|
On July 21 2004 05:43 Teroru wrote: Nazgul, i never claimed my opinion to be without flaw. He offered some reasons as to why PvZ is imbalanced. Those reasons are flawed.
I am not saying there is no possibility of him being right, i'm asking him to provide more information to back up his claim.
Nazgul, is it your belief that ZvP is imbalanced? Or that ZvP is imbalanced on Lost Temple? i believe PvZ is NEVER ever balanced. it all depends on the map to which side it goes there. on lost temple I give Zerg the edge on all positions (excluding 12-3).
|
thanks for the statistics sv14 wow can everyone stop flaming?
ok...im assuming these statistics are from peoples races in game, so maby an explanation for the weird "bumps" in the statistics might be that more players at these levels play random? for some reason? and they might have different skill with different races.
i dont think this would explain it but its just a thought, along the lines of many of the other theories people have stated in this thread.
maby this will lead someone else on the right track to explaining it =)
|
On July 21 2004 05:47 ret wrote: teroru that's a rhetorical question! =)
He has been complaing about it over the years, but pvz has been his problem match, he excels at PvT! (pvz still very good tho :O ) I've been complaining only about lost temple, nostalgia and maps like that. I'm not as good on these maps because my zealot templar control lacks big time, and I do admit this. but when I think about beating some of the best protoss players with MY ZERG, on lost temple without ever playing that, I can't help but feel this matchup is imbalanced.
my pvz at for example char and avant garde is good, and so it is at islands of course
|
WC3 is obviously more balanced, but that's primarily because all races are the same.
|
|
|
Sweden33723 Posts
On July 21 2004 06:46 [pG]Liquid`Nazgul wrote: Show nested quote +On July 21 2004 05:43 Teroru wrote: Nazgul, i never claimed my opinion to be without flaw. He offered some reasons as to why PvZ is imbalanced. Those reasons are flawed.
I am not saying there is no possibility of him being right, i'm asking him to provide more information to back up his claim.
Nazgul, is it your belief that ZvP is imbalanced? Or that ZvP is imbalanced on Lost Temple? i believe PvZ is NEVER ever balanced. it all depends on the map to which side it goes there. on lost temple I give Zerg the edge on all positions (excluding 12-3). You don't think 12P vs 9Z is balanced -_-?
|
|
|
Have you seen Chojja vs Reach on LT, WCG 2003 qualis?  I'll just say Chojja was terrifying.
|
Sweden33723 Posts
On July 21 2004 09:02 MPXMX wrote: Have you seen Chojja vs Reach on LT, WCG 2003 qualis?  I'll just say Chojja was terrifying. Yeah  And Jinnam vs reach on the same spots. Reach still worked some magic in at least jinnam game and almost won!
|
Braavos36402 Posts
tfeign, while your points can have legitimacy and you may feel it's frustrating when you believe people are being stupid (again, an opinion) try not to talk down to people, especially people who are probably better than you. i know skill level may not dictate how well you understand statistics or whatever, but the condescending tone you post with is just not a good idea. i'm not flaming you, it's just a suggestion.
|
On July 21 2004 09:28 Hot_Bid wrote: tfeign, while your points can have legitimacy and you may feel it's frustrating when you believe people are being stupid (again, an opinion) try not to talk down to people, especially people who are probably better than you. i know skill level may not dictate how well you understand statistics or whatever, but the condescending tone you post with is just not a good idea. i'm not flaming you, it's just a suggestion.
Yeah, I'll try to do that. I guess I was just really pissed off because the person who flamed me was the same one who made some of the most ignorant/newb posts I've seen just for the sake of arguing. I mean, I don't even mind if he flamed me and then offered some intelligent comments -- and I would have even let him get away with it if he didn't insult me in the beginning. Basically:
*You did not flame me and make a valid intelligent argument - I'll stfu *You flamed me and made a valid intelligent argument - I'll stfu *You did not flame me and make a dumb/idiotic/newbie arguement - I'll criticize the ideas in your post *You flamed me and made a dumb/idiotic/newbie argument - I'll flame you, seriously.
I guess the 4th one was what happened earlier. I don't try to argue just for the sake of arguing with someone. If someone makes a valid claim or statement, I will gladly accept it. I'm not someone ignorant. Yet, I have read several posts that tried to argue against me just for the sake of arguing, regardless of the nature of the argument -- that's what really piss me off.
Well, I've taken a good night sleep and I feel better today. I'll try to be a bit nicer if I was acting too condescending yesterday.
But again to this argument, a 55% - 67% zvp winning percentage (where the gap, in contrary to popular beliefs, increases with skill level) needs some tuning IMO. Where a zerg winning more than 2 every 3 games at the highest skill levels is saying something. And I'm not suggesting drastic changes like making zealots 2x health or something crazy like that. I suggest minor tunings like a small boost to storm, a small reduction in maelstrom / mind control costs. I believe someone suggested that a goon should be able to kill a scourge in 2 shots by reducing scourge health, but then it would make marines kill scourges faster, so I'm not sure about that. These small changes will effect the game in small ways that would help balance the gap between z&p on LT a bit more.
Another good change would be to update the LT map to new versions which doesn't give advantages due to positions. 90% of games are played on this map -- it's a good idea to balance the game on this map, but updating it to take out racial imbalance would be a big task, if someone is up to it.
|
Russian Federation4447 Posts
Maybe you can make that corsair disruption web thing more powerful... Make it cost less to build the carrier thingy and make it less expensive to research the web. Plus make the web last a bit longer. It would sure as hell help against lurk contain.
I would personally change the thing about dark archons losing all their shields to a mind control. Its utter bullshit. Mind control sucks balls anyways. Mind control a ling? Even mind controlling an ultra isnt as good as maelstorm.
I think Dark archons are to toss what queens are to zerg. DA's have extremely high potential. It is potentially just as good as a storm. Maelstorm combined with storm is just soooo deadly.
|
Tien there were 2 levels P>Z so please do notice that was in there. Also watch mondi vs testi game 4. This is probally more about balance issues but watch DAs and Queens used as game breakers essentially.
|
On July 20 2004 23:45 FrozenArbiter wrote: Show nested quote +On July 20 2004 23:37 tfeign wrote: Intelligent comments to counter my claims will be gladly accepted (which I really haven't found any to counteract the significant zvp win% difference in every skill level)
Ignorant and stupid newbie posts like those by Teroru shall be flamed. -- zvp is hard for the zerg -- protoss is the easiest race to win with -- anyone who says these deserve to just die. If there was a more efficient way to shut newbies than the age old "stfu" method I would all out go for it. Uhm I thought I had provided you with this multiple times? PvZ at low levels is usually easier (I think if 4 minute games were counted/under 900 rating this would hold true statistics wise as well) for the toss since his units has more hp, quite luck based though. PvZ at midlevels is HARD for the toss as midlevel toss players lack a sense of timing. PvZ at quite a high level is NO PROBLEM because the tosses have said timing. PvZ on LT at the highest levels, is hard due to some games now being decided by imbalance (LT IMBALANCE NOT MATCHUP IMBALANCE).
Thing is, some people, myself, like to think that even if I lose vs a zergplayer who is "at my level" at neogamei, it is very possible that I am more skilled than this person and that he only wins because he plays zerg...
Kind of a lose argument but many many times a bad zerg can put up a way better fight vs skilled tosses than tosses can vs a skilled zerg. Just some thoughts that I have...
|
Tfeign: the graphs dont show one thing -the average time someone had played the game. Protoss is not a popular race, so the players who use it usually dont know the game so good like the zergs/terrans (most of the gamers are Koreans, who rarely play protoss). Also I still dont understand, when you say that protoss can make so many mistakes and zerg cant do nearly any. If zerg cant do nearly any mistakes (and the 1200++ zergs nearly dont do them, because they are good), why do 45% or more of the games are won by protoss players? If the matchup was imbalanced zerg would win 99% of the games.
I also remind you, that protoss players are known to be slower than terrans and zergs in terms of apm. I DONT SAY THAT APM=SKILL, but a 250apm zerg probably played the game much longer and has faster reactions, than a protoss with 'just' 150 apm (I dont want to start another apm tread).
In my opinion, you dont 'feel' pvz and instead of learning how to win, you made a trap in your mind telling you "I cant win any pvz. It is imbalanced."
And also a graph with the percantage of the races used among the ranks could be interesting.
Most protoss players are from Europe IMO and they play a lot of pvt games. European/american zergs are shittier and it;s a less popular race among nonkoreans, so the nonkorean pvz skill level is lower. However the pvt is better.
|
On July 21 2004 14:57 8882 wrote: Tfeign: the graphs dont show one thing -the average time someone had played the game. Protoss is not a popular race, so the players who use it usually dont know the game so good like the zergs/terrans (most of the gamers are Koreans, who rarely play protoss). Also I still dont understand, when you say that protoss can make so many mistakes and zerg cant do nearly any. If zerg cant do nearly any mistakes (and the 1200++ zergs nearly dont do them, because they are good), why do 45% or more of the games are won by protoss players? If the matchup was imbalanced zerg would win 99% of the games.
I also remind you, that protoss players are known to be slower than terrans and zergs in terms of apm. I DONT SAY THAT APM=SKILL, but a 250apm zerg probably played the game much longer and has faster reactions, than a protoss with 'just' 150 apm (I dont want to start another apm tread).
In my opinion, you dont 'feel' pvz and instead of learning how to win, you made a trap in your mind telling you "I cant win any pvz. It is imbalanced."
And also a graph with the percantage of the races used among the ranks could be interesting.
Most protoss players are from Europe IMO and they play a lot of pvt games. European/american zergs are shittier and it;s a less popular race among nonkoreans, so the nonkorean pvz skill level is lower. However the pvt is better. no, that apm argument is very flawed. i know friends who've played protoss for 6 years and have under 150 apm, and are very good. you said it yourself, you can't consider apm has a measure for skill, and very much less experience
|
On July 21 2004 15:14 RuGbUg wrote: Show nested quote +On July 21 2004 14:57 8882 wrote: Tfeign: the graphs dont show one thing -the average time someone had played the game. Protoss is not a popular race, so the players who use it usually dont know the game so good like the zergs/terrans (most of the gamers are Koreans, who rarely play protoss). Also I still dont understand, when you say that protoss can make so many mistakes and zerg cant do nearly any. If zerg cant do nearly any mistakes (and the 1200++ zergs nearly dont do them, because they are good), why do 45% or more of the games are won by protoss players? If the matchup was imbalanced zerg would win 99% of the games.
I also remind you, that protoss players are known to be slower than terrans and zergs in terms of apm. I DONT SAY THAT APM=SKILL, but a 250apm zerg probably played the game much longer and has faster reactions, than a protoss with 'just' 150 apm (I dont want to start another apm tread).
In my opinion, you dont 'feel' pvz and instead of learning how to win, you made a trap in your mind telling you "I cant win any pvz. It is imbalanced."
And also a graph with the percantage of the races used among the ranks could be interesting.
Most protoss players are from Europe IMO and they play a lot of pvt games. European/american zergs are shittier and it;s a less popular race among nonkoreans, so the nonkorean pvz skill level is lower. However the pvt is better. no, that apm argument is very flawed. i know friends who've played protoss for 6 years and have under 150 apm, and are very good. you said it yourself, you can't consider apm has a measure for skill, and very much less experience
You confuse apm with useless clicking. THey *can* be the same thing, but they aren't neccesarily the same thing.
If i can micro 3 battles simultaneously, while macro'ing, expanding, and teching at 300 apm, and you can only handle micro'ing the battle at the front of you base because of your 120 apm, who do u think is going to win?
|
On July 21 2004 13:05 tfeign wrote: *You did not flame me and make a valid intelligent argument - I'll stfu *You flamed me and made a valid intelligent argument - I'll stfu *You did not flame me and make a dumb/idiotic/newbie arguement - I'll criticize the ideas in your post *You flamed me and made a dumb/idiotic/newbie argument - I'll flame you, seriously.
I guess the 4th one was what happened earlier.
Many valid arguements were hypothesized: * Toss players are rated higher than they should be due to more Terran players being on the ladder than Zerg players. This leads to protoss players playing Zergs who are better than them. * Slower players play protoss. * Protoss players lack creativity (with the exception of the 45% who infact DO win)
You failed to debate any of those points.
|
On July 21 2004 15:55 Teroru wrote: Show nested quote +On July 21 2004 15:14 RuGbUg wrote: On July 21 2004 14:57 8882 wrote: Tfeign: the graphs dont show one thing -the average time someone had played the game. Protoss is not a popular race, so the players who use it usually dont know the game so good like the zergs/terrans (most of the gamers are Koreans, who rarely play protoss). Also I still dont understand, when you say that protoss can make so many mistakes and zerg cant do nearly any. If zerg cant do nearly any mistakes (and the 1200++ zergs nearly dont do them, because they are good), why do 45% or more of the games are won by protoss players? If the matchup was imbalanced zerg would win 99% of the games.
I also remind you, that protoss players are known to be slower than terrans and zergs in terms of apm. I DONT SAY THAT APM=SKILL, but a 250apm zerg probably played the game much longer and has faster reactions, than a protoss with 'just' 150 apm (I dont want to start another apm tread).
In my opinion, you dont 'feel' pvz and instead of learning how to win, you made a trap in your mind telling you "I cant win any pvz. It is imbalanced."
And also a graph with the percantage of the races used among the ranks could be interesting.
Most protoss players are from Europe IMO and they play a lot of pvt games. European/american zergs are shittier and it;s a less popular race among nonkoreans, so the nonkorean pvz skill level is lower. However the pvt is better. no, that apm argument is very flawed. i know friends who've played protoss for 6 years and have under 150 apm, and are very good. you said it yourself, you can't consider apm has a measure for skill, and very much less experience You confuse apm with useless clicking. THey *can* be the same thing, but they aren't neccesarily the same thing. If i can micro 3 battles simultaneously, while macro'ing, expanding, and teching at 300 apm, and you can only handle micro'ing the battle at the front of you base because of your 120 apm, who do u think is going to win? (#1, i dont have 120 apm, i'm actually a person who argues more apm is better)But what if they can do all taht with 150 apm? then what? my friend can do all that with 150 apm, because hes got a ridiculously fast mouse speed. and what you're pointing out is skill, if you re-read that persons post, he correlating apm with EXPERIENCE, NOT SKILL.
|
On July 21 2004 16:00 Teroru wrote: Show nested quote +On July 21 2004 13:05 tfeign wrote: *You did not flame me and make a valid intelligent argument - I'll stfu *You flamed me and made a valid intelligent argument - I'll stfu *You did not flame me and make a dumb/idiotic/newbie arguement - I'll criticize the ideas in your post *You flamed me and made a dumb/idiotic/newbie argument - I'll flame you, seriously.
I guess the 4th one was what happened earlier. Many valid arguements were hypothesized: * Toss players are rated higher than they should be due to more Terran players being on the ladder than Zerg players. This leads to protoss players playing Zergs who are better than them. * Slower players play protoss. * Protoss players lack creativity (with the exception of the 45% who infact DO win) You failed to debate any of those points.
Slower players play whatever race, and with experience quicken their speed. Protoss is just a slower race, because you have fewer/stronger units, technically you only need 1 builder as oppose to the many needed with zerg/terran, you don't need to do the massive mines/sieging/construction that you do with terran, etc. What im saying is not that slower players play protoss because other races are too fast, but they choose protoss, and protoss is played slower than other races due to there not being as much to handle. And where are you pulling 'protoss players lack creativity', thats a ridiculous generalized explanation for a slightly imbalanced win:loss ratio, please elaborate.
|
|
|
|
|
|