Natsu and the others were born before Erza, but she was revived before them due to the time travel Zeref initiated. That's the why she was alone in a random village. She wasn't born until after the skip or was born right before it. Essentially they are all the same age.

I wonder where Acnologia is and what happened to Mavis and Zeref after her escape. They go off on these tangents and it just doesn't work for me half the time

abuse

Latvia1933 Posts

December 13 2016 07:21 GMT

#4204

It's actually so anti climatic how acnologia killed serena, who was also a dragonslayer, and the scene was made all epic as in Acnologia is now going out to seek out all the dragonslayers and kill them, and now he's probably sleeping somewhere instead for such a long time.

Latham

9560 Posts

December 13 2016 07:48 GMT

#4205

First of all, yeah that was an amazing chapter with all the lore and reveals. Haven't had such a good FT chapter in forever it feels like.
Second of all, yes Acnologia is prolly jacking it off in the woods or so bored he took an afternoon nap. I don't believe for one second he could have been teleported so far away he couldn't have turned into his dragon form and flew right back in a matter of mere minutes.
Shouldn't that also make Elaine Belsarion his prime target? Why go for half-dead chumps like Laxus or Sting/Rogue when you have prolly the most powerful and first-rate firstborn dragonslayer in your reach? He craves battle.

You know why Erza could cross that magic barrier? Simple: At the time Mashima didn't have the plot ready about her and her mother.

I still feel like Lucy's mother should be explored more. Didn't she make Natsu's scarf from Igneel's dragon scales, or was that Lucy's great-great-great-grandmother or something?

sharkie

Austria18413 Posts

December 13 2016 08:50 GMT

#4206

Really? I think the thing with the magic barrier is quite obvious.
The dragon slayers had their dragons in them (all of them easily older than 80 years) that's why they couldn't cross the barrier. Erza did not have a dragon in her.

Also why do people believe that Erza is hundreds of years old?
Were I, a 26 year old, decide to time travel right now 10 years into the future - would I suddenly be 36? No, my body would still be 26...

abuse

Latvia1933 Posts

December 13 2016 09:50 GMT

#4207

On December 13 2016 17:50 sharkie wrote:
Also why do people believe that Erza is hundreds of years old?
Were I, a 26 year old, decide to time travel right now 10 years into the future - would I suddenly be 36? No, my body would still be 26...

I wouldn't be so quick to agree with that, there's room for discussion on what your age would be.
Doesn't matter what your body's age is, it's about how old are you(if you can follow my point). And whether you see, or others see you, as 26 or 36 is up to you/them/whoever wants to think about it.
No way to come to a consensus though, as it is not a possible situation and is up to anyone's interpretation.

also we don't know if erza time travelled at all just yet.

sharkie

Austria18413 Posts

December 13 2016 09:53 GMT

#4208

So if I were to go back 30 years into the past I am -4 years old?
How does this make sense?

abuse

Latvia1933 Posts

December 13 2016 09:54 GMT

#4209

On December 13 2016 18:53 sharkie wrote:
So if I were to go back 30 years into the past I am -4 years old?
How does this make sense?

no that's not what I'm saying.

EDIT: then again, it might be what I'm saying.. in a way. it's hard to follow.. :D
Then again there's not much sense to see in time travelling becuase time travelling itself doesn't make much sense.

Latham

9560 Posts

December 13 2016 10:06 GMT

#4210

The only good time travel iteration is the one with the butterfly effect. You go back or forward in time, fuck up your own timeline, try to correct it, fuck it up even more, sacrifice something you wanted to change in order to go back to your original timeline.
This kind of time travel or The Flash's kind always lead to bullshit somewhere down the line and it's just writing yourself into a corner.

Slaughter

United States20254 Posts

December 13 2016 15:14 GMT

#4211

I don't even remember what time travel you guys are talking about tbh. Only one I remember is what happened during the grand magic games with future Lucy etc.

abuse

Latvia1933 Posts

December 13 2016 15:20 GMT

#4212

about the fact that Erza had to get to the present day somehow, if she was in the belly of eileen 400 years ago.

ZerOCoolSC2

8986 Posts

December 13 2016 16:00 GMT

#4213

And also about when Zeref explained to Natsu his origins.

If you travel back in time Sharkie, no matter you're biological age, your perceived age is what people will latch on to. You wouldn't be -4, you'd just be 26. Both ways.

Dangermousecatdog

United Kingdom7084 Posts

December 13 2016 22:54 GMT

#4214

I think you mixed up biological age with chronological age there.

TheTenthDoc

United States9561 Posts

December 14 2016 01:05 GMT

#4215

Pretty much it depends on how Freed's runes were coded.

If it's: IF (Current Date - Date of Birth)/365 > 80 THEN DO (BLOCK) then there might be an issue.

If it's: IF (Biological days alive)/365 > 80 THEN DO (BLOCK) then there probably wouldn't be.

As far as I know there's no comment on which it is in the manga, and it's magic so there's no reason it couldn't be one or the other.

ZerOCoolSC2

8986 Posts

December 14 2016 01:31 GMT

#4216

On December 14 2016 07:54 Dangermousecatdog wrote:
I think you mixed up biological age with chronological age there.

Biological fits. Could replace chronological with perceived though. Since you're time of aging is changing, but not the way you naturally age. Make sense? Biologically I'm probably 2342 with the way my body feels. But I've been on Earth for 30. (If that even helps)

Forikorder

Canada8840 Posts

December 14 2016 05:38 GMT

#4217

we havent even seen Erza be born yet, her mother must have done something to prevent herself from turning into a dragon, most likely wisdom dragon guy did what Igneel and the rest did and went inside Eileen to cure the changing, eileen goes in stasis and has Erza afterwards

http://www.mangareader.net/fairy-tail/108/9

also doesnt it specifically only forbid MALE?

in hindsight its wierd for it to specifically only prevent male, almost as if the author knew one of the females was actually over 80 and didnt want to create a plot hole

ZerOCoolSC2

8986 Posts

December 14 2016 06:20 GMT

#4218

Those are retranslated pages. So the author appears to have had this plan all along. It's the Ministry of Truth.

Forikorder

Canada8840 Posts

December 14 2016 06:50 GMT

#4219

On December 14 2016 15:20 ZerOCoolSC2 wrote:
Those are retranslated pages. So the author appears to have had this plan all along. It's the Ministry of Truth.

anyone have the raws and know enough japanese to see if it actually specifies males?

Slaughter

United States20254 Posts

December 14 2016 07:00 GMT

#4220

I went and looked it up in my hard copy and in that it says anyone and does not specify males. Not directly from the Japanese but from the official translation that is being sold.