I think TLJ had some interesting meta-commentary on the staleness of The Hero's Journey formula and the copy-pasted feel of TFA but failed to ultimately rise above the light-dark dichotomy in any meaningful way and instead ended in perhaps the most cliche way it possibly could. Perhaps that was intentional, to bait-and-switch the audience twice in the same film by teasing a more nuanced narrative before coming right back down into the same tropes, but it ultimately felt like a tonal rollercoaster with a few standout scenes and some unrealized potential.
Not a bad film overall, but anyone who has any investment in the actual Star Wars saga will, by design, be disappointed by this movie. It's the most ambitious one in the entire franchise by no small margin, and it's the most technically adept one as well in terms of the actual filmmaking, but its circuitous means of reaching the end of film (likely pre-written for Rian Johnson, thus explaining the atonal fuckfest it turned out to be) make it a less than stellar experience on first watch.
I think TLJ had some interesting meta-commentary on the staleness of The Hero's Journey formula and the copy-pasted feel of TFA but failed to ultimately rise above the light-dark dichotomy in any meaningful way and instead ended in perhaps the most cliche way it possibly could. Perhaps that was intentional, to bait-and-switch the audience twice in the same film by teasing a more nuanced narrative before coming right back down into the same tropes, but it ultimately felt like a tonal rollercoaster with a few standout scenes and some unrealized potential.
Not a bad film overall, but anyone who has any investment in the actual Star Wars saga will, by design, be disappointed by this movie. It's the most ambitious one in the entire franchise by no small margin, and it's the most technically adept one as well in terms of the actual filmmaking, but its circuitous means of reaching the end of film (likely pre-written for Rian Johnson, thus explaining the atonal fuckfest it turned out to be) make it a less than stellar experience on first watch.
Nothing was pre-written for Rian Johnson. It is the second movie of a trilogy, so of course there are some constraints, but he had full freedom to do what he wanted. Any flaws of the movie were his own.
That is part of the problem. It could have worked as an individual movie, it is terrible as a sequel to TFA. There is no unified vision. If this movie was about breaking norms, TFA was all about following the SW norms to the letter.
I think TLJ had some interesting meta-commentary on the staleness of The Hero's Journey formula and the copy-pasted feel of TFA but failed to ultimately rise above the light-dark dichotomy in any meaningful way and instead ended in perhaps the most cliche way it possibly could. Perhaps that was intentional, to bait-and-switch the audience twice in the same film by teasing a more nuanced narrative before coming right back down into the same tropes, but it ultimately felt like a tonal rollercoaster with a few standout scenes and some unrealized potential.
Not a bad film overall, but anyone who has any investment in the actual Star Wars saga will, by design, be disappointed by this movie. It's the most ambitious one in the entire franchise by no small margin, and it's the most technically adept one as well in terms of the actual filmmaking, but its circuitous means of reaching the end of film (likely pre-written for Rian Johnson, thus explaining the atonal fuckfest it turned out to be) make it a less than stellar experience on first watch.
Nothing was pre-written for Rian Johnson. It is the second movie of a trilogy, so of course there are some constraints, but he had full freedom to do what he wanted. Any flaws of the movie were his own.
That is part of the problem. It could have worked as an individual movie, it is terrible as a sequel to TFA. There is no unified vision. If this movie was about breaking norms, TFA was all about following the SW norms to the letter.
I meant the ending was likely decided for him. I doubt he would have actually been allowed to follow through on the promise of breaking the formula, because, as you said, there is still a third movie to be made. Certain characters needed certain things to happen to them in order to come into the final film in the right spot. Kylo Ren and Rey, for instance, could not have actually become allies and tried to bring down the Jedi/Sith dichotomy, because they need to be enemies for there to be any impetus in the plot of the third film.
And yes, the movie suffers from those constraints. I think the Rian Johnson version of this film could have been much better. It is the constraints of working within the Disnefied franchise that Star Wars is now that I think is the cause of most of the tonal conflicts and the biggest missteps.
I think TLJ had some interesting meta-commentary on the staleness of The Hero's Journey formula and the copy-pasted feel of TFA but failed to ultimately rise above the light-dark dichotomy in any meaningful way and instead ended in perhaps the most cliche way it possibly could. Perhaps that was intentional, to bait-and-switch the audience twice in the same film by teasing a more nuanced narrative before coming right back down into the same tropes, but it ultimately felt like a tonal rollercoaster with a few standout scenes and some unrealized potential.
Not a bad film overall, but anyone who has any investment in the actual Star Wars saga will, by design, be disappointed by this movie. It's the most ambitious one in the entire franchise by no small margin, and it's the most technically adept one as well in terms of the actual filmmaking, but its circuitous means of reaching the end of film (likely pre-written for Rian Johnson, thus explaining the atonal fuckfest it turned out to be) make it a less than stellar experience on first watch.
Nothing was pre-written for Rian Johnson. It is the second movie of a trilogy, so of course there are some constraints, but he had full freedom to do what he wanted. Any flaws of the movie were his own.
That is part of the problem. It could have worked as an individual movie, it is terrible as a sequel to TFA. There is no unified vision. If this movie was about breaking norms, TFA was all about following the SW norms to the letter.
I meant the ending was likely decided for him. I doubt he would have actually been allowed to follow through on the promise of breaking the formula, because, as you said, there is still a third movie to be made. Certain characters needed certain things to happen to them in order to come into the final film in the right spot. Kylo Ren and Rey, for instance, could not have actually become allies and tried to bring down the Jedi/Sith dichotomy, because they need to be enemies for there to be any impetus in the plot of the third film.
And yes, the movie suffers from those constraints. I think the Rian Johnson version of this film could have been much better. It is the constraints of working within the Disnefied franchise that Star Wars is now that I think is the cause of most of the tonal conflicts and the biggest missteps.
I think TLJ had some interesting meta-commentary on the staleness of The Hero's Journey formula and the copy-pasted feel of TFA but failed to ultimately rise above the light-dark dichotomy in any meaningful way and instead ended in perhaps the most cliche way it possibly could. Perhaps that was intentional, to bait-and-switch the audience twice in the same film by teasing a more nuanced narrative before coming right back down into the same tropes, but it ultimately felt like a tonal rollercoaster with a few standout scenes and some unrealized potential.
Not a bad film overall, but anyone who has any investment in the actual Star Wars saga will, by design, be disappointed by this movie. It's the most ambitious one in the entire franchise by no small margin, and it's the most technically adept one as well in terms of the actual filmmaking, but its circuitous means of reaching the end of film (likely pre-written for Rian Johnson, thus explaining the atonal fuckfest it turned out to be) make it a less than stellar experience on first watch.
Nothing was pre-written for Rian Johnson. It is the second movie of a trilogy, so of course there are some constraints, but he had full freedom to do what he wanted. Any flaws of the movie were his own.
That is part of the problem. It could have worked as an individual movie, it is terrible as a sequel to TFA. There is no unified vision. If this movie was about breaking norms, TFA was all about following the SW norms to the letter.
I meant the ending was likely decided for him. I doubt he would have actually been allowed to follow through on the promise of breaking the formula, because, as you said, there is still a third movie to be made. Certain characters needed certain things to happen to them in order to come into the final film in the right spot. Kylo Ren and Rey, for instance, could not have actually become allies and tried to bring down the Jedi/Sith dichotomy, because they need to be enemies for there to be any impetus in the plot of the third film.
And yes, the movie suffers from those constraints. I think the Rian Johnson version of this film could have been much better. It is the constraints of working within the Disnefied franchise that Star Wars is now that I think is the cause of most of the tonal conflicts and the biggest missteps.
He said in interviews that he had complete freedom. He received no information about what JJ Abrams planned to do with the mysteries he left in TFA or what he planned to do with the characters, and that there was no bigger picture he had to follow. He could do pretty much do whathever he wanted. There was no bigger picture he had to follow because they didn't have a planned story for the whole trilogy. They made one movie at a time.
I think it's very unlikely he was forced to end the movie a certain way considering everything he said about making it.