EPTAnime Discussion Thread - Page 5603
| Forum Index > Media & Entertainment |
If you come in here looking for "anime recommendations" then please refer to this chart before posting: Anime Recommendations (as of may 2014). We also have an IRC channel called #tladt where we all hang out. The channel is on Rizon, not QuakeNet! Feel free to check it out. TLADT discord is Discord.gg For currently airing anime, please see Anichart.net | ||
|
Sentenal
United States12398 Posts
| ||
|
ragz_gt
9172 Posts
On April 26 2016 11:46 Rebs wrote: You could slow down with the "its ok that you dont like it" patronizing. You said it once you dont have to say it over and over. Yeah sure, he made it he can call it Macross then its Macross but you never really addressed that this isnt what one would expect of a show that calls itself Macross. Yes things evolve and all but he literally just dumpstered a bunch of stuff to throw mahou shoujou at you. Thats not Macross to me but thats just me and I never insisted everyone say its not Macross even if I might feel that way. Not sure where you picked that up. I just said its not what you would "expect" of a Macross series. Oh woop Mahou Shoujos.. cool, just your regualar Macross show." Umm no? And the whole damn show so far more about them than anything else. You can paint your car red, put hot chicks in it and call it a Ferrari. Its not. Thats what it feels like anyway. And no its not the same as not using cel. That is pretty stupid. Dumping the spirit of a show to people who were fond of it for what it was is disappointing. On April 26 2016 07:41 Rebs wrote: dafuq, since when did magical girls become expected in a Macross anime ? Let alone all the other issues with it. On April 26 2016 10:02 Rebs wrote: When the mechs dont matter to someone in active combat taking on other mechs. Thats a bit much for me. I get that it needs to trend a bit to be relevant but it kinda butchers Macross cant believe thats even a discussion.Call it Mahou Shoujo Macross but passing it off as an expected kind of Macross is a bit much. On April 26 2016 11:14 Rebs wrote: Dont think you have seen SDF Macross then. Anyway I dont even know what to say to that. For someone who literally started watching anime because of Macross this version is a bit of a fuck you. On April 26 2016 11:14 Rebs wrote: + Show Spoiler + If you are calling this a faithful Macross iteration thats about the worst argument out there. And while we are at it, your the kind of people they butcher it for in the first place so its kind of moot to try to explain it. Gee... I wonder where would I pick THAT up, it's as if you literally called people who don't agree with you either never watched all the Macross before or the reason they ruined the show. And if Ferrari makes a pickup truck. it's still a Ferrari. | ||
|
Rebs
Pakistan10726 Posts
On April 26 2016 12:04 ragz_gt wrote: Gee... I wonder where would I pick THAT up, it's as if you literally called people who don't agree with you either never watched all the Macross before or the reason they ruined the show. And if Ferrari makes a pickup truck. it's still a Ferrari. Yes expected in a Macross series and sure its kinda miserable. But I never said "THIS IS NOT Macross you cannot call it Macross." But its still some serious butchery. Something strawman, something something. Heck I even called it Mahou Shoujo Macross. And the first comment you pointed out was after your patronizing, not before. And that was literally me throwing you a bone. And you went right at it. So you picked up something I said after you made the comment about me saying its not Macross ? Thats some Nosferatu shit right there. I will present to you See. | ||
|
ragz_gt
9172 Posts
| ||
|
Rebs
Pakistan10726 Posts
On April 26 2016 12:17 ragz_gt wrote: There is nothing quoted that's after my first comment today, so not sure what you are talking about. Unless you mean Ferrari comment which is a response to your random nonsense about painting car red. I mean, if Ferrari does it then it makes the car a Ferrari by definition. Perhaps you are misunderstanding... On April 26 2016 11:46 Rebs wrote: You could slow down with the "its ok that you dont like it" patronizing. You said it once you dont have to say it over and over. Yeah sure, he made it he can call it Macross then its Macross but you never really addressed that this isnt what one would expect of a show that calls itself Macross. Yes things evolve and all but he literally just dumpstered a bunch of stuff to throw mahou shoujou at you. Thats not Macross to me but thats just me and I never insisted everyone say its not Macross even if I might feel that way. Not sure where you picked that up. I just said its not what you would "expect" of a Macross series. Oh woop Mahou Shoujos.. cool, just your regualar Macross show." Umm no? And the whole damn show so far more about them than anything else. You can paint your car red, put hot chicks in it and call it a Ferrari. Its not. Thats what it feels like anyway. And no its not the same as not using cel. That is pretty stupid. Dumping the spirit of a show to people who were fond of it for what it was is disappointing. Ill keep watching it because Valkyries but not gonna lie I havent forced myself through shit in years now so it gonna be a chore. You use that as evidence after youve already made the assumption. And I literally edited it in to throw you a bone and see if you would use it and its the first thing you went for. But thats besides the point. Your extrapolating a bit to far either way. | ||
|
ragz_gt
9172 Posts
| ||
|
Rebs
Pakistan10726 Posts
On April 26 2016 12:22 ragz_gt wrote: That's the question I'm responding to............................. not using it as evidence And highlighting that bit and not the question ? | ||
|
ragz_gt
9172 Posts
| ||
|
Rebs
Pakistan10726 Posts
On April 26 2016 12:24 ragz_gt wrote: Because that's the question! No, thats a statement. The question is after it. It is not in anyway pronounced visibly for me to think that is what you are addressing even if it is. | ||
|
ragz_gt
9172 Posts
| ||
|
Rebs
Pakistan10726 Posts
On April 26 2016 12:27 ragz_gt wrote: The question is also meaningless, you stating that you are not trying to convince others is what I'm addressing, which is why it's highlighted. Yes but its still a statement and not a question and on its own just looks like you are using it to prove a point the way the formating works. Rather conveniently the you also left out the question so it would be a bit difficult for me to know that now wouldnt it. Either way, if you look at all that you kinda did the work for me. I didnt really insist anyone not call it Macross or that it wasnt Macross. I wouldnt be upset in the first place if it wasnt a Macross series. You didnt have to really highlight it anyway. I wouldve gotten the point you were trying to make. Seems a bit unnecessary. Its really quite simple. Fuck everything else. If you are going to sit there and say that this is standard fare for a Macross show then thats that. I however do not agree with that and so find it disappointing and not something that I associate with this series. | ||
|
felisconcolori
United States6169 Posts
So I started watching Chihayafuru because of the hype in the thread. Only one episode, but... Taichi was a dick as a kid. So far. Not understanding the insane love for him yet. | ||
|
Sentenal
United States12398 Posts
X Transformable Plane Mecha and Dogfights _ Love Triangles X Emphasis on Music X Deculture Now, from what I gather from Macross Delta, at least 3 of those are satisfied so far. And I'm pretty sure at some point there will be a love triangle, since its Macross, and there is always one. Those things are literally the only unifying things in all of Macross. Everything else, from First Contact, to Top Gun, to Idols, to Magic Guitar piloting, none of those things are "expected" for Macross, they are just the flavors of each iteration. And the flavor of this iteration is magical girls. Sure, its a different flavor, they all are. But it still does, or will probably do, what all Macross anime are expected to do. | ||
|
Miragee
8716 Posts
On April 26 2016 13:28 felisconcolori wrote: rabble rabble rabble. So I started watching Chihayafuru because of the hype in the thread. Only one episode, but... Taichi was a dick as a kid. So far. Not understanding the insane love for him yet. Yes he was. He changes. A lot. | ||
|
Ryuhou)aS(
United States1174 Posts
tbh he acts like a normal elementary kid that likes a girl, and gets jealous of other guy easily. I think he might even be most relate-able and human and normal when he's a young asshole as opposed to how he is later. (which is saying a lot b/c i really related to his position with chihaya later on) | ||
|
Slaughter
United States20255 Posts
On April 26 2016 13:28 felisconcolori wrote: rabble rabble rabble. So I started watching Chihayafuru because of the hype in the thread. Only one episode, but... Taichi was a dick as a kid. So far. Not understanding the insane love for him yet. Hopefully you can get past the 1st few eps. I couldn't  | ||
|
felisconcolori
United States6169 Posts
Also, Chihaya's mom and sister suck, Taichi's mom is also a dick, and I have no basis to make a judgement on Arata's parents at this time. | ||
|
Miragee
8716 Posts
On April 26 2016 15:55 Ryuhou)aS( wrote: tbh he acts like a normal elementary kid that likes a girl, and gets jealous of other guy easily. I think he might even be most relate-able and human and normal when he's a young asshole as opposed to how he is later. (which is saying a lot b/c i really related to his position with chihaya later on) + Show Spoiler + Yeah, I'm not saying that he is not relatable. Kids in that age are usually very self-centered. It's not like in Hourou Musuko where half of the cast is unbelievably self-reflexive and empathetic, more so than tons of adults I know. It's realistic in Chihayafuru, I agree. That doesn't necessarily make it likeable. What he did was still a dick-move. When he grew older however, he learned and changed a lot. I wouldn't say his older self is less relatable. As you have pointed out, you can relate to him strongly, so it depends on the person. Same goes for me. I said this earlier: If I had to name an anime character I could relate the most to I would say Taichi, no doubt, and his position with Chihaya is one of the reasons. His personality later on is probably less common than his personality when he was young. So yeah, more people might be able to relate to his younger self better than to his older self (just speculation of course). But that doesn't make his older self less human imho. | ||
|
Numy
South Africa35471 Posts
This brings me onto the next point. So during my 3 hours of sleep I figured something monumental out. There's a way to solve all this love crisis in Chihaya. It was right there all along. I can't believe I didn't see it earlier. So what needs to happen is Taichi x Arata first. It makes so much sense. Taichi is always thinking about Arata even when he's dreaming. The bromance turned romance. There's even the whole "i hate him but I love him" which describes love so well. Then we get Shinobu x Chihaya. Think about it. Chihaya spends every waking minute thinking about this girl. They both got this airhead weird fetish for children's shows/characters and both crazy about Karuta. They are made for each other. Everyone lands up happy. No broken hearts anything. Once again yuri saves the day. edit: Older Taichi is pretty relatable too. Haven't you ever been in a group setting or project where basically everyone is wishy washy failures and you now have all the responsibility to make this work even if you don't want to do it? That's Taichi in everything. His own competency thrusts him into these positions he doesn't want to be in but he's too nice a guy to ever just be selfish and tell the group to go fail without him. Reminds me of myself before I learnt in University that you can't be responsible for everyone, sometimes you just got to make sure you cover yourself. | ||
|
Miragee
8716 Posts
+ Show Spoiler [Chihayafuru s2 ep12-14] + Damn that match against First Akashi Girl's High School was tense. And they dragged it out so much... I almost felt like watching a damn battle shounen. The photographers were annoying, glad they are goners now. Although that last scene were Megumu picked the batteries instead of the SD-cards was golden. I'm so glad both Oe and Desktomu won! And in such a crucial moment. I expected either of them to win in addition to Taichi and Porky. Expected Chihaya to lose, to set up more tension for the finale where she is probably going to win. But Porky lost, damn. I think he is going to take his match in the finale. My predictions are Chihaya, Taichi and Porky for a 3-2 this time. Akihiro will lose, I admire his move in the end of ep14 though. Although he will lose, he can tell his brothers that he was fielded in the finals.^^ Shinobu was such a comedic relief all match long. And scene where Taichi opened Chihaya's hand was beautiful. | ||
| ||
