On September 26 2026 17:15 JimmyJRaynor wrote: Rob Pardo left in 2014 whining about how big teams and ATVI bureaucracy made the game making process labourious drudgery.
I mean, to be fair, ATVI bureaucracy does make the game making process laborious drudgery.
How excited do you think developers are to make Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 57?
I worked at Activision for ten years so I can tell you: not very.
Pardo later proclaimed "making games should be as fun as playing games".
Well, this is mostly wrong. Making games, the actual part of coding, tweaking and adding art and sound assets, testing, etc, is dull and not fun at all.
The fun part is at the beginning, when you're brainstorming new ideas for fun games, and messing around with prototypes. But sadly that's about 1% of the overall process.
Well, I don't think Pardo is having very much fun because he left Blizzard 12 years ago and he has not made a game.
But he's close! They are still doing private testing, but maybe open beta testing is around the corner? Maybe? Assuming the money is about to run out, it had better be.
Unfortunately for Rob, the game looks really generic and the gameplay loop seems kinda meh. I think they are delaying the game as long as possible because they know the launch will be a disaster.
On September 26 2026 17:15 JimmyJRaynor wrote: Fascinating to see how Rob Pardo, Mike Morhaime, David Kim, and various Blizzard alum did after leaving.
Rob Pardo left in 2014 whining about how big teams and ATVI bureaucracy made the game making process labourious drudgery.
Pardo later proclaimed "making games should be as fun as playing games".
Well, I don't think Pardo is having very much fun because he left Blizzard 12 years ago and he has not made a game.
The issue always feels like long production time results in your early ideas being obsolete and wanting to go back to redo the first 2 years of work, which can be an endless loop. Creatively it's a good thing because you are learning what your game or any creative project should be, but it's obviously expensive and I'm sure it tests morale pretty hardcore.
Rob Pardo is absolutely right though. Why shouldn't games be as fun to make as they are to play? As the player I should see that very obviously on screen however. Arkheron, the Bonfire studios game, has the visual style of Diablo 3 with lots of clutter and, at first glance, pretty generic design. It doesn't necessarily have the quality of people having a blast fulfilling their dreams but more so hoping and praying their big expensive thing works well on Twitch.
The comment about games being fun to make probably doesn't refer to the 99% grind after 1% inspiration that everyone knows exists on any big creative project. I imagine it's more about holding onto that 1% and milking that energy while also shortening the distance between a good idea and its implementation. I feel like some of this is inherently at odds with having a very ambitious idea though. It's almost like nailing what's fundamentally very fun is way more important than scope, and I don't mean that sarcastically.
On September 27 2026 11:11 Mrs Crabbleman wrote: The comment about games being fun to make probably doesn't refer to the 99% grind after 1% inspiration that everyone knows exists on any big creative project. I imagine it's more about holding onto that 1% and milking that energy while also shortening the distance between a good idea and its implementation. I feel like some of this is inherently at odds with having a very ambitious idea though. It's almost like nailing what's fundamentally very fun is way more important than scope, and I don't mean that sarcastically.
I agree with you on this point. I'm not a game designer, so take what I say with a grain of salt, but I feel like too many game designers over-focus on some sort of "clever" new design that will be new and exciting and attract players just because it's such a cool idea. But then they gloss over the hard part, which is whether the moment-to-moment gameplay is actually fun.
I always think about how Super Mario Brothers felt so good just moving Mario left and right on the screen. It turns out there's a lot of tweaking even in a simple 2D platformer to get the acceleration and deceleration to feel really good all the time. Nintendo added a run button that added a bunch of depth to the gameplay, but it was all that tweaking that made things really feel sweet.
I remember reading about the development of Mario 64 as well, where Nintendo basically spent a ridiculous amount of time just making Mario fun to move around in three dimensions, adding a bunch of different jumps, etc, before they ever even put anything else into the levels.
In the case of Akheron, Pardo talks mostly about the idea of the game and how cool it is, and how the team came up with so many different ideas and this was the one everyone agreed was the best. But he never talks about the moment-to-moment gameplay, which seems just kinda okay. The rapid spinning around of the whole playfield even makes a bunch of people dizzy. Would the game feel better without rotation? Maybe?
Of course nothing is this simple in life or game development. The folks at Bungie absolutely nail the moment-to-moment gameplay and the feel of gunplay, but then they keep making high-level mistakes with their game design. They turned Marathon into an extraction shooter, which could have worked, but they made a bunch of basic mistakes that other extraction shooters like ARC Raiders didn't.. Focusing on PVP is always a risk in any case. You can look at MOBAs as being a notable exception, but that gameplay mode was honed over years and years of being a popular WC3 mod.
Anyway, this is now a general game design discussion thread, I guess.
On September 28 2026 04:02 Jeremy Reimer wrote: [They turned Marathon into an extraction shooter, which could have worked, but they made a bunch of basic mistakes that other extraction shooters like ARC Raiders didn't..
Marathon 1994 invented mouse aim and had insanely sophisticated narrative. If it had reload mechanic, I'd say the devs were time-traveling ;D
Marathon 2026 is a mediocre game of the niche genre. It's a hardcore PvP-focused game without any MMR systems. I don't have any ideas how it supposed to be profitable, considering its inflated budget.
It really looks like they don't know what they're doing anymore.
Also, it feels like they're doing some IP bulshittery, like Bethesda did with Prey. I don't see any other reason for them to stick with the Marathon IP. The game is nothing like Marathon 1994.
On September 28 2026 04:02 Jeremy Reimer wrote: [They turned Marathon into an extraction shooter, which could have worked, but they made a bunch of basic mistakes that other extraction shooters like ARC Raiders didn't..
Marathon 1994 invented mouse aim and had insanely sophisticated narrative. If it had reload mechanic, I'd say the devs were time-traveling ;D
Marathon 2026 is a mediocre game of the niche genre. It's a hardcore PvP-focused game without any MMR systems. I don't have any ideas how it supposed to be profitable, considering its inflated budget.
It really looks like they don't know what they're doing anymore.
Also, it feels like they're doing some IP bulshittery, like Bethesda did with Prey. I don't see any other reason for them to stick with the Marathon IP. The game is nothing like Marathon 1994.
As a gigantic Marathon fan, the IP returning in this form rather annoyed me!
I also think Marathon was quite innovative in offering secondary fire options for some weapons as well! I’m sure it’s not the first but it was quite an early adopter
Doesn’t play as well as a Doom, or a Duke 3D but I think it’s general atmosphere and plot definitely knock contemporaries out of the water in that domain
On September 28 2026 04:02 Jeremy Reimer wrote: [They turned Marathon into an extraction shooter, which could have worked, but they made a bunch of basic mistakes that other extraction shooters like ARC Raiders didn't..
Marathon 1994 invented mouse aim and had insanely sophisticated narrative. If it had reload mechanic, I'd say the devs were time-traveling ;D
Marathon 2026 is a mediocre game of the niche genre. It's a hardcore PvP-focused game without any MMR systems. I don't have any ideas how it supposed to be profitable, considering its inflated budget.
It really looks like they don't know what they're doing anymore.
Also, it feels like they're doing some IP bulshittery, like Bethesda did with Prey. I don't see any other reason for them to stick with the Marathon IP. The game is nothing like Marathon 1994.
As a gigantic Marathon fan, the IP returning in this form rather annoyed me!
I also think Marathon was quite innovative in offering secondary fire options for some weapons as well! I’m sure it’s not the first but it was quite an early adopter
Doesn’t play as well as a Doom, or a Duke 3D but I think it’s general atmosphere and plot definitely knock contemporaries out of the water in that domain
The mind-boggling thing is that the template for a new Marathon was right there in Doom (2016). Take the existing IP, make a single player sequel set later on in the timeline, add one or two neat little gameplay tweaks to keep things fresh, and laugh all the way to the bank.
Instead, Bungie's "leadership" thought that making an extraction shooter with tiny maps and forced sweaty PVP would be the road to riches.
On September 28 2026 04:02 Jeremy Reimer wrote: [They turned Marathon into an extraction shooter, which could have worked, but they made a bunch of basic mistakes that other extraction shooters like ARC Raiders didn't..
Marathon 1994 invented mouse aim and had insanely sophisticated narrative. If it had reload mechanic, I'd say the devs were time-traveling ;D
Marathon 2026 is a mediocre game of the niche genre. It's a hardcore PvP-focused game without any MMR systems. I don't have any ideas how it supposed to be profitable, considering its inflated budget.
It really looks like they don't know what they're doing anymore.
Also, it feels like they're doing some IP bulshittery, like Bethesda did with Prey. I don't see any other reason for them to stick with the Marathon IP. The game is nothing like Marathon 1994.
As a gigantic Marathon fan, the IP returning in this form rather annoyed me!
I also think Marathon was quite innovative in offering secondary fire options for some weapons as well! I’m sure it’s not the first but it was quite an early adopter
Doesn’t play as well as a Doom, or a Duke 3D but I think it’s general atmosphere and plot definitely knock contemporaries out of the water in that domain
The mind-boggling thing is that the template for a new Marathon was right there in Doom (2016). Take the existing IP, make a single player sequel set later on in the timeline, add one or two neat little gameplay tweaks to keep things fresh, and laugh all the way to the bank.
Instead, Bungie's "leadership" thought that making an extraction shooter with tiny maps and forced sweaty PVP would be the road to riches.
Pretty much, well I’d have dug it, granted Marathon has a fraction of the IP pull that Doom has
On September 29 2026 04:43 Jeremy Reimer wrote: Instead, Bungie's "leadership" thought that making an extraction shooter with tiny maps and forced sweaty PVP would be the road to riches.
Bungie's leadership is great at hiring though. Every employee they laid off is an ambitious, hard working, super talented, mega genius. No one else on planet earth can hire with this level of great consistency, somehow, video game companies can do it though!
I am sure the laid off Bungie employees will go off on their own and pull a Bob Decrescenzo or Javier Martinez and start cranking out all time classics. I can't wait to see what these future superstars will have for us on Steam!
Seriously though, Bungie was as bad at hiring as they were with their future projections. The employees are only as smart as their leaders.... which .. ain't too smart. Their best move is to get a job at Rob Pardo's Bonfire Studios... that's what I'd do if i were in their position.
Kind of crazy to see this drop, especially when Gobsmack admitted he'd lost contact with the one remaining server dev who had been volunteering his time to slowly code in P2P support, and there hadn't been any updates on the PTR in over three months prior to this one.
It seems like it's Stormgate's fate to remain in a kind of forever limbo, not quite definitively dead but not quite alive either. The PTR update did bump the maximum player count up to 20 in the middle of the week, but it's now down to about 12 or so, where it previously bottomed out.
Hard to even know what to say. It's cool that people are still keeping the embers burning for this game, even just a little, but as usual the end result is negligible.
Meanwhile, Tim Morten hasn't posted on LinkedIn since July 29th. I wonder what he's up to these days?
if Rob Pardo dies before his game comes out imagine the # of LinkenIn people who can pretend like they did 5 years of work on the game. LOL. Talk about fish stories!
Rob Pardo left Blizzard at age 44. The probability of a 44 year old USA male dying before age 57 is 6.86%.
Work continues on Akheron (I never remember the name and always have to Google it). The most recent news about the game is from October 16, and involves a small patch, version 0.23.
Stormgate at least made it to 0.6 after five years of development!. Not sure about this game.
On October 17 2026 09:55 Jeremy Reimer wrote: Work continues on Akheron (I never remember the name and always have to Google it). The most recent news about the game is from October 16, and involves a small patch, version 0.23.
Stormgate at least made it to 0.6 after five years of development!. Not sure about this game.
What a life man. i am seriously jealous of Pardo. The longest i can get fronted money for any software project is 6 months.
Seriously though, I wonder if, when he is much older, he will live to regret living off of VC money and producing nothing for 13 years. There is nothing like the feeling of crunching out a new cool piece of software. The greatest times of my professional life are crunching out a new product. He is missing that.
On October 17 2026 09:55 Jeremy Reimer wrote: Work continues on Akheron (I never remember the name and always have to Google it). The most recent news about the game is from October 16, and involves a small patch, version 0.23.
Stormgate at least made it to 0.6 after five years of development!. Not sure about this game.
What a life man. i am seriously jealous of Pardo. The longest i can get fronted money for any software project is 6 months.
Seriously though, I wonder if, when he is much older, he will live to regret living off of VC money and producing nothing for 13 years. There is nothing like the feeling of crunching out a new cool piece of software. The greatest times of my professional life are crunching out a new product. He is missing that.
As Steve Jobs said, "Real artists ship".
There seems to be a strange mind-worm eating its way through the games industry lately. We're seeing the same broken pattern again and again: announce a huge new "live service" game, spend ridiculous amounts of money on it for years, eventually release an "Early Access" build that's horrible and broken and un-fun, game limps along for a few weeks/months/years, then suddenly the money runs out and the whole thing gets put into a shredder.
The whole industry seems to be doing either that, or slapping together rushed remasters of old games that were fun when they first released.
Because some game devs are artists, and some are just bullshitters. Certain spaces of game dev are no different than any other corporate software entity. Most projects never see the light of day and never do actually get shipped in any meaningful way. A lot of people work on projects for years that are doomed from the start. They take their $150k USD per year, they move the 1s and 0s around, it probably flops, and then move on.
Rob has lived his blessed life at Bonfire I'm sure, just like Tim, spending other people's money on nice furniture and lunches, and providing stable jobs for his friends, and getting himself to retirement soon. He probably has a fun hobby outside of work like carving canoes or playing D&D or whatever. I'm sure he gives 0 fucks about Arkheron because its very obvious, as was said, as soon as it ships that it's DoA so they're gonna hold on for 6-12 more months before imploding. If Rob was a game dev 'artist', Arkheron would have been scrapped 4y ago and they would have tried again to do something with any soul, but I think they just hired whoever and had a fun, cool time. Not unlike the first few years of Stormgate.
<I'm injecting a massive amount of my own personal experience and bias into this, but I think it's true...! I've seen it a ton of times in a ton of different software spaces, both games and 'standard' corporate software>
On October 20 2026 05:57 JimmyJRaynor wrote: I watched five guys take down Microsoft SharePoint. That's the biggest David versus Goliath win I've ever seen in my career.
I mean, given the quality of Microsoft SharePoint, I'm surprised it took more than two guys and a dog.
On October 20 2026 05:57 JimmyJRaynor wrote: I watched five guys take down Microsoft SharePoint. That's the biggest David versus Goliath win I've ever seen in my career.
I mean, given the quality of Microsoft SharePoint, I'm surprised it took more than two guys and a dog.
in 2010 it was 1000 people at MS versus 5 guys at a little know competitor.