Woman will legally etch a man's eyes - Page 32
| Forum Index > General Forum |
|
zeru
8156 Posts
| ||
|
Bonkarooni
United States383 Posts
| ||
|
DatBoiRijad
100 Posts
On May 15 2011 05:08 Jakkerr wrote: How it's wrong? because we don't live in the medieval anymore -.- Victims should never have ANY saying in a legal system since it's supposed to be objective, I'm happy all Western countries came to senses a few hundred years ago ![]() So the victims, the one who the crime happened to, shouldn't have no say? Makes no sense. | ||
|
TYJ.Aoy
Brazil1265 Posts
| ||
|
dakalro
Romania525 Posts
On May 15 2011 05:10 zeru wrote: Grey means there are no statistics for that region... The sources you linked didn't even compare the countries we are talking about directly. I don't see grey = no statistics anywhere but I would tend to agree that's the most likely reason. But that still shows nothing about crime rates in Muslim countries compared to "civilized" counterparts. It wasn't my intention to compare countries, was just to show that "civilized" justice doesn't work that great either. My whole point was not that I feel what they're doing is OK but that it's not much worse than in the rest of the world and we have no right to judge and take the moral high ground until they start releasing statistics that prisoners no longer get beaten, raped, abused, killed, that they don't commit crimes again, that they manage to find jobs and reintegrate in the same % as someone that has never been in jail. Until then you are simply saying burning someone with acid as retribution is barbaric while letting someone be abused in jail is civilized. It's a simple matter of "let he who is without sin cast the first stone". In an ideal world I would say this is barbaric but so is the current justice/punishment system in the entire world, or most of it anyway. (I'm somewhere between atheist and possibly there might be a being out there but fuck organized religion, it's literally the work of the devil; have read the Bible out of curiosity and while fiction it's not without lessons) | ||
|
DatBoiRijad
100 Posts
On May 15 2011 05:12 DizzyDrone wrote: Nobody deserves this type of punishment. Preventing people from being punished this way is the entire reason for having a declaration of human rights in the first place. The reason doesn't matter, you're still allowing someone to "throw acid on his face". The fact is, you're saying: "That's a TERRIBLE thing to do to a human being!" while at the same time allowing her to do that to another human being. If you can't understand the problem with that I don't know what to tell you. Who says nobody deserves this type of punishment? You? Human rights, don't make me laugh. Who chose these rights again? If he threw acid into a girl face are you honestly just going to let him sit in jail? It's called a punishment, and it's not a bad thing. I doubt people will be murdering/throwing acid into peoples eyes if they realize they're going to get the same punishment back. | ||
|
Djzapz
Canada10681 Posts
On May 15 2011 05:23 TYJ.Aoy wrote: Its amusing how many cute little chaps condene this, eye for an eye in this case is completely just, maybe he should suffer even more since his act had such a vain motive. It's not just. It's vengeance being carried through. Will the world be a better place? No. The guy will be free, and could still hurt people. You have to be extremely shallow and vindictive to not realize that this is absurd. | ||
|
checo
Mexico1364 Posts
| ||
|
Kojak21
Canada1104 Posts
On May 15 2011 05:23 TYJ.Aoy wrote: Its amusing how many cute little chaps condene this, eye for an eye in this case is completely just, maybe he should suffer even more since his act had such a vain motive. i agree, he should suffer more | ||
|
Djzapz
Canada10681 Posts
On May 15 2011 05:27 DatBoiRijad wrote: Who says nobody deserves this type of punishment? You? Human rights, don't make me laugh. Who chose these rights again? If he threw acid into a girl face are you honestly just going to let him sit in jail? It's called a punishment, and it's not a bad thing. I doubt people will be murdering/throwing acid into peoples eyes if they realize they're going to get the same punishment back. No, they'll still do it because they'll think they won't get caught. Odds are a few people will be afraid of the State's retribution so they won't do whatever, but that'd be completely counterbalanced by the fact that the State is barbaric as hell. In the end, more people get butchered. | ||
|
BlackJack
United States10574 Posts
He's actually suffering a lot less. Sedated + he doesn't have a disfigured face? That's not even half as bad as what she got. | ||
|
Cloud9157
United States2968 Posts
"I'm going to show its wrong by doing it to you, lolz" Good to know that violence is still the preferred punishment in the world. | ||
|
teekesselchen
Germany886 Posts
On May 15 2011 04:44 Phenny wrote: No, supporting this particular instance is very different from supporting the disgusting clusterfuck that is Sharia. Is it? Sharia pleads for harsh punishment without human rights or anything, this is the prime example for it. | ||
|
Kindred
Canada396 Posts
This is why the Sharia, applied properly, can be really good since the victims have a CHOICE. Something which our system does not offer so you end up with people going to prison for a bit and out. | ||
|
DatBoiRijad
100 Posts
On May 15 2011 05:31 Djzapz wrote: No, they'll still do it because they'll think they won't get caught. Odds are a few people will be afraid of the State's retribution so they won't do whatever, but that'd be completely counterbalanced by the fact that the State is barbaric as hell. In the end, more people get butchered. No.. say when they do catch someone, and they do the thing this lady is about to do, they might actually figure out that they aren't invincible and actually may get caught, and they wont do such a crazy thing. The people that say send him to jail and let him have a fair trail are the ones who think we can live in a perfect world and everyone is great inside. Truth is, most people that come out of prison are doing the same things that got them their, they haven't changed. | ||
|
Kindred
Canada396 Posts
On May 15 2011 05:32 Cloud9157 wrote: Lol, this eye for an eye (literally and figuratively) shit needs to disappear. "I'm going to show its wrong by doing it to you, lolz" Good to know that violence is still the preferred punishment in the world. Its comments like these that I find insensitive. Get acid thrown in your face, be permanently disfigured and traumatized, then when you have the choice of whether to have him in jail or get acid in his eye, pick whatever will make YOU feel better. | ||
|
Phenny
Australia1435 Posts
On May 15 2011 05:32 Cloud9157 wrote: Lol, this eye for an eye (literally and figuratively) shit needs to disappear. "I'm going to show its wrong by doing it to you, lolz" Good to know that violence is still the preferred punishment in the world. I think it's excellent. It's not about showing it's wrong, it's about don't fuck with me. | ||
|
DwmC_Foefen
Belgium2186 Posts
On May 15 2011 04:44 Phenny wrote: No, supporting this particular instance is very different from supporting the disgusting clusterfuck that is Sharia. Elaborate please. | ||
|
Djzapz
Canada10681 Posts
On May 15 2011 05:34 DatBoiRijad wrote: No.. say when they do catch someone, and they do the thing this lady is about to do, they might actually figure out that they aren't invincible and actually may get caught, and they wont do such a crazy thing. The people that say send him to jail and let him have a fair trail are the ones who think we can live in a perfect world and everyone is great inside. Truth is, most people that come out of prison are doing the same things that got them their, they haven't changed. Many assumptions that seem wrong. People don't learn much from other people's mistakes, I think that's pretty much understood by most. | ||
|
Bippzy
United States1466 Posts
On May 15 2011 05:15 zeru wrote: Well, i'd say there's a pretty damn good reason we moved away from 3500 year old laws. And yeah, something like this will always be a clash of opinions i guess, not a discussion. Her throwing acid in his eyes makes her just as bad as him though, imo. Are you saying the reason we moved away from 3500 year old laws is because of how old they are? this is not the case. It's more about how the eye for an eye system can be abused. If I am not a singer and miley cyrus is, and i kill her vocal chords somehow and then she kills mine, she has much worse consequences. That said, I actually think she deserves to put acid in his eyes and send him to jail. It prevents people from doing this again, which is the whole point of law. Saying this guy has human rights not to lose his eyesight is bull, because she had the same rights and they were violated. | ||
| ||

"