|
On May 15 2011 05:15 zeru wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 05:11 BlackJack wrote:On May 15 2011 05:04 zeru wrote:On May 15 2011 04:55 DatBoiRijad wrote:On May 15 2011 04:53 Gigaudas wrote: "An eye for an eye" - imagine the damage this sentence has done to humanity.
She is no better than he is. Please explain how an eye for an eye is wrong? So we should just let people do what ever they want, but treat them fairly if they get caught? Because lex talionis and code of hammurabi something we in the modern world have somewhat abandoned, and invented new and better ways as far as i know. The only countries still using those laws are muslim countries which still use sharia. That doesn't answer his question at all, it just says "our way is better  " That seems to be the bulk of arguments that oppose this. Just a whole lot of "that's just wrong!" "retribution is just wrong" "An eye for an eye is just wrong" etc. I find this discussion to be very similar to abortion debates where both sides are convinced that their way is the "right way" when there's really no way to prove your sense of morality is superior to another person's. They are just opinions.. Well, i'd say there's a pretty damn good reason we moved away from 3500 year old laws. And yeah, something like this will always be a clash of opinions i guess, not a discussion. Her throwing acid in his eyes makes her just as bad as him though, imo.
So you must not enjoy films like Kill Bill, Oldboy, Memento, Leon the Professional, etc. You have nobody to root for since Uma Thurman's character is just as evil as Bill
|
|
|
On May 15 2011 05:36 Djzapz wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 05:34 DatBoiRijad wrote:On May 15 2011 05:31 Djzapz wrote:On May 15 2011 05:27 DatBoiRijad wrote:On May 15 2011 05:12 DizzyDrone wrote:On May 15 2011 04:51 DatBoiRijad wrote: he's getting everything he deserves.
Nobody deserves this type of punishment. Preventing people from being punished this way is the entire reason for having a declaration of human rights in the first place. On May 15 2011 04:52 RoosterSamurai wrote: We aren't throwing acid on his face for no apparent reason.
The reason doesn't matter, you're still allowing someone to "throw acid on his face". The fact is, you're saying: "That's a TERRIBLE thing to do to a human being!" while at the same time allowing her to do that to another human being. If you can't understand the problem with that I don't know what to tell you. Who says nobody deserves this type of punishment? You? Human rights, don't make me laugh. Who chose these rights again? If he threw acid into a girl face are you honestly just going to let him sit in jail? It's called a punishment, and it's not a bad thing. I doubt people will be murdering/throwing acid into peoples eyes if they realize they're going to get the same punishment back. No, they'll still do it because they'll think they won't get caught. Odds are a few people will be afraid of the State's retribution so they won't do whatever, but that'd be completely counterbalanced by the fact that the State is barbaric as hell. In the end, more people get butchered. No.. say when they do catch someone, and they do the thing this lady is about to do, they might actually figure out that they aren't invincible and actually may get caught, and they wont do such a crazy thing. The people that say send him to jail and let him have a fair trail are the ones who think we can live in a perfect world and everyone is great inside. Truth is, most people that come out of prison are doing the same things that got them their, they haven't changed. Many assumptions that seem wrong. People don't learn much from other people's mistakes, I think that's pretty much understood by most.
Yes they do. People who have friends who die from drinking and driving don't drink and drive. People who hear about hitler do not try to start a new holocaust. The only time that people don't learn from other people's mistakes is if they are stupid, or crazy. In this case, the guy was crazy with rejection and stupid for acting violently. And this response is completely just, even though i feel the guy deserves a greater punishment.
|
On May 15 2011 05:33 Kindred wrote: The traumatic stress and pain this woman was put through cannot be understood by anybody here. When it is her decision what should happen to him, this is a way of giving her closure. If all she needed was to put him in jail, she would do that. But if putting acid in his eye is the way she can feel better, then good for her.
Of course everyone here can intellectually - though not emotionally reproduce- grasp what she feels. You do so, too, or else you couldn't be so convinced that it was very likely far beyond everything a person still roaming on Team Liquid has experienced.
Even so, revenge and hard line is no solution.... look at what's going on in middle east, would that happen when people would forgive each other? No, that happens because people want their revenge... There have been many things beeing destroyed by revenge. The developement between WW1 and WW2? A lot about revenge and disgrace, and not enough forgiveness.
|
On May 15 2011 05:36 DwmC_Foefen wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 04:44 Phenny wrote:On May 15 2011 04:33 DwmC_Foefen wrote: I think half of the people of this thread should turn to Sharia if they support this retributionsystem... See how they like it. No, supporting this particular instance is very different from supporting the disgusting clusterfuck that is Sharia. Elaborate please.
I believe that under these circumstances an eye for an eye is the perfect logical consequence for the crime. I do not believe that this holds true for other crimes necessarily but I don't think it to be any worse/less just than to chuck him in a prison for a while.
|
On May 15 2011 05:36 Djzapz wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 05:34 DatBoiRijad wrote:On May 15 2011 05:31 Djzapz wrote:On May 15 2011 05:27 DatBoiRijad wrote:On May 15 2011 05:12 DizzyDrone wrote:On May 15 2011 04:51 DatBoiRijad wrote: he's getting everything he deserves.
Nobody deserves this type of punishment. Preventing people from being punished this way is the entire reason for having a declaration of human rights in the first place. On May 15 2011 04:52 RoosterSamurai wrote: We aren't throwing acid on his face for no apparent reason.
The reason doesn't matter, you're still allowing someone to "throw acid on his face". The fact is, you're saying: "That's a TERRIBLE thing to do to a human being!" while at the same time allowing her to do that to another human being. If you can't understand the problem with that I don't know what to tell you. Who says nobody deserves this type of punishment? You? Human rights, don't make me laugh. Who chose these rights again? If he threw acid into a girl face are you honestly just going to let him sit in jail? It's called a punishment, and it's not a bad thing. I doubt people will be murdering/throwing acid into peoples eyes if they realize they're going to get the same punishment back. No, they'll still do it because they'll think they won't get caught. Odds are a few people will be afraid of the State's retribution so they won't do whatever, but that'd be completely counterbalanced by the fact that the State is barbaric as hell. In the end, more people get butchered. No.. say when they do catch someone, and they do the thing this lady is about to do, they might actually figure out that they aren't invincible and actually may get caught, and they wont do such a crazy thing. The people that say send him to jail and let him have a fair trail are the ones who think we can live in a perfect world and everyone is great inside. Truth is, most people that come out of prison are doing the same things that got them their, they haven't changed. Many assumptions that seem wrong. People don't learn much from other people's mistakes, I think that's pretty much understood by most. You've never been to China, have you? I'll stop now since you really aren't addressing my points anymore.
|
On May 15 2011 05:42 Bippzy wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 05:36 Djzapz wrote:On May 15 2011 05:34 DatBoiRijad wrote:On May 15 2011 05:31 Djzapz wrote:On May 15 2011 05:27 DatBoiRijad wrote:On May 15 2011 05:12 DizzyDrone wrote:On May 15 2011 04:51 DatBoiRijad wrote: he's getting everything he deserves.
Nobody deserves this type of punishment. Preventing people from being punished this way is the entire reason for having a declaration of human rights in the first place. On May 15 2011 04:52 RoosterSamurai wrote: We aren't throwing acid on his face for no apparent reason.
The reason doesn't matter, you're still allowing someone to "throw acid on his face". The fact is, you're saying: "That's a TERRIBLE thing to do to a human being!" while at the same time allowing her to do that to another human being. If you can't understand the problem with that I don't know what to tell you. Who says nobody deserves this type of punishment? You? Human rights, don't make me laugh. Who chose these rights again? If he threw acid into a girl face are you honestly just going to let him sit in jail? It's called a punishment, and it's not a bad thing. I doubt people will be murdering/throwing acid into peoples eyes if they realize they're going to get the same punishment back. No, they'll still do it because they'll think they won't get caught. Odds are a few people will be afraid of the State's retribution so they won't do whatever, but that'd be completely counterbalanced by the fact that the State is barbaric as hell. In the end, more people get butchered. No.. say when they do catch someone, and they do the thing this lady is about to do, they might actually figure out that they aren't invincible and actually may get caught, and they wont do such a crazy thing. The people that say send him to jail and let him have a fair trail are the ones who think we can live in a perfect world and everyone is great inside. Truth is, most people that come out of prison are doing the same things that got them their, they haven't changed. Many assumptions that seem wrong. People don't learn much from other people's mistakes, I think that's pretty much understood by most. People who hear about hitler do not try to start a new holocaust. lol...
um...
LOL.
But seriously, they don't learn that much, stop making bad comparisons.
On May 15 2011 05:44 DatBoiRijad wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 05:36 Djzapz wrote:On May 15 2011 05:34 DatBoiRijad wrote:On May 15 2011 05:31 Djzapz wrote:On May 15 2011 05:27 DatBoiRijad wrote:On May 15 2011 05:12 DizzyDrone wrote:On May 15 2011 04:51 DatBoiRijad wrote: he's getting everything he deserves.
Nobody deserves this type of punishment. Preventing people from being punished this way is the entire reason for having a declaration of human rights in the first place. On May 15 2011 04:52 RoosterSamurai wrote: We aren't throwing acid on his face for no apparent reason.
The reason doesn't matter, you're still allowing someone to "throw acid on his face". The fact is, you're saying: "That's a TERRIBLE thing to do to a human being!" while at the same time allowing her to do that to another human being. If you can't understand the problem with that I don't know what to tell you. Who says nobody deserves this type of punishment? You? Human rights, don't make me laugh. Who chose these rights again? If he threw acid into a girl face are you honestly just going to let him sit in jail? It's called a punishment, and it's not a bad thing. I doubt people will be murdering/throwing acid into peoples eyes if they realize they're going to get the same punishment back. No, they'll still do it because they'll think they won't get caught. Odds are a few people will be afraid of the State's retribution so they won't do whatever, but that'd be completely counterbalanced by the fact that the State is barbaric as hell. In the end, more people get butchered. No.. say when they do catch someone, and they do the thing this lady is about to do, they might actually figure out that they aren't invincible and actually may get caught, and they wont do such a crazy thing. The people that say send him to jail and let him have a fair trail are the ones who think we can live in a perfect world and everyone is great inside. Truth is, most people that come out of prison are doing the same things that got them their, they haven't changed. Many assumptions that seem wrong. People don't learn much from other people's mistakes, I think that's pretty much understood by most. You've never been to China, have you? I'll stop now since you really aren't addressing my points anymore. Why would I address assumptions? :/ Sorry man I can't. You just assume things and bring no data to support it. You might as well tell me you believe in unicorns and I can't disprove it.
|
So he threw acid in a womens face and now he gets acis in his face/eye from that women. Seems reasonable to me. If he complains id just laugh at him.
I really dont know whats wrong with all you people who are screaming barbaric.. This actualy is good stuff. The real deal.
I dont want to live in a world where i can kill someone by random and get 10 years for it and im done. I cant even imagine why you would even try to resocialise a murderer or similiar. They forfeit their right to live. Anything else is inacceptable. Think about the victims.
|
It's not like the guy is going to feel it. so I don't really see the problem. If this was done without anesthetic then it would be considered torture.. isn't this is just a crude way of blinding him? I don't know if I could go through with it.. but if someone threw acid at me because I didn't want to marry them I would probably feel differently..
One thing I do find quite interesting is that he would prefer to go to jail than taste his own medicine.. so he's afraid of having it done to him.. but has no remorse for doing it? I say let her do it.. she has to live with her conscience afterward, not the rest of the world. She wasn't allowed to choose between jail or acid.. why should he?
|
On May 15 2011 05:35 Kindred wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 05:32 Cloud9157 wrote: Lol, this eye for an eye (literally and figuratively) shit needs to disappear.
"I'm going to show its wrong by doing it to you, lolz"
Good to know that violence is still the preferred punishment in the world. Its comments like these that I find insensitive. Get acid thrown in your face, be permanently disfigured and traumatized, then when you have the choice of whether to have him in jail or get acid in his eye, pick whatever will make YOU feel better.
So a murderer kills your loved one, so you should demand he dies to show that what he did is wrong?
Fuck this "but it makes me feel better" stuff. You say that now, but when you look back on it, is it really going to make you feel any better?
I know every time I try to get revenge on someone, I just feel worse than before. Just my experience though.
|
On May 15 2011 05:39 BlackJack wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 05:15 zeru wrote:On May 15 2011 05:11 BlackJack wrote:On May 15 2011 05:04 zeru wrote:On May 15 2011 04:55 DatBoiRijad wrote:On May 15 2011 04:53 Gigaudas wrote: "An eye for an eye" - imagine the damage this sentence has done to humanity.
She is no better than he is. Please explain how an eye for an eye is wrong? So we should just let people do what ever they want, but treat them fairly if they get caught? Because lex talionis and code of hammurabi something we in the modern world have somewhat abandoned, and invented new and better ways as far as i know. The only countries still using those laws are muslim countries which still use sharia. That doesn't answer his question at all, it just says "our way is better  " That seems to be the bulk of arguments that oppose this. Just a whole lot of "that's just wrong!" "retribution is just wrong" "An eye for an eye is just wrong" etc. I find this discussion to be very similar to abortion debates where both sides are convinced that their way is the "right way" when there's really no way to prove your sense of morality is superior to another person's. They are just opinions.. Well, i'd say there's a pretty damn good reason we moved away from 3500 year old laws. And yeah, something like this will always be a clash of opinions i guess, not a discussion. Her throwing acid in his eyes makes her just as bad as him though, imo. So you must not enjoy films like Kill Bill, Oldboy, Memento, Leon the Professional, etc. You have nobody to root for since Uma Thurman's character is just as evil as Bill
I'm watching movies just for the heck of it. I'm not rooting for anyone. Are you like the stereotypical black people in the cinema, always screaming at the screen?
|
On May 15 2011 05:44 Djzapz wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 05:42 Bippzy wrote:On May 15 2011 05:36 Djzapz wrote:On May 15 2011 05:34 DatBoiRijad wrote:On May 15 2011 05:31 Djzapz wrote:On May 15 2011 05:27 DatBoiRijad wrote:On May 15 2011 05:12 DizzyDrone wrote:On May 15 2011 04:51 DatBoiRijad wrote: he's getting everything he deserves.
Nobody deserves this type of punishment. Preventing people from being punished this way is the entire reason for having a declaration of human rights in the first place. On May 15 2011 04:52 RoosterSamurai wrote: We aren't throwing acid on his face for no apparent reason.
The reason doesn't matter, you're still allowing someone to "throw acid on his face". The fact is, you're saying: "That's a TERRIBLE thing to do to a human being!" while at the same time allowing her to do that to another human being. If you can't understand the problem with that I don't know what to tell you. Who says nobody deserves this type of punishment? You? Human rights, don't make me laugh. Who chose these rights again? If he threw acid into a girl face are you honestly just going to let him sit in jail? It's called a punishment, and it's not a bad thing. I doubt people will be murdering/throwing acid into peoples eyes if they realize they're going to get the same punishment back. No, they'll still do it because they'll think they won't get caught. Odds are a few people will be afraid of the State's retribution so they won't do whatever, but that'd be completely counterbalanced by the fact that the State is barbaric as hell. In the end, more people get butchered. No.. say when they do catch someone, and they do the thing this lady is about to do, they might actually figure out that they aren't invincible and actually may get caught, and they wont do such a crazy thing. The people that say send him to jail and let him have a fair trail are the ones who think we can live in a perfect world and everyone is great inside. Truth is, most people that come out of prison are doing the same things that got them their, they haven't changed. Many assumptions that seem wrong. People don't learn much from other people's mistakes, I think that's pretty much understood by most. People who hear about hitler do not try to start a new holocaust. lol... um... LOL. But seriously, they don't learn that much, stop making bad comparisons. Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 05:44 DatBoiRijad wrote:On May 15 2011 05:36 Djzapz wrote:On May 15 2011 05:34 DatBoiRijad wrote:On May 15 2011 05:31 Djzapz wrote:On May 15 2011 05:27 DatBoiRijad wrote:On May 15 2011 05:12 DizzyDrone wrote:On May 15 2011 04:51 DatBoiRijad wrote: he's getting everything he deserves.
Nobody deserves this type of punishment. Preventing people from being punished this way is the entire reason for having a declaration of human rights in the first place. On May 15 2011 04:52 RoosterSamurai wrote: We aren't throwing acid on his face for no apparent reason.
The reason doesn't matter, you're still allowing someone to "throw acid on his face". The fact is, you're saying: "That's a TERRIBLE thing to do to a human being!" while at the same time allowing her to do that to another human being. If you can't understand the problem with that I don't know what to tell you. Who says nobody deserves this type of punishment? You? Human rights, don't make me laugh. Who chose these rights again? If he threw acid into a girl face are you honestly just going to let him sit in jail? It's called a punishment, and it's not a bad thing. I doubt people will be murdering/throwing acid into peoples eyes if they realize they're going to get the same punishment back. No, they'll still do it because they'll think they won't get caught. Odds are a few people will be afraid of the State's retribution so they won't do whatever, but that'd be completely counterbalanced by the fact that the State is barbaric as hell. In the end, more people get butchered. No.. say when they do catch someone, and they do the thing this lady is about to do, they might actually figure out that they aren't invincible and actually may get caught, and they wont do such a crazy thing. The people that say send him to jail and let him have a fair trail are the ones who think we can live in a perfect world and everyone is great inside. Truth is, most people that come out of prison are doing the same things that got them their, they haven't changed. Many assumptions that seem wrong. People don't learn much from other people's mistakes, I think that's pretty much understood by most. You've never been to China, have you? I'll stop now since you really aren't addressing my points anymore. Why would I address assumptions? :/ Sorry man I can't. You just assume things and bring no data to support it. You might as well tell me you believe in unicorns and I can't disprove it. Do you see the Chinese even trying to sell drugs? No, because they have a death penalty. I don't agree with the death penalty, but it sure has stopped the Chinese people from doing drugs.
you're losing this argument btw.
|
|
|
On May 15 2011 05:48 zeru wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 05:44 Djzapz wrote:On May 15 2011 05:44 DatBoiRijad wrote:On May 15 2011 05:36 Djzapz wrote:On May 15 2011 05:34 DatBoiRijad wrote:On May 15 2011 05:31 Djzapz wrote:On May 15 2011 05:27 DatBoiRijad wrote:On May 15 2011 05:12 DizzyDrone wrote:On May 15 2011 04:51 DatBoiRijad wrote: he's getting everything he deserves.
Nobody deserves this type of punishment. Preventing people from being punished this way is the entire reason for having a declaration of human rights in the first place. On May 15 2011 04:52 RoosterSamurai wrote: We aren't throwing acid on his face for no apparent reason.
The reason doesn't matter, you're still allowing someone to "throw acid on his face". The fact is, you're saying: "That's a TERRIBLE thing to do to a human being!" while at the same time allowing her to do that to another human being. If you can't understand the problem with that I don't know what to tell you. Who says nobody deserves this type of punishment? You? Human rights, don't make me laugh. Who chose these rights again? If he threw acid into a girl face are you honestly just going to let him sit in jail? It's called a punishment, and it's not a bad thing. I doubt people will be murdering/throwing acid into peoples eyes if they realize they're going to get the same punishment back. No, they'll still do it because they'll think they won't get caught. Odds are a few people will be afraid of the State's retribution so they won't do whatever, but that'd be completely counterbalanced by the fact that the State is barbaric as hell. In the end, more people get butchered. No.. say when they do catch someone, and they do the thing this lady is about to do, they might actually figure out that they aren't invincible and actually may get caught, and they wont do such a crazy thing. The people that say send him to jail and let him have a fair trail are the ones who think we can live in a perfect world and everyone is great inside. Truth is, most people that come out of prison are doing the same things that got them their, they haven't changed. Many assumptions that seem wrong. People don't learn much from other people's mistakes, I think that's pretty much understood by most. You've never been to China, have you? I'll stop now since you really aren't addressing my points anymore. Why would I address assumptions? :/ Sorry man I can't. You just assume things and bring no data to support it. You might as well tell me you believe in unicorns and I can't disprove it. Well, in previous threads he has stated things like that he wants to put gay people in prison until they "straighten" out. So him believing in unicorns wouldnt exactly surprise me. But yeah, if your gonna make such statements you really need to bring data... Yeah lets just use personal attacks!
|
|
|
On May 14 2011 08:49 kerpal wrote:...makes the whole world blind -gandhi
Not unless you don't take an eye to begin with? If anything eye for an eye is a deterrent.
The punishment is actually too lenient. He should be jailed/fined in addition to this, or does not deserve sedation (she didn't receive it during her ordeal.)
|
On May 15 2011 05:39 zeru wrote: The reason is that we developed more modern and civil ways to deal with crime, not because a law is old...
But have we really? It looks to me that our way is great in theory, punish them some with isolation, keep them away for a while and help teach them how to behave (all that rehabilitation is supposed to be included here). But practice is what shows the real face of humanity, we don't give a shit, most of us, lock them out of sight and let them rot. Reality is we haven't evolved much and I wonder if there weren't people preaching these rehabilitation ideas thousands of years ago and getting ignored.
Maybe in a few generations but ask your parents and grandparents what they think, should they be taxed more to help criminals become citizens? Who cares if the criminal made one mistake, he has to pay for the rest of his life because lower taxes are more important (going to say that for some countries this might not be true but for most ...).
|
The reason is that we developed more modern and civil ways to deal with crime, not because a law is old...
Modern and civil ways. Frankly, our civil way to deal with crime is to throw them in jail at cost to society because we can't kill them, thats not civil. Responding to uncivilness with civilness is pointless, and has negative consequences to society and eye for an eye is a much more easy way to deal with crime. Easy, not civil. Does it work 100%? No. But it works. I just think jail has much larger consequences to society as a whole.
|
On May 15 2011 05:46 Blurio wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 05:39 BlackJack wrote:On May 15 2011 05:15 zeru wrote:On May 15 2011 05:11 BlackJack wrote:On May 15 2011 05:04 zeru wrote:On May 15 2011 04:55 DatBoiRijad wrote:On May 15 2011 04:53 Gigaudas wrote: "An eye for an eye" - imagine the damage this sentence has done to humanity.
She is no better than he is. Please explain how an eye for an eye is wrong? So we should just let people do what ever they want, but treat them fairly if they get caught? Because lex talionis and code of hammurabi something we in the modern world have somewhat abandoned, and invented new and better ways as far as i know. The only countries still using those laws are muslim countries which still use sharia. That doesn't answer his question at all, it just says "our way is better  " That seems to be the bulk of arguments that oppose this. Just a whole lot of "that's just wrong!" "retribution is just wrong" "An eye for an eye is just wrong" etc. I find this discussion to be very similar to abortion debates where both sides are convinced that their way is the "right way" when there's really no way to prove your sense of morality is superior to another person's. They are just opinions.. Well, i'd say there's a pretty damn good reason we moved away from 3500 year old laws. And yeah, something like this will always be a clash of opinions i guess, not a discussion. Her throwing acid in his eyes makes her just as bad as him though, imo. So you must not enjoy films like Kill Bill, Oldboy, Memento, Leon the Professional, etc. You have nobody to root for since Uma Thurman's character is just as evil as Bill I'm watching movies just for the heck of it. I'm not rooting for anyone. Are you like the stereotypical black people in the cinema, always screaming at the screen?
Wow, I feel bad for you if you get so little joy from movies that you only watch them for the heck of it.
|
On May 14 2011 08:49 kerpal wrote:...makes the whole world blind -gandhi and if you dont do anything you are just walked all over, so i'd say it depends on the situation. not that im saying ghandi is saying anything thats wrong, its a nice thing to aspire to.
|
|
|
|
|
|