|
On May 14 2011 13:36 EmeraldSparks wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 13:29 EmeraldSparks wrote:On May 14 2011 13:28 SevenBunnies wrote:On May 14 2011 13:23 MarkBolinder3 wrote: if this were a man and another man it would be a whole other story,
i think that because it is a women that got hurt it is why we as Americans are more on the lenient side If a man did this to another man, we would call him barbaric. Since it's a woman doing it to a man, we call her liberated. Maybe you would, but please, speak for yourself. On second thought, I can easily see a lot of opinions changing if a woman had thrown acid into a man's face because he went out and messed with some other girls, and in response the man initiated a judicial process that culminated in the state burning out her eyes. My initial reaction to the situation was different. How intriguing.
She did not cheat or anything. The man basically was her insane stalker. So if you imagine it reversed, you should not imagine a couple in a relationship, but one of them a stalker and the other a creeped out victim.
|
On May 14 2011 13:44 Ropid wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 13:36 EmeraldSparks wrote:On May 14 2011 13:29 EmeraldSparks wrote:On May 14 2011 13:28 SevenBunnies wrote:On May 14 2011 13:23 MarkBolinder3 wrote: if this were a man and another man it would be a whole other story,
i think that because it is a women that got hurt it is why we as Americans are more on the lenient side If a man did this to another man, we would call him barbaric. Since it's a woman doing it to a man, we call her liberated. Maybe you would, but please, speak for yourself. On second thought, I can easily see a lot of opinions changing if a woman had thrown acid into a man's face because he went out and messed with some other girls, and in response the man initiated a judicial process that culminated in the state burning out her eyes. My initial reaction to the situation was different. How intriguing. She did not cheat or anything. The man basically was her insane stalker. So if you imagine it reversed, you should not imagine a couple in a relationship, but one of them a stalker and the other a creeped out victim. The same principle continues to hold. My assessments of the genderswapped situations are different.
|
On May 14 2011 13:46 EmeraldSparks wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 13:44 Ropid wrote:On May 14 2011 13:36 EmeraldSparks wrote:On May 14 2011 13:29 EmeraldSparks wrote:On May 14 2011 13:28 SevenBunnies wrote:On May 14 2011 13:23 MarkBolinder3 wrote: if this were a man and another man it would be a whole other story,
i think that because it is a women that got hurt it is why we as Americans are more on the lenient side If a man did this to another man, we would call him barbaric. Since it's a woman doing it to a man, we call her liberated. Maybe you would, but please, speak for yourself. On second thought, I can easily see a lot of opinions changing if a woman had thrown acid into a man's face because he went out and messed with some other girls, and in response the man initiated a judicial process that culminated in the state burning out her eyes. My initial reaction to the situation was different. How intriguing. She did not cheat or anything. The man basically was her insane stalker. So if you imagine it reversed, you should not imagine a couple in a relationship, but one of them a stalker and the other a creeped out victim. The same principle continues to hold. My assessments of the genderswapped situations are different.
Well, I cannot muster up compassion for the culprit that will be blinded. If he would not have done what he did, he would not have any problems now. Same with a reversed situation with a woman being a crazy stalker and throwing a bottle of acid in someone's face. It is ugly no matter what.
Best course of action is going at it emotionless and following the laws in the trial, to get to an objective judgement and I suppose that is what happened. The laws in Iran do not seem to necessarily have the option for the culprit to reform himself, and there is that choice for the victim to let the culprit suffer in the same way. It is what it is.
|
On May 14 2011 09:05 Circos wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 08:48 aimaimaim wrote:The man was crazy. The woman had the right to exact revenge Humanitarians can sometimes be really stupid. You go girl  On May 14 2011 08:47 daytrippers wrote: will there be a stream? how much is HD pass The man will be sedated .. Theres no fun in that but would still love to see it though  Everything about this is just terrible. The fuck is wrong with you?
This is bullshit TL, You guys are warning people for supporting this trial but letting people like him go.
This is a starcraft forum, who is to say what is wrong/right, and justice
There is so much western subjectivism in here
|
I find this thread amusing in light of the "are morals subjective or objective" thread being hot shit yesterday.
Sad topic, but the oh the irony -_-
|
On May 14 2011 14:15 maize wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 09:05 Circos wrote:On May 14 2011 08:48 aimaimaim wrote:The man was crazy. The woman had the right to exact revenge Humanitarians can sometimes be really stupid. You go girl  On May 14 2011 08:47 daytrippers wrote: will there be a stream? how much is HD pass The man will be sedated .. Theres no fun in that but would still love to see it though  Everything about this is just terrible. The fuck is wrong with you? This is bullshit TL, You guys are warning people for supporting this trial but letting people like him go. This is a starcraft forum, who is to say what is wrong/right, and justice There is so much western subjectivism in here
Calm down Kiddo, don't go blowing your Lid with silly statements like "there is so much western subjectivism in here"
|
If it indeed works the way she thinks it is ( set an example for all the other men that want to randomly throw acid over their women ) then I'm all for it.
Like it or not, we need a justice system that actually works. Not as in punishing for the sake of the victim, or paying the victim a huge sum of money to soothe the pain. But by stopping the crime from happening again. Currently, our prison system doesn't do that, it simply contains the offender.
I am not saying the Sharia law is better than our system. I'm merely talking about this case.
|
On May 14 2011 08:49 kerpal wrote:...makes the whole world blind -gandhi ...but if you let him go, then that evil person is free to make others blind too. ...also, i'd rather live in a blind world than let only the evil ones see and take advantage of the good blind people.
|
I have a problem with people that say "an eye for an eye makes the whole world blind." What's the alternative to that, that everyone is blind except for the people that throw acid on your face? I'd rather have everybody be blind than the only non-blind people to be psychopaths, thank you very much.
Or the other alternative is we just throw them in jail. So now half the world is blind and the other half that can see is in jail. That doesn't do us much good. We're all bumping into each other because of our blindness and the people that can see have nothing productive to do with it in their cell where there is nothing to do and nobody to bump into.
|
what would be his punishment in the US? just for a comparative analysis. I know a few states banned shahria law. Also, who the fuck has acid laying around and ready to throw. I have acid but its not ready to through. . . you think they would throw something random like a shoe or chair. The pre-mediation involved is kinda even more fucked up imo.
|
On May 14 2011 14:42 BlackJack wrote: I have a problem with people that say "an eye for an eye makes the whole world blind." What's the alternative to that, that everyone is blind except for the people that throw acid on your face? I'd rather have everybody be blind than the only non-blind people to be psychopaths, thank you very much.
Or the other alternative is we just throw them in jail. So now half the world is blind and the other half that can see is in jail. That doesn't do us much good. We're all bumping into each other because of our blindness and the people that can see have nothing productive to do with it in their cell where there is nothing to do and nobody to bump into.
well who would watch them to make sure they dont escape? lolz. also, if she dumps the acid on him, does she get to be REAL close so she can see it?? kinda shity if she doesnt get see.
|
You want to know why I try not to judge their system. I don't live over there. Their political, economical, social, and cultural situation is different from where I live. They're a different country, and the average person over there probably does not have as much opportunities, luxuries, and/or power/rights as I do.
EDIT: I should say "most likely" instead of "probably."
|
Stupid woman.
Stupid legal system.
I lose a little more faith in humanity every time I hear some idiots trying to justify the "eye for an eye" bullshit that has plagued people's idea of "justice".
Pleiades makes a good point in not being too critical of a legal system of a place you don't live in.. but goddamn I can't imagine a world in which a properly functioning legal system allows such barbaric and archaic practices happen under their watch. I'm sorry but the Iranian government, legal system included, is a joke and its a matter of time before enough people wake up and do something about it. Someone needs to explain to them (government, not Iranians) thats change, i.e. progress is nothing to be afraid of. For the most part Iran is a full millenium behind the rest of the world on social issues, and based on my interactions with Iranian people that have left the country, that simply does not add up with the beliefs of the constituents... at least not the educated ones.
|
That's why the younger generation are protesting and rebelling in other arab countries, they do want change.
|
|
|
People who just blindly assume that eye for an eye is a good way to deal with criminals don't even remotely think about its complications. In such a system a person who murdered in the heat of the moment (aka 3rd degree murder/manslaughter in Canada) will have to be punished by a capital punishment. Is this justified? What about euthanasia? a doctor who assisted someone with painless suicide to end suffering of a terminal disease? is the doctor needs to be punished in the way he committed the murder? There are prisons for a reason, the main one is to institutionalize the criminals for correctional purposes. If you don't give a chance for a person to improve upon his crimes you will have the most tyrannical government.
|
It was probably the tipical case where the girl flirts with the guy and just plain knowingly plays with his feelings while never really wanting anything romantic with him but knowing he loves her, of course the criminal act is way over the top
|
Damn it what is wrong with some of these people!? Acid? Look at her pictures! That is so horrible. I can't even begin to think how shattered she must be mentally as a woman and human being. This is something that destroys you for the rest of your life in a way that I absolutely wish to noone.
My mind is looking for a just solution, but fuuuu just kill this guy. I know it's not the right way, but fuck it man, unless he's like one step away form curing parkinson or some shit just wack him off. Which I'm surprised didn't happen anyway...
|
On May 14 2011 15:20 Jayson X wrote: Damn it what is wrong with some of these people!? Acid? Look at her pictures! That is so horrible. I can't even begin to think how shattered she must be mentally as a woman and human being. This is something that destroys you for the rest of your life in a way that I absolutely wish to noone.
My mind is looking for a just solution, but fuuuu just kill this guy. I know it's not the right way, but fuck it man, unless he's like one step away form curing parkinson or some shit just wack him off. Which I'm surprised didn't happen anyway... THAT IS the main reason that it is wrong to give the authority for the victim to punish the criminal.
|
On May 14 2011 15:05 Reason.SC2 wrote: Stupid woman.
Stupid legal system.
I lose a little more faith in humanity every time I hear some idiots trying to justify the "eye for an eye" bullshit that has plagued people's idea of "justice".
Pleiades makes a good point in not being too critical of a legal system of a place you don't live in.. but goddamn I can't imagine a world in which a properly functioning legal system allows such barbaric and archaic practices happen under their watch. I'm sorry but the Iranian government, legal system included, is a joke and its a matter of time before enough people wake up and do something about it. Someone needs to explain to them (government, not Iranians) thats change, i.e. progress is nothing to be afraid of. For the most part Iran is a full millenium behind the rest of the world on social issues, and based on my interactions with Iranian people that have left the country, that simply does not add up with the beliefs of the constituents... at least not the educated ones.
You can say what you want about the legal system, that's your opinion. But the women is a victim of a cruel act here, I think the majority of people anywhere will lose civility and would choose the same thing given the chance. Imagine some idiot basically just ended any chance of you living a normal life. Even if you think its wrong you would do it in heart beat in that situation. So calling her names is very insensitive As for the legal system allowing her to do that is different matter. However, I think if you are willing to criticise this system, you need to be open to criticise all others systems out there. People try their victimisers not for "greater justice" but for retribution, the method being different has nothing to do with the actual concept. Your argument as you say it has nothing to do with morality, its just conflicting social conventions, and you think its out of fashion. which I can also respect, but you need to be less judgemental if you're using that.
|
|
|
|
|
|