|
On January 16 2018 03:33 Faruko wrote: You give him enough notice because it's ilegal to fire someone without a month prior notice, not because he is your friend
at least in Chile This is the nation of Esports, where I’m not even sure players are considered employees. Being a member of a team in Esports works on Uber employment logic, where the player is whatever gives them the least rights and burdens the team with the fewest responsibilities
|
professionalize is the next logical step in the esports scene, but i doubt they even know what that word means
|
On January 16 2018 03:35 teddyoojo wrote: holy shit u act like competition is a real work environment like ur 9-5 jobs
rofl its almost like u think him not getting a paycheck is the issue I don’t give a shit what his specific paycheck issue is. This is the reality for all Esports. Players have no rights and can be fucked over at a moment’s notice. And if they were all making bank, that would be great. But the millions upon millions going into Dota isn’t making it to all the pro players. They are at the bottom of the food chain.
|
slomo + goody stacks when? also hang in there buddy, if there's a good thing out of it all you're back to posting here at a greater frequency and im sure we all enjoy your company in the thread
|
hows this different from any sports? opportunity to get someone better u get someone better and bench the former i dont get it
|
On January 16 2018 03:35 teddyoojo wrote: holy shit u act like competition is a real work environment like ur 9-5 jobs
rofl its almost like u think him not getting a paycheck is the issue I dont act. I tell you how it is from the organisations standpoint. If the team wanted to kick him, so be it. But be honest about it and tell him before you use him to qualify for a major and dispose him an hour later. I put the blame on fnatic as organisation, not EE or anyone else.
I still feel like you never worked at a place where people arent dicks towards each other.
On January 16 2018 03:36 Plansix wrote:Show nested quote +On January 16 2018 03:33 Faruko wrote: You give him enough notice because it's ilegal to fire someone without a month prior notice, not because he is your friend
at least in Chile This is the nation of Esports, where I’m not even sure players are considered employees. Being a member of a team in Esports works on Uber employment logic, where the player is whatever gives them the least rights and burdens the team with the fewest responsibilities This is the sad truth. Nobody cares about any contracts. Its all about short term goals and burning bridges.
|
On January 16 2018 03:44 2009 wrote: slomo + goody stacks when? also hang in there buddy, if there's a good thing out of it all you're back to posting here at a greater frequency and im sure we all enjoy your company in the thread Probably not at all because of timezones.
|
On January 16 2018 03:47 teddyoojo wrote: hows this different from any sports? opportunity to get someone better u get someone better and bench the former i dont get it ?????
Most players in professional sports are part of a union or have contracts that are enforceable. There isn’t a professional sports team in the US that could have pulled that fnatic just pulled. They would be facing a lawsuit for breach of contract and a lawsuit from the player’s union. Because normal professional sports players realized long ago that it could be any of them. Esports players haven’t figured that shit out yet.
|
I don't think people know exactly what happens with his contract. Fnatic said in their "press release" that Ohaiyo would stay in the org for now but has been given the permission to pursue other options. It seems to me that they simply removed him from the starting lineup, they didn't somehow throw the contract in the bin and stop all salary etc. But ofc I'm guessing based on how they framed it.
Concerning the time, it's specifically the roster shuffle period Valve has assigned so there is not anything weird about the timing in that way. It just so happens that due to the packed schedule there are qualifiers going on at the same time, and for whatever reason Universe couldn't get there before the quals started although clearly they made the decision some time before if he had time to fly over there. The questionable thing is not letting Ohaiyo know immediately after they made the decision, but of course the team doesn't want to risk them performing poorly if the atmosphere becomes terrible and Ohaiyo has little incentive to try his best.
|
On January 16 2018 03:51 Plansix wrote:Show nested quote +On January 16 2018 03:47 teddyoojo wrote: hows this different from any sports? opportunity to get someone better u get someone better and bench the former i dont get it ????? Most players in professional sports are part of a union or have contracts that are enforceable. There isn’t a professional sports team in the US that could have pulled that fnatic just pulled. They would be facing a lawsuit for breach of contract and a lawsuit from the player’s union. Because normal professional sports players realized long ago that it could be any of them. Esports players haven’t figured that shit out yet. ?????
its not like they tore up his contract they literally said hes off the starting 5 which is literally what would happen in any sports
|
On January 16 2018 03:56 teddyoojo wrote:Show nested quote +On January 16 2018 03:51 Plansix wrote:On January 16 2018 03:47 teddyoojo wrote: hows this different from any sports? opportunity to get someone better u get someone better and bench the former i dont get it ????? Most players in professional sports are part of a union or have contracts that are enforceable. There isn’t a professional sports team in the US that could have pulled that fnatic just pulled. They would be facing a lawsuit for breach of contract and a lawsuit from the player’s union. Because normal professional sports players realized long ago that it could be any of them. Esports players haven’t figured that shit out yet. ????? its not like they tore up his contract they literally said hes off the starting 5 which is literally what would happen in any sports Benched players still get paid the same amount. When a team wins the super bowl, they all get paid the prize money and get a ring. Even the back up players. In this case, he doesn’t get to play and doesn’t’ get to win Dota prize money, despite being on the team through qualifiers. Unless you have some top secret inside information that the prize money is being split 6 ways if they win.
Again, no professional sports team would be able to pull that in the US. The teams win collectively.
|
Aren't professional sports in the US rather ruthless for the fringe players? Hard to compare a dota team of 5 to some hockey team for example, but from what I understand most players in the NHL can be traded to another team without asking them just because the back office likes the deal. Their salary runs the same of course, but you still have to take your family and so on and move it elsewhere. Also as a young player you can't decide which team you want to go to but instead you get drafted. If you get to a team with terrible management, bad luck.
|
It depends on the sport and the trading rules. Most players have some level of stability and can expect to be in a city for a fully season or so. But the pay scale is on a whole different level for almost every professional sport in the US. Moving to a new city isn’t as big of an ask for them.
|
Sounds like your issue is that dota isn't fully established yet? It'll get there, it just takes time
|
On January 16 2018 04:35 Nevuk wrote: Sounds like your issue is that dota isn't fully established yet? It'll get there, it just takes time Or it will never get there because Valve owns all of Dota 2 and can end the entire Dota 2 thing at any time. I’m sure that will be once the new cash cow comes in and they don’t have people invested in doing shit like TI any more.
|
The possibility of moving comes with the job. Can't really do a lot about that, it being US sports or not.
|
On January 16 2018 03:50 Slomo wrote:Show nested quote +On January 16 2018 03:44 2009 wrote: slomo + goody stacks when? also hang in there buddy, if there's a good thing out of it all you're back to posting here at a greater frequency and im sure we all enjoy your company in the thread Probably not at all because of timezones. idk man he invited me a few days ago at like 6pm CET except i was afk at the time
|
Not sure how the dota scene (or some other one) could get structured in the future in a way that makes sense. As a viewer I selfishly like that it's sort of free for all where everyone just tries to win and people aren't really stuck on teams, but of course opinions differ. As I've said many times in the past in different threads, I think it's a mistake to directly compare dota or esports in general to team sports. In a lot of ways it's closer to something like tennis. I don't know all the revenue streams of tennis players, but from what I gather the sport is also pretty top heavy. If you are good and popular, you make a lot of prize money and a lot of sponsorship revenue. If you are ranked 200, you may not be making all that much, especially if you happen to get injured.
One issue in dota is that not many players are trying actively to get other revenue streams and instead are just going for the prize money. Of course it takes time and it's understandable that players don't think about it that much, but at some point I'd expect them to start getting better help to get individual sponsorships and so on. In my view an individual sponsorship of let's say Arteezy could make a lot more sense than sponsoring a team that Arteezy is on but may leave in 2 months.
|
On January 16 2018 04:38 Plansix wrote:Show nested quote +On January 16 2018 04:35 Nevuk wrote: Sounds like your issue is that dota isn't fully established yet? It'll get there, it just takes time Or it will never get there because Valve owns all of Dota 2 and can end the entire Dota 2 thing at any time. I’m sure that will be once the new cash cow comes in and they don’t have people invested in doing shit like TI any more. Honestly? There's still WC3 dota, HoN is still around. I'm sure someone would clone it again if Valve just shut it all down for some reason. (I think this is all pretty unlikely but the only thing with a similarly long lasting, large competitive scene to Dota is CS. Maybe melee, maybe broodwar (blizzard's sc2 strategy lol)
|
There is always another modern day feudalistic lord willing to let you work the land they own for a small cut.
|
|
|
|
|
|