|
On May 14 2011 23:52 TheHova wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 23:45 RockIronrod wrote:On May 14 2011 23:41 TheHova wrote: The path of the righteous man is beset on all sides by the inequities of the selfish and the tyranny of evil men. Blessed is he who, in the name of charity and good will, shepherds the weak through the valley of darkness, for he is truly his brother's keeper and the finder of lost children. also fuck gay people wat? Bible joke. Yes, turn the other cheek, but also women can't speak in church.
On May 14 2011 23:53 Blurio wrote: This is retarded. All the people that support this should imagine this situation. Dude A kills your son. You have all rights to be fucking angry at him, cause he fucked up your whole life. Now you're legally allowed to kill him. That would be an ok judgement, cause he killed your son. Duda A is 18. Now he's dead. Imagine to be in his family. Don't they have the right to kill you now? How can anyone be against things, like murder or this shit, but on the other hand support it in different circumstances? That's like saying that after each criminal serves his time in prison, the victim must also do the same.
|
On May 14 2011 23:24 Darksidius wrote: Awefull to see that there are actually people who support this kind of legal system... One would hope that the West has advanced since the Middle Ages, not everyone is happy with this advance it seems.
Just because the retarded legal system they have in those countries sounds to some acceptable doesn't mean that it is. (with those I mean countries that have Sharia law). This is a inhumane form of law, no matter how much people think the accused deserves the revenge.
By the way, the same law-system will hang you if you are gay, or will stone you to death if you are a woman and are raped, or will cut off your hand if you steal.
The whole law system (including this verdict) is backwards and retarded.
I don't know why you would say we agree with the whole system when we're just agreeing with this one law in this one instance. If theres a car accident and someone dies, but the driver lives, we wouldn't be saying its a good idea for the driver to get hit by a car as punishment...
Our "humane" forms for punishment are why there is so much crime. If people actually feared the repercussions of the crime they're planning to commit they would be more likely to either not do it, or seek mental help to prevent them from doing it. If a rapist would be brutally sodomized, in public, by his victim until she was "satisfied" don't you think there would be less rapes? As it is, they get a few years is jail, with a place warm to sleep and 3 meals a day, which by the way, all come out of your pocket as a taxpayer.
Prison just isn't a good enough punishment for some crimes.
|
Adults who support personal vengeance instead of a proper legal trial are either vastly immature or very short-sighted. Since when has vengance spawned anything but hate and counter-vengeance? Look at Sicily, the male population were nearly extinguished from vendettas.
Half the point about being a modern human being is knowing when to give in to primal instincts, and when to don't. Everyone has something within them that craves vengeance, but everyone should also know that it leads to no good.
|
On May 15 2011 00:02 Bosko wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 23:24 Darksidius wrote: Awefull to see that there are actually people who support this kind of legal system... One would hope that the West has advanced since the Middle Ages, not everyone is happy with this advance it seems.
Just because the retarded legal system they have in those countries sounds to some acceptable doesn't mean that it is. (with those I mean countries that have Sharia law). This is a inhumane form of law, no matter how much people think the accused deserves the revenge.
By the way, the same law-system will hang you if you are gay, or will stone you to death if you are a woman and are raped, or will cut off your hand if you steal.
The whole law system (including this verdict) is backwards and retarded. I don't know why you would say we agree with the whole system when we're just agreeing with this one law in this one instance. If theres a car accident and someone dies, but the driver lives, we wouldn't be saying its a good idea for the driver to get hit by a car as punishment... Our "humane" forms for punishment are why there is so much crime. If people actually feared the repercussions of the crime they're planning to commit they would be more likely to either not do it, or seek mental help to prevent them from doing it. If a rapist would be brutally sodomized, in public, by his victim until she was "satisfied" don't you think there would be less rapes? As it is, they get a few years is jail, with a place warm to sleep and 3 meals a day, which by the way, all come out of your pocket as a taxpayer. Prison just isn't a good enough punishment for some crimes. Do you honestly believe that crimes like murder and rape (or any other) will be repelled bij what kind of punishment you can get? From all the countries in the Western world, the United States have one of the harshest legal systems. Capital punishment included. They also have the highest crime and murder rate of the Western world.
But this isn't about law, it is about revenge. Once you go down that road, you must also kill the driver by hitting him with a car. You can't support one and not the other, it is exactly the same (except the brutality).
|
Our "humane" forms for punishment are why there is so much crime. If people actually feared the repercussions of the crime they're planning to commit they would be more likely to either not do it, or seek mental help to prevent them from doing it. If a rapist would be brutally sodomized, in public, by his victim until she was "satisfied" don't you think there would be less rapes? As it is, they get a few years is jail, with a place warm to sleep and 3 meals a day, which by the way, all come out of your pocket as a taxpayer.
Do the tax payers pay for the guys sodomizing the rapist? Hm come to think of it I guess they'd do it for free if that's what they're into. You do raise an interesting point though, maybe we should punish all the rapists by raping them. That's sure to get the number of rapes down.
|
I can relate to this; I once massacred an entire Zerg hive cluster as retribution for their hydralisks spitting acid in my zealot's eyes.
User was warned for this post
|
If Ghandi said it, it must be true, right?
If i quote someone great saying something, it must be true
|
On May 14 2011 23:49 zeru wrote: While the man deserves to be punished for what he did, retribution isn't justice. An-eye-for-an-eye-for-an-eye-for-an-eye ... ends in making everybody blind.
Or it ends up making all the people blinding other people blind, while the people not blinding people in the first place don't get blinded
|
United Arab Emirates245 Posts
On May 14 2011 23:35 kardinal wrote:![[image loading]](http://www.mediafire.com/imgbnc.php/2c28804425437e667800c035e4d40c399c09e2153d1206a3e96cefcec4f406c64g.jpg) vs dripping a few drops into the eye with sedatives.
Ouch
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
On May 14 2011 23:36 Darksidius wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 23:32 Sanjuro wrote:+ Show Spoiler +On May 14 2011 23:24 Darksidius wrote: Awefull to see that there are actually people who support this kind of legal system... One would hope that the West has advanced since the Middle Ages, not everyone is happy with this advance it seems.
Just because the retarded legal system they have in those countries sounds to some acceptable doesn't mean that it is. (with those I mean countries that have Sharia law). This is a inhumane form of law, no matter how much people think the accused deserves the revenge.
By the way, the same law-system will hang you if you are gay, or will stone you to death if you are a woman and are raped, or will cut off your hand if you steal.
The whole law system (including this verdict) is backwards and retarded. if it happened to you or someone you care about, and you could give a verdict on the punishment, what would it be? If someone keyed my car I would like to see them hanged... does that mean that that makes it a suitable punnishment? No, it's retarded. This is retarded, no matter how awefull it is to the woman.
if im not mistaken the base for syariah law can be divided into two, sins against God and sins against other people. And God can only forgive the sins against other people if the sinner is forgiven by the person that have been sinned (this includes with things like debts, broken promises, killing(forgiven by the family/relatives) etc. Even if you say something that hurt somebodies feeling, God will not forgive you for that sin until you are forgiven by that person)
thats why the legal system permits eye for an eye, it all comesback to what muslim believe will happen to you in the afterlife if its not forgiven.
sorry about the religion mumbo jumbo, just trying to explain on how people that practice syariah law sees it. And hanging for ruining a paintjob is not "eye for an eye"
|
I love humankind. Most don't understand how I'm able to but it's easy: You just need to handle other humans like a source of amusement. Like watching ants in an insectarium rather than like something even remotely similar to yourself.
I can understand the victims wish to take revenge. But to think that the legal system allows it, after thousands of years since the invention of writing.... Can't help feeling superior.
|
On May 15 2011 00:02 Bosko wrote: Our "humane" forms for punishment are why there is so much crime. If people actually feared the repercussions of the crime they're planning to commit they would be more likely to either not do it, or seek mental help to prevent them from doing it. That has proven to be wrong so many times, who do people still bring that bullshit up?
And why do some countries with a more relaxed law have less crimes than countries with a very strict law?
€ And to suggest that a rape victim should have sexual intercourse with the offender again...dude are you serious? That is so wrong and disgusting. Besides, I doubt ANY rape victim would want that, they want them dead or be as far away from them as possible( offender locked away), don't you think?
|
On May 15 2011 00:26 Sanjuro wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 23:36 Darksidius wrote:On May 14 2011 23:32 Sanjuro wrote:+ Show Spoiler +On May 14 2011 23:24 Darksidius wrote: Awefull to see that there are actually people who support this kind of legal system... One would hope that the West has advanced since the Middle Ages, not everyone is happy with this advance it seems.
Just because the retarded legal system they have in those countries sounds to some acceptable doesn't mean that it is. (with those I mean countries that have Sharia law). This is a inhumane form of law, no matter how much people think the accused deserves the revenge.
By the way, the same law-system will hang you if you are gay, or will stone you to death if you are a woman and are raped, or will cut off your hand if you steal.
The whole law system (including this verdict) is backwards and retarded. if it happened to you or someone you care about, and you could give a verdict on the punishment, what would it be? If someone keyed my car I would like to see them hanged... does that mean that that makes it a suitable punnishment? No, it's retarded. This is retarded, no matter how awefull it is to the woman. if im not mistaken the base for syariah law can be divided into two, sins against God and sins against other people. And God can only forgive the sins against other people if the sinner is forgiven by the person that have been sinned (this includes with things like debts, broken promises, killing(forgiven by the family/relatives) etc. Even if you say something that hurt somebodies feeling, God will not forgive you for that sin until you are forgiven by that person) thats why the legal system permits eye for an eye, it all comesback to what muslim believe will happen to you in the afterlife if its not forgiven. sorry about the religion mumbo jumbo, just trying to explain on how people that practice syariah law sees it. And hanging for ruining a paintjob is not "eye for an eye" Gining it a religious background doesn't make the sharia-law any less barbaric.
|
On May 14 2011 23:34 vdale wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2011 23:32 Sanjuro wrote:+ Show Spoiler +On May 14 2011 23:24 Darksidius wrote: Awefull to see that there are actually people who support this kind of legal system... One would hope that the West has advanced since the Middle Ages, not everyone is happy with this advance it seems.
Just because the retarded legal system they have in those countries sounds to some acceptable doesn't mean that it is. (with those I mean countries that have Sharia law). This is a inhumane form of law, no matter how much people think the accused deserves the revenge.
By the way, the same law-system will hang you if you are gay, or will stone you to death if you are a woman and are raped, or will cut off your hand if you steal.
The whole law system (including this verdict) is backwards and retarded. if it happened to you or someone you care about, and you could give a verdict on the punishment, what would it be? The good thing is that in our legal system the victims aren't the judges.
what i meant was the punishment, not the verdict (the verdict would be totally biased) my writing skills is still in bronze
|
i think the woman's decision to enact the same pain on this man is valididated in that, a man so foolish to hurt someone for such selfish reasons is clearly not using their eyes to begin with. in a metaphorical sense.
|
|
|
Rightfully etch ? Can't you use a better word that people know ?
|
|
|
|
|
|