|
We understand that this topic evokes strong feelings. In the interest of maintaining a necessary and productive discussion, we will be taking a strong stance against posters that clearly do not contribute to this aim. Dishonest and bad faith arguments, victim blaming, and attacks on other users, will be strictly moderated. A post which only serves to muddy the waters and dishonestly portray the nature of assault and harassment (and corresponding accusations) is also unwelcome. This is a serious topic. Please treat it as such. If you have feedback on how we should approach this topic on LiquidDota, please see here. |
United States15275 Posts
On June 28 2020 05:31 saocyn wrote:on Another Topic Kips writes a post, exonerating Zyori with the approval of Meruna https://medium.com/@KipspulZyori had a classy response i can't fault the guy at all.
Not sure I enjoy or approve of the equivocation present in the article. Regarding the seriousness of Ashni's claims, "subtle rape" - whether it was intentional or not - qualifies as a traumatic criminal offense that was furthermore publicly claimed. It's not like she can turn back the clock and absolve Zyori of his offenses to make this disappear down the memory hole. If Ashni holds onto her original statement, it deserves police investigation and possibly a trial regardless of whether Zyori deserves to painted as a irredeemable felon. If it's not true, an apology should be rendered at minimum.
Filing charges is up to the victim (and Ashni still has years of wiggle room according to California law), but I find frivolous to act like claims of sexual assault can be advanced or retracted at will as if it's just a private dispute between friends.
|
On June 28 2020 05:55 CosmicSpiral wrote:Not sure I enjoy or approve of the equivocation present in the article. Regarding the seriousness of Ashni's claims, "subtle rape" - whether it was intentional or not - qualifies as a traumatic criminal offense that was furthermore publicly claimed. It's not like she can turn back the clock and absolve Zyori of his offenses to make this disappear down the memory hole. If Ashni holds onto her original statement, it deserves police investigation and possibly a trial regardless of whether Zyori deserves to painted as a irredeemable felon. If it's not true, an apology should be rendered at minimum. Filing charges is up to the victim (and Ashni still has years of wiggle room according to California law), but I find frivolous to act like claims of sexual assault can be advanced or retracted at will as if it's just a private dispute between friends.
that's the larger issue at hand. We are in a time where, people FEEL like they can come out and speak about these things, I don't think it's right that we stifle their voice when it's already difficult enough to come out about these allegations.
On the other hand, if you do come out with allegations and receive support, yeah i think there is some responsibility on your behalf to clarify the accusations so it's crystal clear what was done.
The question is should she be able to talk about her abuse openly and get supported regardless of what degree the allegations are? absolutely. Does that mean court, police, etc need to be involved to come out? no.
Last i checked no one has broken ties with zyori. In fact BTS got the brunt of the flack FOR previously employing both kips, zyori, grant, demon and toby. I don't see JoinDOTA getting the flack for employing Toby for 7 years while all this was happening on their watch. That's the outrage.
|
Luke Cotton releases a 3rd statement.
He's doing a lot of backpedaling with 3 different narratives. Seems like there's more in play, it feels like there's upper management putting pressure on Luke to settle this.
and it makes sense. James has no beef with luke, luke leveraged 3 statements against James in order to protect his business interest. Now the real question is why does Luke care about PAUL that much? sure he's one of the co-owners, you could always replace him, what's in it for luke to keep paul on the roster and to deny James the ability to enact justice on Paul?
The irony of James first statement was that they would threaten and blackmail him if he released the statement, luke cotton proved just that by releasing 3 statements attempting to silence him and or get his way.
|
United States15275 Posts
On June 28 2020 06:12 saocyn wrote: that's the larger issue at hand. We are in a time where, people FEEL like they can come out and speak about these things, I don't think it's right that we stifle their voice when it's already difficult enough to come out about these allegations.
On the other hand, if you do come out with allegations and receive support, yeah i think there is some responsibility on your behalf to clarify the accusations so it's crystal clear what was done.
The question is should she be able to talk about her abuse openly and get supported regardless of what degree the allegations are? absolutely. Does that mean court, police, etc need to be involved to come out? no.
Last i checked no one has broken ties with zyori. In fact BTS got the brunt of the flack FOR previously employing both kips, zyori, grant, demon and toby. I don't see JoinDOTA getting the flack for employing Toby for 7 years while all this was happening on their watch. That's the outrage.
I'm not debating whether this ought to be a career-ending allegation for Zyori. My position is if you make a public accusation of a named individual and the alleged crime turns out to be true, the police should get involved as a matter of course. The decision to press charges comes afterwards and it is her decision alone. In most cases of sexual assault and rape, the victim is trapped in a private affair and must visit a medical center/contact police/call 911. Then it becomes public record and once the perpetrator is identified, the same decision applies.
Rape is one of the worst offenses morally and legally. Extenuating circumstances aside, I don't see why Kips should bury the hatchet other than convenience or reluctance to make the situation more harrowing than it is. When a person commits a crime the court of law should determine the severity of sentence, not the court of public opinion. If Ashni doesn't want to see that, then she should disavow the word "rape" as a proper description of that night.
I'm being hard-nosed on this topic because I don't believe what constitutes actual crimes should be processed, judged, and put to rest within the community even if the end result is salutary. We're not exempt from regular society like the Italian mob. This whole series of debacles stems from the attitude.
|
How many times do people have to be told that what's legal isn't equal to what's right, just because there isn't enough evidence to convict someone doesn't mean they did nothing wrong. It's super fucking weird that people always fall back on this to defend against allegations of sexual harassment/assault
|
On June 28 2020 06:51 CosmicSpiral wrote:Show nested quote +On June 28 2020 06:12 saocyn wrote: that's the larger issue at hand. We are in a time where, people FEEL like they can come out and speak about these things, I don't think it's right that we stifle their voice when it's already difficult enough to come out about these allegations.
On the other hand, if you do come out with allegations and receive support, yeah i think there is some responsibility on your behalf to clarify the accusations so it's crystal clear what was done.
The question is should she be able to talk about her abuse openly and get supported regardless of what degree the allegations are? absolutely. Does that mean court, police, etc need to be involved to come out? no.
Last i checked no one has broken ties with zyori. In fact BTS got the brunt of the flack FOR previously employing both kips, zyori, grant, demon and toby. I don't see JoinDOTA getting the flack for employing Toby for 7 years while all this was happening on their watch. That's the outrage. I'm not debating whether this ought to be a career-ending allegation for Zyori. My position is if you make a public accusation of a named individual and the alleged crime turns out to be true, the police should get involved as a matter of course. The decision to press charges comes afterwards and it is her decision alone. In most cases of sexual assault and rape, the victim is trapped in a private affair and must visit a medical center/contact police/call 911. Then it becomes public record and once the perpetrator is identified, the same decision applies. Rape one of the worst offenses. Extenuating circumstances aside, I don't see why Kips should bury the hatchet other than convenience or reluctance to make the situation more harrowing than it is. When a person commits a crime the court of law should determine the severity of sentence, not the court of public opinion. If Ashni doesn't want to see that, then she should disavow the word "rape" as a proper description of that night. I'm being hard-nosed on this topic because I don't believe what constitutes actual crimes should be processed, judged, and put to rest within the community even if the end result is salutary. We're not exempt from regular society like the Italian mob. This whole series of debacles stems from that attitude.
We don't live in a perfect world where due process happens immediately every time. America is probably one of the worst places economically to allow you to pursue these avenues. Remember, the victim faces not just rejection from her peers and family, but also repercussion from her employer, especially if that person she is with has a business relationship. These things inflict trauma, embarrassment, shame, guilt and silences the victim which is why it takes so long to come out, if they even ever do. It's not a straight forward logical process the way you describe it. It's not yup, he raped me, we're taking it to court now.
Police are the least trusted at this time, and these things are rarely ever settled by police.
Sure i agree with some of the misuse of the word, as i've agreed before. Allegations should be set straight if they do come out. but i'm also on the side of it being better to allow the victim to come out at all, than never being able to. We're only seeing back lash now from cancel culture, but you also must realize for the longest time the corrupt in position of power has been able to silence and repress the victims for a very long time. From Trump with his NDA's and Tobi with Kelly Ong. Tobi was effectively able to slut shame and turn an entire community against her and Cyborggmat simply due to him being the face of dota. I'd rather the corrupt never be allowed to use the means of settling matters in private, for these people in power can always pay it off and be done with it.
These people in power like Tobi were able to remove people from attendance contractually simply because he didn't like their race. It's time we stopped these people from abusing the power of settling it in private. You don't just get to settle it with money, we settle it with justice. We mourn for these victims, feel empathy for them because some of us know or are the victims themselves. You don't just get to run roughshod over another person's life simply because you're in a position of power.
|
I also petition the title of the thread be changed to Sexual Harassment & Abuse, so it's not just sexual abuse.
The red-eye situation is drama but mostly abuse.
TL;DR: Pyrion says it's been a long time coming. On a persona level red-eye was nothing but nice to him, but he's seen pretty outlandish behavior from him like the way he yells at staff. Had to do damage control behind his back because of how bad it was. He's a narcissist with an ego who needs help. Claims EVERYONE has a story about red-eye.
Pyrion Flax speaks on Red Eye clips.twitch.tv
Full vod starts here www.twitch.tv
So we're gonna be seeing a lot about this guy soon.
|
United States15275 Posts
On June 28 2020 06:59 TomatoBisque wrote: How many times do people have to be told that what's legal isn't equal to what's right, just because there isn't enough evidence to convict someone doesn't mean they did nothing wrong. It's super fucking weird that people always fall back on this to defend against allegations of sexual harassment/assault
I assume you're being facetious or you went temporarily blind when reading my post. I said the opposite.
On June 28 2020 07:03 saocyn wrote: We don't live in a perfect world where due process happens immediately every time. America is probably one of the worst places economically to allow you to pursue these avenues. Remember, the victim faces not both rejection from her peers and family, but also repercussion from her employer, especially if that person she is with, has a business relationship as well. These things inflict trauma, embarrassment, shame, guilt and silences the victim which is why it takes so long to come out. It's not a straight forward logical process the way you describe it. It's not yup, he raped me, we're taking it to court now.
The victim is already facing possible rejection from all said parties because she broadcasted the accusation publicly. Due process has been thrown out the window and the opinions of strangers or mere acquisitions will largely dictate the future of her career. It is hardly more equitable or just to let this scenario remain nebulous because it makes the in-crowd happy. Imagine what happens if known Dota 2 talent support her publicly but shun her privately because they couldn't read her motivations here. Imagine what happens if the people grousing over her "getting off scot-free" start a personal vendetta because they can tell themselves she was a liar and manipulator. There will never be any resolution.
The point of making this a "straight forward logical process" is giving victims recourse to an (supposedly) far-reaching, neutral institution that defends her rights without self-interest. Not a crowd whose whims shift with the breeze, not a select group of Dota 2 insiders who must hash out the pragmatic benefits and drawbacks of taking her side. Otherwise she becomes a pawn to whatever conflicting narratives are popular within the community. Sorry, she is one right now: her perceived integrity depends on whether the individual in question believes her account, not whether it actually happened.
On June 28 2020 07:03 saocyn wrote: Police are the least trusted at this time, and these things are rarely ever settled by police.
Whether or not the case goes to court, the Dota 2 community needs to recognize internal disputes can't stay internal forever. And unlike the subreddit, the police has no stakes to distort their view of events. I assure you, this won't be settled by the community either. People will despise and slander Ashni for years over this fiasco regardless of the truth.
On June 28 2020 07:03 saocyn wrote: Sure i agree with some of the misuse of the word, as i've agreed before. Allegations should be set straight if they do come out. but i'm also on the side of it being better to allow the victim to come out at all, than never being able to.
Which is an investigation's function. This is especially pertinent when dealing with rape, notorious for the paucity of clear evidence and figuring out how much autonomy plays into borderline cases.
Note I don't believe Zyori actually raped her or forced her into unwilling sex based on all the available evidence. But that shouldn't be my call, nor the collective opinion of other people who either have no connection to the situation or too much conflict of interest.
On June 28 2020 07:03 saocyn wrote: We're only seeing back lash now from cancel culture, but you also must realize for the longest time the corrupt in position of power has been able to silence and repress the victims for a very long time. From Trump with his NDA's and Tobi with Kelly Ong. Tobi was effectively able to slut shame and turn an entire community against her and Cyborgmatt simply due to him being the face of dota. I'd rather the corrupt never be allowed to use the means of settling matters in private, for these people in power can always pay it off and be done with it.
Sigh...that's my entire point. We can't keep having these controversies devolve into mudslinging battles of reputation, with the results dictated by a fanbase with far too much emotional investment to support or denounce anything clearly (just look at the rationalizations people gave to excuse Tobi's endemic creepiness). These Twitter apologetics and hoop-jumping antics are due to people prioritizing optics above everything else. And this will continue forever as long as the Dota 2 community insists on staying insular with regard to how it resolves its problems. Let's not pretend those in power won't find new ways to cow and intimidate people they're offended, nor that the vague parameters regarding interaction within the scene won't continue to produce disaffected, angry, and conceited members.
I may not like the police but I'd select LAPD or SART in a heartbeat to handle this case over handling over duties to Twitter, the antithesis of objective, impartial and dedicated to looking out for people's well-being.
On June 28 2020 07:03 saocyn wrote: These people in power like Tobi were able to remove people from attendance contractually simply because he didn't like their race. It's time we stopped these people from abusing the power of settling it in private. You don't just get to settle it with money, we settle it with justice. We mourn for these victims, feel empathy for them because some of us know or are the victims themselves. You don't just get to run roughshod over another person's life simply because you're in a position of power.
Then make them answerable to a higher power that couldn't give a fig about their popularity or standing.
|
Red Eyes Response
Response to Redeyes Response
|
On June 28 2020 06:59 TomatoBisque wrote: How many times do people have to be told that what's legal isn't equal to what's right, just because there isn't enough evidence to convict someone doesn't mean they did nothing wrong. It's super fucking weird that people always fall back on this to defend against allegations of sexual harassment/assault
You seem to have decided to fall on the side of calling relations between people with different power dynamics immoral....your welcome to that opinion.
Knowing 3 women who have had such relationships.... I will relay the general take on Zyori/Ashni situation as they all three agree:
"I am horrified that my Son will have to grow up in this atmosphere." As for the one of the three that was held down and raped by two seniors when she was 14..... yeah she thinks Ashne's description of her situation as rape to be a tad pathetic...
So you are welcome to your opinion.....
But the world you think we should have is a fictional delusion....
|
On June 28 2020 09:27 Toc1982 wrote:Show nested quote +On June 28 2020 06:59 TomatoBisque wrote: How many times do people have to be told that what's legal isn't equal to what's right, just because there isn't enough evidence to convict someone doesn't mean they did nothing wrong. It's super fucking weird that people always fall back on this to defend against allegations of sexual harassment/assault You seem to have decided to fall on the side of calling relations between people with different power dynamics immoral....your welcome to that opinion. Knowing 3 women who have had such relationships.... I will relay the general take on Zyori/Ashni situation as they all three agree: "I am horrified that my Son will have to grow up in this atmosphere." As for the one of the three that was held down and raped by two seniors when she was 14..... yeah she thinks Ashne's description of her situation as rape to be a tad pathetic... So you are welcome to your opinion..... But the world you think we should have is a fictional delusion.... Your response has pretty much nothing to do with what I said or the context of the situation. Let me make it clear:
Zyori did something wrong. We do not need a judicial court to determine that he did something wrong. That said, his career should not end or be otherwise damaged. People can do bad things without being bad people or having it ruin their life. He has shown he understands it was wrong as well as the mindset he had that lead to this behavior. No one (including the accusers!) believes there was any malice or otherwise ill-will in his heart. The usage of "rape" in the accusations was bad, but it does not mean that Ashni and Kips should be punished, because again, people can do bad things without requiring their life to be ruined as a result, and they did not have malice in their hearts when coming out with this information.
If you still think I'm delusional then I don't know what to tell you.
On June 28 2020 07:23 saocyn wrote:I also petition the title of the thread be changed to Sexual Harassment & Abuse, so it's not just sexual abuse. The red-eye situation is drama but mostly abuse. TL;DR: Pyrion says it's been a long time coming. On a persona level red-eye was nothing but nice to him, but he's seen pretty outlandish behavior from him like the way he yells at staff. Had to do damage control behind his back because of how bad it was. He's a narcissist with an ego who needs help. Claims EVERYONE has a story about red-eye. Pyrion Flax speaks on Red Eye clips.twitch.tvFull vod starts here www.twitch.tvSo we're gonna be seeing a lot about this guy soon. Having personally known narcissists, everything Flax said in that clip is a huge fucking red flag to me, and the bit about Redeye being nice to him personally means nothing. Narcissists need constant praise and admiration, and what better way to get it than doing good things for others? Now, doing good things for other people is good, but I make this point specifically because it is not, should not, and can not be used as a defense for the rest of Redeye's actions.
I don't really know what to say about this because my experience is that these kinds of people are beyond help and are toxic to every community and relationship that they involve themselves in, but I am also incredibly biased.
|
The main reason I have for not wanting to rename the thread to harassment/abuse is because the main story is how pervasive those acts (and general sexual misconduct) were in the scene. This thread was for talking about the culture and smaller incidents overall, while the others were for specific massive allegations against specific high profile community members.
So far there are only really two notable people accused of non sexual misconduct - Grant and Redeye. Grant was also accused of sexual misconduct directly, and Redeye has been accused of it in a vague manor ("rumors say" "no one willing to go on record but" sorts of things). Redeye is also not a primarily DotA personality - he seems even bigger in CSGO, and of course quake before that.
That said, I'll still mention it to other members of the staff and get their opinion.
(In the future, this can be brought up in website feedback. It gets checked more often than individual threads, usually).
|
What RedEye reminds me very much of why BBC fire Jeremy Clarkson . Reason I bring this up, is that Amazon just after hired him to host a bunch of show to bring in more viewer to Amazon Prime. They also own Twitch so wondering if people are gonna boycut Twitch now.
|
I think the organisations haven't done enough to protect people. As a consumer I have a decision to make. Should I keep my twitch subscription to BTS and others? Should I buy a battlepass? As of now I have not seen enough evidence of these organisations to support or take sufficient action to justify me supporting them financially and since money is where it hurts most I have decided to unsubscribe most of my Dota 2 twitch subscriptions and not buy the battlepass. I am only one person so it probably means nothing to them but consciously I cannot support these organisations that failed to take basic measures to provide a safe place when allegations and concerns were already raised.
|
On June 28 2020 21:22 volvo fix matchmakin wrote: I think the organisations haven't done enough to protect people. As a consumer I have a decision to make. Should I keep my twitch subscription to BTS and others? Should I buy a battlepass? As of now I have not seen enough evidence of these organisations to support or take sufficient action to justify me supporting them financially and since money is where it hurts most I have decided to unsubscribe most of my Dota 2 twitch subscriptions and not buy the battlepass. I am only one person so it probably means nothing to them but consciously I cannot support these organisations that failed to take basic measures to provide a safe place when allegations and concerns were already raised. Then again, if you havent bought BP until now, it's unlikely that the recent scandals had any impact on that decision.
Coincidentally, the revenue from BP points purchases skyrocketed in the past week, so I think it's really unwise to correlate finances with the healthiness of the scene/community. If that were the case, Valve should orchestrate a scandal every other month or so, since it seems to boost the sales. + Show Spoiler +(actually I have no idea why the spike happened, but it did in the same time as these stories broke)
|
The spike is from the battlepass points bundle being released. Obviously is good to vote with your wallet when you want to influence a company. One individual's purchases may not be much aggregated they will have an impact, probably more so to the smaller actors BTS, streamers etc rather than valve's dota revenue but still it's all forwards. No reasons to financially support a company you don't find worthwhile supporting.
|
|
|
Redeye is stepping away from esports
|
Lalalaland34510 Posts
Probably worth a separate thread.
|
Netherlands6192 Posts
|
|
|
|
|
|