Prismata, a new strategy card game - Page 10
| Forum Index > General Games |
|
Relevation
1 Post
| ||
|
fezvez
France3021 Posts
| ||
|
HaRuHi
1220 Posts
I must have overlooked something, I cannot believe that a group of MIT dropouts would create such a shallow game. I hope this finds fans, I probably need a husky to explain the absolute basics to me. | ||
|
Cel.erity
United States4890 Posts
On November 23 2014 08:55 HaRuHi wrote: I really really don't get the game. I don't get the appeal. I played around 20 games, going 10/10. It feels tedious. Since it is a game of perfect information you can see what you opponent has planned 6-7turns ahead, and since it is a game with a mechanic requirement of 0 I just end up multiplying ressource costs in my head and then have to click and learn shortcuts to execute something in a game that a computer could probably learn to play perfect within a very short amount of time. I must have overlooked something, I cannot believe that a group of MIT dropouts would create such a shallow game. I hope this finds fans, I probably need a husky to explain the absolute basics to me. Each game has vastly more possibilities than chess, and computers haven't solved chess yet, despite millions of dollars and man-hours being thrown at that endeavor. I would say chess has more subtleties, but in any case, it's not such a simple matter to just "solve" a set. It would require at least a few days of very dedicated analysis. And every set is different, so good luck solving 186,000,000,000 combinations of units in your spare time. Also, if you believe you can visualize 6 turns ahead, that just proves you are not seeing anything important. It's basically impossible for a human being to plan exact attack/defense/gold values that many turns in advance. If you could do it, you would never lose a game. | ||
|
Markwerf
Netherlands3728 Posts
Either way it's not a bad game at all and it has some things going for it, the engineers are a nice touch for example I think providing a nice reason to go from boosting economy to making army. Some small things: 1. why bother with so many modes when it's a new smallish game. Few times I played I coulnd't find people to play online against. I'd advise to only have 1 or 2 modes for online play, do people really care enough to have the options? If you only provides 30 secs timer, base cards + 8 it would be easier to find someone perhaps. It reminds me off some ipad boardgame apps I had, they are fun but if you can't find human opponents conveniently the fun is off. Making sure you can match is far more important than having multiple modes. 2. is it really worth it to have drones be clickable? Aren't you just using drones to make money 99% of the time anyway? Yes I understand there are times to not use a drone so it can act as a blocker. Doesn't this come up quite rarely though? It would only be useful to prevent a breach, but if you are breached aren't drones typically the priority target for your opponent anyway?? Tarsiers are the only somewhat frequent exception here I think which are a better target than a drone. Not using the drone and having it block costs you the drone and the 1 lost income so 4 money and the tarsier is worth more than that (especially a ready one) so yes it's useful to use drones as blockers occasionally with tarsiers. However that's the only easy exception I can think of. If you made drones just autoproduce money you'd lose a very small bit of gameplay but you could easily adjust I think, as I'd think only tarsiers would be nerfed slightly as a result. However you would gain a whole bit of elegance and simplicity. Mandatory clicks are just annoying and the whole decision moment of using your drone or not isn't very interesting anyway. Heck if you really wanted to keep the functionality of the drone as blocker you could just add a unit to the baseset: 1 money, sacrifice a drone, blocks for 1 instantly.. Elegance of design is very important in this kind of game I think and removing the tedious must-clicking and thus need for knowing hotkeys is just annoying. 3. I can't help but feel this game would work better as an actual boardgame. I'm more of a boardgame fan than computer gamer nowadays and each have their own merits and plenty of games can exist well in both worlds. Boardgames are more fun face to face but computer games can do a lot of stuff that doesn't work well in boardgames. For simpler games without lots of upkeep work, real time elements, short gameplay and few players a boardgame works better though I think. You could very easily make a simple neat print-and-play version of this game like many can be found on boardgamegeek. The game is only cards and bit of resources. Resources that can be held over turns (money & green) could easily be tracked with a cube on a sheet, ranging from 0 to 20. Clicking is the same as tapping and would be easy to use. Cards in production could easily be indentified with a small chit which you could make doublesided, one side with 1 turn the other with 2 turns. For the few exceptions that are in production for 3 turns you'd use 2 chits. Finally drones would be cumbersome as it's not unlikely to reach high numbers. However you could easily have drones be counted with a small track on it ranging from say 0 to 30 which you just track with a cube. Especially if you would implement point 2 above this would be very easy. Plus it would be much easier to see how much drones you have which is another small oversight in the implementation as it is now I think, it's mostly mental calculation this game, why not make it easier for players? It would be a bunch of cards, some 'under construction' chits, a couple cubes and 2 overview cards with 5 tracks (1 for drones, 1 for money, 1 for green and 2 short ones for blue/red) plus possibly a summary of rules. Optionally a sand timer for the timed mode. I'm not saying it is bad as a computer implementation but let's be honest. As a computer game it has to compete with far slicker productions like the tons of free to play games we see on facebook. As a card game I would like it more I think and could be a nice 2 player filler. With a little redesign on drones and possibly engineers the card count would be low enough I think that it would work quite neatly, a bit like Dominion but an engine builder instead of a deck builder. | ||
|
Veliel
18 Posts
I dont understand some of your criticism. 1. I mean there arent that many game modes, and you can just check them. 95% of games are either +5 or +8. Yea sometimes its 90 sec or 60 or whatever you checked, but I don't find it a big deal or great difference. I dont think many people change it much from the standard options. The playerpool is tiny to begin with anyway. 2. You use drones as defenders in pretty much every game and its a pretty important part of the strategy. It's also only 1 click ? 3. Yea seems like a neat idea. They started the game like this as well, just as a fun home game with cards. Multiple Units / shuffling could be a bit annoying though. As far as production value goes, I agree. There is nothing shiny or great about it. It just does its job i guess, nothing more. The core game however is pretty awesome. Before i played I was worried that always having the same starting deck and just shared units would make the games pretty stale. (maybe it happens a bit at higher skill level) But so far it hasn't been my experience. Edit: Just wanted to add that this game has very much a strategy game vibe to it. Things like early pressure / transitioning etc. It does not at all play like a card game like mtg / hearthstone etc. | ||
|
Buckyman
1364 Posts
| ||
|
Wuster
1974 Posts
On November 24 2014 05:25 Veliel wrote: Edit: Just wanted to add that this game has very much a strategy game vibe to it. Things like early pressure / transitioning etc. It does not at all play like a card game like mtg / hearthstone etc. Though I haven't gotten in yet, this game looks a lot more lie a deck building game than a card game. And those definitely rely less on surprising yor opponent since all the tricks are put out in the open. Takes a different skillset, though this game also appears to have taken the draw / rng out of deck building games too. | ||
|
Cel.erity
United States4890 Posts
On November 24 2014 01:21 Markwerf wrote: 2. is it really worth it to have drones be clickable? Aren't you just using drones to make money 99% of the time anyway? Yes I understand there are times to not use a drone so it can act as a blocker. Doesn't this come up quite rarely though? It would only be useful to prevent a breach, but if you are breached aren't drones typically the priority target for your opponent anyway?? Say you have 3 attack and I have only a Wall. If I let you attack, my wall dies. If I put up a drone, my drone dies and my wall absorbs 2. Much better. Plus lots of other reasons why you wouldn't want to get breached, like if you can only afford to get breached by a specific amount, etc. | ||
|
mahrgell
Germany3943 Posts
I think my most interesting set today was actually a B+5... It had: Apollo Centurion Scorchilla Energy Matrix Chrono Filter Somehow all the cards interact really nicely here. Scorchilla is always an early threat, but Apollo seems to simply counter it. But with Energy Matrix Centurion, it also does not turn into the usual Apollo game, because suddenly Blocking is really a thing for quite a long time. Chronofilter gives a much easier access to Centurion and Apollo then usual. I actually started with early Scorchilla into Centurion, Apollo. He was a bit on the defense in the early, but a Energy matrix deflected it nicely. I got my Centurion 2 turns and my Apollo one turn ahead of him, but somehow we both had econed up to about 20 drones and now it turned into a huge grindfest. In the end I think my 2 Conduits won me the game, as I was a bit faster on the gaussguns, which were basically the only damage dealer in the game, that did not immediatetly went poof to apollo. In the end we ended with all walls, energy matrizes completely out of stock, he still had two gaussguns in stock, I had none. Neither of us had many drones left. Forcefields were nearly used up, as were Rhinos. Looking back I think I misplayed the game slightly by not trying to build more engis to make defending a bit easier. (When you only have a 5HP and a 6HP Blocker, because Apollo snipes everything, Engis would have been actually super useful to absorb damage better without using drones. But then again, I simply tried to squeeze in as many Gausses as possible. Mirrormatches are so difficult ^.^ So many small decisions that decide in the end. | ||
|
Markwerf
Netherlands3728 Posts
On November 24 2014 16:50 Cel.erity wrote: Not going to address anything, but about this: Say you have 3 attack and I have only a Wall. If I let you attack, my wall dies. If I put up a drone, my drone dies and my wall absorbs 2. Much better. Plus lots of other reasons why you wouldn't want to get breached, like if you can only afford to get breached by a specific amount, etc. Fair enough, there is some play to it. Still an option for automatically using the drones instead of hotkeys would be nice, the few times i want to use a drone to block you could manually just click one. I get that there is an easy hotkey but having to use the keyboard at all kind of detracts already from what is otherwise a relaxing mouse only game. Also just having a number shown for both players how many drones they have would be nice. I get that they are grouped by 5 etc. but why should i be bothered to do some manual count when it's such a pivotal part of the gameplay. | ||
|
Kavas
Australia3421 Posts
Does anyone have a key to spare? Thanks a bunch. | ||
|
Capresis
United States518 Posts
On November 24 2014 18:38 Markwerf wrote: Fair enough, there is some play to it. Still an option for automatically using the drones instead of hotkeys would be nice, the few times i want to use a drone to block you could manually just click one. I get that there is an easy hotkey but having to use the keyboard at all kind of detracts already from what is otherwise a relaxing mouse only game. Also just having a number shown for both players how many drones they have would be nice. I get that they are grouped by 5 etc. but why should i be bothered to do some manual count when it's such a pivotal part of the gameplay. On drones: I asked him on stream why it wasn't the reverse as well, where drones automatically mine and you click them if you want to block with them. He said there were a number of reasons, but was busy playing and didn't have time to go over it in detail. If we asked on r/prismata he'd probably write a few paragraphs as to why drones are the way they are. On November 24 2014 19:56 Kavas wrote: Getting Hearthstone players to publicize their game was how I found out about this. Does anyone have a key to spare? Thanks a bunch. You can donate to their kickstarter and get a key (: $17 CAD though. | ||
|
Cy_
9 Posts
![]() I've a spare key, will give it to the good hands, just PM me, but also please support the Prismata kickstarter, this game is going to be awesome! | ||
|
Cy_
9 Posts
| ||
|
[BSP]Kain
119 Posts
I'm torn here, I want to support it on the Kickstarter, but on the other hand I have a rule to never buy stuff blindly. :/ Oh well, I guess I will have to stick to watching more streams for now. | ||
|
fezvez
France3021 Posts
On November 27 2014 02:22 [BSP]Kain wrote: Hmm, game definitely looks promising. I'm torn here, I want to support it on the Kickstarter, but on the other hand I have a rule to never buy stuff blindly. :/ Oh well, I guess I will have to stick to watching more streams for now. Just ask for a key, here or on r/prismata. There are a ton of key available since they give more than one per Kickstarter backer. I 100% agree with you that you should try it first. I personally tried it extensively before pledging | ||
|
Probemicro
3708 Posts
| ||
|
Tarias
Netherlands480 Posts
You'll run into things like "If I buy these extra attackers now instead of defenders, I will get breached for 1 this turn, then next turn kill 2 of his attackers." etc. In those kinds of situations you really just have to calculate it. | ||
|
chroniX
517 Posts
![]() | ||
| ||
