she chooses to refrain from making a decision, then she was at least afforded an opportunity to play a major role in the system. In all matters, it is about the victim. The subject matter of the penal system becomes the heroism of the victim (or lack of it in another's eyes). The fact that so much time is given towards the guilty instead of the victim is, in my opinion, very unfortunate.
I think that quite to the contrary such a legal system enforces exactly what it tries to prevent. If you give this much power to a victim, you actually turn the victim into an offender. You basically say: A person can do something so grave to another person that justice is only served, if the offender is killed/ blinded / mutilated / etc. This in effect endorses the "means" and merely criticizes the "end". From that it is only a small step for any individual to conclude that since what has been done to him "hurts so horribly" in their eyes, it merits such an "otherwise completely acceptable" punishment. "Honour crimes" are no normal crimes. These people actually think that by spraying acid into some women's face, they restore justice. I think the more effective path to prevent these cruelties is to condemn the means. No person "deserves" to be killed / blinded / mutilated / etc. whatever the deed and there is nothing good coming out of this kind of retribution. The act itself is barbarous. The more people in a society understand that, the less likely it is to occur.
|
|
|
|
|
|