|
On July 21 2004 14:57 8882 wrote: Tfeign: the graphs dont show one thing -the average time someone had played the game. Protoss is not a popular race, so the players who use it usually dont know the game so good like the zergs/terrans (most of the gamers are Koreans, who rarely play protoss). Also I still dont understand, when you say that protoss can make so many mistakes and zerg cant do nearly any. If zerg cant do nearly any mistakes (and the 1200++ zergs nearly dont do them, because they are good), why do 45% or more of the games are won by protoss players? If the matchup was imbalanced zerg would win 99% of the games.
I also remind you, that protoss players are known to be slower than terrans and zergs in terms of apm. I DONT SAY THAT APM=SKILL, but a 250apm zerg probably played the game much longer and has faster reactions, than a protoss with 'just' 150 apm (I dont want to start another apm tread).
In my opinion, you dont 'feel' pvz and instead of learning how to win, you made a trap in your mind telling you "I cant win any pvz. It is imbalanced."
And also a graph with the percantage of the races used among the ranks could be interesting.
Most protoss players are from Europe IMO and they play a lot of pvt games. European/american zergs are shittier and it;s a less popular race among nonkoreans, so the nonkorean pvz skill level is lower. However the pvt is better.
1. I have made many explanations/examples earlier regarding why toss's mistakes are very disastrous while zerg's mistakes are alot more forgivable in comparison.
2. If the matchup was imbalanced zerg would win 99% of the games.
No...just no. This is just totally, completely wrong.
3. In my opinion, you dont 'feel' pvz and instead of learning how to win, you made a trap in your mind telling you "I cant win any pvz. It is imbalanced."
I never said pvz is impossible. I never said I can't win pvz. I never said I can't beat Z. I do say that pvz is imbalanced in favor of z -- and the statistics do show that zerg win at an approximate 60%-30% average at the 1200+ level.
|
Russian Federation4447 Posts
I do believe changes should be made but these changes have to be very slight or else the percentiles will reverse. Like you cannot raise the templar storm damage up unless you really want protoss to dominate zerg. Lowering lurker health is DISASTROUS for ZvT because tanks will plow through them faster.
I really think making disruption web more feasible and easier to get will make this spell more often used. That and Dark archons should be supped just a bit and I think the balance issue will be resolved. I would say increase reaver AI but that would just be too damn devestating. I saw that video clip of how reaver AI used to be and it was damn powerful.
One more thing. Do any of you know how to beat mech as a zerg?? Do I macro or tech? I have NO IDEA how to beat mech. I've used mech against many zergs and I've beaten them all, and I dont even play terran. Or maybe queens > . Damn never even thought of using queens vs mech!! Ive just solved my own problem.
|
On July 21 2004 16:00 Teroru wrote: Show nested quote +On July 21 2004 13:05 tfeign wrote: *You did not flame me and make a valid intelligent argument - I'll stfu *You flamed me and made a valid intelligent argument - I'll stfu *You did not flame me and make a dumb/idiotic/newbie arguement - I'll criticize the ideas in your post *You flamed me and made a dumb/idiotic/newbie argument - I'll flame you, seriously.
I guess the 4th one was what happened earlier. Many valid arguements were hypothesized: * Toss players are rated higher than they should be due to more Terran players being on the ladder than Zerg players. This leads to protoss players playing Zergs who are better than them. * Slower players play protoss. * Protoss players lack creativity (with the exception of the 45% who infact DO win) You failed to debate any of those points.
The last 2 points are very generalized stereotypes. The first point, however is a valid, intelligent argument.
So I did a bit of analyzation.
From the PvT chart:
And from the race statistics: Terrans: 42% Zergs: 30% Protoss: 28%
Percentage that Protoss player will face a terran: 42% Percentage that Protoss player will face a non-terran: 58%
So even though T is the most used race in ng-i, P players actually will encounter non-T more times than they would encounter them at a 58%-42% ratio.
And from the PvT chart, you can see that the PvT % is more or less balanced. At the lower level, P has about 52% vs T.
So as you can see, the PvT impact which is argued to be raising P's rating is actually very little due to:
1. P would encounter non-terrans more times than terrans at a 58%-42% ratio
2. The PvT ratio is actually balanced enough as you can see from the charts that you can't say T is helping to boost P's ratings -- it only does so at the lower ratings at a very small margin.
and this final point is what really disproves that argument:
PvT at the highest level is extremely horrible. At the highest level, T beats P at an approximate 62%-38% ratio. Now look at the PvZ chart:
At the highest level, Z beats P at an approximate 67%-33%.
Therefore the argument that at more T players helping to inflate P players, allowing P players to play Z who are better than them is strongly disproved here because at the high level, the population of T is actually deflating P's ratings, however, the PvZ percentage is actually deflating as well, which goes against the argument. In conconclusion, what this show is that the amount of terran players and their have little to no significance in pvz statistics.
Very intelligent argument, however, a closer look at the statistics show that it has little to no significance.
If anyone is confused let me know and I'll try to summarize it to give an easier explanation.
|
u need to re-explain. I think what ur saying SHOULD make sense, but its a bit beyond me.
And the other 2 points are not stereotypical. Unless you would try to argue that Nazgul can play Zerg or Terran.
Infact, if yuo could give me more than 5 names of any1 with any skill below 150 apm with zerg or terran, i would be extremely surprised. This is extremely relevant.
As for the last point, about protoss players being creative; its a combination of creativty and logic. When i play ZvP, i exploit the protosses mistakes repeatedly. No single mistake loses protoss the game, but the many mistakes they seem to repeat over and over again. This is why many of them lose. For some reason, when zergs make mistakes, the protosses stand by and let them recover.
|
Russian Federation4447 Posts
Well if terran beats protoss at the highest level than we should do something about that too?
I dont think its up for us to decide what is best for the game, I think the amount of time you've spent looking up statistics would have been a lot better spent playing PvZ and improving YOUR OWN style. I dont see players like Nal_ra, Reach, or Zeus complaining about imbalance. They just practice. And they dominate whoever comes across them, terran, zerg or protoss.
Before I couldnt understand what the hell people were doing in zvz and got owned repeatedly. Then I spent time and around 20 games to figure out how the pros do it. Then slowly zvz became one of my strongest. Now it sucks cuz gamei zergs are so good at it. I dont think PvZ is out of the question and cannot be overcome. Ask yourself this question: have you ever analyzed your own style of playing and trying to find out it's weaknesses and spend extra time turning those weaknesses into strengths? Im guessing this answer will be no.
I think the only time we can find out about balance is when we consult the elite progamers. Find out what they have to say about it.
Let blizzard decide the changes, they aren't really bad at these balance issues. Compared to the orginal version we've gone a long way.
For now, just practice more. Nal_Ra isnt the person he is today by whining about race imbalances.
|
you don't speak korean no surprise you don't here them complaining
progamers complain about map imbalances all the time, you'd know this if you actually knew them personally. maps are imbalanced. period. no map is 100% balanced, so you better accept it as a fact. imbalances can be overcome; fact as well. we can go on forever about this but living in a dream world doesn't help anyone.
|
Sweden33723 Posts
On July 21 2004 14:03 Uboat wrote: Show nested quote +On July 20 2004 23:45 FrozenArbiter wrote: On July 20 2004 23:37 tfeign wrote: Intelligent comments to counter my claims will be gladly accepted (which I really haven't found any to counteract the significant zvp win% difference in every skill level)
Ignorant and stupid newbie posts like those by Teroru shall be flamed. -- zvp is hard for the zerg -- protoss is the easiest race to win with -- anyone who says these deserve to just die. If there was a more efficient way to shut newbies than the age old "stfu" method I would all out go for it. Uhm I thought I had provided you with this multiple times? PvZ at low levels is usually easier (I think if 4 minute games were counted/under 900 rating this would hold true statistics wise as well) for the toss since his units has more hp, quite luck based though. PvZ at midlevels is HARD for the toss as midlevel toss players lack a sense of timing. PvZ at quite a high level is NO PROBLEM because the tosses have said timing. PvZ on LT at the highest levels, is hard due to some games now being decided by imbalance (LT IMBALANCE NOT MATCHUP IMBALANCE). Thing is, some people, myself, like to think that even if I lose vs a zergplayer who is "at my level" at neogamei, it is very possible that I am more skilled than this person and that he only wins because he plays zerg... Kind of a lose argument but many many times a bad zerg can put up a way better fight vs skilled tosses than tosses can vs a skilled zerg. Just some thoughts that I have... It only seems that way because PvZ IS imbalanced without timing and most people don't have it until higher levels -.-
|
Sweden33723 Posts
On July 21 2004 17:02 smalltoss wrote: Show nested quote +On July 21 2004 16:00 Teroru wrote: On July 21 2004 13:05 tfeign wrote: *You did not flame me and make a valid intelligent argument - I'll stfu *You flamed me and made a valid intelligent argument - I'll stfu *You did not flame me and make a dumb/idiotic/newbie arguement - I'll criticize the ideas in your post *You flamed me and made a dumb/idiotic/newbie argument - I'll flame you, seriously.
I guess the 4th one was what happened earlier. Many valid arguements were hypothesized: * Toss players are rated higher than they should be due to more Terran players being on the ladder than Zerg players. This leads to protoss players playing Zergs who are better than them. * Slower players play protoss. * Protoss players lack creativity (with the exception of the 45% who infact DO win) You failed to debate any of those points. Slower players play whatever race, and with experience quicken their speed. Protoss is just a slower race, because you have fewer/stronger units, technically you only need 1 builder as oppose to the many needed with zerg/terran, you don't need to do the massive mines/sieging/construction that you do with terran, etc. What im saying is not that slower players play protoss because other races are too fast, but they choose protoss, and protoss is played slower than other races due to there not being as much to handle. And where are you pulling 'protoss players lack creativity', thats a ridiculous generalized explanation for a slightly imbalanced win:loss ratio, please elaborate. I used to have quite high apm when I played PvZ reach style (keying my gates and macroing during battle as well as setting rally-.-)
|
Sweden33723 Posts
On July 21 2004 23:51 [pG]Liquid`Nazgul wrote: you don't speak korean no surprise you don't here them complaining
progamers complain about map imbalances all the time, you'd know this if you actually knew them personally. maps are imbalanced. period. no map is 100% balanced, so you better accept it as a fact. imbalances can be overcome; fact as well. we can go on forever about this but living in a dream world doesn't help anyone.
I think elky (or was it you?) once said that progamers complain non-stop in an effort to strenghten their race so they can make more money
|
not me
that sounds ridiculous I doubt elky said that
|
Russian Federation4447 Posts
I was talking about race imbalance. Of course map imbalance is a huge factor and no doubt people would complain about maps like paradoxxx. But i dont think they will really complain too much about race imbalance. Like protoss is weaker than zerg or zerg is weaker than terran. This protoss is weaker than zerg thing was disproved when reach knocked yellow out. And this zerg was weaker than terran was disproved when Junwi came around and knocked all the terrans out.
|
Sweden33723 Posts
On July 22 2004 06:25 [pG]Liquid`Nazgul wrote: not me
that sounds ridiculous I doubt elky said that Oops meant map imbalance I think long ago~ And by more money I meant succses ><
|
This old post is unavailable due to an encoding issue. Please contact an admin if you would like this post restored for historical reasons.
|
54.1 vs 45.9 over hundredss of thousands of games sounds like something that matters doesnt it?
|
post the stats on neogamei.com plz
|
On July 22 2004 15:52 STIMEY d okgm fish wrote: 54.1 vs 45.9 over hundredss of thousands of games sounds like something that matters doesnt it? It depends on what you mean by "matters". As far as matchup balance is concerned, no, I don't think it matters at all (for the reasons listed in the second paragraph of my post above). There are tons of things that could cause the difference in percentages, matchup imbalance being one of the least likely causes.
|
I really don't get all those people that say Protoss players are globally weaker somehow (slower, less creative) than other players in the same ranking as them. That argument amounts to saying P is overpowered, and it means that for example if any given Z or T player switched to P with all his gosu speed and creativity and whatever, they would actually win more. So with that kind of incentive who wouldn't switch to toss? Especially for pros where there is money on the line. This is a dumb argument. When I play T or Z I often have more APM than with my toss even though I'm a TOTAL NOOB with either race. This is not because I automagically transform into a faster player suddenly, but simply because there are just more things to be doing... I do 110 apm with zerg and feel like I'm barely doing anything, and with 100 apm I do more or less whatever I want with toss. Toss needs to think ahead of their opponents, build counters in advance and position their units at the right places, being an ultra fast clicker just isn't a big advantage for them.
I do think PvT is easier than PvZ up to a certain level. And yes, since there are also more T than Z players, P ratings will get ahead of their PvZ levels until 1400-1450 or so. Then lots of P players of wildly varied PvZ skills will get clumped with 1400's ratings. in 1500+ there is a big jump in the PvZ skill of toss players, and further on (1600+) the high-end P < T and P < Z imbalances brings them down in the win % again.
|
|
|
So, to summarize it, we Protoss players are doomed?
|
I thinck this statistics are irelevant...If someone would make a statistic of witch colour wins in chess i am almost sure it won't be 50%-50%. I asume eveyone would agree that at least in chess everything is balanced...Is like the flipping of a coin experiment, if u repeat the experiments a 100 times you should get equal results for both sides...well try it....see how many times you get the right result...
|
|
|
|
|
|