...makes the whole world blind
I heard it was Oprah Winfrey... lol.
Oh well...
| Forum Index > General Forum |
|
Angueo
Korea (South)53 Posts
...makes the whole world blind I heard it was Oprah Winfrey... lol. Oh well... | ||
|
mutantmagnet
United States3807 Posts
On May 15 2011 01:45 teekesselchen wrote: What's mainly been worrying me is the fact, that so many people on international and German boards agreed with the judgement, some partially, some absolutely. It seems that really a lot of people don't agree with fundamental human rights anymore. What about her rights? The man didn't have acid thrown in his face by some gang. He was arrested and put through a judicial process. This process grants the accuser options and she exercised her options under law. Most cases like this is supposed to end with the guy getting away scott free since the system is stacked against women or pay out big time to the victim and go to jail for those who made it too easy to get convicted. The fact they don't rely on eye for an eye as their sole method of penalizing the accused makes this system acceptable. This doesn't mean I believe she doesn't need to forgive him at some point because forgiveness is the best way to move on from grudges that are psychologically eating you up. Yet there is no reason for him to be given a slap on the wrist. He needs to be penalized some how for his actions. | ||
|
Terranist
United States2496 Posts
| ||
|
Dagobert
Netherlands1858 Posts
| ||
|
Aphelion
United States2720 Posts
This will make a much deeper impression. | ||
|
clusen
Germany8702 Posts
On May 15 2011 03:17 mutantmagnet wrote: This doesn't mean I believe she doesn't need to forgive him at some point because forgiveness is the best way to move on from grudges that are psychologically eating you up. She can only forgive him now, she can't forgive him after she took revenge. There is nothing to forgive anymore according to the eye for an eye-logic. | ||
|
RandomAccount#81004
Finland612 Posts
| ||
|
EmeraldSparks
United States1451 Posts
On May 15 2011 03:20 Terranist wrote: I think people who advocate retributive justice, the Iranian legal system, and the woman who had acid thrown into her face and is now disfigured for life are all sheltered children who watched too much Death Note. Sorry, it doesn't work like that. | ||
|
Iyerbeth
England2410 Posts
| ||
|
Aphelion
United States2720 Posts
On May 15 2011 03:20 Terranist wrote: what a bunch of little sheltered psuedo-kiras we have in this thread. this is not crime deterrence, this is an inhumane display of government sponsored torture. they are walking the razor's edge. Justice isn't all about deterrance and rehabilitation. Vengeance is a important and essential component of justice. There's a reason why tit for tat is at the center of most moral codes, its because it emphasizes equality and that no one gets away scott-free. At the most basic level, that is what justice is, not this modern, pussified, notions witch confuse harmony with fairness, and compassion with justice. | ||
|
Mjolnir
912 Posts
On May 15 2011 02:42 Iron_Booger wrote: I think people on the thread are conflating a lot of issues that need to be separated from each other. The issue of whether Sharia Law, or religious laws in general, can be just in any society is an issue on its own. The issue of whether moral prescriptions are relative to a society, or whether they can be universal, is a separate one as well. Moral relativism, at least in the academic world (my major is philosophy/ethics), has been thoroughly invalidated. In pop American culture, the debate seems to surround this notion that the only alternative to relativism is divine universal law, and that dichotomy is terribly incomplete. If you are a relativist, on the basis that God's law seems silly and unjustified, then you are only half right, and the Christians have still duped you into thinking that those are the only two lines of thinking. Now on the issue of this woman and this "punishment" of her assaulter, the answer has got to be more clear than people are saying here. Would you honestly, truly, feel that your society was a fair and just one if people were literally sanctioned by law to burn each others eyes out? It may well be what /she/ wants, or what you would want if you were her, but that's the whole point of having a system that doesn't allow victims to exact whatever punishment satisfies them! Letting victims decide punishment is unjust in that the punishments themselves will become disproportional and arbitrary relative to each other. Committing crimes against pacifists would, I suppose, also be in a sense freely licensed. Isn't anyone concerned about the logical ends of this law? If Bob attacks Jim with a power drill, does Jim get to do the same? How about if Bob goes after Jim's legs with a chainsaw... does Jim get to do the same by court sanction? Does this sound just or modern in any way? Is this how a civil society handles violent crime, by arming the victims and having them double down on the brutality? I liked your post, and I have a few questions: Would you honestly, truly, feel that your society was a fair and just one if people were literally sanctioned by law to burn each others eyes out? It may well be what /she/ wants, or what you would want if you were her, but that's the whole point of having a system that doesn't allow victims to exact whatever punishment satisfies them! Letting victims decide punishment is unjust in that the punishments themselves will become disproportional and arbitrary relative to each other. Yeah, I can say that I would honestly feel that my society was fair and just if certain crimes were punished by some form of retributive justice - specifically that which is sanctioned and supervised by the state to ensure it is commensurate with the offense and no greater. In this case, the victim doesn't decide the punishment, the offender does, or the state does. The victim just has a choice of options. Here, she chose an option that seems foreign to us; but does that make it wrong? I don't believe the argument that "an eye for an eye makes the whole world blind" really works in this case because this is an example of the state moderating a punishment. If we can accept that this scenario ends with the offender's punishment, it's simply "an eye for an eye." It is possible that he retaliates again - perhaps on another person entirely but we can't be sure that will happen. Who is to say that this doesn't end when the punishment ends? Isn't anyone concerned about the logical ends of this law? If Bob attacks Jim with a power drill, does Jim get to do the same? How about if Bob goes after Jim's legs with a chainsaw... does Jim get to do the same by court sanction? Does this sound just or modern in any way? Is this how a civil society handles violent crime, by arming the victims and having them double down on the brutality? Is it not possible that we are viewing this from a framework of a society that has told us all since birth that "violence is bad - no matter what"? What if it isn't always bad? What if there are instances where an appropriate response to an action is violence but we've just been taught not to think that way? It does sound "just" to me that if Bob rips through Jim's legs with a chainsaw that Jim should be able to do likewise to Bob if he so chooses it to be an adequate punishment according to the laws of whatever state. To be quite honest - I'd prefer it if Jim got his version of justice and Bob was then thrown in jail on top of it for initiating the crime. To me it sounds just - brutal - but just. Why can't a civil society handle crime in such a manner? Does the notion that "what you do to others will be done to you" seem so uncivil? Maybe it seems so extreme to us because we're dealing with physical pain and damage - these are injuries that can't be compensated for; which might be part of the reason so many in this thread feel the response is justified. You can't buy a new face or eyes. You can't grow them back given enough time. You're ruined for life. Nothing will get back what you lost. How can the criminal possibly understand the totality of their crime if they don't experience it? Now, what if it was a crime where someone stole money, or crashed into your car and left the scene? I imagine nobody is expecting anything near as extreme; rather the return of lost goods or reparations for damage. Not all crimes need to be punished with such extremes; one of the aspects of retributivism that is overlooked in this thread, I think. Obviously, it's a complex issue. I'm not bashing anyone's views, only trying to get across why I think this is just. On that note, I am interested in an explanation as to what those calling this "unjust" would consider a just punishment. Specifically, why? Why is whatever option presented just - what makes it just? I see a lot of people saying "this is unjust" but not offering alternatives - or better yet, explaining why their alternatives are just, rather than simply 'not barbaric'. Again, not trying to raise a stink - I'm just after some clarification. I may very well be completely wrong in my line of thought and I'm willing to consider any argument offered. Just looking for some additional viewpoints ![]() | ||
|
Bosko
United States155 Posts
On May 15 2011 00:10 Darksidius wrote: Show nested quote + On May 15 2011 00:02 Bosko wrote: On May 14 2011 23:24 Darksidius wrote: Awefull to see that there are actually people who support this kind of legal system... One would hope that the West has advanced since the Middle Ages, not everyone is happy with this advance it seems. Just because the retarded legal system they have in those countries sounds to some acceptable doesn't mean that it is. (with those I mean countries that have Sharia law). This is a inhumane form of law, no matter how much people think the accused deserves the revenge. By the way, the same law-system will hang you if you are gay, or will stone you to death if you are a woman and are raped, or will cut off your hand if you steal. The whole law system (including this verdict) is backwards and retarded. I don't know why you would say we agree with the whole system when we're just agreeing with this one law in this one instance. If theres a car accident and someone dies, but the driver lives, we wouldn't be saying its a good idea for the driver to get hit by a car as punishment... Our "humane" forms for punishment are why there is so much crime. If people actually feared the repercussions of the crime they're planning to commit they would be more likely to either not do it, or seek mental help to prevent them from doing it. If a rapist would be brutally sodomized, in public, by his victim until she was "satisfied" don't you think there would be less rapes? As it is, they get a few years is jail, with a place warm to sleep and 3 meals a day, which by the way, all come out of your pocket as a taxpayer. Prison just isn't a good enough punishment for some crimes. Do you honestly believe that crimes like murder and rape (or any other) will be repelled bij what kind of punishment you can get? From all the countries in the Western world, the United States have one of the harshest legal systems. Capital punishment included. They also have the highest crime and murder rate of the Western world. But this isn't about law, it is about revenge. Once you go down that road, you must also kill the driver by hitting him with a car. You can't support one and not the other, it is exactly the same (except the brutality). Tell me how the west has the harshest legal system. Motel-like prisons with gyms better then the one down the street I pay $30 a month to go to? The only thing that makes it harsh are the other criminals inside. And as for the car accident analogy its not at all "exactly the same." Ones is an accident, one is going to whatever store it is you buy acid, buying it, brining it home, setting it up, going to the persons house, knocking on the door, asking if shes home, waiting for her to come to the door, and then THROWING ACID IN HER FACE. How is that the same act to you? Stop spewing jibberish if you're seriously trying to convince people its wrong or I'm going to start thinking you're trolling us. | ||
|
Omegalisk
United States337 Posts
On May 15 2011 03:15 Deadlyfish wrote: Sometimes they are the same though. In the case of your example of the serial murder, i would argue that killing him would be the moral choice and serve justice at the same time. How would killing him be moral? Morality doesn't consider things like what they have done, or whether they are a good person or not. Morality only considers consequences, and in both cases of life sentence and killing him, the end consequence would be the same except one has one more murder in the picture. | ||
|
Terranist
United States2496 Posts
On May 15 2011 03:26 Aphelion wrote: Show nested quote + On May 15 2011 03:20 Terranist wrote: what a bunch of little sheltered psuedo-kiras we have in this thread. this is not crime deterrence, this is an inhumane display of government sponsored torture. they are walking the razor's edge. Justice isn't all about deterrance and rehabilitation. Vengeance is a important and essential component of justice. There's a reason why tit for tat is at the center of most moral codes, its because it emphasizes equality and that no one gets away scott-free. At the most basic level, that is what justice is, not this modern, pussified, notions witch confuse harmony with fairness, and compassion with justice. that is not how civilized people operate. judgments like these only promote degenerative behavior. you don't get to shoot, stab, bludgeon, or even throw acid at an unarmed person with the basis of, "he started it." | ||
|
Baum
Germany1010 Posts
It's incredibly stupid to think that eye for an eye will stop people from committing such things. It's education and prosperity that reduces violence. | ||
|
mutantmagnet
United States3807 Posts
On May 15 2011 03:23 clusen wrote: Show nested quote + On May 15 2011 03:17 mutantmagnet wrote: This doesn't mean I believe she doesn't need to forgive him at some point because forgiveness is the best way to move on from grudges that are psychologically eating you up. She can only forgive him now, she can't forgive him after she took revenge. There is nothing to forgive anymore according to the eye for an eye-logic. *shrugs* Some people would see this is cathartic but in reality it isn't the most effective way to heal yourself mentally. Eye for an eye is a punishment system and in most cases a bad one because the punishment doesn't fit the crime. Not only does the punishment here fit the crime, it wasn't the only option in their laws. I have to respect that type of flexibility. Would you honestly, truly, feel that your society was a fair and just one if people were literally sanctioned by law to burn each others eyes out? It may well be what /she/ wants, or what you would want if you were her, but that's the whole point of having a system that doesn't allow victims to exact whatever punishment satisfies them! Letting victims decide punishment is unjust in that the punishments themselves will become disproportional and arbitrary relative to each other. This is the problem people against this ruling have a hard time comprehending. Neither the court nor do their laws say the victim has carte blanche in choosing their penalty. The outcome we are getting here isn't disproportionate to the crime. That's why I'm in support of this. If the options for thievery, for example, was the victim gets their possessions back or financial compensation if their property can't be recovered, or the thief gets their hand cut off, I wouldn't be in support of it. The last option is disproportionate with the crime. It's in no way equitable. For once the justice system worked as it needs to and the only discrepancies to take care of is the cost benefit analysis to society, the rehabilitation of the victim and re-socialization of the penalized. | ||
|
shtdisturbance
Canada613 Posts
| ||
|
SeRenExZerg
United States401 Posts
| ||
|
Neo7
United States922 Posts
On May 15 2011 03:20 Terranist wrote: what a bunch of little sheltered psuedo-kiras we have in this thread. this is not crime deterrence, this is an inhumane display of government sponsored torture. they are walking the razor's edge. In the anime/manga, Kira "exercised justice" while completely bypassing the justice system. This man was arrested, put through trial, found guilty of the said crime, and sentenced at the mercy of the woman he violated. He knew the rules as set by Sharia Law and that it could lead to such a situation (or at the very least had access to such information since it is public). It's a fair judgement. IIRC, L was just as ruthless in seeking out the maximum punishment himself (except going through the justice system). So no, it is not "Kira-like" | ||
|
teekesselchen
Germany886 Posts
On May 15 2011 03:17 mutantmagnet wrote: Show nested quote + On May 15 2011 01:45 teekesselchen wrote: What's mainly been worrying me is the fact, that so many people on international and German boards agreed with the judgement, some partially, some absolutely. It seems that really a lot of people don't agree with fundamental human rights anymore. What about her rights? The man didn't have acid thrown in his face by some gang. He was arrested and put through a judicial process. This process grants the accuser options and she exercised her options under law. Most cases like this is supposed to end with the guy getting away scott free since the system is stacked against women or pay out big time to the victim and go to jail for those who made it too easy to get convicted. The fact they don't rely on eye for an eye as their sole method of penalizing the accused makes this system acceptable. This doesn't mean I believe she doesn't need to forgive him at some point because forgiveness is the best way to move on from grudges that are psychologically eating you up. Yet there is no reason for him to be given a slap on the wrist. He needs to be penalized some how for his actions. You really don't seem to understand what human rights mean. Human rights are rights that every human has, without conditions. Even a criminal still has them. By not accepting them as universal, things like protection from torture and physical punishment are not mandatory anymore, with potentialy devastating consequences. Of course she has rights, too, and of course it is bad that her rights have been violated, but that cannot be equaled out by violating the criminal's rights, too. And: Allowing personal vengeance? This is totally broken. I think you should read Freesia one day. On May 15 2011 03:45 Neo7 wrote: Show nested quote + On May 15 2011 03:20 Terranist wrote: what a bunch of little sheltered psuedo-kiras we have in this thread. this is not crime deterrence, this is an inhumane display of government sponsored torture. they are walking the razor's edge. In the anime/manga, Kira "exercised justiced" while completely bypassing the justice system. This man was arrested, put through trial, found guilty of the said crime, and sentenced at the mercy of the woman he violated. He knew the rules as set by Sharia Law and that it could lead to such a situation (or at the very least had access to such information since it is public). It's a fair judgement. So no, it is not "Kira-like" See above, Freesia is a really great manga actually capturing this exact situation. It plays in a dystopic future, where it is allowed to take personal vengeance for oneself or related victims of crimes in so called "enforcements". Really no children's story à la Naruto (and even Death Note actually) etc., this is dystopic, good literature. About Kira... Kira had a different thought I think. His idea was to create actually working deterance, which an "earthly" legal system cannot create. Criminals don't think "For 10 years of prison I'll kill him, for 20 I won't", or even about whether they will be locked up for eternity or killed. But immediate death from a seemingly "heavenly", mystical source, upon crimes? That's a whole different story - still not working as an omnipotent deterrence, but much stronger than what humans can do. Also, leading into atrocity even in Death Note. | ||
| ||
SOOP
SC2 Kevin Scrim 4v4
IntoTheiNu
FanTaSy79
Maru
SHIN
Rex32
soO30
ByuN (SOOP)
Rogue
herO (SOOP)
Classic
[ Submit Event ] |
|
|
Replay Cast
Monday Night Weeklies
PiGosaur Cup
The PondCast
OSC
Replay Cast
GSL
Patches Events
OSC
Replay Cast
[ Show More ] KCM Race Survival
RSL Revival
BSL
eOnzErG vs StRyKeR
Cross vs JDConan
RSL Revival
BSL
Bonyth vs Doodle
Kyrie vs Jimin
WardiTV Weekly
|
|
|