|
On May 14 2011 08:52 Glaven wrote:Are you also from the 16th century? Nice to see people here support a justice system based on retribution. To be honest i live in 2011 atm and i find this is fair. Nobody has the right to destroy someones life in such a way. IF he does it means that he has some kind of mental problems. The victim has the choice to either be the better person and let him be or do what he did to her. Wich seems a little bit cruel but fair to me. No judge or anyone can feel what she feels so it sounds fair to me to let her decide. Personal opinion
|
On May 14 2011 08:52 Glaven wrote:Are you also from the 16th century? Nice to see people here support a justice system based on retribution.
The question remains: would such terrible, disgraceful deeds happen in a justice system from the 16th century? Where everyone would have to be afraid of being tortured for several days/weeks and THEN killed publicly for even minor violations of the law?
Or to put it the other way: how much humanity can we actually afford in our justice systems until our society crumbles under the pressure of those who have more in common with animals than human beings?
|
On August 01 2011 23:24 sleepingdog wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 08:52 Glaven wrote:On May 14 2011 08:47 jstar wrote: I like that legal system. Are you also from the 16th century? Nice to see people here support a justice system based on retribution. The question remains: would such terrible, disgraceful deeds happen in a justice system from the 16th century?
Judging by how many people were killed / tortured during the 16th century, yes.
|
Although I do not support "eye for an eye" legal systems, I must say many legal systems from the past were far, far worse. "Eye for an eye" is still a crude form of justice, despite being rather barbaric.
In England at one time, the death penalty was given out for over two hundred types of crimes, including stealing a small amount of goods (say a basket of bread) or poaching animals from the king's hunting grounds. Then we have the witch trials during the Dark Ages, when anyone could be burnt on trumped-up charges. Compared to this, the verdict we discuss here is like community service. Frankly speaking, I feel that other Islamic laws rile me up much more, such as thieves' hands being cut off, adultery being punished by stoning to death, and a large host of other laws against women.
In comparison to that, this case made me go "oh that's a bit barbaric", but neither did it really impinge severely on my sense of justice...
|
This is why an eye for an eye doesn't work in most of the countries now.
|
On August 01 2011 23:18 Voldron wrote: To be honest i live in 2011 atm and i find this is fair. Nobody has the right to destroy someones life in such a way.
Nobody has the right to destroy someones life in such a way.
Nobody has the right to destroy someones life in such a way.
Nobody has the right to destroy someones life in such a way.
and quote for emphasis:
Nobody has the right to destroy someones life in such a way.
thank god democracy doesn't actually work
|
¯\_(ツ)_/¯ what can i say? Their legal system sucks, and the people do the stupid shit
|
She has decided to not blind him anyways
|
On May 14 2011 08:55 Derez wrote: This pretty much proves why victims shouldn't have any say in the punishment of an offender.
'An eye for an eye' isn't justice, it's just retribution.
Ya
|
On August 01 2011 22:13 maartendq wrote:Show nested quote +On August 01 2011 05:20 Horst wrote:On August 01 2011 05:11 bluQ wrote:On August 01 2011 04:08 Grenadieris wrote:On August 01 2011 03:12 Gamegene wrote:On August 01 2011 02:47 Stratos_speAr wrote: Why is it wrong to do this to him though? That's the question. He (arguably) deserves it for completely ruining this woman's life. This sounds naive, foolish and possibly even idealistic: Because it's not right. It's not right to do that action, regardless of the reason. Do you send a rapist to get raped? Do you let drunk drivers get hit by drunk drivers? We live in the 21st fucking century. There's 5000+ years of despicable cruel and unusual punishment all under this simple (and dumb) idea that it's okay because it's an "eye for an eye". Let's try to grow up a little bit as a society. I don't get how 5000 years of wrong punishments is connected to "eye for an eye". People got their fingers/hands cut off for stealing, clearly that's going over the top. Some got beheaded for treason, that doesn't seem like "eye for an eye" neither. Actually yeah, I do think rapists should get raped and etc., maybe that would actually achieve some results. As we can observe rapists who leave prison often rape again. Of course I'm exaggerating, but there is no prison that would do justice enough to this man. It's simple as that. Sometimes animals need to put down. You do know you will create an infinity loop? I first giggled when i recon that but then got sad that we would have a world full of rapist I'm actually in favor of flat out death penalty for violent criminals, at least when their crimes result in permanent harm to their victims. Its not a matter of cruelty, or of punishing them. Its simply that their behavior is not tolerable in society, they are defective. The cost of rehabilitating them, combined with their potential to backslide, is greater than their potential value to society. The only rational course of action is to dispose of such waste. There are two ways you can look at a violent criminal. Either he cannot be made well again, in which case ending his life is the only way to prevent relapse, or he CAN be made well again, in which case he will be wracked with guilt over his past actions, and killing him is a mercy. Cruelty doesn't factor into this, nor does punishment. Its the only logical solution. Do you, by chance, watch way too many movies or anime series? Because seriously, that's not how reality works. People can live with guilt without being suicidal, you know.
Actually I was paraphrasing starship troopers 
|
On August 02 2011 02:08 tayscrim wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 08:55 Derez wrote: This pretty much proves why victims shouldn't have any say in the punishment of an offender.
'An eye for an eye' isn't justice, it's just retribution. And what is wrong with retribution? She doesn't deserve this after what he has done to her? Something is wrong with you. Retribution does not solve anything. That's what's wrong with it. It does not bring your eyesight back, it does not bring murdered relatives back from the dead, it does nothing. It's highly irrational.
|
I'm really surprised so many of you are saying that she shouldn't do it because it's not right etc.
Women get treated like vermin in Iran. Girls that go to school are attacked with acid all the time because their culture think that only boys should go and girls should stay at home doing housework and cooking. As a woman, the only thing going for you is your attractive looks. Having that taken away is almost like cutting off a man's penis and cutting off his hands so he cannot make money.
It's a little sickening to me how many of you sit comfortably in your air conditioned rooms with fast internet and three hot meals a day and say that "hurr durr this is wrong bla bla we should be the better man".
Get the fuck out.
If your girlfriend/wife or mother were attacked and ended up looking like a fucking ghoul, never to be able to hold their head high in public, never able to sexually arouse another male, you wouldn't let it go either. I know I wouldn't.
Until there exists scientific evidence that having such a revenge system doesn't lower the acid attacks on women, I don't see any fucking reason at all to stop this.
|
On August 02 2011 01:08 chaosfreak11 wrote: She has decided to not blind him anyways
Source?
|
On August 02 2011 03:44 maartendq wrote:Show nested quote +On August 02 2011 02:08 tayscrim wrote:On May 14 2011 08:55 Derez wrote: This pretty much proves why victims shouldn't have any say in the punishment of an offender.
'An eye for an eye' isn't justice, it's just retribution. And what is wrong with retribution? She doesn't deserve this after what he has done to her? Something is wrong with you. Retribution does not solve anything. That's what's wrong with it. It does not bring your eyesight back, it does not bring murdered relatives back from the dead, it does nothing. It's highly irrational. It satisfies a need. http://www.20min.ch/news/kreuz_und_quer/story/19383443 here is a source, it's in german so just copy pasta headline in google translate or something if you wanna read it yourself
|
But really guys... I have an ingenious 100% foolproof system to ensure no repeat offenses.
Death penalty. BOOM.
|
Maybe one day we can move beyond this violent revenge. For now, I guess we should just be glad that the man is being punished at all. Needless violence demands justice, and a move towards justice is a move in the right direction.
Still, this makes me feel a little sick.
|
Im from UK, and I support the death penalty, Im not in favor of government money looking after rapists and murderers, just kill them, they deserve it. If they inflict pain on someone else, they deserve everything that comes to them.
|
On August 02 2011 03:56 pyrogenetix wrote: I'm really surprised so many of you are saying that she shouldn't do it because it's not right etc.
Women get treated like vermin in Iran. Girls that go to school are attacked with acid all the time because their culture think that only boys should go and girls should stay at home doing housework and cooking. As a woman, the only thing going for you is your attractive looks. Having that taken away is almost like cutting off a man's penis and cutting off his hands so he cannot make money.
It's a little sickening to me how many of you sit comfortably in your air conditioned rooms with fast internet and three hot meals a day and say that "hurr durr this is wrong bla bla we should be the better man".
Get the fuck out.
If your girlfriend/wife or mother were attacked and ended up looking like a fucking ghoul, never to be able to hold their head high in public, never able to sexually arouse another male, you wouldn't let it go either. I know I wouldn't.
Until there exists scientific evidence that having such a revenge system doesn't lower the acid attacks on women, I don't see any fucking reason at all to stop this.
and if there is evidence that this isn't enough to reduce the acid attacks, they should do something more drastic
|
On August 02 2011 04:04 Mr. Wiggles wrote:Show nested quote +On August 02 2011 01:08 chaosfreak11 wrote: She has decided to not blind him anyways Source?
Link
|
On August 02 2011 03:56 pyrogenetix wrote: I'm really surprised so many of you are saying that she shouldn't do it because it's not right etc.
Women get treated like vermin in Iran. Girls that go to school are attacked with acid all the time because their culture think that only boys should go and girls should stay at home doing housework and cooking. As a woman, the only thing going for you is your attractive looks. Having that taken away is almost like cutting off a man's penis and cutting off his hands so he cannot make money.
It's a little sickening to me how many of you sit comfortably in your air conditioned rooms with fast internet and three hot meals a day and say that "hurr durr this is wrong bla bla we should be the better man".
Get the fuck out.
If your girlfriend/wife or mother were attacked and ended up looking like a fucking ghoul, never to be able to hold their head high in public, never able to sexually arouse another male, you wouldn't let it go either. I know I wouldn't.
Until there exists scientific evidence that having such a revenge system doesn't lower the acid attacks on women, I don't see any fucking reason at all to stop this.
How exactly will revenge help her? I think a lot of people have forgotten that the point of a prison system it to serve as both punishment and rehabilitation. An eye for an eye will not suddenly make the men view the women as being equal, if anything it will cause further hate between them.
|
|
|
|
|
|