|
On July 23 2015 05:58 BluemoonSC wrote:Show nested quote +On July 23 2015 05:49 Plansix wrote:On July 23 2015 05:46 BluemoonSC wrote: i mean everyone is different, developmentally..but ultimately Sumail's decision making isn't fully developed yet at that age. but that's a good thing because he's gaining a TON of experience and he will be disgusting when he reaches his full potential as he matures. Confirmed greater potential that RTZ due to earlier training. lol idk about that. he has to expand his hero pool a little further and not build euls on ember  Underdeveloped decision making skills....
On July 23 2015 05:57 dfs wrote: Fear sucked for 3 years straight. Is that now?
|
On July 23 2015 06:00 Plansix wrote:. Is that now? He did, but not really as a player but as a Captain/leader. Do you remember all the failboat Demon teams he tried to force with NA dota? That's on him.
|
fear killed eg as a captain for like 2 years
|
iirc, his support play wasn't that bad or was it
|
He clearly wasn't a good captain. But he saw that and decided to not do it any more. That is a lot better than some Dota pros and captaining skills. Sure he could have figured it out faster, but I am not really sure what the goal of bringing this up is.
At some point in their career every player is bad.
|
Russian Federation4050 Posts
That's a very weird thing to praise someone by.
|
Fear was a really good carry while he was a captain.
but jesus he had fucking JEYO on his team he had NO HOPE
|
Didn't Maelk draft for EG when he played for them
|
Russian Federation4050 Posts
Those Golden Chronospheres of Fear will always have a place in my mind.
|
On July 23 2015 05:56 Plansix wrote: Some people keep saying Fear is a bad player or not very good just because he doesn’t’ really play flashy heroes. Or PPD isn’t a good support. People will think of any number of reasons why a player on a team isn’t good, even if the team wins a lot. Armchair coaching/play calling part of all competitive everything. Really can't see how people can claim PPD as a bad support. He's like easily top 3 at what he does. He buys most consumables and yet he never dies with so few real items. Amazing player, doesn't get nowhere near the recognition he deserves for his play, most just talks about him as a good captain/drafter.
|
On July 23 2015 06:10 Rocket-Bear wrote:Show nested quote +On July 23 2015 05:56 Plansix wrote: Some people keep saying Fear is a bad player or not very good just because he doesn’t’ really play flashy heroes. Or PPD isn’t a good support. People will think of any number of reasons why a player on a team isn’t good, even if the team wins a lot. Armchair coaching/play calling part of all competitive everything. Really can't see how people can claim PPD as a bad support. He's like easily top 3 at what he does. He buys most consumables and yet he never dies with so few real items. Amazing player, doesn't get nowhere near the recognition he deserves for his play, most just talks about him as a good captain/drafter.
you don't find many people saying he's a bad support the consensus on ppd is that he is a mechanically sound player who is a very good drafter/igl/captain
you're right that he's probably still underrated but most people don't think that he's bad
|
On July 23 2015 06:10 Rocket-Bear wrote:Show nested quote +On July 23 2015 05:56 Plansix wrote: Some people keep saying Fear is a bad player or not very good just because he doesn’t’ really play flashy heroes. Or PPD isn’t a good support. People will think of any number of reasons why a player on a team isn’t good, even if the team wins a lot. Armchair coaching/play calling part of all competitive everything. Really can't see how people can claim PPD as a bad support. He's like easily top 3 at what he does. He buys most consumables and yet he never dies with so few real items. Amazing player, doesn't get nowhere near the recognition he deserves for his play, most just talks about him as a good captain/drafter. People don't respect the position 6 earthshaker who sets up almost every fight with a fissure. Or when he keeps all the towers alive forever as Tree and gets his team amazing information while not dying ever.
tehh4ck3r: I've seen people saying that Aui or Zia are better supports because they farm more and have a greater impact. Also, what Sn0_man said.
|
most haters prefer hating PPD the person rather than PPD the player
|
with campers 14 - 16 is when I find they start developing actual personalities but also when they often turn into unruly (if hilarious) little shits. Also when they start liking boys/girls/whatever which is annoying in a camp setting.
The cabin I sort of had last week was 15-ish year olds and the boys thought it was hilarious to, every time I left at night, play "guess the car" where one of them would make car sounds and the other had to guess what car it was. It's actually one of the most stupidly funny games I've heard someone play in a while. Also had the Pruis changeup for lulz.
Don't think a single car was guessed successfully lol.
I'm sure this applies to the conversation/sumail somehow
|
I have the impression that I still have recently seen people who call PPD "bad mechanically". Of course never specifying what he has actually now done poorly "mechanically".
I also don't even see that much PPD the person hate. Maybe I'm just ignoring it. He often seems confident and sometimes makes salty comments, but he isn't really awkward in doing so imo. He doesn't give as much ammunition and room to speculate about their "autism" as one other "controversial" NA player.
|
He admits he is a shit storm player and hates playing ember. But I see him play cores all the time on his stream and do well. He only consistently loses when he plays poverty dota on supports.
|
On July 23 2015 06:21 Plansix wrote: He admits he is a shit storm player and hates playing ember. But I see him play cores all the time on his stream and do well. He only consistently loses when he plays poverty dota on supports.
But in PPD's case his ability to play cores is hardly even relevant. His job is to play support well, not stomp pubs with Lesh SF etc and play mid. I suppose it happens that people watch his stream and then evaluate his "mechanics" but it doesn't seem very relevant to me.
|
On July 23 2015 06:25 spudde123 wrote:Show nested quote +On July 23 2015 06:21 Plansix wrote: He admits he is a shit storm player and hates playing ember. But I see him play cores all the time on his stream and do well. He only consistently loses when he plays poverty dota on supports. But in PPD's case his ability to play cores is hardly even relevant. His job is to play support well, not stomp pubs with Lesh SF etc and play mid. I suppose it happens that people watch his stream and then evaluate his "mechanics" but it doesn't seem very relevant to me. I agree. But people who evaluate "mechanics" by using that term are normally pretty disingenuous. Hence why no examples are provided.
|
mechanics is something pretty hard to evaluate just by talking about in a forum tbh its not even a truly defined term in dota unlike starcraft or whatever
|
Dota is a lot like other teams sports in that it is better to talk about specific skills like “positioning”, than vague terms like mechanics. Even in SC2 it’s the most useless phrase. Telling me a player has great “mechanics” doesn’t really tell me anything beyond that s/he is good.
|
|
|
|
|
|