|
We understand that this topic evokes strong feelings. In the interest of maintaining a necessary and productive discussion, we will be taking a strong stance against posters that clearly do not contribute to this aim. Dishonest and bad faith arguments, victim blaming, and attacks on other users, will be strictly moderated. A post which only serves to muddy the waters and dishonestly portray the nature of assault and harassment (and corresponding accusations) is also unwelcome. This is a serious topic. Please treat it as such. If you have feedback on how we should approach this topic on LiquidDota, please see here. |
This is actually the worst response to accusations you could ever make. Did anyone read this and think, "wow it seems like DeMoN is innocent of everything," ?
Absolutely wild that an actual human being wrote this.
|
28104 Posts
On June 30 2020 05:24 overt wrote:This is actually the worst response to accusations you could ever make. Did anyone read this and think, "wow it seems like DeMoN is innocent of everything," ? Absolutely wild that an actual human being wrote this. It goes heavily against PR 101. It's almost laughable how often he's like "I'm sorry, but..."
|
Jimmy's case is an oddone. I do lean more in defense of jimmy than I do for Elaine on the following premise. (this does not mean I don't favor the OTHER victims, but in terms of Elaine, I don't quite believe her based off of the following)
So i'll caveat that my opinion is based solely on what i've read between Jimmy And Elaine.
1. Sex did not occur in this scenario between any of the parties. 2. Sexual Assault also did not occur based on the instances listed. (Between him and elaine) - Asking to kiss someone is not a crime. - Having a playboy "persona" is not a crime. - Being flirty is not a crime. 3. The incident that could be interpreted as sexual assault (between him and anonymous/wicked) have yet to provide any evidence.
What remains to be seen in order for me to believe Elaine - Specify what "advances" in detail occurred during the car ride? - Can someone point me to where she identifies he grabbed her underwear? or is she retelling someone else's accounts? - She feels justified to "mock" him even though the things that occurred with her and jimmy, were just discomfort. Jimmy never did anything she said no to. multiple attempts by jimmy but result in him respecting her no, does not equate to sexual assault. - She was not propositioned for sex, or anything outside of a kiss and perhaps aggressive hand grabbing. Sure that's unprofessional but is it sexual assault? she seems vindictive in her reasoning.
I don't believe there is enough evidence provided by Elaine to form a favorable opinion in defense of her. We might need a jimmy thread but so far the other victims retelling and accounting have purely been anonymous. We'll need more people to come forward and more context to be provided.
|
We definitely don't need a Jimmy thread.
Two of the things he cites as being his defense are that he wouldn't get an erection in that situation and that if he did grab a girl's underwear she could just walk away. He cites his playboy pick up line and charms...
Like, if no one made any accusations against him and you just read his response I don't think any organization would ever want to work with him. It reeks of someone who is a womanizer. And what's worse is he took what, 4-5 days to write that? So it wasn't even like he wrote it in the heat of the moment.
|
Jimmy's response is possibly the dumbest I've ever seen.
He started insulting the accusers on twitter, whining about false accusations, then finally said he was going offline for a few days.
His FINAL statement is what he should have led with :
...I got the total opposite impression from his initial statement.
|
On June 30 2020 06:05 overt wrote: We definitely don't need a Jimmy thread.
Two of the things he cites as being his defense are that he wouldn't get an erection in that situation and that if he did grab a girl's underwear she could just walk away. He cites his playboy pick up line and charms...
Like, if no one made any accusations against him and you just read his response I don't think any organization would ever want to work with him. It reeks of someone who is a womanizer. And what's worse is he took what, 4-5 days to write that? So it wasn't even like he wrote it in the heat of the moment.
If the focus is on his "Playboy pickup lines and charm" whatever that means, it's still very aloof and nothing definitive. it's all speculative.
Yes, there are grounds to say jimmy is unprofessional, but not enough evidence from her to say he is a predator.
I say this only in the context of the relationship between Jimmy and Elaine, I think the only thing he did wrong with elaine was he mixed Business and pleasure. Which is the premise of how all these guys fuck up. The only difference between all the cases is how far they've escalated that relationship after doing so and if they respected boundaries.
Jimmy's case with elaine can be summarized as he hit on her and verbally demonstrated his intentions, and she replied no. proceeds to laugh at him with nothing else happening. Zyori's case is he ended up having sex and there were mixed feelings. Jimmy's case seems more benign than zyoris.
Now that doesn't mean Jimmy is innocent of what the anonymous accuser has mentioned. I can understand if you don't like jimmy for being a creep at a party sure. But in regards to JUST elaine, he spent his time with her, he tried, nothing happened. And she is the only one who came forward with something concrete. We need the person who said he grinded on her with an erection to really give further details or the person who said he tried to pull her panties.
Sure his reactions are dimwitted, and his defense is dumb, but we still need more context to be built and evidence to be provided for me to really believe he did do it. The first defense is him probably replying to the mass influx of comments in his twitter, that one i don't blame him for. His initial reaction is poor but there's no concrete evidence to compare it to.
Unlike the other cases where there were MULTIPLE accusations and allegations that did pile up, there's only really 2 in this case and 1 is benign. The bigger picture isn't there yet for me to give the benefit of the doubt to the multiple accusers. we'll have to wait as more comes out.
|
I don't think anything else is going to come out. If Jimmy just apologized and talked about trying to reform he probably would've been back in the Dota scene later this year. His response basically killed any chance he has at ever coming back.
I'll sum up my thoughts on Jimmy with the #1 thing I disliked the most about his response. The statement of,
"If boy started to casually touch girl, and girl is horrified by it, she could’ve easily just walked away before he ‘grabbed her underwear.” Grabbing someone’s underwear sounds like a lot of effort. In essence, this may not be the best ‘defense’ or 'explanation' on my part only because once again, this claim is flat out dubious."
If you actually believe that then you should probably do what people have been ironically advising and get a written statement before you have sex with someone because holy yikes.
|
On June 30 2020 06:42 overt wrote: I don't think anything else is going to come out. If Jimmy just apologized and talked about trying to reform he probably would've been back in the Dota scene later this year. His response basically killed any chance he has at ever coming back.
yeah, I share the same sentiment. I don't think jimmy has multiple accusers.
So I will go on a limb to give him the benefit of the doubt, the only thing I'm holding off on is the anonymous report, but those are accusations with no one else coming forward to confirm them, and no further evidence is provided.
I'm all for cleaning up the community, but this case, this isn't it. I need to wait on Ken & Anonymous / Wicked & Anonymous. Elaine doesn't bring enough to the table to add oil to the fire. Her responses seem more vindictive than they seem credible.
His defense is bad but he's talking about the accusations levied against him. He's talking about the hypothetical situation in which it does occur and why it wouldn't. It's not good PR but it's honest. It's not enough for me to believe he admits to it though.
|
Demon has multiple, but only one named. The accusations are also more mild than the others.
|
Fair enough. I forgot that Godz, Hotbid & LD decided to part ways with him. So there's something we don't know...
Someone on reddit posted this, which I couldn't help but laugh "Classic Jimmy going for the high risk, low reward play" In reference to his defense.
|
I could live with Jimmy remaining in the scene. The things he allegedly did are things that are forgivable. I think it entirely depends if his accusers forgive him.
I didn’t read his twitlonger yet, but from the reactions from this thread —looks like he blew his chance.
|
Maybe everyone will be too busy laughing at this absurd twitlonger to stay outraged. Seems like Eleine might be on board.
I feel bad finding this shit as funny as I do, 'cause it came out of something serious, but man Jimmy's writing is hilarious.
|
28104 Posts
On June 30 2020 08:49 ASoo wrote:Maybe everyone will be too busy laughing at this absurd twitlonger to stay outraged. Seems like Eleine might be on board. I feel bad finding this shit as funny as I do, 'cause it came out of something serious, but man Jimmy's writing is hilarious. I feel like him becoming more of a joke/meme due to this is probably one of the better punishments she could have hoped for. The accusation itself while bad, probably wasn't bad enough to really get him out of the community completely. At most he probably would have been shamed for a month or two, and then all of this would have been forgotten. Now he still has to live with that shame and he's also going to be ridiculed for a very long ass time lol.
|
To be honest, I don't even think the women whom he grinded on/was creepy towards would've cared if he continued on in the scene. I think they just wanted him to reflect on his interactions with women. (though I obviously don't know this for certain)
I hate terms like, "cancel culture," but Jimmy literally cancelled himself.
|
28104 Posts
On June 30 2020 09:00 overt wrote: To be honest, I don't even think the women whom he grinding on/was creepy towards would've cared if he continued on in the scene. I think they just wanted him to reflect on his interactions with women.
I hate terms like, "cancel culture," but Jimmy literally cancelled himself. Yea it's honestly hilarious. I can't even believe he wrote this.
|
[QUOTE]On June 30 2020 06:17 saocyn wrote: [QUOTE]On June 30 2020 06:05 overt wrote: We definitely don't need a Jimmy thread.
Jimmy's case with elaine can be summarized as he hit on her and verbally demonstrated his intentions, and she replied no. proceeds to laugh at him with nothing else happening. Zyori's case is he ended up having sex and there were mixed feelings. Jimmy's case seems more benign than zyoris.
[/QUOTE]
I will agree with you that all of 'these guys' made the mistake of mixing business and pleasure....I am gonna object to your characterization of Zyoris actions as being less benign with Jimmy's... In the end mixing personal and business is simply not a question of morality but professionalism. That the silly narrative that bosses sleeping with employee's is innately predatory has been allowed to be perpetuated is just obtuse. If having potential power over your job means someone should never engage with you sexually because of the power differential is just ignoring reality. In 99.9% of heterosexual relationships the male has far greater potential power of the woman than just her job prospects.... Physically, he will almost always have the ability to kill rape or batter her....
Either you define 'Predatory behavior" to be exercising the potential power differential to take advantage of the other person.....
Or you define "Predatory behavior' to even entering a relationship with a power differential that could be exploited to take advantage of the other.
If the Latter is your definition.... You have literally just claimed 99.9% of all sexual relationships throughout history have been 'predatory".....and of an order of magnitude more predatory than Zyori in a boss/employee relationship would be...
I don't hate on Zyori for caving to the pressures of moral busybodies given the the utter unchecked destruction they have been pushing through every social institution in Western societies. For all I know the poor guy has had his mind damaged by this ideological clap trap and he really believes he did something morally wrong. But while he made a respectable statement.... the fact that he pushes the narrative is indication that he has not made progress but rather that he has now adopted simplistic, delusional understandings about power dynamics in social interactions....
The only 'immoral' thing Zyori may have done was if he had an agreement with his company that he wouldn't date fellow employee's and violated that, or the little immorality of possibly hurting his employer by engaging in a relationship within the office....
|
|
|
Looks like Jimbo gonna live with the meme. Which is totally befitting of his character.
|
On June 30 2020 05:26 TheEmulator wrote:Show nested quote +On June 30 2020 05:24 overt wrote:This is actually the worst response to accusations you could ever make. Did anyone read this and think, "wow it seems like DeMoN is innocent of everything," ? Absolutely wild that an actual human being wrote this. It goes heavily against PR 101. It's almost laughable how often he's like "I'm sorry, but..." It's funny to me when men refer to themselves as "Playboy's" because hugh Hefner spent his life paying women to make his friends horny and hang out at a house that became so disgusting it had an outbreak of legionnaires disease
Pretty much one of the worst examples of a "suave" man.
|
On June 30 2020 10:55 saocyn wrote:clips.twitch.tvPurge talking to Slacks about jimmy's line lololol
I looked at that clip 10 times and I'm still laughing. :D
|
|
|
|
|
|