|
On May 14 2011 20:25 mcc wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 19:41 RockIronrod wrote: There is no objectively superior justice system, westerners should stop bragging about our "throw them in a hole and hope they're better for it" way of doing things. It's hardly rehabilitation or justice, any more than an eye for an eye system is. In some countries it's pure vengeance, the holes we throw them in being purposefully dark, dank and rapey. How is a lifetime of rectal bleeding, humiliation, assault and confinement with propagators of the aforementioned and more humane than being blinded? How is a blanket punishment for all crimes any more "fair" than custom punishments suited to each crime? How is rehabilitating a criminal any more just than punishing him?
It's not, stop being elitist.
That said, I disagree with Sharia law in most instances personally, including this. Actually it is very easy to say sometimes which society is better. If one society has less murders, less rapes, less assaults, .... it is better. It is theoretically possible to say which justice system is better, it is just hard in practice. If you could show that one system leads to lower number of murders, .... ,lower recidivity and has lower number of judicial errors that system would be better. Problem is accounting for all other variables that can have influence on those numbers, that is why I only said it is theoretically possible. But that does not prevent us from having strong indicators about which system is better. Also your examples of mistreatment in prisons are highly US based. US prison system is quite terrible for a 1st world country. But there are countries that limit that mistreatment to much lower amount. Murder numbers will show which is better for preventing murder. Not what is a better society, because "better" is subjective. A tyrannical dictatorship like North Korea would have absurdly low crime rates because the masses are brainwashed. Is that a better society?
On May 14 2011 20:25 mcc wrote:
If it is possible to rehabilitate a criminal it is pretty clearly better than not to do so as he will not commit any more crimes, he will become productive member of society and society will not have to pay for his future crimes. Of course depends on the cost of rehabilitation and if it is in fact even possible (often it is not).
I agree. Keyword here being "I."
On May 14 2011 20:25 mcc wrote: Yes I am elitist and I do not intend to stop. I always wonder why people think labeling someone as elitist is automatically an insult. You are also an elitist, or when you are sick do you go to a butcher instead of a doctor, do you think uneducated people should be allowed to build nuclear power plants ? It was bad wording on my part, yeah. Nationalistic would've been better.
|
On May 14 2011 08:49 kerpal wrote:...makes the whole world blind -gandhi
I take advice from dead people!
|
Just heard it in the radio, the revenge has been postponed to an unknown date.
|
On May 14 2011 19:43 RockIronrod wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 19:39 W2 wrote: If I were one of the assistants at the "etching retribution" I would switcheroo the acid with water, tell the offender to fake it, and once it all blows over, send him overseas where my friend will give him a job while keeping an eye on him for misbehavior.
This way, everyone wins. The woman gets satisfaction from her retribution, nobody gets harmed, and the cover-up acts still acts as a deterrent. And a criminal goes rewarded for throwing acid in peoples faces. I think you're too blinded by bias against the people defending the punishments to realise HE THREW ACID IN SOMEONES FACE FOR SHITS AND GIGGLES.
I'm just saying what I would have done if I were one of the assistants. If I were the victim then my actions/thoughts might be a lot different than what I described But you have to agree, that's a pretty good scenario as long as the cover doesn't get blown.
I'm a person who is forgiving and willing to give second chances as long as he isn't batshit crazy. But I also hold personal grudges like no other. Sigh, I am such a hypocrite.
|
This might seem like justice if you assume that the person that has been found guilty really is guilty. Unfortunately it is never possible to determine with 100% certainty whether someone really did something or not. That is (one of) the reason(s) why any modern justicial system does not include such punishments as they are inreversible and above all cruel. IMO anyone who still thinks that civilization is a real thing should be offended and disgusted by these sorts of practices.
Also it's not sharia law, sharia means law.
|
On May 14 2011 20:57 DisneylandSC wrote: Also it's not sharia law, sharia means law.
Agreed, its ridiclous how some peole would take a word from another language for law and attach an islamic stigma to it. When if fact just their law.
EDIT: Translation : http://translate.google.com/#auto|en|شريعة
|
Revenge might not make her feel better, but as a punishment, I think this has the added bonus of teaching the offender why what he did was wrong. I'm usually a liberal person, but in this case I believe it will teach the violent bastard a lesson.
edit:
On May 14 2011 20:57 DisneylandSC wrote: This might seem like justice if you assume that the person that has been found guilty really is guilty. Unfortunately it is never possible to determine with 100% certainty whether someone really did something or not. That is (one of) the reason(s) why any modern justicial system does not include such punishments as they are inreversible and above all cruel. IMO anyone who still thinks that civilization is a real thing should be offended and disgusted by these sorts of practices.
Also it's not sharia law, sharia means law. Seriously, you think that she doesn't remember THE LAST THING SHE EVER SAW? Of course he's guilty.
|
Honestly, I don't know what gives anyone the impression that our modern sense of justice is any better or more ethical than the eye-for-an-eye system. Take someone's freedom for 10-20 years, lock them up with a bunch of people who would kill them for a good meal, yeah that seems totally humane.
Anyway, the punishments we've devised for crimes in America and elsewhere are just man-made ideas for keeping troublesome people out of the way of the general population while offending the least amount of humanitarians. It's not some divine morality. Blinding this guy seems just as moral/immoral as locking him away to me, considering what he did.
|
It surprises me how silly people still are today
|
So...
Did they went through with it? :s
|
On May 14 2011 21:29 DwmC_Foefen wrote: So...
Did they went through with it? :s Nope, was supposed to happen in 2009, but it was delayed for some reason, and again like, today, but apparently it's been postponed. Also, while we're correcting things, the attacks in Cambodia aren't due to suppression of women. Women are in fact somewhat dominant in that society, because of Pol Pot killing off most of the men while he was in charge. The acid attacks there are usually female on female, wifes attacking their husbands lovers.
|
Turn the other cheek is good and all, but eye for an eye works better in some situations, this being one of them. If this story convinces one person NOT to throw acid in someones face, it's worth the blemish on this womans conscience.
The only problem I see here is that they're going to sedate the man when he should just be restrained. It would be more effective that way.
|
It sucks that some psycho threw acid on her face, but good for her that she gets to give revenge to this guy. He definitely deserves what he is going to get, and I sincerely hope that she goes with acid punishment instead of money. This is how criminal justice should be carried out. Then, not so many psychos would go around throwing acid on people's faces.
|
A lot of you idiots don't know the difference between revenge and justice. Systems should be solely based on an act of justice, not of revenge. We should aspire to have a liberal justice system, not some medieval eye-for-an-eye vengeance system.
Throwing acid on this guy won't bring her any satisfaction in the end because she'll have to live with still being ugly and blind and on top of that, knowing she ruined another human being's life. And if she does get satisfaction from knowing that, well I wouldn't call her a good person, that's for fucking sure.
|
On May 14 2011 20:44 LAN-f34r wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 08:49 kerpal wrote:On May 14 2011 08:46 Airship wrote: An eye for an eye. ...makes the whole world blind -gandhi I take advice from dead people!
So should we all.
|
I do not think adding another blind guy will benefit any society at all. In the worst case scenario just give him the capital punishment. This retribution law is just cruel and primitive.
|
I think I would have done the same decision as the woman and I`m normally all against sharia and things like mutilation for stealing but in this special case I think its the right thing as it will be a huge deterrent for all those similar cases if its 100% sure that the man was the one who did it and that he was mentally healthy and that it was premeditated.
|
Snet
United States3573 Posts
What a wonderful thing. I am a strong supporter of bringing back hangings and the guillotine for violent criminals. If someone commits a violent crime that can be proven without a doubt to be premeditated (like rape, child abuse, beatings, murder), then they should have swift and lethal punishment. The only fault I find in this article is they are going to sedate the man beforehand. She did not have that luxury.
|
I really think there's a difference between her blinding a man that has no remorse or ability to actually feel compassion or respect for the life of another human being just because she's a woman, and cutting off the hand of a pickpocket (which is obviously not a fitting punishment for the crime). There are far too many people in the world to feel sorry and not enact punishments that actually make sense in tune with crimes performed with extremely malicious intent. This punishment is actually logical as opposed to needlessly evil, such as cutting off someone's hand when they simply took things that actually have monetary value.
|
On May 14 2011 22:53 Klaus1986 wrote: A lot of you idiots don't know the difference between revenge and justice. Systems should be solely based on an act of justice, not of revenge. We should aspire to have a liberal justice system, not some medieval eye-for-an-eye vengeance system.
Throwing acid on this guy won't bring her any satisfaction in the end because she'll have to live with still being ugly and blind and on top of that, knowing she ruined another human being's life. And if she does get satisfaction from knowing that, well I wouldn't call her a good person, that's for fucking sure.
coming into a thread and starting off by calling people idiots isn't exactly great behaviour either...
To add to your point though, I think it's also important to distinguish not only between vengeance and justice, but also justice and law. I don't support acts of violence as a form of justice, but I share the feeling, that if the roles had been reversed, the courts would not have tried so hard to talk the man out of taking his revenge. If this act of brutality improves the situation of women in Iran, I think she should go trhough with it.
I read in the newspaper today though, that the high court has postponed the blinding indefinitely, without giving any reason why.
|
|
|
|
|
|