|
On July 21 2015 05:29 Plansix wrote:Show nested quote +On July 21 2015 05:22 tehh4ck3r wrote:On July 21 2015 05:21 Plansix wrote:On July 21 2015 05:16 Sn0_Man wrote: What about the part where good players are already eschewing teams that can pay them because most of the money in the scene comes from prizes in the first place (especially with the majors being announced) how would you set up paid standin positions for them considering there's no way they'd split proceeds with players who just sit on the bench. There are systems in professional sports for this already. Everyone on the NFL team that wins the super bowl gets paid, even the 3rd string players who didn't even step on the field. A small amount of the winnings wouldn't be unreasonable, since they are forgoing a chance to be on another team and could have helped practice. theres no way team secret pays 2 players to standin and gives them a share of their prize money Lets make it one stand in and its .5% of each players winnings. That 2.5% total. Of a 40K that home for a small even, that's $1,000. Plus a pay monthly pay check while s/he gets the practice experience. Not saying its a perfect system. But teams being the exact number of players needed to play means that any shift in roster is a huge problem for them. That could be mitigated by having just up and coming player one extra player on staff. isn't an up and comer going to want to play on a team regularly and get consistent experience/practice instead of sitting on the sidelines
|
dota me teddy dota me hard
|
r u still in poland tuna do you agree with Thorin's assessment of that fine nation?
|
i think im allergic to the country ive been having hay fever the entire time ive been here
idk maybe
bluemoon is a level 5 gyro tho smh
|
i have invited 5 ppl and only 1 accepted so far guys this is unacceptable
|
On July 21 2015 05:33 CorsairHero wrote:Show nested quote +On July 21 2015 05:29 Plansix wrote:On July 21 2015 05:22 tehh4ck3r wrote:On July 21 2015 05:21 Plansix wrote:On July 21 2015 05:16 Sn0_Man wrote: What about the part where good players are already eschewing teams that can pay them because most of the money in the scene comes from prizes in the first place (especially with the majors being announced) how would you set up paid standin positions for them considering there's no way they'd split proceeds with players who just sit on the bench. There are systems in professional sports for this already. Everyone on the NFL team that wins the super bowl gets paid, even the 3rd string players who didn't even step on the field. A small amount of the winnings wouldn't be unreasonable, since they are forgoing a chance to be on another team and could have helped practice. theres no way team secret pays 2 players to standin and gives them a share of their prize money Lets make it one stand in and its .5% of each players winnings. That 2.5% total. Of a 40K that home for a small even, that's $1,000. Plus a pay monthly pay check while s/he gets the practice experience. Not saying its a perfect system. But teams being the exact number of players needed to play means that any shift in roster is a huge problem for them. That could be mitigated by having just up and coming player one extra player on staff. isn't an up and comer going to want to play on a team regularly and get consistent experience instead of sitting on the sidelines Some of them, for sure. But not every talented player can get on a stable team. Others might not have the connections or any offers to join a team that stands a chance. Being on a team isn’t just about playing, it could be a chance to network and experience working with people who are way better than you. And maybe they let you play in a qualifier game that doesn’t matter to give time in a real match. Like a paid dota internship.
As I said before, I don’t think its perfect at all and likely the scene isn’t big enough to support teams having deeper rosters. It’s a good stop gap between what we have and a farm league.
|
I can join if needed teddy.
|
28104 Posts
I'll be able to play next game but I gtg for about 20-30 minutes, sorry.
|
fpl does a pretty good job of networking and playing with pros already imo
|
Im up for a game. Watching your current game i think.
|
Time to create dragongirl in superiorest MMO, FFXIV
Or not...need to download Havensward first because their client is different than Steam's -.-
|
its fucking impossible to play terrorblade when u have 4 ppl afk standing around in ur whole jungle
|
|
|
I think Plansix is really wrong in this discussion on stand-ins. I think a move that would force teams to employ deeper rosters would actually hurt the current scene (for most teams) than help.
Dota professional teams don't need stand-in's because the sport* itself is volatile and lends itself to injury or unplayable fatigue like traditional sports leverage deep rosters. In dota 2, teams need standins because the scene is still so poor that most players are not 'professionals'. Most pros have to continue studying in school and/or work part time jobs to make bills etc., which makes their availability at times questionable. We need teams to further incentivize their starting 5, to allow them the safety net (salary, livable wage/conditions) to go full stock in dota, not spread the company money further by employing back-up members.
There are a million things that could be done to improve dota for the up & comer and the established veteran, forcing teams to employ deeper rosters isn't one of them.
|
On July 21 2015 06:27 teddyoojo wrote: its fucking impossible to play terrorblade when u have 4 ppl afk standing around in ur whole jungle Every 2K game with cores that need farm. All the tier 1s go down and then everyone just hangs out in the jungle until we lose all our tier 1s. Then confusion and demanding wards.
|
Its not really a coincidence that team sports that allow subbing players during the match like football or basketball have rosters with more players while sports like beach volleyball, curling, polo, etc. where you don't sub people during the game typically don't have rosters bigger than the playing field.
|
On July 21 2015 06:30 crms wrote: I think Plansix is really wrong in this discussion on stand-ins. I think a move that would force teams to employ deeper rosters would actually hurt the current scene (for most teams) than help.
Dota professional teams don't need stand-in's because the sport* itself is volatile and lends itself to injury or unplayable fatigue like traditional sports leverage deep rosters. In dota 2, teams need standins because the scene is still so poor, that most players are not 'professionals'. Most pros have to continue studying in school, and/or work part time jobs to make bills etc., which makes their availability at times questionable. We need teams to further incentivize their starting 5, to allow them the safety net (salary, livable wage/conditions) to go full stock in dota, not spread the company money further by employing back-up members.
There are a million things that could be done to improve dota for the up & comer and the established veteran, forcing teams to employ deeper rosters isn't one of them.
This is the a viable counter argument and I agree that Dota does not have the same issues with injuries that requires addition players. The livable wage is a big problem for "new blood dota." I just don't know how to get the new teams money.
|
|
|
That Saudi Prince gave 32 billion to charity. Someone needs to figure out how to tap into a tiny fraction of that and we are OK.
|
In general getting more money to lower tier teams is problematic imo, because of how online viewership tends to work. If I host a tennis tournament, I can maybe get it broadcasted on my own country's tv channels and get sponsorship deals from companies in my country, even if it isn't the biggest event with all the stars. It's still the only proper event in my town. If I follow a football club, there's not many choices where I can easily go to see a live match. So I will go to see my local club. Due to things happening in different parts of the world, there is often some local interest in even lower tier events or teams.
But in esports in general, what reason is there for me to watch lower tier players/teams play on twitch? If I watch online, I can also watch the top teams play. There is nothing special about seeing the lower tier teams play (like seeing the game live on location), and in fact often the broadcast can be of lower quality due to studios not putting as much effort into it. If there's no viewership for lower tier teams, there's not going to be much money involved from outside sponsors.
Though I have to admit I didn't really pay attention to the numbers for example BTS Americas got. The only real hope to get viewers for those games I think is to have it scheduled similarly to how it was now: top teams are not playing for a while and viewers are looking for some competitive dota to watch.
|
|
|
|
|
|