• Log InLog In
  • Register
Liquid`
Team Liquid Liquipedia
EST 06:16
CET 12:16
KST 20:16
  • Home
  • Forum
  • Calendar
  • Streams
  • Liquipedia
  • Features
  • Store
  • EPT
  • TL+
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Smash
  • Heroes
  • Counter-Strike
  • Overwatch
  • Liquibet
  • Fantasy StarCraft
  • TLPD
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Blogs
Forum Sidebar
Events/Features
News
Featured News
[ASL22] Finals Preview: Sweet Victory!12[ASL22] Ro4 Preview: Mirror Mirror6[ASL22] Ro8 Preview: Within Reach5[ASL22] Ro8 Preview: In A Tizzy11[ASL22] Ro16 Preview: Holy Diver5
Community News
Weekly Cups (Nov 9-15): Clem and herO take over0Dark completes military service, returns to SC212[BSL23] RO16 Group Stage20Weekly Cups (Nov 2-8): herO back on top?2Weekly Cups (Oct 26 - Nov 1): MaxPax, herO, Solar win0
StarCraft 2
General
Weekly Cups (Nov 9-15): Clem and herO take over No more SC2 streamers on team liquid? Dark completes military service, returns to SC2 Serral's getting trashed by New Catsle's Mind Weekly Cups (Nov 2-8): herO back on top?
Tourneys
RSL goes to London! 2026 Offline Finals Nov 21-22 Sparkling Tuna Cup - Weekly Open Tournament Sea Duckling Open (Global, Bronze-Diamond) Dark returns! GSL CK #7 4v4 Team Battle (Nov 19) soO & FanTaSy return! SC2 Kevin Scrim 4v4 (Nov 16)
Strategy
[H] ZvP Mid-Late Game: Stalkers Collossi HT
Custom Maps
[G] How to playtest arcade maps Starcraft 2 Advance [D] the control group Simple Questions/Answers
External Content
Mutation # 552 Secret Storm The PondCast: SC2 News & Results Mutation # 551 Robotic Revival Mutation # 550 Graveyard Shift
Brood War
General
BW General Discussion List of top players active on ShieldBattery NaDa's Body Shield Battery Server New Patch BGH Auto Balance -> http://bghmmr.eu/
Tourneys
[IPSL] Winter 26-27 Round of 16! [Megathread] Daily Proleagues 2v2v2v2 Tournament Stage 2: Players [$1250] International ShieldBattery League
Strategy
Pluto's TvP 5Marine 2Medic Push Simple Questions, Simple Answers Infested Terran strategies in 2026 Nuke strategy worked in K-League 2026-11-09
Other Games
General Games
Stormgate/Frost Giant Megathread Free Space RTS Game, optimised f. Phone/Tablet etc Nintendo Switch Thread List of Game Threads The PlayStation 5
Dota 2
League of Legends
[TL LoL EUW IHs] Teemo shall perish
Heroes of the Storm
Heroes of the Storm 2.0
Hearthstone
Deck construction bug
TL Mafia
TL Mafia Community Thread
Community
General
US Politics Mega-thread Russo-Ukrainian War Thread Artificial Intelligence Thread Things Aren’t Peaceful in Palestine Trading/Investing Thread
Fan Clubs
Fan Club Resource Thread Reynor Fan Club The Flash Fan Club
Media & Entertainment
Movie Discussion! Anime Discussion Thread [Manga] One Piece
Sports
Football (Soccer) Thread TeamLiquid Health and Fitness Initiative For 2023 MLB/Baseball 2023
World Cup 2022
Tech Support
Computer Build, Upgrade & Buying Resource Thread
TL Community
The Automated Ban List Recent Gifted Posts
Blogs
The time I organised my…
AssyrianKing
Why I built Repalyzer (1.1.…
BlueStar
Innovate or Game Over?
TrAiDoS
ShieldBattery on Mac
Kraekkling
Can Bots Beat Pros?? Starcr…
namkraft
Customize Sidebar...

Website Feedback

Closed Threads



Active: 16026 users

#Ineedmasculism - Page 6

Forum Index > Closed
Post a Reply
Prev 1 4 5 6 All
GnarlyArbitrage
Profile Blog Joined October 2011
575 Posts
February 12 2013 12:15 GMT
#101
On February 12 2013 20:22 khaydarin9 wrote:
In the case of abortion, it's not that no one cares that it's the guy's child, too, it's more that there is no moral justification for someone to say "Hey, you have to endure nine months of pregnancy, and a lifetime of physical and social consequences of having been pregnant because I want you to." And before you claim that there's equally no moral justification for forcing a man to pay 18 years' worth of child support for a child he didn't want in the first place, consider that whether or not a woman carries the child to term, she'll be enduring a range of physical and psychological changes due to the pregnancy, so it's not that women just get off consequence-free if she does choose to have an abortion. And before you try to claim that if a woman doesn't want to endure consequences, she shouldn't have had sex - neither should men. Everyone should be prepared to accept the consequences - physical, financial, whatever - of their actions.

It would be very inconsistent to say that it's wrong for parents to have executive power over their children's bodies (in situations like circumcision) and then turn around and say that women have no right to decide what happens to their own reproductive systems.


So, because the woman has to carry the baby for nine months, the father must live the rest of his life knowing the mother murdered his child?

On February 12 2013 20:54 Ianuus wrote:
Show nested quote +
On February 12 2013 20:07 GnarlyArbitrage wrote:
On February 12 2013 19:44 Ianuus wrote:
On February 12 2013 19:33 GnarlyArbitrage wrote:
On February 12 2013 19:29 Ianuus wrote:
On February 12 2013 19:18 GnarlyArbitrage wrote:
On February 12 2013 19:10 Ianuus wrote:
On February 12 2013 03:27 GnarlyArbitrage wrote:
I'm the way I am because I know no one will be able to come up with an argument using sources against me. When you start calling me names and refuse to use any intelligence, I'm just going to either ignore you or tell you what's up.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clitoral_hood

female human anatomy, the clitoral hood (also called preputium clitoridis and clitoral prepuce) is a fold of skin that surrounds and protects the glans of the clitoris; it also covers the external shaft and develops as part of the labia minora and is homologous with the foreskin (equally called prepuce) in male genitals.


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreskin

In male human anatomy, the foreskin is a double-layered fold of skin and mucous membrane that covers the glans penis and protects the urinary meatus (pron.: /miːˈeɪtəs/) when the penis is not erect. The foreskin is typically retractable over the glans. It is also described as the prepuce, a technically broader term that also includes the clitoral hood in women, to which the foreskin is embryonically homologous.


The same fucking purpose as foreskin. Think medical science has been wrong all this time? Well, guess you showed science! Wonder why women have orgasms? It's because men had them, then evolution was like, "oh, let me vacuum this cum up." The penis can be inverted into a vagina, the testicles are the ovaries, they are the same, in a sense. Just one gets testosterone and the other estrogen.

Yes, I'm sure that this has nothing to do with all the trolls who are using #IneedMasculism to troll uptight feminists.


I guess the feminists are immune from getting banned when they troll. Wonder what makes them so special. Oh, that's right, they have periods and get raped. (Even though, legally, before 2012, men couldn't legally be raped.) Remember, it was the feminist who hijacked the tag and got it national media attention. Not the "trollers".

Oh god, do you actually think that that is a result of coporate censorship, rather than an algorithm which displays results based on historic search data? Now I'm seriously not sure if you're trolling or not.


That page was getting MASSIVE hits from multiple sites. There is no reason why you could not find the search AT ALL when it's getting massive traffic.

P.S. I'm pretty sure you don't know what humanism actually means.


I'm a secular humanist. That's my "religion". Want to step on that subject some more?


Ok, I'm pretty sure you don't understand what homology is as well; so let me explain. A whale's flipper is homologous to a human hand; yet they have vastly different functions and forms; the human appendix is homologous to a herbivore's cecum, yet cutting one off is a medical procedure and cutting the other would cause immediate trauma, if not death by starvation. Well done on misconstruing quotes and definitions to suit your own skewed world view.

You're far from a humanist; you're a failed humanist at best, an pseudo-intellectual phoney at worst. One of the major themes of the humanist movement is the triumph of an individual rational human mind in its ability to objectively analyse facts and evidences in order to make sense of how the world works. You have failed that criterion at every step (the above basterdisation of the meaning of "homology" is just one of them), instead succumbing to a populist movement in which the power of the individual to analyse deeper truths is lost among surface half-truths and irrelvant observations twisted by demagogues to suit their own ends. Humanism isn't just a label you can apply to yourself to seem morally superior to those "dark-age religious nuts"; rational thought won't forgive your sins just because you are willing to pay lip service - you have to earn the right to be a humanist, and you are heading quite opposite to where you're supposed to go.


Man, men's rights must REALLY piss some of you guys off. What is with these personal attacks? Why not try to provide an intellectual argument? I've been providing sources for most of my arguments, yet I haven't seen the opposition do so. Keep up the ad hominens; my sides are enjoying it.

1
a : having the same relative position, value, or structure: as (1) : exhibiting biological homology (2) : having the same or allelic genes with genetic loci usually arranged in the same order <homologous chromosomes>


I guess the clitoral hood having some similarities to the foreskin is no argument against legal circumcision of males.


Well, you did ask me to step on your "secular humanism", so I did. Hope you enjoyed

Well well, we've gone from "The same fucking purpose as foreskin" to "having some similarities". Horray, progress! I was thinking it would never happen to such a caudex.


Purpose is the same, structure is a little different. They both cover the thing that gives pleasure. I'd like to see you refute that one.


Once again, irrelvant information. I would pose that the legality of circumcision rests on the effect on circumsised individuals, which depends on the structure, rather than on its teleology.

P.S. At risk of ad-homineming your fragile little ego, I would also like to point out that your self-righteous tone, triumphant arrogance, liberal use of explicatives and constant "come at me bro" attitude puts a rather large dent on your attempt to sound intellectual - there is a difference between enlightened fervour and just being crude. Work on that, will you?


How is the purpose of the foreskin/clitoral hood irrelevant in the discussion of circumcision legality?

Keep up the attacks. My ego is at critical HP, I think I need a potion.


Because even if its purpose is exactly the same, what happens when you mutilate the organ and the effect it has on the subject may be completely different. For example - if you cut off a tail of some species of lizard, it ain't even mad and will regenerate it. If you cut off the tail of a cat, it's pretty much fucked. Thus, even if in both species the primary purpose of tails are for balance, one could make a case of the legality of lizard tail mutiliation over cat tail mutiliation.


"May be completely different." Sounds like you know your stuff.

Cutting the tail off a lizard, something that grows back, is no where near the same as cutting the skin off a dick or vagina. The skin doesn't grow back, just like the cat's tail.

Just because lizards seemingly don't feel the pain of their tails being cut off, you think that's an argument for legalizing "lizard cruelty"? Honestly, what the fuck is wrong with you?
Ianuus
Profile Blog Joined May 2010
Australia349 Posts
February 12 2013 12:30 GMT
#102
On February 12 2013 21:15 GnarlyArbitrage wrote:
Show nested quote +
On February 12 2013 20:22 khaydarin9 wrote:
In the case of abortion, it's not that no one cares that it's the guy's child, too, it's more that there is no moral justification for someone to say "Hey, you have to endure nine months of pregnancy, and a lifetime of physical and social consequences of having been pregnant because I want you to." And before you claim that there's equally no moral justification for forcing a man to pay 18 years' worth of child support for a child he didn't want in the first place, consider that whether or not a woman carries the child to term, she'll be enduring a range of physical and psychological changes due to the pregnancy, so it's not that women just get off consequence-free if she does choose to have an abortion. And before you try to claim that if a woman doesn't want to endure consequences, she shouldn't have had sex - neither should men. Everyone should be prepared to accept the consequences - physical, financial, whatever - of their actions.

It would be very inconsistent to say that it's wrong for parents to have executive power over their children's bodies (in situations like circumcision) and then turn around and say that women have no right to decide what happens to their own reproductive systems.


So, because the woman has to carry the baby for nine months, the father must live the rest of his life knowing the mother murdered his child?

Show nested quote +
On February 12 2013 20:54 Ianuus wrote:
On February 12 2013 20:07 GnarlyArbitrage wrote:
On February 12 2013 19:44 Ianuus wrote:
On February 12 2013 19:33 GnarlyArbitrage wrote:
On February 12 2013 19:29 Ianuus wrote:
On February 12 2013 19:18 GnarlyArbitrage wrote:
On February 12 2013 19:10 Ianuus wrote:
On February 12 2013 03:27 GnarlyArbitrage wrote:
I'm the way I am because I know no one will be able to come up with an argument using sources against me. When you start calling me names and refuse to use any intelligence, I'm just going to either ignore you or tell you what's up.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clitoral_hood

female human anatomy, the clitoral hood (also called preputium clitoridis and clitoral prepuce) is a fold of skin that surrounds and protects the glans of the clitoris; it also covers the external shaft and develops as part of the labia minora and is homologous with the foreskin (equally called prepuce) in male genitals.


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreskin

In male human anatomy, the foreskin is a double-layered fold of skin and mucous membrane that covers the glans penis and protects the urinary meatus (pron.: /miːˈeɪtəs/) when the penis is not erect. The foreskin is typically retractable over the glans. It is also described as the prepuce, a technically broader term that also includes the clitoral hood in women, to which the foreskin is embryonically homologous.


The same fucking purpose as foreskin. Think medical science has been wrong all this time? Well, guess you showed science! Wonder why women have orgasms? It's because men had them, then evolution was like, "oh, let me vacuum this cum up." The penis can be inverted into a vagina, the testicles are the ovaries, they are the same, in a sense. Just one gets testosterone and the other estrogen.

Yes, I'm sure that this has nothing to do with all the trolls who are using #IneedMasculism to troll uptight feminists.


I guess the feminists are immune from getting banned when they troll. Wonder what makes them so special. Oh, that's right, they have periods and get raped. (Even though, legally, before 2012, men couldn't legally be raped.) Remember, it was the feminist who hijacked the tag and got it national media attention. Not the "trollers".

Oh god, do you actually think that that is a result of coporate censorship, rather than an algorithm which displays results based on historic search data? Now I'm seriously not sure if you're trolling or not.


That page was getting MASSIVE hits from multiple sites. There is no reason why you could not find the search AT ALL when it's getting massive traffic.

P.S. I'm pretty sure you don't know what humanism actually means.


I'm a secular humanist. That's my "religion". Want to step on that subject some more?


Ok, I'm pretty sure you don't understand what homology is as well; so let me explain. A whale's flipper is homologous to a human hand; yet they have vastly different functions and forms; the human appendix is homologous to a herbivore's cecum, yet cutting one off is a medical procedure and cutting the other would cause immediate trauma, if not death by starvation. Well done on misconstruing quotes and definitions to suit your own skewed world view.

You're far from a humanist; you're a failed humanist at best, an pseudo-intellectual phoney at worst. One of the major themes of the humanist movement is the triumph of an individual rational human mind in its ability to objectively analyse facts and evidences in order to make sense of how the world works. You have failed that criterion at every step (the above basterdisation of the meaning of "homology" is just one of them), instead succumbing to a populist movement in which the power of the individual to analyse deeper truths is lost among surface half-truths and irrelvant observations twisted by demagogues to suit their own ends. Humanism isn't just a label you can apply to yourself to seem morally superior to those "dark-age religious nuts"; rational thought won't forgive your sins just because you are willing to pay lip service - you have to earn the right to be a humanist, and you are heading quite opposite to where you're supposed to go.


Man, men's rights must REALLY piss some of you guys off. What is with these personal attacks? Why not try to provide an intellectual argument? I've been providing sources for most of my arguments, yet I haven't seen the opposition do so. Keep up the ad hominens; my sides are enjoying it.

1
a : having the same relative position, value, or structure: as (1) : exhibiting biological homology (2) : having the same or allelic genes with genetic loci usually arranged in the same order <homologous chromosomes>


I guess the clitoral hood having some similarities to the foreskin is no argument against legal circumcision of males.


Well, you did ask me to step on your "secular humanism", so I did. Hope you enjoyed

Well well, we've gone from "The same fucking purpose as foreskin" to "having some similarities". Horray, progress! I was thinking it would never happen to such a caudex.


Purpose is the same, structure is a little different. They both cover the thing that gives pleasure. I'd like to see you refute that one.


Once again, irrelvant information. I would pose that the legality of circumcision rests on the effect on circumsised individuals, which depends on the structure, rather than on its teleology.

P.S. At risk of ad-homineming your fragile little ego, I would also like to point out that your self-righteous tone, triumphant arrogance, liberal use of explicatives and constant "come at me bro" attitude puts a rather large dent on your attempt to sound intellectual - there is a difference between enlightened fervour and just being crude. Work on that, will you?


How is the purpose of the foreskin/clitoral hood irrelevant in the discussion of circumcision legality?

Keep up the attacks. My ego is at critical HP, I think I need a potion.


Because even if its purpose is exactly the same, what happens when you mutilate the organ and the effect it has on the subject may be completely different. For example - if you cut off a tail of some species of lizard, it ain't even mad and will regenerate it. If you cut off the tail of a cat, it's pretty much fucked. Thus, even if in both species the primary purpose of tails are for balance, one could make a case of the legality of lizard tail mutiliation over cat tail mutiliation.


"May be completely different." Sounds like you know your stuff.

Cutting the tail off a lizard, something that grows back, is no where near the same as cutting the skin off a dick or vagina. The skin doesn't grow back, just like the cat's tail.

Just because lizards seemingly don't feel the pain of their tails being cut off, you think that's an argument for legalizing "lizard cruelty"? Honestly, what the fuck is wrong with you?



Once again, since you lack the ability to see any logical flaws in the premise of my argument, you resort to putting words in my mouth then attacking the strawman which you've created. Since when did I promote animal cruelty? I merely compared two cases in their relative morality, not the morality of either case as an absolute. Your righteous indignation further erodes any pretence of a legitimate argument.

I did say "may be completely different", since I am not an arrogant prick such as you, and I do not pretend to have detailed knowledge of human anatomy, as you do. I can merely point out the flaws in your argument on principle. Arrogance starts where ability ends, and my ability with male and female circumcision is limited at best.
GnarlyArbitrage
Profile Blog Joined October 2011
575 Posts
February 12 2013 12:36 GMT
#103
On February 12 2013 21:30 Ianuus wrote:
Show nested quote +
On February 12 2013 21:15 GnarlyArbitrage wrote:
On February 12 2013 20:22 khaydarin9 wrote:
In the case of abortion, it's not that no one cares that it's the guy's child, too, it's more that there is no moral justification for someone to say "Hey, you have to endure nine months of pregnancy, and a lifetime of physical and social consequences of having been pregnant because I want you to." And before you claim that there's equally no moral justification for forcing a man to pay 18 years' worth of child support for a child he didn't want in the first place, consider that whether or not a woman carries the child to term, she'll be enduring a range of physical and psychological changes due to the pregnancy, so it's not that women just get off consequence-free if she does choose to have an abortion. And before you try to claim that if a woman doesn't want to endure consequences, she shouldn't have had sex - neither should men. Everyone should be prepared to accept the consequences - physical, financial, whatever - of their actions.

It would be very inconsistent to say that it's wrong for parents to have executive power over their children's bodies (in situations like circumcision) and then turn around and say that women have no right to decide what happens to their own reproductive systems.


So, because the woman has to carry the baby for nine months, the father must live the rest of his life knowing the mother murdered his child?

On February 12 2013 20:54 Ianuus wrote:
On February 12 2013 20:07 GnarlyArbitrage wrote:
On February 12 2013 19:44 Ianuus wrote:
On February 12 2013 19:33 GnarlyArbitrage wrote:
On February 12 2013 19:29 Ianuus wrote:
On February 12 2013 19:18 GnarlyArbitrage wrote:
On February 12 2013 19:10 Ianuus wrote:
On February 12 2013 03:27 GnarlyArbitrage wrote:
I'm the way I am because I know no one will be able to come up with an argument using sources against me. When you start calling me names and refuse to use any intelligence, I'm just going to either ignore you or tell you what's up.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clitoral_hood
[quote]

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreskin

[quote]

The same fucking purpose as foreskin. Think medical science has been wrong all this time? Well, guess you showed science! Wonder why women have orgasms? It's because men had them, then evolution was like, "oh, let me vacuum this cum up." The penis can be inverted into a vagina, the testicles are the ovaries, they are the same, in a sense. Just one gets testosterone and the other estrogen.

[quote]

I guess the feminists are immune from getting banned when they troll. Wonder what makes them so special. Oh, that's right, they have periods and get raped. (Even though, legally, before 2012, men couldn't legally be raped.) Remember, it was the feminist who hijacked the tag and got it national media attention. Not the "trollers".

[quote]

That page was getting MASSIVE hits from multiple sites. There is no reason why you could not find the search AT ALL when it's getting massive traffic.

[quote]

I'm a secular humanist. That's my "religion". Want to step on that subject some more?


Ok, I'm pretty sure you don't understand what homology is as well; so let me explain. A whale's flipper is homologous to a human hand; yet they have vastly different functions and forms; the human appendix is homologous to a herbivore's cecum, yet cutting one off is a medical procedure and cutting the other would cause immediate trauma, if not death by starvation. Well done on misconstruing quotes and definitions to suit your own skewed world view.

You're far from a humanist; you're a failed humanist at best, an pseudo-intellectual phoney at worst. One of the major themes of the humanist movement is the triumph of an individual rational human mind in its ability to objectively analyse facts and evidences in order to make sense of how the world works. You have failed that criterion at every step (the above basterdisation of the meaning of "homology" is just one of them), instead succumbing to a populist movement in which the power of the individual to analyse deeper truths is lost among surface half-truths and irrelvant observations twisted by demagogues to suit their own ends. Humanism isn't just a label you can apply to yourself to seem morally superior to those "dark-age religious nuts"; rational thought won't forgive your sins just because you are willing to pay lip service - you have to earn the right to be a humanist, and you are heading quite opposite to where you're supposed to go.


Man, men's rights must REALLY piss some of you guys off. What is with these personal attacks? Why not try to provide an intellectual argument? I've been providing sources for most of my arguments, yet I haven't seen the opposition do so. Keep up the ad hominens; my sides are enjoying it.

1
a : having the same relative position, value, or structure: as (1) : exhibiting biological homology (2) : having the same or allelic genes with genetic loci usually arranged in the same order <homologous chromosomes>


I guess the clitoral hood having some similarities to the foreskin is no argument against legal circumcision of males.


Well, you did ask me to step on your "secular humanism", so I did. Hope you enjoyed

Well well, we've gone from "The same fucking purpose as foreskin" to "having some similarities". Horray, progress! I was thinking it would never happen to such a caudex.


Purpose is the same, structure is a little different. They both cover the thing that gives pleasure. I'd like to see you refute that one.


Once again, irrelvant information. I would pose that the legality of circumcision rests on the effect on circumsised individuals, which depends on the structure, rather than on its teleology.

P.S. At risk of ad-homineming your fragile little ego, I would also like to point out that your self-righteous tone, triumphant arrogance, liberal use of explicatives and constant "come at me bro" attitude puts a rather large dent on your attempt to sound intellectual - there is a difference between enlightened fervour and just being crude. Work on that, will you?


How is the purpose of the foreskin/clitoral hood irrelevant in the discussion of circumcision legality?

Keep up the attacks. My ego is at critical HP, I think I need a potion.


Because even if its purpose is exactly the same, what happens when you mutilate the organ and the effect it has on the subject may be completely different. For example - if you cut off a tail of some species of lizard, it ain't even mad and will regenerate it. If you cut off the tail of a cat, it's pretty much fucked. Thus, even if in both species the primary purpose of tails are for balance, one could make a case of the legality of lizard tail mutiliation over cat tail mutiliation.


"May be completely different." Sounds like you know your stuff.

Cutting the tail off a lizard, something that grows back, is no where near the same as cutting the skin off a dick or vagina. The skin doesn't grow back, just like the cat's tail.

Just because lizards seemingly don't feel the pain of their tails being cut off, you think that's an argument for legalizing "lizard cruelty"? Honestly, what the fuck is wrong with you?



Once again, since you lack the ability to see any logical flaws in the premise of my argument, you resort to putting words in my mouth then attacking the strawman which you've created. Since when did I promote animal cruelty? I merely compared two cases in their relative morality, not the morality of either case as an absolute. Your righteous indignation further erodes any pretence of a legitimate argument.

I did say "may be completely different", since I am not an arrogant prick such as you, and I do not pretend to have detailed knowledge of human anatomy, as you do. I can merely point out the flaws in your argument on principle. Arrogance starts where ability ends, and my ability with male and female circumcision is limited at best.


You're saying that person can make a case for cutting off a lizards tail, legally. If you're not saying that, then let me show you where you said that:

Thus, even if in both species the primary purpose of tails are for balance, one could make a case of the legality of lizard tail mutiliation over cat tail mutiliation.


Seek help.
Ianuus
Profile Blog Joined May 2010
Australia349 Posts
Last Edited: 2013-02-12 12:46:40
February 12 2013 12:40 GMT
#104
On February 12 2013 21:36 GnarlyArbitrage wrote:
Show nested quote +
On February 12 2013 21:30 Ianuus wrote:
On February 12 2013 21:15 GnarlyArbitrage wrote:
On February 12 2013 20:22 khaydarin9 wrote:
In the case of abortion, it's not that no one cares that it's the guy's child, too, it's more that there is no moral justification for someone to say "Hey, you have to endure nine months of pregnancy, and a lifetime of physical and social consequences of having been pregnant because I want you to." And before you claim that there's equally no moral justification for forcing a man to pay 18 years' worth of child support for a child he didn't want in the first place, consider that whether or not a woman carries the child to term, she'll be enduring a range of physical and psychological changes due to the pregnancy, so it's not that women just get off consequence-free if she does choose to have an abortion. And before you try to claim that if a woman doesn't want to endure consequences, she shouldn't have had sex - neither should men. Everyone should be prepared to accept the consequences - physical, financial, whatever - of their actions.

It would be very inconsistent to say that it's wrong for parents to have executive power over their children's bodies (in situations like circumcision) and then turn around and say that women have no right to decide what happens to their own reproductive systems.


So, because the woman has to carry the baby for nine months, the father must live the rest of his life knowing the mother murdered his child?

On February 12 2013 20:54 Ianuus wrote:
On February 12 2013 20:07 GnarlyArbitrage wrote:
On February 12 2013 19:44 Ianuus wrote:
On February 12 2013 19:33 GnarlyArbitrage wrote:
On February 12 2013 19:29 Ianuus wrote:
On February 12 2013 19:18 GnarlyArbitrage wrote:
On February 12 2013 19:10 Ianuus wrote:
[quote]

Ok, I'm pretty sure you don't understand what homology is as well; so let me explain. A whale's flipper is homologous to a human hand; yet they have vastly different functions and forms; the human appendix is homologous to a herbivore's cecum, yet cutting one off is a medical procedure and cutting the other would cause immediate trauma, if not death by starvation. Well done on misconstruing quotes and definitions to suit your own skewed world view.

You're far from a humanist; you're a failed humanist at best, an pseudo-intellectual phoney at worst. One of the major themes of the humanist movement is the triumph of an individual rational human mind in its ability to objectively analyse facts and evidences in order to make sense of how the world works. You have failed that criterion at every step (the above basterdisation of the meaning of "homology" is just one of them), instead succumbing to a populist movement in which the power of the individual to analyse deeper truths is lost among surface half-truths and irrelvant observations twisted by demagogues to suit their own ends. Humanism isn't just a label you can apply to yourself to seem morally superior to those "dark-age religious nuts"; rational thought won't forgive your sins just because you are willing to pay lip service - you have to earn the right to be a humanist, and you are heading quite opposite to where you're supposed to go.


Man, men's rights must REALLY piss some of you guys off. What is with these personal attacks? Why not try to provide an intellectual argument? I've been providing sources for most of my arguments, yet I haven't seen the opposition do so. Keep up the ad hominens; my sides are enjoying it.

1
a : having the same relative position, value, or structure: as (1) : exhibiting biological homology (2) : having the same or allelic genes with genetic loci usually arranged in the same order <homologous chromosomes>


I guess the clitoral hood having some similarities to the foreskin is no argument against legal circumcision of males.


Well, you did ask me to step on your "secular humanism", so I did. Hope you enjoyed

Well well, we've gone from "The same fucking purpose as foreskin" to "having some similarities". Horray, progress! I was thinking it would never happen to such a caudex.


Purpose is the same, structure is a little different. They both cover the thing that gives pleasure. I'd like to see you refute that one.


Once again, irrelvant information. I would pose that the legality of circumcision rests on the effect on circumsised individuals, which depends on the structure, rather than on its teleology.

P.S. At risk of ad-homineming your fragile little ego, I would also like to point out that your self-righteous tone, triumphant arrogance, liberal use of explicatives and constant "come at me bro" attitude puts a rather large dent on your attempt to sound intellectual - there is a difference between enlightened fervour and just being crude. Work on that, will you?


How is the purpose of the foreskin/clitoral hood irrelevant in the discussion of circumcision legality?

Keep up the attacks. My ego is at critical HP, I think I need a potion.


Because even if its purpose is exactly the same, what happens when you mutilate the organ and the effect it has on the subject may be completely different. For example - if you cut off a tail of some species of lizard, it ain't even mad and will regenerate it. If you cut off the tail of a cat, it's pretty much fucked. Thus, even if in both species the primary purpose of tails are for balance, one could make a case of the legality of lizard tail mutiliation over cat tail mutiliation.


"May be completely different." Sounds like you know your stuff.

Cutting the tail off a lizard, something that grows back, is no where near the same as cutting the skin off a dick or vagina. The skin doesn't grow back, just like the cat's tail.

Just because lizards seemingly don't feel the pain of their tails being cut off, you think that's an argument for legalizing "lizard cruelty"? Honestly, what the fuck is wrong with you?



Once again, since you lack the ability to see any logical flaws in the premise of my argument, you resort to putting words in my mouth then attacking the strawman which you've created. Since when did I promote animal cruelty? I merely compared two cases in their relative morality, not the morality of either case as an absolute. Your righteous indignation further erodes any pretence of a legitimate argument.

I did say "may be completely different", since I am not an arrogant prick such as you, and I do not pretend to have detailed knowledge of human anatomy, as you do. I can merely point out the flaws in your argument on principle. Arrogance starts where ability ends, and my ability with male and female circumcision is limited at best.


You're saying that person can make a case for cutting off a lizards tail, legally. If you're not saying that, then let me show you where you said that:

Show nested quote +
Thus, even if in both species the primary purpose of tails are for balance, one could make a case of the legality of lizard tail mutiliation over cat tail mutiliation.


Seek help.



"one could make a case of the legality of lizard tail mutiliation over cat tail mutiliation"

Comparatives, man, learn to understand them. Since you have failed so far, I will provide you with an easy-to-understand example: "a nanometer is longer than a picometer" does not imply that either is long.

P.S. Here's another example of you arguing a point not related to the premise of the argument with flawed logic. I think this is another one of those fallacies in argument along with your favourite "ad-hominem attacks". Maybe look over those again and see what you can learn?
GnarlyArbitrage
Profile Blog Joined October 2011
575 Posts
February 12 2013 13:53 GMT
#105
On February 12 2013 21:40 Ianuus wrote:
Show nested quote +
On February 12 2013 21:36 GnarlyArbitrage wrote:
On February 12 2013 21:30 Ianuus wrote:
On February 12 2013 21:15 GnarlyArbitrage wrote:
On February 12 2013 20:22 khaydarin9 wrote:
In the case of abortion, it's not that no one cares that it's the guy's child, too, it's more that there is no moral justification for someone to say "Hey, you have to endure nine months of pregnancy, and a lifetime of physical and social consequences of having been pregnant because I want you to." And before you claim that there's equally no moral justification for forcing a man to pay 18 years' worth of child support for a child he didn't want in the first place, consider that whether or not a woman carries the child to term, she'll be enduring a range of physical and psychological changes due to the pregnancy, so it's not that women just get off consequence-free if she does choose to have an abortion. And before you try to claim that if a woman doesn't want to endure consequences, she shouldn't have had sex - neither should men. Everyone should be prepared to accept the consequences - physical, financial, whatever - of their actions.

It would be very inconsistent to say that it's wrong for parents to have executive power over their children's bodies (in situations like circumcision) and then turn around and say that women have no right to decide what happens to their own reproductive systems.


So, because the woman has to carry the baby for nine months, the father must live the rest of his life knowing the mother murdered his child?

On February 12 2013 20:54 Ianuus wrote:
On February 12 2013 20:07 GnarlyArbitrage wrote:
On February 12 2013 19:44 Ianuus wrote:
On February 12 2013 19:33 GnarlyArbitrage wrote:
On February 12 2013 19:29 Ianuus wrote:
On February 12 2013 19:18 GnarlyArbitrage wrote:
[quote]

Man, men's rights must REALLY piss some of you guys off. What is with these personal attacks? Why not try to provide an intellectual argument? I've been providing sources for most of my arguments, yet I haven't seen the opposition do so. Keep up the ad hominens; my sides are enjoying it.

[quote]

I guess the clitoral hood having some similarities to the foreskin is no argument against legal circumcision of males.


Well, you did ask me to step on your "secular humanism", so I did. Hope you enjoyed

Well well, we've gone from "The same fucking purpose as foreskin" to "having some similarities". Horray, progress! I was thinking it would never happen to such a caudex.


Purpose is the same, structure is a little different. They both cover the thing that gives pleasure. I'd like to see you refute that one.


Once again, irrelvant information. I would pose that the legality of circumcision rests on the effect on circumsised individuals, which depends on the structure, rather than on its teleology.

P.S. At risk of ad-homineming your fragile little ego, I would also like to point out that your self-righteous tone, triumphant arrogance, liberal use of explicatives and constant "come at me bro" attitude puts a rather large dent on your attempt to sound intellectual - there is a difference between enlightened fervour and just being crude. Work on that, will you?


How is the purpose of the foreskin/clitoral hood irrelevant in the discussion of circumcision legality?

Keep up the attacks. My ego is at critical HP, I think I need a potion.


Because even if its purpose is exactly the same, what happens when you mutilate the organ and the effect it has on the subject may be completely different. For example - if you cut off a tail of some species of lizard, it ain't even mad and will regenerate it. If you cut off the tail of a cat, it's pretty much fucked. Thus, even if in both species the primary purpose of tails are for balance, one could make a case of the legality of lizard tail mutiliation over cat tail mutiliation.


"May be completely different." Sounds like you know your stuff.

Cutting the tail off a lizard, something that grows back, is no where near the same as cutting the skin off a dick or vagina. The skin doesn't grow back, just like the cat's tail.

Just because lizards seemingly don't feel the pain of their tails being cut off, you think that's an argument for legalizing "lizard cruelty"? Honestly, what the fuck is wrong with you?



Once again, since you lack the ability to see any logical flaws in the premise of my argument, you resort to putting words in my mouth then attacking the strawman which you've created. Since when did I promote animal cruelty? I merely compared two cases in their relative morality, not the morality of either case as an absolute. Your righteous indignation further erodes any pretence of a legitimate argument.

I did say "may be completely different", since I am not an arrogant prick such as you, and I do not pretend to have detailed knowledge of human anatomy, as you do. I can merely point out the flaws in your argument on principle. Arrogance starts where ability ends, and my ability with male and female circumcision is limited at best.


You're saying that person can make a case for cutting off a lizards tail, legally. If you're not saying that, then let me show you where you said that:

Thus, even if in both species the primary purpose of tails are for balance, one could make a case of the legality of lizard tail mutiliation over cat tail mutiliation.


Seek help.



"one could make a case of the legality of lizard tail mutiliation over cat tail mutiliation"

Comparatives, man, learn to understand them. Since you have failed so far, I will provide you with an easy-to-understand example: "a nanometer is longer than a picometer" does not imply that either is long.

P.S. Here's another example of you arguing a point not related to the premise of the argument with flawed logic. I think this is another one of those fallacies in argument along with your favourite "ad-hominem attacks". Maybe look over those again and see what you can learn?



"FGM is worse than MGM" doesn't imply that either is wrong. Easy enough.

Still, seek help.
Ianuus
Profile Blog Joined May 2010
Australia349 Posts
February 12 2013 14:21 GMT
#106
On February 12 2013 22:53 GnarlyArbitrage wrote:
Show nested quote +
On February 12 2013 21:40 Ianuus wrote:
On February 12 2013 21:36 GnarlyArbitrage wrote:
On February 12 2013 21:30 Ianuus wrote:
On February 12 2013 21:15 GnarlyArbitrage wrote:
On February 12 2013 20:22 khaydarin9 wrote:
In the case of abortion, it's not that no one cares that it's the guy's child, too, it's more that there is no moral justification for someone to say "Hey, you have to endure nine months of pregnancy, and a lifetime of physical and social consequences of having been pregnant because I want you to." And before you claim that there's equally no moral justification for forcing a man to pay 18 years' worth of child support for a child he didn't want in the first place, consider that whether or not a woman carries the child to term, she'll be enduring a range of physical and psychological changes due to the pregnancy, so it's not that women just get off consequence-free if she does choose to have an abortion. And before you try to claim that if a woman doesn't want to endure consequences, she shouldn't have had sex - neither should men. Everyone should be prepared to accept the consequences - physical, financial, whatever - of their actions.

It would be very inconsistent to say that it's wrong for parents to have executive power over their children's bodies (in situations like circumcision) and then turn around and say that women have no right to decide what happens to their own reproductive systems.


So, because the woman has to carry the baby for nine months, the father must live the rest of his life knowing the mother murdered his child?

On February 12 2013 20:54 Ianuus wrote:
On February 12 2013 20:07 GnarlyArbitrage wrote:
On February 12 2013 19:44 Ianuus wrote:
On February 12 2013 19:33 GnarlyArbitrage wrote:
On February 12 2013 19:29 Ianuus wrote:
[quote]

Well, you did ask me to step on your "secular humanism", so I did. Hope you enjoyed

Well well, we've gone from "The same fucking purpose as foreskin" to "having some similarities". Horray, progress! I was thinking it would never happen to such a caudex.


Purpose is the same, structure is a little different. They both cover the thing that gives pleasure. I'd like to see you refute that one.


Once again, irrelvant information. I would pose that the legality of circumcision rests on the effect on circumsised individuals, which depends on the structure, rather than on its teleology.

P.S. At risk of ad-homineming your fragile little ego, I would also like to point out that your self-righteous tone, triumphant arrogance, liberal use of explicatives and constant "come at me bro" attitude puts a rather large dent on your attempt to sound intellectual - there is a difference between enlightened fervour and just being crude. Work on that, will you?


How is the purpose of the foreskin/clitoral hood irrelevant in the discussion of circumcision legality?

Keep up the attacks. My ego is at critical HP, I think I need a potion.


Because even if its purpose is exactly the same, what happens when you mutilate the organ and the effect it has on the subject may be completely different. For example - if you cut off a tail of some species of lizard, it ain't even mad and will regenerate it. If you cut off the tail of a cat, it's pretty much fucked. Thus, even if in both species the primary purpose of tails are for balance, one could make a case of the legality of lizard tail mutiliation over cat tail mutiliation.


"May be completely different." Sounds like you know your stuff.

Cutting the tail off a lizard, something that grows back, is no where near the same as cutting the skin off a dick or vagina. The skin doesn't grow back, just like the cat's tail.

Just because lizards seemingly don't feel the pain of their tails being cut off, you think that's an argument for legalizing "lizard cruelty"? Honestly, what the fuck is wrong with you?



Once again, since you lack the ability to see any logical flaws in the premise of my argument, you resort to putting words in my mouth then attacking the strawman which you've created. Since when did I promote animal cruelty? I merely compared two cases in their relative morality, not the morality of either case as an absolute. Your righteous indignation further erodes any pretence of a legitimate argument.

I did say "may be completely different", since I am not an arrogant prick such as you, and I do not pretend to have detailed knowledge of human anatomy, as you do. I can merely point out the flaws in your argument on principle. Arrogance starts where ability ends, and my ability with male and female circumcision is limited at best.


You're saying that person can make a case for cutting off a lizards tail, legally. If you're not saying that, then let me show you where you said that:

Thus, even if in both species the primary purpose of tails are for balance, one could make a case of the legality of lizard tail mutiliation over cat tail mutiliation.


Seek help.



"one could make a case of the legality of lizard tail mutiliation over cat tail mutiliation"

Comparatives, man, learn to understand them. Since you have failed so far, I will provide you with an easy-to-understand example: "a nanometer is longer than a picometer" does not imply that either is long.

P.S. Here's another example of you arguing a point not related to the premise of the argument with flawed logic. I think this is another one of those fallacies in argument along with your favourite "ad-hominem attacks". Maybe look over those again and see what you can learn?



"FGM is worse than MGM" doesn't imply that either is wrong. Easy enough.

Still, seek help.


You mean "either is right" right?
GnarlyArbitrage
Profile Blog Joined October 2011
575 Posts
February 12 2013 14:41 GMT
#107
On February 12 2013 23:21 Ianuus wrote:
Show nested quote +
On February 12 2013 22:53 GnarlyArbitrage wrote:
On February 12 2013 21:40 Ianuus wrote:
On February 12 2013 21:36 GnarlyArbitrage wrote:
On February 12 2013 21:30 Ianuus wrote:
On February 12 2013 21:15 GnarlyArbitrage wrote:
On February 12 2013 20:22 khaydarin9 wrote:
In the case of abortion, it's not that no one cares that it's the guy's child, too, it's more that there is no moral justification for someone to say "Hey, you have to endure nine months of pregnancy, and a lifetime of physical and social consequences of having been pregnant because I want you to." And before you claim that there's equally no moral justification for forcing a man to pay 18 years' worth of child support for a child he didn't want in the first place, consider that whether or not a woman carries the child to term, she'll be enduring a range of physical and psychological changes due to the pregnancy, so it's not that women just get off consequence-free if she does choose to have an abortion. And before you try to claim that if a woman doesn't want to endure consequences, she shouldn't have had sex - neither should men. Everyone should be prepared to accept the consequences - physical, financial, whatever - of their actions.

It would be very inconsistent to say that it's wrong for parents to have executive power over their children's bodies (in situations like circumcision) and then turn around and say that women have no right to decide what happens to their own reproductive systems.


So, because the woman has to carry the baby for nine months, the father must live the rest of his life knowing the mother murdered his child?

On February 12 2013 20:54 Ianuus wrote:
On February 12 2013 20:07 GnarlyArbitrage wrote:
On February 12 2013 19:44 Ianuus wrote:
On February 12 2013 19:33 GnarlyArbitrage wrote:
[quote]

Purpose is the same, structure is a little different. They both cover the thing that gives pleasure. I'd like to see you refute that one.


Once again, irrelvant information. I would pose that the legality of circumcision rests on the effect on circumsised individuals, which depends on the structure, rather than on its teleology.

P.S. At risk of ad-homineming your fragile little ego, I would also like to point out that your self-righteous tone, triumphant arrogance, liberal use of explicatives and constant "come at me bro" attitude puts a rather large dent on your attempt to sound intellectual - there is a difference between enlightened fervour and just being crude. Work on that, will you?


How is the purpose of the foreskin/clitoral hood irrelevant in the discussion of circumcision legality?

Keep up the attacks. My ego is at critical HP, I think I need a potion.


Because even if its purpose is exactly the same, what happens when you mutilate the organ and the effect it has on the subject may be completely different. For example - if you cut off a tail of some species of lizard, it ain't even mad and will regenerate it. If you cut off the tail of a cat, it's pretty much fucked. Thus, even if in both species the primary purpose of tails are for balance, one could make a case of the legality of lizard tail mutiliation over cat tail mutiliation.


"May be completely different." Sounds like you know your stuff.

Cutting the tail off a lizard, something that grows back, is no where near the same as cutting the skin off a dick or vagina. The skin doesn't grow back, just like the cat's tail.

Just because lizards seemingly don't feel the pain of their tails being cut off, you think that's an argument for legalizing "lizard cruelty"? Honestly, what the fuck is wrong with you?



Once again, since you lack the ability to see any logical flaws in the premise of my argument, you resort to putting words in my mouth then attacking the strawman which you've created. Since when did I promote animal cruelty? I merely compared two cases in their relative morality, not the morality of either case as an absolute. Your righteous indignation further erodes any pretence of a legitimate argument.

I did say "may be completely different", since I am not an arrogant prick such as you, and I do not pretend to have detailed knowledge of human anatomy, as you do. I can merely point out the flaws in your argument on principle. Arrogance starts where ability ends, and my ability with male and female circumcision is limited at best.


You're saying that person can make a case for cutting off a lizards tail, legally. If you're not saying that, then let me show you where you said that:

Thus, even if in both species the primary purpose of tails are for balance, one could make a case of the legality of lizard tail mutiliation over cat tail mutiliation.


Seek help.



"one could make a case of the legality of lizard tail mutiliation over cat tail mutiliation"

Comparatives, man, learn to understand them. Since you have failed so far, I will provide you with an easy-to-understand example: "a nanometer is longer than a picometer" does not imply that either is long.

P.S. Here's another example of you arguing a point not related to the premise of the argument with flawed logic. I think this is another one of those fallacies in argument along with your favourite "ad-hominem attacks". Maybe look over those again and see what you can learn?



"FGM is worse than MGM" doesn't imply that either is wrong. Easy enough.

Still, seek help.


You mean "either is right" right?


I don't think you understand what I did there. I just switched some words using your logic to show you the fallacy of it.
FryBender
Profile Joined January 2011
United States290 Posts
February 12 2013 15:05 GMT
#108
On February 12 2013 23:41 GnarlyArbitrage wrote:
Show nested quote +
On February 12 2013 23:21 Ianuus wrote:
On February 12 2013 22:53 GnarlyArbitrage wrote:
On February 12 2013 21:40 Ianuus wrote:
On February 12 2013 21:36 GnarlyArbitrage wrote:
On February 12 2013 21:30 Ianuus wrote:
On February 12 2013 21:15 GnarlyArbitrage wrote:
On February 12 2013 20:22 khaydarin9 wrote:
In the case of abortion, it's not that no one cares that it's the guy's child, too, it's more that there is no moral justification for someone to say "Hey, you have to endure nine months of pregnancy, and a lifetime of physical and social consequences of having been pregnant because I want you to." And before you claim that there's equally no moral justification for forcing a man to pay 18 years' worth of child support for a child he didn't want in the first place, consider that whether or not a woman carries the child to term, she'll be enduring a range of physical and psychological changes due to the pregnancy, so it's not that women just get off consequence-free if she does choose to have an abortion. And before you try to claim that if a woman doesn't want to endure consequences, she shouldn't have had sex - neither should men. Everyone should be prepared to accept the consequences - physical, financial, whatever - of their actions.

It would be very inconsistent to say that it's wrong for parents to have executive power over their children's bodies (in situations like circumcision) and then turn around and say that women have no right to decide what happens to their own reproductive systems.


So, because the woman has to carry the baby for nine months, the father must live the rest of his life knowing the mother murdered his child?

On February 12 2013 20:54 Ianuus wrote:
On February 12 2013 20:07 GnarlyArbitrage wrote:
On February 12 2013 19:44 Ianuus wrote:
[quote]

Once again, irrelvant information. I would pose that the legality of circumcision rests on the effect on circumsised individuals, which depends on the structure, rather than on its teleology.

P.S. At risk of ad-homineming your fragile little ego, I would also like to point out that your self-righteous tone, triumphant arrogance, liberal use of explicatives and constant "come at me bro" attitude puts a rather large dent on your attempt to sound intellectual - there is a difference between enlightened fervour and just being crude. Work on that, will you?


How is the purpose of the foreskin/clitoral hood irrelevant in the discussion of circumcision legality?

Keep up the attacks. My ego is at critical HP, I think I need a potion.


Because even if its purpose is exactly the same, what happens when you mutilate the organ and the effect it has on the subject may be completely different. For example - if you cut off a tail of some species of lizard, it ain't even mad and will regenerate it. If you cut off the tail of a cat, it's pretty much fucked. Thus, even if in both species the primary purpose of tails are for balance, one could make a case of the legality of lizard tail mutiliation over cat tail mutiliation.


"May be completely different." Sounds like you know your stuff.

Cutting the tail off a lizard, something that grows back, is no where near the same as cutting the skin off a dick or vagina. The skin doesn't grow back, just like the cat's tail.

Just because lizards seemingly don't feel the pain of their tails being cut off, you think that's an argument for legalizing "lizard cruelty"? Honestly, what the fuck is wrong with you?



Once again, since you lack the ability to see any logical flaws in the premise of my argument, you resort to putting words in my mouth then attacking the strawman which you've created. Since when did I promote animal cruelty? I merely compared two cases in their relative morality, not the morality of either case as an absolute. Your righteous indignation further erodes any pretence of a legitimate argument.

I did say "may be completely different", since I am not an arrogant prick such as you, and I do not pretend to have detailed knowledge of human anatomy, as you do. I can merely point out the flaws in your argument on principle. Arrogance starts where ability ends, and my ability with male and female circumcision is limited at best.


You're saying that person can make a case for cutting off a lizards tail, legally. If you're not saying that, then let me show you where you said that:

Thus, even if in both species the primary purpose of tails are for balance, one could make a case of the legality of lizard tail mutiliation over cat tail mutiliation.


Seek help.



"one could make a case of the legality of lizard tail mutiliation over cat tail mutiliation"

Comparatives, man, learn to understand them. Since you have failed so far, I will provide you with an easy-to-understand example: "a nanometer is longer than a picometer" does not imply that either is long.

P.S. Here's another example of you arguing a point not related to the premise of the argument with flawed logic. I think this is another one of those fallacies in argument along with your favourite "ad-hominem attacks". Maybe look over those again and see what you can learn?



"FGM is worse than MGM" doesn't imply that either is wrong. Easy enough.

Still, seek help.


You mean "either is right" right?


I don't think you understand what I did there. I just switched some words using your logic to show you the fallacy of it.



So you got confused by your own arguments and then you pretend like it's your great plan to "switch up words" in order to prove someone wrong? This means one of two things: either you're an idiot or you think that this is Looney Toons and the Bugs Bunny strategy of "no yes no yes no yes yes no" would work. Either way this is entertaining.
GnarlyArbitrage
Profile Blog Joined October 2011
575 Posts
February 12 2013 15:29 GMT
#109
On February 13 2013 00:05 FryBender wrote:
Show nested quote +
On February 12 2013 23:41 GnarlyArbitrage wrote:
On February 12 2013 23:21 Ianuus wrote:
On February 12 2013 22:53 GnarlyArbitrage wrote:
On February 12 2013 21:40 Ianuus wrote:
On February 12 2013 21:36 GnarlyArbitrage wrote:
On February 12 2013 21:30 Ianuus wrote:
On February 12 2013 21:15 GnarlyArbitrage wrote:
On February 12 2013 20:22 khaydarin9 wrote:
In the case of abortion, it's not that no one cares that it's the guy's child, too, it's more that there is no moral justification for someone to say "Hey, you have to endure nine months of pregnancy, and a lifetime of physical and social consequences of having been pregnant because I want you to." And before you claim that there's equally no moral justification for forcing a man to pay 18 years' worth of child support for a child he didn't want in the first place, consider that whether or not a woman carries the child to term, she'll be enduring a range of physical and psychological changes due to the pregnancy, so it's not that women just get off consequence-free if she does choose to have an abortion. And before you try to claim that if a woman doesn't want to endure consequences, she shouldn't have had sex - neither should men. Everyone should be prepared to accept the consequences - physical, financial, whatever - of their actions.

It would be very inconsistent to say that it's wrong for parents to have executive power over their children's bodies (in situations like circumcision) and then turn around and say that women have no right to decide what happens to their own reproductive systems.


So, because the woman has to carry the baby for nine months, the father must live the rest of his life knowing the mother murdered his child?

On February 12 2013 20:54 Ianuus wrote:
On February 12 2013 20:07 GnarlyArbitrage wrote:
[quote]

How is the purpose of the foreskin/clitoral hood irrelevant in the discussion of circumcision legality?

Keep up the attacks. My ego is at critical HP, I think I need a potion.


Because even if its purpose is exactly the same, what happens when you mutilate the organ and the effect it has on the subject may be completely different. For example - if you cut off a tail of some species of lizard, it ain't even mad and will regenerate it. If you cut off the tail of a cat, it's pretty much fucked. Thus, even if in both species the primary purpose of tails are for balance, one could make a case of the legality of lizard tail mutiliation over cat tail mutiliation.


"May be completely different." Sounds like you know your stuff.

Cutting the tail off a lizard, something that grows back, is no where near the same as cutting the skin off a dick or vagina. The skin doesn't grow back, just like the cat's tail.

Just because lizards seemingly don't feel the pain of their tails being cut off, you think that's an argument for legalizing "lizard cruelty"? Honestly, what the fuck is wrong with you?



Once again, since you lack the ability to see any logical flaws in the premise of my argument, you resort to putting words in my mouth then attacking the strawman which you've created. Since when did I promote animal cruelty? I merely compared two cases in their relative morality, not the morality of either case as an absolute. Your righteous indignation further erodes any pretence of a legitimate argument.

I did say "may be completely different", since I am not an arrogant prick such as you, and I do not pretend to have detailed knowledge of human anatomy, as you do. I can merely point out the flaws in your argument on principle. Arrogance starts where ability ends, and my ability with male and female circumcision is limited at best.


You're saying that person can make a case for cutting off a lizards tail, legally. If you're not saying that, then let me show you where you said that:

Thus, even if in both species the primary purpose of tails are for balance, one could make a case of the legality of lizard tail mutiliation over cat tail mutiliation.


Seek help.



"one could make a case of the legality of lizard tail mutiliation over cat tail mutiliation"

Comparatives, man, learn to understand them. Since you have failed so far, I will provide you with an easy-to-understand example: "a nanometer is longer than a picometer" does not imply that either is long.

P.S. Here's another example of you arguing a point not related to the premise of the argument with flawed logic. I think this is another one of those fallacies in argument along with your favourite "ad-hominem attacks". Maybe look over those again and see what you can learn?



"FGM is worse than MGM" doesn't imply that either is wrong. Easy enough.

Still, seek help.


You mean "either is right" right?


I don't think you understand what I did there. I just switched some words using your logic to show you the fallacy of it.



So you got confused by your own arguments and then you pretend like it's your great plan to "switch up words" in order to prove someone wrong? This means one of two things: either you're an idiot or you think that this is Looney Toons and the Bugs Bunny strategy of "no yes no yes no yes yes no" would work. Either way this is entertaining.


I'm enjoying these attacks. Must really piss you guys off that men think they have rights.
FryBender
Profile Joined January 2011
United States290 Posts
February 12 2013 15:43 GMT
#110
On February 13 2013 00:29 GnarlyArbitrage wrote:
Show nested quote +
On February 13 2013 00:05 FryBender wrote:
On February 12 2013 23:41 GnarlyArbitrage wrote:
On February 12 2013 23:21 Ianuus wrote:
On February 12 2013 22:53 GnarlyArbitrage wrote:
On February 12 2013 21:40 Ianuus wrote:
On February 12 2013 21:36 GnarlyArbitrage wrote:
On February 12 2013 21:30 Ianuus wrote:
On February 12 2013 21:15 GnarlyArbitrage wrote:
On February 12 2013 20:22 khaydarin9 wrote:
In the case of abortion, it's not that no one cares that it's the guy's child, too, it's more that there is no moral justification for someone to say "Hey, you have to endure nine months of pregnancy, and a lifetime of physical and social consequences of having been pregnant because I want you to." And before you claim that there's equally no moral justification for forcing a man to pay 18 years' worth of child support for a child he didn't want in the first place, consider that whether or not a woman carries the child to term, she'll be enduring a range of physical and psychological changes due to the pregnancy, so it's not that women just get off consequence-free if she does choose to have an abortion. And before you try to claim that if a woman doesn't want to endure consequences, she shouldn't have had sex - neither should men. Everyone should be prepared to accept the consequences - physical, financial, whatever - of their actions.

It would be very inconsistent to say that it's wrong for parents to have executive power over their children's bodies (in situations like circumcision) and then turn around and say that women have no right to decide what happens to their own reproductive systems.


So, because the woman has to carry the baby for nine months, the father must live the rest of his life knowing the mother murdered his child?

On February 12 2013 20:54 Ianuus wrote:
[quote]

Because even if its purpose is exactly the same, what happens when you mutilate the organ and the effect it has on the subject may be completely different. For example - if you cut off a tail of some species of lizard, it ain't even mad and will regenerate it. If you cut off the tail of a cat, it's pretty much fucked. Thus, even if in both species the primary purpose of tails are for balance, one could make a case of the legality of lizard tail mutiliation over cat tail mutiliation.


"May be completely different." Sounds like you know your stuff.

Cutting the tail off a lizard, something that grows back, is no where near the same as cutting the skin off a dick or vagina. The skin doesn't grow back, just like the cat's tail.

Just because lizards seemingly don't feel the pain of their tails being cut off, you think that's an argument for legalizing "lizard cruelty"? Honestly, what the fuck is wrong with you?



Once again, since you lack the ability to see any logical flaws in the premise of my argument, you resort to putting words in my mouth then attacking the strawman which you've created. Since when did I promote animal cruelty? I merely compared two cases in their relative morality, not the morality of either case as an absolute. Your righteous indignation further erodes any pretence of a legitimate argument.

I did say "may be completely different", since I am not an arrogant prick such as you, and I do not pretend to have detailed knowledge of human anatomy, as you do. I can merely point out the flaws in your argument on principle. Arrogance starts where ability ends, and my ability with male and female circumcision is limited at best.


You're saying that person can make a case for cutting off a lizards tail, legally. If you're not saying that, then let me show you where you said that:

Thus, even if in both species the primary purpose of tails are for balance, one could make a case of the legality of lizard tail mutiliation over cat tail mutiliation.


Seek help.



"one could make a case of the legality of lizard tail mutiliation over cat tail mutiliation"

Comparatives, man, learn to understand them. Since you have failed so far, I will provide you with an easy-to-understand example: "a nanometer is longer than a picometer" does not imply that either is long.

P.S. Here's another example of you arguing a point not related to the premise of the argument with flawed logic. I think this is another one of those fallacies in argument along with your favourite "ad-hominem attacks". Maybe look over those again and see what you can learn?



"FGM is worse than MGM" doesn't imply that either is wrong. Easy enough.

Still, seek help.


You mean "either is right" right?


I don't think you understand what I did there. I just switched some words using your logic to show you the fallacy of it.



So you got confused by your own arguments and then you pretend like it's your great plan to "switch up words" in order to prove someone wrong? This means one of two things: either you're an idiot or you think that this is Looney Toons and the Bugs Bunny strategy of "no yes no yes no yes yes no" would work. Either way this is entertaining.


I'm enjoying these attacks. Must really piss you guys off that men think they have rights.


Yep that's exactly why I'm making fun of you. It has nothing to do with your shitty posts that prove nothing, your use of every false logic argument out there, your over-inflated ego in thinking you're better and smarter then everyone, your weasely ways of trying to change topics when your arguments are proven false over and over and over again and just your crappy attitude that makes you sound like you're 14. All of that has nothing to do with anything. I'm making fun of you because I'm pissed off that men want rights. How dare they (I?)?
Ianuus
Profile Blog Joined May 2010
Australia349 Posts
February 12 2013 16:09 GMT
#111
You know OP, the sad thing is that most people here probably agree with the principle of your position, but just think that the way you express your points and the way you argue are obnoxiously retarded.
GnarlyArbitrage
Profile Blog Joined October 2011
575 Posts
February 12 2013 16:25 GMT
#112
On February 13 2013 00:43 FryBender wrote:
Show nested quote +
On February 13 2013 00:29 GnarlyArbitrage wrote:
On February 13 2013 00:05 FryBender wrote:
On February 12 2013 23:41 GnarlyArbitrage wrote:
On February 12 2013 23:21 Ianuus wrote:
On February 12 2013 22:53 GnarlyArbitrage wrote:
On February 12 2013 21:40 Ianuus wrote:
On February 12 2013 21:36 GnarlyArbitrage wrote:
On February 12 2013 21:30 Ianuus wrote:
On February 12 2013 21:15 GnarlyArbitrage wrote:
[quote]

So, because the woman has to carry the baby for nine months, the father must live the rest of his life knowing the mother murdered his child?

[quote]

"May be completely different." Sounds like you know your stuff.

Cutting the tail off a lizard, something that grows back, is no where near the same as cutting the skin off a dick or vagina. The skin doesn't grow back, just like the cat's tail.

Just because lizards seemingly don't feel the pain of their tails being cut off, you think that's an argument for legalizing "lizard cruelty"? Honestly, what the fuck is wrong with you?



Once again, since you lack the ability to see any logical flaws in the premise of my argument, you resort to putting words in my mouth then attacking the strawman which you've created. Since when did I promote animal cruelty? I merely compared two cases in their relative morality, not the morality of either case as an absolute. Your righteous indignation further erodes any pretence of a legitimate argument.

I did say "may be completely different", since I am not an arrogant prick such as you, and I do not pretend to have detailed knowledge of human anatomy, as you do. I can merely point out the flaws in your argument on principle. Arrogance starts where ability ends, and my ability with male and female circumcision is limited at best.


You're saying that person can make a case for cutting off a lizards tail, legally. If you're not saying that, then let me show you where you said that:

Thus, even if in both species the primary purpose of tails are for balance, one could make a case of the legality of lizard tail mutiliation over cat tail mutiliation.


Seek help.



"one could make a case of the legality of lizard tail mutiliation over cat tail mutiliation"

Comparatives, man, learn to understand them. Since you have failed so far, I will provide you with an easy-to-understand example: "a nanometer is longer than a picometer" does not imply that either is long.

P.S. Here's another example of you arguing a point not related to the premise of the argument with flawed logic. I think this is another one of those fallacies in argument along with your favourite "ad-hominem attacks". Maybe look over those again and see what you can learn?



"FGM is worse than MGM" doesn't imply that either is wrong. Easy enough.

Still, seek help.


You mean "either is right" right?


I don't think you understand what I did there. I just switched some words using your logic to show you the fallacy of it.



So you got confused by your own arguments and then you pretend like it's your great plan to "switch up words" in order to prove someone wrong? This means one of two things: either you're an idiot or you think that this is Looney Toons and the Bugs Bunny strategy of "no yes no yes no yes yes no" would work. Either way this is entertaining.


I'm enjoying these attacks. Must really piss you guys off that men think they have rights.


Yep that's exactly why I'm making fun of you. It has nothing to do with your shitty posts that prove nothing, your use of every false logic argument out there, your over-inflated ego in thinking you're better and smarter then everyone, your weasely ways of trying to change topics when your arguments are proven false over and over and over again and just your crappy attitude that makes you sound like you're 14. All of that has nothing to do with anything. I'm making fun of you because I'm pissed off that men want rights. How dare they (I?)?


Show me the proof. Lol.
KwarK
Profile Blog Joined July 2006
United States44456 Posts
February 12 2013 16:28 GMT
#113
I'm a guy and I need feminism. I don't see what the big deal is. It's not like the things feminists (in general, not the crazy ones (there's always some)) are asking for are things men don't want too. There are a lot of fucked up things about society's view on gender identity and challenging it should be encouraged. Unfortunately shit like the men's rights subreddits are hateful circle jerks of misogyny which make me feel ashamed to share a species with them so whatever, I need feminism, deal with it.
ModeratorThe angels have the phone box
GnarlyArbitrage
Profile Blog Joined October 2011
575 Posts
February 12 2013 17:02 GMT
#114
On February 13 2013 01:28 KwarK wrote:
I'm a guy and I need feminism. I don't see what the big deal is. It's not like the things feminists (in general, not the crazy ones (there's always some)) are asking for are things men don't want too. There are a lot of fucked up things about society's view on gender identity and challenging it should be encouraged. Unfortunately shit like the men's rights subreddits are hateful circle jerks of misogyny which make me feel ashamed to share a species with them so whatever, I need feminism, deal with it.



Why do you need it?

Women want reproductive rights, but by allowing the mother to get an abortion without the consent of the father is not what men want. Men should be allowed reproductive rights, as well. Hopefully, you or I, or anyone else on this board, will not have to be told their child will be murdered by the mother without their consent.

>Oh, we carry the baby for nine months! We tough now

To this, I'd say, if the man doesn't want to the child, he at least has to pay nine months child support. If the mother doesn't want it, then she doesn't have to pay child support, but it should not be solely her right to terminate the baby. Nine months has fucking nothing on two life times. One for the dead baby, two for the father that will have to live the rest of his life knowing his child was murdered before he even got to see the child.
KwarK
Profile Blog Joined July 2006
United States44456 Posts
February 12 2013 17:03 GMT
#115
Sorry, you seem to have confused the abortion discussion (which by the way you're a fucking moron on) with anything I just said in that post you quoted.
ModeratorThe angels have the phone box
corumjhaelen
Profile Blog Joined October 2009
France6884 Posts
February 12 2013 17:04 GMT
#116
I wanted to jump on the bandwagon on finding you a moron.
Just reading you in this thread disgust me, the worst part being you seem to find yourself smart.
Amazing.
‎numquam se plus agere quam nihil cum ageret, numquam minus solum esse quam cum solus esset
KwarK
Profile Blog Joined July 2006
United States44456 Posts
Last Edited: 2013-02-12 17:07:43
February 12 2013 17:05 GMT
#117
In fact, closing this because the level of the points you're bringing ("why do you want to kill babies") is so incredibly degrading to the dignity of this the site and humanity as a whole that I just can't bear it. Maybe try commenting on YouTube videos.

You've let me down, you've let men down, you've let teamliquid down, but most of all you've let yourself down.
ModeratorThe angels have the phone box
Prev 1 4 5 6 All
Please log in or register to reply.
Live Events Refresh
LiuLi Cup
20:00
#55
Maru vs RogueLIVE!
Clem vs herO
IntoTheiNu 636
Rex89
TKL 78
IndyStarCraft 44
Liquipedia
[ Submit Event ]
Live Streams
Refresh
StarCraft 2
Lowko377
Rex 89
TKL 78
IndyStarCraft 44
StarCraft: Brood War
Britney 8085
Calm 5023
GuemChi 1665
Zeus 1153
Bisu 925
Horang2 747
Jaedong 458
actioN 394
BeSt 390
Larva 303
[ Show more ]
Yoon 269
ggaemo 259
Leta 234
Mini 198
Light 193
firebathero 179
Rush 120
Soulkey 116
EffOrt 114
Stork 100
hero 95
Killer 93
Pusan 92
JYJ 84
Hyun 80
Movie 64
ZerO 54
Sacsri 51
Free 35
Barracks 33
sorry 31
ToSsGirL 27
Sharp 22
NotJumperer 21
Classic 18
yabsab 16
soO 14
Sea.KH 13
scan(afreeca) 10
Bishop 8
zelot 8
Dota 2
syndereN305
monkeys_forever113
XcaliburYe64
League of Legends
JimRising 337
Reynor82
Counter-Strike
olofmeister1318
shoxiejesuss1088
Heroes of the Storm
Trikslyr20
Other Games
summit1g11749
B2W.Neo188
Pyrionflax151
dupreeh149
Fuzer 149
crisheroes99
Mew2King60
ZerO(Twitch)15
Organizations
Other Games
gamesdonequick481
StarCraft: Brood War
lovetv 8
[ Show 9 non-featured ]
StarCraft 2
• LUISG 34
• AfreecaTV YouTube
• intothetv
• Kozan
• IndyKCrew
• Migwel
StarCraft: Brood War
• BSLYoutube
• STPLYoutube
• ZZZeroYoutube
Upcoming Events
Monday Night Weeklies
5h 45m
PiGosaur Cup
13h 45m
The PondCast
22h 45m
LiuLi Cup
23h 45m
OSC
1d 4h
Replay Cast
1d 11h
GSL
2 days
Maru vs Dark
Patches Events
2 days
OSC
2 days
Replay Cast
2 days
[ Show More ]
KCM Race Survival
2 days
RSL Revival
3 days
BSL
4 days
eOnzErG vs StRyKeR
Cross vs JDConan
RSL Revival
5 days
IPSL
5 days
Ret vs ggnore13
nOmaD vs Aether
BSL
5 days
Bonyth vs Doodle
Kyrie vs Jimin
Replay Cast
5 days
WardiTV Weekly
6 days
Kung Fu Cup
6 days
Liquipedia Results

Completed

Proleague 2026-11-16
Blizzard Classic Cup 2026
HCC Season 3

Ongoing

Acropolis #5
KCM Race Survival 2026 Season 4
International ShieldBattery League
BSL Season 23
IPSL Winter 2026-27
Calamity Cup Div. A Season 8
Underdog Cup 2026 Div 2-3
Stake Ranked Episode 6
BLAST Rivals Fall 2026
IEM Beijing 2026
PGL Masters Bucharest 2026
Stake Ranked Episode 5
1win Private Club #2
Thunderpick World Champ. '26
ESL Pro League Season 24
Stake Ranked Episode 4
1win Private Club #1
Logitech G Play Connect 2026
SL StarSeries Fall 2026
FISSURE Playground #3
BLAST Open Fall 2026

Upcoming

Sector 591
YSL S4
SC4ALL II: Brood War
NBSL 2026 Xiamen LAN
BSL 23: Non-Korean Championship
HSC XXX
Stellar Fest 2: Lunar Cup
StarCraft2 Weekly Open Tournament 2026 Grand Finals
SC4ALL II: StarCraft II
Kung Fu Cup 2026 Grand Finals
RSL Offline Finals
IEM Kraków 2027
PGL Bucharest 2027
BLAST Bounty Winter 2027
PGL Major Singapore 2026
TLPD

1. ByuN
2. TY
3. Dark
4. Solar
5. Stats
6. Nerchio
7. sOs
8. soO
9. INnoVation
10. Elazer
1. Rain
2. Flash
3. EffOrt
4. Last
5. Bisu
6. Soulkey
7. Mini
8. Sharp
Sidebar Settings...

Advertising | Privacy Policy | Terms Of Use | Contact Us

Original banner artwork: Jim Warren
The contents of this webpage are copyright © 2026 TLnet. All Rights Reserved.