|
Show nested quote +On August 29 2010 08:26 Hidden_MotiveS wrote: Thread is too theoretical for my taste. Has anarcho-capitalism, whatever this political system is, ever worked before? If not, has anyone tried it?
some other time the OP of this thread wrote (it's on page 2)http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_anarchist_communitiesNone of them were really capitalistic though imo. I like the american wild west example best, it's a complete myth that it was a lawless land. Less homicides than the eastern part at least. I'm no empiricist so I'll stop there though. Well people have stated that the lawless west wasn't really lawless and that it did take on a form of government spontaneously so it did not last. Therefore I would argue that the lawless west did not sustain anarchy and therefore did not work.
The time era and environment are also significantly different from what we have today.
I checked out the last three anarchistic societies listed on wikipedia since all of the other ones ceased to exist.
The first: Freetown Christiania Seems like it won't last as the local dutch government and the people nearby are pushing so hard for its removal. Any greater power will exert influence on a lesser one.
The second: Zapatista Autonomous Municipalities Does not sound so bad.
The assemblies and councils serve not as traditional governing bodies but as instruments of the people to provide medicine, education, food, and other essentials. The "laws" passed by the Good Government Councils are not enforced with policemen and prisons, but in a way that respects "criminals" as members of the community. For example, it was decided to ban alcohol and drugs,[16] due to their nefarious influence on Indians in the past (though alcohol/drug prohibition is considered in conflict with anarchist principles). Violation of this law is surprisingly rare; those who do may be required, for example, to help build something their community needs. Some anarchists believe this to be a decentralized, non-authoritarian style similar to what they advocate, having always loathed prisons, police power, and capital punishment.
The third Abahlali baseMjondolo: South Africa Says that the location is a constant violent struggle. Someone will probably assume control soon enough.
You say you are not an empiricist. I am quite the opposite. As long as something has been proven not to work time and again, I don't believe that it will work any time soon. Perhaps in a thousand years when society has evolved enough to be completely different from what it is today, an anarcho-capitalistic society of people could exist on a large scale.
It'd have to be a future very different from the starcraft one though.
|
On August 31 2010 11:39 Badjas wrote:Show nested quote +On August 31 2010 11:06 Yurebis wrote:On August 31 2010 10:57 Badjas wrote:On August 31 2010 10:38 Yurebis wrote:On August 31 2010 09:31 Badjas wrote:On August 31 2010 08:40 Yurebis wrote:On August 31 2010 07:23 Badjas wrote:On August 31 2010 05:46 Yurebis wrote:On August 30 2010 23:19 silynxer wrote: You call it presupposed authority i call it clever marketing. Can you see the fraud then? Does your question imply that you agree with the original analogy he made? No, I don't, but if you see the marketing, I suspected you could see the lies as well. But I was wrong I suppose. Can you then provide an actual argument against the analogy? Antagonizing governments doesn't get you there. Is it marketing for me to punch you in the nose and require ten bucks? Is it marketing for the mafia to extort protection money from a business? No, it's just coercion. That makes no sense. What they say or justify it with may be marketing, but the acts themselves aren't marketing. They're physical aggression or threats thereof. I was referring to the start of this little bit, being here. (Reading back I see I wasn't being clear on that, sorry) Okay, well, whether they have good marketing or not is irrelevant to it's coercive practices, and the coercive practices are fully defined in property rights theory. You can choose not to respect a certain property rights theory, but it's inconsistent to both disrespect property rights, and want property rights for yourself. It is also inconsistent by the part of the state to claim that they're protecting property rights, but necessarily intruding them for taxation, regulation, etc. You can call it good marketing, and I see why, but I disagree, merely because the act, for me, is very clearly coercive. I think the original message had nothing to do with property rights or marketing. (that was a follow-up on some argumentation). If I read it correctly, it equates current government to a company that could arise in the environment that ancap provides. I see various people arguing this (I think I mentioned something likewise, less precise) in various forms, but can you give a really easy to follow transparent argument that shows that such a mega-conglomeration could not come to fruition? If it's the brand which has bought land, raised buildings, and have people move over, there's absolutely nothing stopping that, and I would expect the contracts to be very extent and detailed on how the company promises to run the city or town, but in the end, it's a choice by the tenant to move in to such a place.
If it's the "I own all land now mwhahaha" brand, I can't say it can't happen either, however knowing that it can happen is already half the way to prevent it from happening. The right question to ask, in ancap, is not just "can it happen", but "how can we prevent the undesirable from happening" (most preferably without violence). Well, the main companies that would be able to become a state are the PDAs, who have most of the guns and weaponry. Perhaps private armies too, circumstantially formed to defend against foreign invasion. But mainly PDAs, because they already have similar infrastructures of the today's police force, so they're close by the residents, and they arguably have the means to do something like that.
Well, what can the people in ancap do to stop a PDA from becoming too big, and giving it the chance to become a state again? I can think of many things. 1-Account for that risk by not necessarily picking always the cheapest and largest PDA, but the second best, third, fourth, etc. 2-Require of the insurance agencies or other third parties some sort of oversight over the PDAs (it will come at a cost, of course, everything does lol) 3-Require less entangling contracts, allowing you to immediately quit your membership with the PDA (or insurance->PDA, however the model is), whenever you see something funny. (comes at a greater premium or at a penalty) 4-Be better prepared yourself, as an individual and in your community, to react to such a possibility, arming yourself, making a local militia (which already exist btw) 5-Even if it becomes a state, just resist as much as it's feasible. The rogue PDA runs at a loss if the people resist, like don't pay taxes, civil disobedience (lol), just make their work suck. Don't really need to be violent back, though of course if they shoot first there's nothing you can do but fight back. Anyway, it will eventually become bankrupt. It will fuck up the entire society, but it will go down with it. That goes for foreign powers too.
Since this is completely open information, and the PDAs themselves aren't dumb, I think it will be very unlikely that they will ever turn society back into a state again. Even if people just forget that it's possible for them to do so, the moment they do, it will resurface. It has to. Well, if it won't, then we're fucked, but... uh.. knowing that we may forget... there may be a way not to? Heh.
|
On August 31 2010 11:41 jgad wrote: If there is one thing I've learned as an anarcho-capitalist, it's that it's not worth debating with other people about anarcho-capitalism. Society is not ready for it. Until states fall apart under their own weight it won't happen - like asking an addict to quit heroin. There is no rational argument you can make that will make them change their mind. They just have to hit rock bottom first. We're not there yet. I'm being patient. :D
|
On August 31 2010 12:09 Adila wrote: The more I read, the more I believe this is unfeasible without there being a global catastrophe of some kind that eliminates all the states ability to function and a drastic drop in population. It would need a reset of thousands of years of history and behavior that have been ingrained into our psyche.
Even then, it is debatable whether or not people would behave in a way that would support this or just revert back to the basics that start the formation of governments/states.
The only other possibility is to have like-minded people settle another planet to have it work on a large-scale basis. Well, if you believe in free markets, then it has to follow that the state is pretty bad at everything. And that includes preserving itself, so, it's not a stretch to say that the state may trip on it's own foot; it has happened so many times in history. The question is indeed like you said, whether people are ready for it, and don't just stand around confused and waiting for a new ruler.
Though it's not a complicated idea.. not at all. It may be complicated if you want to understand the entire economy, of course, that's biologically impossible for any single individual, but as far as generalities go, if even a dumbass troll idiot retarded OP like me can understand it, I think society can be ready in under 100 years easily. Especially at the velocities the flow of information is going.
|
sounds impossible, I think its way easier to have a UED than that
|
On August 31 2010 12:27 Yurebis wrote:Show nested quote +On August 31 2010 12:09 Adila wrote: The more I read, the more I believe this is unfeasible without there being a global catastrophe of some kind that eliminates all the states ability to function and a drastic drop in population. It would need a reset of thousands of years of history and behavior that have been ingrained into our psyche.
Even then, it is debatable whether or not people would behave in a way that would support this or just revert back to the basics that start the formation of governments/states.
The only other possibility is to have like-minded people settle another planet to have it work on a large-scale basis. Well, if you believe in free markets, then it has to follow that the state is pretty bad at everything. And that includes preserving itself, so, it's not a stretch to say that the state may trip on it's own foot; it has happened so many times in history. The question is indeed like you said, whether people are ready for it, and don't just stand around confused and waiting for a new ruler. Though it's not a complicated idea.. not at all. It may be complicated if you want to understand the entire economy, of course, that's biologically impossible for any single individual, but as far as generalities go, if even a dumbass troll idiot retarded OP like me can understand it, I think society can be ready in under 100 years easily. Especially at the velocities the flow of information is going.
There's more than 1 society on Earth though. You would, at the very least, need Russia and China on board. Quite frankly, I don't believe those societies are anywhere near capable of adapting this idea, especially China.
|
On August 31 2010 11:58 Yurebis wrote:Show nested quote +On August 31 2010 11:12 Sultan.P wrote:On August 31 2010 10:27 Yurebis wrote:
Actually, that's more like anarcho-communism or anarcho-syndicalism. Anarcho-capitalism retains all private functions that exist today, and creates new ones where the state didn't allow competition for.
You have to define your ideology. Clearly please. You can't just go rambling random things as it does not make sense. Since I pulled the definition from wikipedia, and you are saying it is incorrect. Explain yourself more clearly than what you just put there. No, the wikipedia version is good. Sorry, I should have closed the quotes where it mattered I was answering to this by you: I'm imagining some hippie idea where everyone pitches in for the defense of the community.In regards to warlords taking over, there is no reason why the defense agencies that we already pay today can't keep being paid voluntarily if they deem to be necessary. It would probably be even better of course, because we (the people who want to pay for it) would be paying the market price, not a coercive monopolist price, which is the one overpriced today. Show nested quote +On August 31 2010 11:12 Sultan.P wrote:The cops as they are today could very well just be privatized, and if they're efficient enough that no demand for competition arises, then it could be exactly the same as is. The multi-trillion military industrial complex would probably be liquidated, but that's not to say people can't organize and hire mercenaries or armies with their own money. If an invasion from a foreign power is imminent, then I don't see why people wouldn't be up to it, just like people voluntarily join the army in times of distress. No drafts would be legal of course, as that's just slavery. When I read this, all I could think about how I hope I'm not wasting my time in this tread, as I enjoy a good exchange of ideas. My argument addresses something completely different then what you are talking about. I am saying that the theory fails because the person that would end up calling the shots would be the most ruthless and blood thirsty "mercenary," or whatever you want to call it. Your response addresses nothing of what I am talking about. How can you quote my argument and just write random things that make no sense to what I am talking about. Multi-trillion military industrial complex? Draft is slavery? Stay on point man! Well, there are several reasons why this wouldn't happen. First of all, who would pay him, for how much, and how much do you think he could make by savaging ancap land? This of course depends on the strength that the free marketeers have in defending themselves. In a reactionary way 1- Mercenaries are a minority. 2- Mercenaries are in town, killing and looting. 3- Demand for defense increases as the mercenaries are clearly seen as unjustified, and people notice they would be better off without them. 4- Defense will be bought, as soon as possible, to stop the mercenaries. And in a pro-active way 1-Mercenaries are an increasingly possible threat 2-Demand for defense increases 3-Defense will be bought, as much as people evaluate the safety is worth
Although I was extremely critical of your posts early in this thread, I must admit you take many of these criticisms rather reasonably. However in this specific post I think you are underestimating the amount of organization and resources that are needed to defend a country from outside aggressors.
Do you think that in world war 2 era united states, an anarcho-capitalist society would be able to collaborate their effects on a project of the proportion to lets say, the Manhattan project? People aren't battling and looting in towns with shotguns and pistols during a war anymore. Countries have entire airforces and weapons capable of instantly destroying a city in a split second. Do you really think an anarcho-capitalist society would be pro active enough to be able to deal with such a threat? Are there going to be groups willing enough to dedicate trillions of dollars along with years of some of the hardest, most technologically advanced man labor there is?
An anarcho-capitalist society fuels itself on the production of capital. Sure a war can actually improve the economy; WW II put enough people to work to get us out of a depression. Now things have changed a lot since the 40's and as military technology has advanced, the cost for maintaining a pro-active armed force has increased dramatically. The arms race forced us to dedicate trillions of dollars to keeping an arsenal of ready-to-go weapons in surplus. Keeping an armed force up to par with today's technological standards is a giagantic vaccum of capitial, essentially going against everything the ano-cap theory stands for.
Now before I sound like some war-hungry idiot, I'll agree with you before you even have to say it; we waste a lot of money on a military budget. I'll go as far as to say this is probably the single most wasteful part of our countries finances besides maybe our health care system (lol I can see you shaking your head as you read this right now). Regardless, townspeople becoming up in arms against a country with fighter jets raining missiles down on our cities from miles in the sky is not going to cut it. Simply not enough organization and resources.
So I want you to at least answer one question directly and with an explanation if you could please. Do you think an anarcho-capitalist society could band together in WW II era USA, to create something on the scale of the Manhattan Project?
|
On August 31 2010 12:22 Yurebis wrote:+ Show Spoiler +On August 31 2010 11:39 Badjas wrote:Show nested quote +On August 31 2010 11:06 Yurebis wrote:On August 31 2010 10:57 Badjas wrote:On August 31 2010 10:38 Yurebis wrote:On August 31 2010 09:31 Badjas wrote:On August 31 2010 08:40 Yurebis wrote:On August 31 2010 07:23 Badjas wrote:On August 31 2010 05:46 Yurebis wrote:On August 30 2010 23:19 silynxer wrote: You call it presupposed authority i call it clever marketing. Can you see the fraud then? Does your question imply that you agree with the original analogy he made? No, I don't, but if you see the marketing, I suspected you could see the lies as well. But I was wrong I suppose. Can you then provide an actual argument against the analogy? Antagonizing governments doesn't get you there. Is it marketing for me to punch you in the nose and require ten bucks? Is it marketing for the mafia to extort protection money from a business? No, it's just coercion. That makes no sense. What they say or justify it with may be marketing, but the acts themselves aren't marketing. They're physical aggression or threats thereof. I was referring to the start of this little bit, being here. (Reading back I see I wasn't being clear on that, sorry) Okay, well, whether they have good marketing or not is irrelevant to it's coercive practices, and the coercive practices are fully defined in property rights theory. You can choose not to respect a certain property rights theory, but it's inconsistent to both disrespect property rights, and want property rights for yourself. It is also inconsistent by the part of the state to claim that they're protecting property rights, but necessarily intruding them for taxation, regulation, etc. You can call it good marketing, and I see why, but I disagree, merely because the act, for me, is very clearly coercive. I think the original message had nothing to do with property rights or marketing. (that was a follow-up on some argumentation). If I read it correctly, it equates current government to a company that could arise in the environment that ancap provides. I see various people arguing this (I think I mentioned something likewise, less precise) in various forms, but can you give a really easy to follow transparent argument that shows that such a mega-conglomeration could not come to fruition? If it's the brand which has bought land, raised buildings, and have people move over, there's absolutely nothing stopping that, and I would expect the contracts to be very extent and detailed on how the company promises to run the city or town, but in the end, it's a choice by the tenant to move in to such a place. If it's the "I own all land now mwhahaha" brand, I can't say it can't happen either, however knowing that it can happen is already half the way to prevent it from happening. The right question to ask, in ancap, is not just "can it happen", but "how can we prevent the undesirable from happening" (most preferably without violence). Well, the main companies that would be able to become a state are the PDAs, who have most of the guns and weaponry. Perhaps private armies too, circumstantially formed to defend against foreign invasion. But mainly PDAs, because they already have similar infrastructures of the today's police force, so they're close by the residents, and they arguably have the means to do something like that. Well, what can the people in ancap do to stop a PDA from becoming too big, and giving it the chance to become a state again? I can think of many things. 1-Account for that risk by not necessarily picking always the cheapest and largest PDA, but the second best, third, fourth, etc. 2-Require of the insurance agencies or other third parties some sort of oversight over the PDAs (it will come at a cost, of course, everything does lol) 3-Require less entangling contracts, allowing you to immediately quit your membership with the PDA (or insurance->PDA, however the model is), whenever you see something funny. (comes at a greater premium or at a penalty) 4-Be better prepared yourself, as an individual and in your community, to react to such a possibility, arming yourself, making a local militia (which already exist btw) 5-Even if it becomes a state, just resist as much as it's feasible. The rogue PDA runs at a loss if the people resist, like don't pay taxes, civil disobedience (lol), just make their work suck. Don't really need to be violent back, though of course if they shoot first there's nothing you can do but fight back. Anyway, it will eventually become bankrupt. It will fuck up the entire society, but it will go down with it. That goes for foreign powers too. Since this is completely open information, and the PDAs themselves aren't dumb, I think it will be very unlikely that they will ever turn society back into a state again. Even if people just forget that it's possible for them to do so, the moment they do, it will resurface. It has to. Well, if it won't, then we're fucked, but... uh.. knowing that we may forget... there may be a way not to? Heh. Thanks for laying it out. I find that you assume quite a lot, and towards favoring ancap without any basis really. I know that it might work that way and could be stable. But color me skeptical of the human race. The biggest threat I see is in conglomeration, monopoly forming and cartels. Greed. PDA's will work for money and they will work for those with a huge accumulation of wealth/power. Others have mentioned this a lot in this thread already. I find it not believable that anything but an institute explicitly responsible towards the people, can deal with these issues. A big pillar in today's society, and what also would be for the ancap society from the examples you mention, is the freedom of information. If people know wrongs, they can take action. Many governments work too much in secrecy, I'm sure you'll agree on that. But how does ancap provide a guarantee for freedom of information, and how can information manipulation be battled? Skeptical me again saying that you can't. But these arguments are of course only really verifiable in a real life situation that would involve at least a million people. (edit typo's)
|
Anyone who's posting here claiming that the state is bad has to contend with the powerful argument in THIS IMAGE. It strikes me as intellectually arrogant to simply state that these institutions could be replaced without real knowledge of the consequences. Uncertainty is a powerful force--- yesterday an oil rig in the Gulf of Mexico simply explodes and causes an environmental disaster, and tomorrow who knows? It's hardly a conservative position to suggest that the impact of "replacing the state" with an anarcho-capitalist (u/dis)topia could result in just about anything and no one here knows what that would be.
|
On August 31 2010 10:54 Yurebis wrote:Show nested quote +On August 31 2010 10:02 Myrkul wrote: I'm afraid I'm not very well educated on the subject, and my English is a bit lacking, especially the spelling, but I'll do my best.
I'm going to use a hypothetical example to illustrate my point. It's a known fact in economics that transport plays a vital role in the reproduction cycle. Raw resources need to be transported to facilities were goods will be made out of them, which in turn need to be transported to warehouses etc, and eventually to the consumer. Thus the more advanced transport is, the more efficient the economy is. Now this is a good reason to build massive highways that for example make a huge grid in the US, or any other country. Now, to make the grid optimal in terms of cost-efficiency requires the work of very educated people, advanced mathematics, huge amounts of collected data on the needs of transport in the area in question, well educated engineers, lots of labor etc.
Now the first thing that puzzles me is how would this Ancap society even have high education, university's etc.. required for the job. These things obviously cost alot of money, but in the eyes of your average joe serve no real purpose. Or atleast cost more than they should, which tends to be the opinion of everybody about the things they don't really understand. From what I understand nobody in this soceity gives his capital to anything he does not want to, so given that a vast majority of today's population are not economists, presumably they would say something along the lines of "I manage with the current roads just fine thank you, your fancy highway that goes to places I've never even heard of, nor have the need to travel to doesn't interest me". So I presume you would have to have people walking around and explaining the basics of the economics, that the better the roads are the cheaper you get your goods and so on. But then who would pay these people to do that, who would justify their existence to your average joe? It seems to me that everyone in this Ancap soceity would have to be very well educated in every field of human research for it to be efficient. Otherwise it looks to me like everyone just looks after himself and very capital intensive long-run return on investment projects (like science) would never be aproved.
I don't really understand how you can call something like collecting funds(taxes) and spending it on something like subatomic particle research "stealing". The necessity or desirability of a service to you or to others in your perspective is no justification that they have to be coercively organized in any central way. Many things depend on many things in the market, and yet the companies that are depended on by others could fall the very next day. What happens if the metallurgy goes broke? Then the engineering firms, car industries, would all go broke too? What happens if the milkman had a heart attack, and no milk was delivered for a day? What if, what if... So many things could happen that it does kind of scare you, because we are indeed in a very interconnected and interdependent, highly specialized market. But coercion, you have to understand, would only make things worse. A central planner, coercing a population to pay for a certain project or business model, and not allowing others to present what could be a better answer, will always lead to more inefficiencies than if the market were able to operate on it's own. Because the thousands of entrepreneurs already did and constantly ask themselves the questions which you too fear. They know their business best than anyone else, because they have all the incentives and market inputs to do so. Government on the other hand, has neither appropriate incentives, nor can it even know what the prices of its services should be, apart from emulating signals from elsewhere and crossing their fingers. The market of higher education today IS the next bubble, and it costs a lot exactly because it is inflated. People are getting diplomas for jobs that won't exist, because again, the government has fiddled with student loans, and people are going to college with near 0 liability, at 0 initial cost, so yeah. Roads can also exist privately. Again, just because the state has built them coercively, doesn't mean they can't be built voluntarily, and I believe they would be not only cheaper but also free of externalities, such as destroying people's property that are on the way... and THEN paying them a fraction of what it was worth. Addressing the last sentence: I could just as well say "I don't really understand how can you call something like 'me grabbing money from your wallet' and spending on something like a new computer for myself 'stealing'". It is stealing, plainly because if it wasn't, then no taxes are needed, people would just donate to the government what they think is due. Or even better, people could buy only those services they want. Which is what I've been advocating all this thread...
I am not satisfied with your answer, but unfortunately I don't have time right now, and I'm going out of town till the end of the week and I won't have any internet access probably, and by that time this thread will probably be dead, which is a shame. Oh well thanks Yurebis for bringing to my attention an interesting topic, it's always good to question things one takes for granted.
|
Voluntarily assemble... governing systems are not about voluntarism, it's about forcing everyone in
But it's ok I mean, I've made way more strawmen throughout this thread than you could ever fit in a post. It would hit the character limit LOL. ...Is there even a character limit?
The concept of choice only arises out of the lack of solidarity. Or in capitalistic terms, the lack of monopoly. If we assume that humanity will always, and should always develop existing infrastructure, and will always form infrastructures of cooperation, then after sufficient development and sufficient solidarity, both which are completely inevitable as time progresses (though it can be slowed), then you end up with a state, unless you have a governing body to prevent it, which does not exist in an ancap.
If people have moved in, they accepted rent conditions If you just claimed to own everything, then it's a fraud, and it's a state.
I'm not talking about a single landowner (which could easily occur fyi), I'm talking about a monopoly of security companies/other crucial infrastructure companies normally left to the government,
Welp, if teared down for the right reasons, aka understanding of private property, I doubt it would come back up, just like an understanding of "civil liberties" and partial individual rights won't allow for slavery to come back up.
It wouldn't be impossible of course, but it would take quite the deterioration, multiple times worse that the deterioration of the constitutional republic of the USA.
You've already set up a structure for the state to "come back" in the form of private companies. You don't need a forced takeover of "private property" for a state to emerge. Let me ask you a question, what is the difference between a region with only one or two private infrastructural companies and a state?
On August 31 2010 09:12 Half wrote: Show nested quote + So what? I'm incompatible with you right now. Is there anything bad going on? I'm against coercion, not incompatibility. If I wanted compatibility I would be for a state to kill and imprison all that disagree with its rule. But I don't think that's the way to go. Aggressing the population to save it from aggression, is kiiiind of incompatible, lol.
Thats not what we I mean, and so far, we haven't demonstrated ourselves incompatible. I'm talking about physical incompatibilities. Like if I want X law, and you don't, a physcal incompatibility. However the point is irrelevant now because the reason why I made the example is to demonstrate why people will tend to organize by common/compatible interests, which you already agreed to.
Oh ok, a dispute over capital, property. Well I believe any dispute can be settled in court, before the need of a gun. And most generally people are able to deter eachother from aggression by having some retaliatory force on their own.
The state of course, only diminishes both the ability of all disputes from being taken to court (by having shitty laws that imprison even victimless crime offenders), and reduces the ability for each person to best defend themselves through taxation and a socialized police force.
Thats not really what I meant, but as I said, its irrelevant now as it was just an example to prove a point we've reached a mutual consensus on.
But um...you said private courts earlier. Whos private court do we go to????? lol.
Latent racism, yeah. But not deal-breaking. People aren't like that anymore. "Sorry, I don't sell cars to blacks". heh :/ . Most establishments in the US have no problem getting any customer of any race, as long as they pay, IMO.
For someone who isn't an empiricist, your fixating awfully hard on specifics. My point behind racism is to illustrate a simple point-The State forces cooperation upon people who would not otherwise cooperate. You argue that these people are only behaving as is because of the state, but I'd argue that the forced requisite by the state to "share" is all thats keeping them from fragmenting.
Again, it is anarcho-capitalism. Not the conventional definition of anarchy, aka, chaos. That would indeed be kind of silly. "Why chaos can't work?". Well, I think the definition pretty much covers that it's a non-working, purposeless state.
Their is absolutely no difference between an Ancap and a Anarchy on an theoretical level. By definition, there cannot be. You either have an ancap, or have anarchy. It just depends on the environment in which the state is dissolved. In principal, they are one and the same.
And structures of organization exist on all levels. Pure Anarchy is like everyone living in the woods with no human contact. We no shit that wouldn't work, if not else, theres not enough room lol. Anarchy usually is limiting this to a organizational structures on the scale of small voluntary tribes, while ancap limits this to company like structures. The nation state of course, would be the second largest form of organization, one step below world government.
The idea of Anarchy, of any form, is silly for this reason. The desire to organize and expand is one of the only human attributes present throughout history. Anarchy's, of any form, point towards a level of organization, and say "STOP THERE". Why? Why would it "stop there"? Because people understand "private property"?
You argue that there should be choice among companies, a primary distinguishment between that statism, but you forget to account for limited resources. There is only so many customers, so many resources, to allow for so many infrastructural companies on a large scale (pmcs, etc). And in the end, you've certainly broken down the institution of state into many small pieces, but states nonetheless.
Well, there are several reasons why this wouldn't happen. First of all, who would pay him, for how much, and how much do you think he could make by savaging ancap land? This of course depends on the strength that the free marketeers have in defending themselves. In a reactionary way
1- Mercenaries are a minority. 2- Mercenaries are in town, killing and looting. 3- Demand for defense increases as the mercenaries are clearly seen as unjustified, and people notice they would be better off without them. 4- Defense will be bought, as soon as possible, to stop the mercenaries.
And in a pro-active way
1-Mercenaries are an increasingly possible threat 2-Demand for defense increases 3-Defense will be bought, as much as people evaluate the safety is worth
This kinda shows you have a misconception of how exactly defense works in this world. As much as the US wastes on defense, its probably, in the end, actually made huge economic progress because of it. Defense is preemptory. A billion spent on prevention a day beats 2 billion spent on defense, because that 2 billion comes with it economic damage.
There was a very real chance the cold war would have erupted had the US not "wasted" trillions of dollars on defense research and paramilitary operations throughout the "cold war". And had a non-nuclear cold war occured, the world economy would have suffered greater damage and growth would have been more greatly slowed then if the US simply had "wasted" this money on defense that was not used.
|
Chiming in to say that further discussion isn't going to lead to anything actionable, as we've already strayed far away from empiricism, scholarship, and on the whole, reality.
|
Without any sort of environmental regulation, what's to stop companies from spewing chemicals into the air and the oceans? Libertarians often say all property being private is enough to stop pollution but how do you privatize the air and the oceans?
I can envisage how this kind of world would be amazing for rich people- they could buy up all the the parks, national parks and beaches and prevent the 'plebes' from having access to them and their companies could pollute the air and oceans with impunity. For others else it wouldn't necessarily be so great though. There would be no more free libraries and those without enough money for healthcare would be dying in the streets. 5 year-olds from poor backgrounds would be putting in 14-hour days in sweat shops until they drop dead. Workers could try to go on strike to get some rights but risk being slaughtered by the private armies of the billionaires they work for.
All you would be doing by abolishing government is creating a vacuum of power that has to be filled. Once the billionaires become powerful enough society would basically revert to being a feudal serfdom until the serfs have had enough and finally rebel and bring back a some form of democratic government.
Yes, this is speculation but so it's also speculation when the libertatians/ ancaps/ whatever try to tell us that without any government and with corporations in total control the world would be some kind of utopia.
|
On August 31 2010 17:04 Tuneful wrote: Chiming in to say that further discussion isn't going to lead to anything actionable, as we've already strayed far away from empiricism, scholarship, and on the whole, reality.
Applicability to reality has never been the strong point of anarcho-anything, but that doesn't stop its legions of adherents from singing its praises to high heaven regardless.
|
On August 31 2010 08:40 dvide wrote:
Seriously what is it with your hang up on this? I know you think you're being really clever here, but you're just being really annoying.
I think the "hang up" results from the special pleading which you and Yurebis constantly show. You equate the state with coercion and say the fact that you can simply move to another country with different terms is somehow invalid, because all states are illegitimate. But at the same time, in an anarcho-capitalistic society, where all land is owned by other people/companies, whenever I want to "rent" a space of living somewhere, then this constitutes a valid choice, since if I don't want to move to the land of somebody, I just go to somebody else. But what if none of the offered terms are acceptable to me? Well, then it's my (or Yurebis famous "nobody's") fault and I can at least chose to die ... the fact that none of the terms that different states have to offer are acceptable to you, however, is the states' fault ... this does not compute.
|
On August 31 2010 13:18 kidcrash wrote:Sure a war can actually improve the economy; WW II put enough people to work to get us out of a depression.
Don't kid yourself - there is one and ONLY one way to profit from war and that is to sell supplies to BOTH sides of the war. This is how the US got rich during WWII, not because of some magical pseudo-economic notion that paying people to build bombs makes them richer and happier people. Where's the profit? Think about it.
|
Longest troll thread on TL I've seen in a while, 4/10 though because it's as boring as dead moths.
|
On August 31 2010 19:11 MiraMax wrote: I think the "hang up" results from the special pleading which you and Yurebis constantly show. You equate the state with coercion and say the fact that you can simply move to another country with different terms is somehow invalid, because all states are illegitimate. I don't equate the state with coercion alone, but with the false meme that they have moral right to use coercion. I've attempted to make this distinction many, many times. But hey, if you want to be a serf and think that your government owns the entire Deutschland legitimately somehow, and that you just rent it from the elites running your country, then your rent analogy would actually hold some water. But nobody has yet explained to me how this legitimacy came into being. Voting is it? How did the government come to acquire the land? Called dibs did they?
And if you want to say oh, well, the government is just "the people", so it's really just the people who own the Deutschland. Well, why would it stop at the Deutschland? Those borders are completely arbitrary. And even in the UK where the borders are arguably not completely arbitrary (because it's an island), I live near Manchester which is to the north of England. What possible claim do I have to a collective share of a plot of land in Cornwall? It doesn't make any sense. I've never even been to Cornwall. I just receive that collective share of the land in Cornwall because I happened to be born in the UK, so now I have the legitimacy to charge rent for it through the machinery of the democratic state? No. What's more, I only receive my share when I am 18 because obviously it doesn't make sense to receive it when I am 5. What are you going to do, allow toddlers to vote? But why 18? Is that written into the moral fabric of reality? More arbitrary magic.
Legitimate ownership accrues to individuals through original appropriation or voluntary trade.
But what if none of the offered terms are acceptable to me? Well, then it's my (or Yurebis famous "nobody's") fault and I can at least chose to die ... the fact that none of the terms that different states have to offer are acceptable to you, however, is the states' fault ... this does not compute.
This is just a nonsense scare scenario. Ohmigads what if I can't afford to live anywhere?! It's like asking what if I couldn't afford food? Well, food is pretty cheap right? People are willing to sell food for very low prices and they still make decent profit off of it. And if you still think you'd be better off growing your own food instead of buying it, then go do it. Nobody is stopping you (except the government of course). But inarguably at least you have a much greater opportunity today to get your food, and much more varied food at that.
Plus it would be much easier to earn a living. Your money would have greater purchasing power, and there wouldn't be bullshit regulations in place stopping you from creating your own florist business, or getting a job cutting hair or whatever it is that you want to do with your life. Food will be even cheaper because people will be that much wealthier.
But how do states supposedly solve this problem? Wouldn't there be drastically more land options available to you if entire continents were not owned by relatively few elites, but instead only the land that is being made use of was owned by the individuals making use of it? Why is it so much better that a few elites are able to charge monopoly rates for land because they called dibs, rather than having competitive prices? I don't understand. Cheap land gives you more opportunity than expensive land. But even then, you can always go into the wilderness and build a house there and farm for your food, or hunt for your food. But saying the same thing to us is just retarded, because the entire question is whether or not the government legitimately owns the land in the first place. You claim they do, so I'd like to know how they acquired it.
|
On August 31 2010 12:56 D10 wrote: sounds impossible, I think its way easier to have a UED than that Why.
|
A fellow mises.org comrade? All the best at debate here
|
|
|
|
|
|