|
On May 14 2011 08:52 Glaven wrote:Are you also from the 16th century? Nice to see people here support a justice system based on retribution.
In the past, I would have supported your position. But when I see the light slaps most of the offenders get, or the fact that they sometimes go and outright kill the women, is what made me stop caring for a "just" system anymore. Maybe I have turned Nihilistic, but again these acid throwers will NEVER learn their lesson unless they have fear of the same.
|
On May 14 2011 08:49 kerpal wrote:...makes the whole world blind -gandhi
In this case it actually only makes men who throw acid on women's faces blind, which I'm fine with to be honest.
|
I don't get it, so you blind him just to make yourself feel better?
Well I definitely have different values in life, hard to say it's wrong because who knows what is right and what is wrong - but in my world this is radical, unnecessary, mostrous etc. If I was the woman I probably would like to even kill him.
|
I cant belive so many actually support this =/
|
lol sharia as a whole, im glad I live in the western world
|
The guy should just be snuffed out,, eye for an eye type punishment is often far too ugly and savage.
|
Throwing acid on someone in the first place is a fairly...interesting(?) response to being rejected in the first place? Who actually does that? There was adrop in that crime sector, am I reading that correctly as this is a common occurance and this messed up punishment is having an effect in reducing it?
That whole situation seems really messed up. Also vengence is not justice, regardless of how much an *expletive of your choice* the guy was.
|
On May 14 2011 08:56 loiop wrote: I cant belive so many actually support this =/
The criminals doesn't deserve this kind of punishment.
The man in question on the other hand ...
On May 14 2011 08:56 Iyerbeth wrote: Throwing acid on someone in the first place is a fairly...interesting(?) response to being rejected in the first place? Who actually does that? There was adrop in that crime sector, am I reading that correctly as this is a common occurance and this messed up punishment is having an effect in reducing it?
That whole situation seems really messed up. Also vengence is not justice, regardless of how much an *expletive of your choice* the guy was.
Put yourself in the woman's position then.
|
Seriously did we not learn anything from the other prison thread?
Enacting revenge and retribution is unjust, and inflicting pain on fellow humans with this goal is both backwards, unhumanitarian and wrong. Yet all over the world, prison and justice systems follow these archaic principles and thus enjoy high crime rate and a complete failure of the prison and justice system
People seem to want to enact bigger and bigger revenge on each other and just want to kill and torture others instead of showing compassion and kindness even to those who have wronged you
|
On May 14 2011 08:52 funnybananaman wrote: Shit good thing kansas passed a law against sharia law or we'd have this in america
Yeah fucking savages eh. Just lock em up for life in an merciless environment where they face violence and abuse everyday for the rest of their lives instead. God bless!
|
I hate blind retribution and calling it justice, but it is fucking ridiculous how often you hear stories about men in these regions throwing acid on women for the stupidest fucking reasons.
It's time for these retards to grow up, maybe this will let them know it's not some joke throwing acid on a person.
|
Good. Permananetely crippling someones body does not equal=an assualt or whatever's worth of time in prison
|
I wish that he wasn't allowed to be sedated.
|
On May 14 2011 08:52 clusen wrote: @ Reaper I don't know if such crazy bullshit happens more often in Iran than this one incident, but if it does and the offenders do not get punished the legal system is just bad, eye for an eye is not the solution. Well in the UK commiting a crime or being a general douchebag pretty much gets you free education/training/house/money at the taxpayers expense while victims get nothing so as sad as it is, eye for an eye is currently probably the best deterant.
The murder of James Bulger probably being one of the most publicised examples of criminal support which is debateable.
|
On May 14 2011 08:58 opsayo wrote: I hate blind retribution and calling it justice, but it is fucking ridiculous how often you hear stories about men in these regions throwing acid on women for the stupidest fucking reasons.
It's time for these retards to grow up, maybe this will let them know it's not some joke throwing acid on a person.
Blame the one who blinded her
|
On May 14 2011 08:58 opsayo wrote: I hate blind retribution and calling it justice, but it is fucking ridiculous how often you hear stories about men in these regions throwing acid on women for the stupidest fucking reasons.
It's time for these retards to grow up, maybe this will let them know it's not some joke throwing acid on a person. Exactly my position. Rationally, the choice the woman was offered is insane in my mind. I don't think I would ever wish this on a fellow being even if I was inflicted the same (although I would not know my mental state at that point in all seriousness.) In my heart though, I understand the woman perfectly. A lot of these women commit suicide or are stigmatized in society.
|
The hell is wrong with you people?
How can you condone this? This is no better then removing the hand of a pickpocket or forcing a woman to be blinded due to looking at another man.
This isn't justice, this is disgustingly barbaric and you can't stand for this without standing for all the other terrible things Sharia law allows.
No amount of acid is going to take back the pain, nor is it going to make her feel better to hear some bastard screaming bloody murder as acid is poured into his eye. Would you feel better? Would you really feel better taking that revenge as you watched someone else go through the pain and horror she experienced again?
I can't believe anyone could ever condone this. Ignoring all of this. Money can be used for plastic surgery to help restore a sense of normalcy which is the point of justice it's to restore things to normalcy not.. not this. This is just barbaric in the truest sense of the word.
|
Barbaric legal systems get barbaric results!
|
On May 14 2011 08:55 Derez wrote: This pretty much proves why victims shouldn't have any say in the punishment of an offender.
'An eye for an eye' isn't justice, it's just retribution. why is retribution not justice in this case?
|
On May 14 2011 08:58 BrTarolg wrote: Enacting revenge and retribution is unjust
Enacting revenge and retribution is the purest form of justice that exists. I think you're confusing justice and compassion, which are absolutely not the same thing.
|
|
|
|
|
|