This is a thread that is dedicated to discussing One Piece. Do not read this thread if you are not currently caught up as there are spoilers in here.

If an episode or a chapter has already been officially released, then it is not necessary to post using spoilers.

If you have knowledge on a chapter that has not been officially released yet, do NOT post it in this thread. Ignoring this public note will result in a mod action.

shark.

593 Posts

January 15 2014 20:08 GMT

#12381

It's somewhere half between both translations that i was tryng to explain as you could view it as DD explaining her betrayal and him thinking he has already seen through the plan and that she has "forced" his hand into completely crushing the alliance as opposed to the indifference he sort of felt towards Luffy.

Though I'm still not sure other people will read these posts as I'm trying to have them read....

sumsaR

Sweden1812 Posts

January 15 2014 20:17 GMT

#12382

My interpretation of the situation didn't really change either way reading the different translations.

Canucklehead

Canada5074 Posts

January 15 2014 20:21 GMT

#12383

On January 16 2014 05:17 sumsaR wrote:
My interpretation of the situation didn't really change either way reading the different translations.

Really, they have vastly different meanings to me? The part about her insisting on breaking the alliance made it seem it was still ongoing and she was acting as a double agent for DD to break them from the inside. Now with the new translation, it turns out her wanting to break the alliance was a complete fabrication due to the mistranslation and never part of the story.

At least that's how I read it, which is why I was confused.

sumsaR

Sweden1812 Posts

January 15 2014 20:33 GMT

#12384

I interpreted both translations as things that had happened in the past. Considering how she changed side since the last time she spoke to DD (i.e. when she could express her opinion of wanting to break the alliance — though that never happened according to the latter translation), it was irrelevant information at this point. She had already switched sides (thanks to Sanji) and wouldn't have been more of a double agent than she would have been otherwise.

Sentenal

United States12398 Posts

January 15 2014 22:32 GMT

#12385

On December 29 2013 14:32 Forikorder wrote:
cavens never going to do anything important hes a gag character hes got chump written all over him in pink glitter pen the only reason for his existance is at best to hype whoever takes him out

On December 29 2013 15:22 Forikorder wrote:

Show nested quote +

the dude rides a horse and his motivation for hating luffy is because luffy is more famous

hes a gag character whith no plot importance at all, and never will be important AKA a chump

Sup Forikorder, how does it feel? You predictions and theories about One Piece are so good. Please tell me more about how Cavendish is a chump gag character.

sumsaR

Sweden1812 Posts

January 15 2014 22:51 GMT

#12386

Inb4 "it doesn't count because he's got split personality disorder and it wasn't he who did it".

Mensol

14536 Posts

January 15 2014 22:55 GMT

#12387

Forikorder's rokushiki discussion is the best discussion i've ever read on TL.

I love to read his therories and would like to know his thoughts on Cavendish atm.

Sincerely, Mensol.

Afmug

58 Posts

January 15 2014 23:29 GMT

#12388

waitwaitwait. in the chapter it seemed like this cavendish kid was fully aware of both of his personalities, although that could be wrong, but if he is, then why did he leave rebecca (coldly assuming he knows he didnt slice her, and a master swordsman should know that) the last fighter standing? or is this me being silly?

Sentenal

United States12398 Posts

January 15 2014 23:40 GMT

#12389

Rebecca avoided the blade. So it wasn't ENTIRELY luck.

Slaughter

United States20255 Posts

January 15 2014 23:44 GMT

#12390

Oda is making Rebecca strong but not OP because the strawhats obviously need a princess crew member since they missed out on the last one.

Kirsed

9380 Posts

January 16 2014 00:34 GMT

#12391

On January 16 2014 08:44 Slaughter wrote:
Oda is making Rebecca strong but not OP because the strawhats obviously need a princess crew member since they missed out on the last one.

Please no.

Powermanga translation kind of clears of Cavendish's back story a little better.

Dreamer.T

United States3584 Posts

January 16 2014 00:37 GMT

#12392

On January 16 2014 08:44 Slaughter wrote:
Oda is making Rebecca strong but not OP because the strawhats obviously need a princess crew member since they missed out on the last one.

You can't compare Rebecca to Vivi in terms of awesomeness. Not to say Rebecca is trashy.

Sentenal

United States12398 Posts

January 16 2014 00:39 GMT

#12393

Vivi also had a lot more chapters of content to build her up than Rebecca has. Although Vivi was kind of grating to me. If she had joined, I'd easily be able to peg her as my least favorite of the crew (which is a lot to me, since I like every member of the Strawhats).

Slaughter

United States20255 Posts

January 16 2014 00:42 GMT

#12394

Rebecca has had a tenth of the screen time Vivi had so you really can't compare the two. It was sarcasm anyway, OP only has like what? 1-2 top teir female in terms of strength? There are very little mid teir female characters as well. I actually wish that OP had more strong females in it, which is why I wouldn't mind another female crew member who can take out more then fodder (that is if the SH even get anymore members besides possibly adding Jinbe).

Kirsed

9380 Posts

January 16 2014 00:45 GMT

#12395

On January 16 2014 09:39 Sentenal wrote:
Vivi also had a lot more chapters of content to build her up than Rebecca has. Although Vivi was kind of grating to me. If she had joined, I'd easily be able to peg her as my least favorite of the crew (which is a lot to me, since I like every member of the Strawhats).

I just reread the first 350 chapters. And at the point that Vivi had the chance to join she had been on the ship for 100 chapters. And at that point they were at chapter 200 so she was around for 50% of the manga. Tons of content!

flamewheel

FREEAGLELAND26782 Posts

January 16 2014 00:57 GMT

#12396

i lub da vivi

Dreamer.T

United States3584 Posts

January 16 2014 01:32 GMT

#12397

Big Mom's like the strongest female by far, and then the next strongest we've seen is like a huge notch below that. Still better than Naruto in terms of female strength though

Sentenal

United States12398 Posts

January 16 2014 01:34 GMT

#12398

Big Mom and Boa Hancock are the two strongest females we have seen. Can't think of any other females near their level.

Mensol

14536 Posts

January 16 2014 01:47 GMT

#12399

Sugar D. Addy is quite strong too.

How about Poseidon?

terranghost

United States980 Posts

January 16 2014 02:22 GMT

#12400

http://www.mangapanda.com/103-2531-19/one-piece/chapter-424.html

I was rereading the cp9 arc and I ran across this.

People were discussing Luffy's mother a while back. I still don't think it is crocodile but the question was.
Won't you draw Luffy's parents?
The answer was that will be drawn in the next chapter. Which I'm sure just referenced the fact that dragon was mentioned but he says they and parents thus one could take it as Luffy's mother was in that same chapter and since she was apparently already drawn it is a character we know.