|
On July 24 2015 01:01 SKC wrote: Its just that you talk a lot about them for someone that doesnt care about formats. You didnt give a damn about the Bo1 groups at TI4, but complain about Bo1s outside of it. Its just weird. I don't remember the group stage of TI4 that much, only that we knew who won the winners bracket really early on and that seemed take out a bit of the hype.
I will amend my statement to say: I don't care about the specific format when it comes to brackets vs group stages, single elimination vs double. I do like all sets to be Bo3.
|
BO7 would be find if like, the last day was ONLY the finals or if it were like baseball HEHE but u know thats not possible yet i guess
|
world cup is bo1 why isn't international bo1
|
Have they ever tried a Bo7 finals for DotA 2?
|
Yes.
Remember that 0-3 comeback in DK vs iG?
|
Was it good/watchable?
On July 24 2015 01:11 SKC wrote: Yes.
Remember that 0-3 comeback in DK vs iG?
Vaguely, I wasn't really following DotA at that point. School kept me busy.
|
On July 24 2015 01:10 IntoTheheart wrote: Have they ever tried a Bo7 finals for DotA 2? ya chinese finals a lot of the time are bo7 its okay
|
I can’t remember the source, but someone said almost all pros HATE best of 7. It’s like 8-9 hours of dota once it is all said and done. I’m not a fan because I think the quality of games drops if it goes long.
|
On July 24 2015 01:12 Plansix wrote: I can’t remember the source, but someone said almost all pros HATE best of 7. It’s like 8-9 hours of dota once it is all said and done. I’m not a fan because I think the quality of games drops if it goes long. I remember reading something similar-ish regarding a Bo5 finals, and how that's an incredible amount of DotA to play.
|
Its too long. It needs a break in the middle, and some people dont like it because it kills the momentum. I dont think that its necessarily bad for that reason, sports have finals that happen for weeks, but you really dont need that many games.
|
Even a best of 5 much come to like 5-7 hours of dota if they have to play the full set and its broadcast. That’s a long time to be under a lot of stress.
|
I think a single elim tournament with full bo5 would be fine. But if you have that much time people always just do double elim. bo3 is still quite volatile.
|
Bo5 is a lot but for grand finals especially of TI I like it. Could be as few as 3 games.
Bo7 is a disgusting joke that's been tried I think twice in china to awful results and universal complaints.
The only thing "between" that I could see would be double-Bo3 finals in a double elim tournament where lower bracket contestant had to win 2 bo3s where as upper bracket had to win 1, but that seems worse overall than just Bo5 no advantage.
Last year one whole day was just finals iirc and it was pretty shit so this year its loser finals and finals together on the last day which I can get behind.
|
Yesss. Tobi + Synd casting GFs in TI. Finally!
|
I honestly would prefer a tournament of single elimination bo5 over double elim bo3 and bo1's. Only issue would be a team playing 2 bo5's in a single day but im sure theres a way around that?
|
Last year it was also on a monday morning. Its like they wanted people to think the final day never happened.
On July 24 2015 01:19 Comeh wrote: I honestly would prefer a tournament of single elimination bo5 over double elim bo3 and bo1's. Only issue would be a team playing 2 bo5's in a single day but im sure theres a way around that? Depends on how tight the schedule is. But teams have played 3 bo3s in a day which isnt that diferent. One Bo5 in the morning and one in the evening sounds tight but doable if the organization is good.
|
SoCal8933 Posts
On July 24 2015 01:17 Sn0_Man wrote: Bo5 is a lot but for grand finals especially of TI I like it. Could be as few as 3 games.
Bo7 is a disgusting joke that's been tried I think twice in china to awful results and universal complaints.
The only thing "between" that I could see would be double-Bo3 finals in a double elim tournament where lower bracket contestant had to win 2 bo3s where as upper bracket had to win 1, but that seems worse overall than just Bo5 no advantage.
Last year one whole day was just finals iirc and it was pretty shit so this year its loser finals and finals together on the last day which I can get behind.
ya im gonna agree with you.
of course people wanna see an epic Bo7 where the teams are so evenly matched, one team is on match point and the other goes on to win like 3 in a row to take it home..but is that really good for the players/fans? i feel like after game 5 or 6 you're not really playing your best dota because you've been going for 7 or 8 hours straight. i don't think a Bo7 is good for anyone, really. even the casters.
plus, who has time to watch that much DOTA in a row, usually?
as for 2 Bo3's, i would much prefer that over a winner's advantage in a Bo5 where you start up 1-0. either way, i would much rather see a Bo5 and let that be that. to me, thats like watching a football game for 4 quarters and it goes to overtime to decide the winner.
e: for starcraft, the finals better be a best of 7 or riot
|
Hey guys who do you think is the best non-JRPG videogame grill/waifuu
|
On July 24 2015 01:23 BluemoonSC wrote:Show nested quote +On July 24 2015 01:17 Sn0_Man wrote: Bo5 is a lot but for grand finals especially of TI I like it. Could be as few as 3 games.
Bo7 is a disgusting joke that's been tried I think twice in china to awful results and universal complaints.
The only thing "between" that I could see would be double-Bo3 finals in a double elim tournament where lower bracket contestant had to win 2 bo3s where as upper bracket had to win 1, but that seems worse overall than just Bo5 no advantage.
Last year one whole day was just finals iirc and it was pretty shit so this year its loser finals and finals together on the last day which I can get behind. ya im gonna agree with you. of course people wanna see an epic Bo7 where the teams are so evenly matched, one team is on match point and the other goes on to win like 3 in a row to take it home..but is that really good for the players/fans? i feel like after game 5 or 6 you're not really playing your best dota because you've been going for 7 or 8 hours straight. i don't think a Bo7 is good for anyone, really. even the casters. plus, who has time to watch that much DOTA in a row, usually? as for 2 Bo3's, i would much prefer that over a winner's advantage in a Bo5 where you start up 1-0. either way, i would much rather see a Bo5 and let that be that. to me, thats like watching a football game for 4 quarters and it goes to overtime to decide the winner. 1-0 Bo5 is how Starladder does it, and I'm pretty okay with that format.
On July 24 2015 01:24 Comeh wrote: Hey guys who do you think is the best non-JRPG videogame grill
DAO Morrigan.
|
On July 24 2015 01:24 Comeh wrote: Hey guys who do you think is the best non-JRPG videogame grill/waifuu Yennefer of Vengerberg.
|
|
|
|
|
|