|
On May 14 2011 10:51 Hinanawi wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 10:27 koreasilver wrote: Justice != Vengeance
itt, concrete examples of why and how the world froths around in an unquenchable rage. Vengeance is justice. I don't know where you all are getting the idea that it isn't, they're practically synonyms. Not the case, no.
|
sharia law sounds like a law form the 1800's
|
So no prison time for the man ? Wonder if he's not just gonna want to get back at her, again. If he felt, that he needed to pour down acid in her eyes, for rejecting him, I wonder what he wants to do after this. Remember that men is the dominating gender, in some parts of the middle east.
I understand the womans decision to want revenge, but it's not exactly gonna promote the red socks movement.
|
I see the pro-choice pundits from abortion threads carefully sidestepping the explosive connection that this was a pro-choice sentencing.
|
An eye for an eye makes the world go blind doesn't compute. One eye for one eye and the equation is solved. There's no chaining it to the rest of the population.
|
On May 14 2011 10:51 Hinanawi wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 10:27 koreasilver wrote: Justice != Vengeance
itt, concrete examples of why and how the world froths around in an unquenchable rage. Vengeance is justice. I don't know where you all are getting the idea that it isn't, they're practically synonyms.
Are you going to make an effort to prove that exact statement, or do you expect us to take your word for it?
jus·tice/ˈjəstis/Noun 1. Just behavior or treatment. 2. The quality of being fair and reasonable.
According to you, vengeance is synonymous to being fair and reasonable.
|
On May 14 2011 11:02 MoltkeWarding wrote:I see the pro-choice pundits from abortion threads carefully sidestepping the explosive connection that this was a pro-choice sentencing.  Because there is no connection?
|
On May 14 2011 08:46 Airship wrote: An eye for an eye.
impeccable timing.
|
On May 14 2011 08:49 kerpal wrote:...makes the whole world blind -gandhi In the land of the blind the One-Eyed man is king
He gets what he deserves. Though their legal system is definitely fucked up though.
|
On May 14 2011 08:55 Derez wrote: This pretty much proves why victims shouldn't have any say in the punishment of an offender.
'An eye for an eye' isn't justice, it's just retribution.
except retribution is often seen as justice by the victim
who can blame her?
|
On May 14 2011 11:03 Talin wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 10:51 Hinanawi wrote:On May 14 2011 10:27 koreasilver wrote: Justice != Vengeance
itt, concrete examples of why and how the world froths around in an unquenchable rage. Vengeance is justice. I don't know where you all are getting the idea that it isn't, they're practically synonyms. Are you going to make an effort to prove that exact statement, or do you expect us to take your word for it? jus·tice/ˈjəstis/Noun 1. Just behavior or treatment. 2. The quality of being fair and reasonable. According to you, vengeance is synonymous to being fair and reasonable.
Tell me, what does it mean 99.99% of the time when you hear that someone has been 'brought to justice'? Does it mean they got 'rehabilitated'? I'm also waiting on a response to my hypothetical scenario with the mind-reading machine. Vengeance is at least part of justice, and always has been.
|
On May 14 2011 11:03 Talin wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 10:51 Hinanawi wrote:On May 14 2011 10:27 koreasilver wrote: Justice != Vengeance
itt, concrete examples of why and how the world froths around in an unquenchable rage. Vengeance is justice. I don't know where you all are getting the idea that it isn't, they're practically synonyms. Are you going to make an effort to prove that exact statement, or do you expect us to take your word for it? jus·tice/ˈjəstis/Noun 1. Just behavior or treatment. 2. The quality of being fair and reasonable. According to you, vengeance is synonymous to being fair and reasonable.
An eye for an eye IS fair and reasonable. It's a perfectly fair trade, the most fair possible.
Why is it more reasonable to lock people up and feed them for years?
|
What right did the guy have to inflict such a horrific injury on a girl that has rejected him? He had absolutely NO right! and if he decides that he gets to use such an extreme act to show that he got emotionally hurt by the rejection then HELL yeah, the woman is right for choosing to have the same done to him.
Thats retribution yes, if the guy spends time in jail he may or may not die there (we dont know the coniditons in their jail), provided he serves his time without any incidents, he still has his eyesight, his face is not disfigured and he can quietly glee at how horrible his victim must feel while he still manages to percieve the world how the rest of us are.
Not only that, he should be etched AND sent to prison, this is just outright disgusting
|
On May 14 2011 11:06 VIB wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 11:02 MoltkeWarding wrote:I see the pro-choice pundits from abortion threads carefully sidestepping the explosive connection that this was a pro-choice sentencing.  Because there is no connection? 
"Unless you are a woman, you have no right to speak on this issue" sound familiar to you?
|
the original meaning of "eye for an eye" was really more like "only one eye for one eye", meaning that the punishment should never exceed the crime.
|
On May 14 2011 11:02 HowitZer wrote: An eye for an eye makes the world go blind doesn't compute. One eye for one eye and the equation is solved. There's no chaining it to the rest of the population.
The victim to the victim may disagree about that (in general terms).
In this specific case even, the criminal even gets to walk away after being blinded, so what if the third eye to be taken is actually the girl's life? And then the guy's life? And then the life of girl's relatives?
It's not some proverbial saying people throw around. It's a FACT in societies that sported this tradition known as blood feud that many seem to be promoting here. And it can chain over several generations.
|
On May 14 2011 08:49 kerpal wrote:...makes the whole world blind -gandhi
Better the whole world blind than the only people with eyesight being evil.
|
On May 14 2011 11:09 Talin wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 11:02 HowitZer wrote: An eye for an eye makes the world go blind doesn't compute. One eye for one eye and the equation is solved. There's no chaining it to the rest of the population. The victim to the victim may disagree about that (in general terms). In this specific case even, the criminal even gets to walk away after being blinded, so what if the third eye to be taken is actually the girl's life? And then the guy's life? And then the life of girl's relatives? It's not some proverbial saying people throw around. It's a FACT in societies that sported this tradition known as blood feud that many seem to be promoting here. And it can chain over several generations.
If in the Nation X, murder resulted in execution 100% of the time, do you think the rate of murder would be as high?
y/n?
|
On May 14 2011 11:06 Hinanawi wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 11:03 Talin wrote:On May 14 2011 10:51 Hinanawi wrote:On May 14 2011 10:27 koreasilver wrote: Justice != Vengeance
itt, concrete examples of why and how the world froths around in an unquenchable rage. Vengeance is justice. I don't know where you all are getting the idea that it isn't, they're practically synonyms. Are you going to make an effort to prove that exact statement, or do you expect us to take your word for it? jus·tice/ˈjəstis/Noun 1. Just behavior or treatment. 2. The quality of being fair and reasonable. According to you, vengeance is synonymous to being fair and reasonable. Tell me, what does it mean 99.99% of the time when you hear that someone has been 'brought to justice'? Does it mean they got 'rehabilitated'? I'm also waiting on a response to my hypothetical scenario with the mind-reading machine. Vengeance is at least part of justice, and always has been.
It may not mean they got "rehabilitated", but it means they were given a chance, and it means the state did not condone and commit cruelty that it punishes people for (in this specific example it's actually the EXACT same crime on both sides, except the latter case is state sanctioned crime).
You can't punish somebody for committing an act you define as crime, and then commit that very same act and expect such a system to actually work out.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|