|
The first episode of Code Geass: Lelouch of the Rebellion unfolds at
rollercoaster pace, leaving no time for the viewer to let the events sink in,
let alone reflect on them. I found myself having to pause frequently to keep up
with what was happening. Scores of characters are introduced (barely), most of
them walking clichés. Some High School Girls are shown just long enough to set
up for a high-school-lovey-dovey-harem-romance scenario. The Evil Tough Guy in
charge of the Imperial Royal Guard wouldn't convince a three-year-old. The main
character is a Fallen Prince with an Idiot Friend. The dialogue is stilted and
sometimes nonsensical (at least going by the translation), with cringeworthy
attempts at humor.
There is copious mecha (human-controlled robots and machines) pew-pew to spice
things up, adding "action". A Japanese quarter is wiped out in a Britannian
cover-up job in order to demonstrate the utter evil of the White Devils who now
rule the world and only have contempt for the noble Japanese. The plot is a
series of rather convenient coincidences, and every event, theme and character
crammed into the 24-minute duration has the subtlety of a sledgehammer.
The only thing Code Geass R1 E01 gave me was an urge to write this.
 
|
United Kingdom3685 Posts
I opened this blog hoping for a funny story about Doraemon or Anpanman. Now I'm sad 
|
Anpanman?
![[image loading]](http://www.haozxwang.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/11/315.jpg)
Anime is not for everyone. I don't know what you like but I can recommend you check out Gintama.
|
I haven't seen Code Geass, so I can't say for sure, but the chances are good that the translations screwed up a lot of things. Anime translations generally are pretty bad.
If this is your first anime, then it's no surprise you'd find it stupid. Most anime don't make much sense in a vacuum, they use certain genre-typical (genres within the medium anime, that is) elements over and over again, the real content lies behind that. You kind of have to learn how to watch anime.
And of course there are plenty of crap anime out there, no denying that. Just as with everything else. Not a reason to call them "kiddy-cartoons".
|
Well Code Geass is one of the most overrated piece of garbage animes out there, so i mostly agree with what you said. However there are some gems out there which avoid all the nonsensical and genre-typical anime bullshit. Like Mushishi or Logh
|
|
|
I always wondered what people like about Code Geass. Not only is it not all that great by itself, it's also aimed at girls. Not that Shoujo can't be entertaining or well-made, but it becomes weird when you're used to shounen using a similar style.
|
Hong Kong9154 Posts
welcome to bad, but popular, anime
|
Also, IMO, the drawing style is not to my liking. That's what put me off Codea Geass at first. Still watched it and enjoyed it in the end.
And I'd say the scenes when the ladies suit up and get down into the robot, the show is definately Shonen.
After thinking it through more, I'd say that CG is half shonen half shoujo ^^
|
Yeah, most are kiddy like.
I have seen plenty and I just can't take any more anime where noone dies whatsoever, there is no personal relationship coherence(main character befriending everyone that tries to kill him after their villain arc is done) and stuff like that.
There are no consequences it feels like.
But occasionally you will find the odd Madoka, Steins Gate, Psycho Pass and you will enjoy them.
Plus if you are new to the genre you can always watch the classics and understand why so many people came to love anime.
|
its CLAMP! noodle people with Sunrise MECHA! YEAH! :D
Anyways itsjustatank totally nailed it already (even though i still enjoy bad anime just cuz I can sit back and just watch it for the mecha/fan service every once in a while)
>Madoka being good LOL
cuz anything that is grim dark (inb4 deconstruction gets used) is good now.
Also title is misleading I was thinking of doraemon as well since CG is mostly aimed that a slightly older age group.
|
When people shit on anime for being for kids and having no depth, the go-to answer is that they should watch Monster.
|
On October 25 2013 00:59 Tobberoth wrote:
When people shit on anime for being for kids and having no depth, the go-to answer is that they should watch Monster.
Except the OP who is clueless about the subject noone else said that all anime are childish crap.
But the occasional gem like monster doesn't mean the opposite.
|
T.O.P.
Hong Kong4685 Posts
Code Geass is the greatest anime of all time. All Hail Britiannia!
I bet you are all Sword Art Online haters too.
|
On October 24 2013 22:17 spinesheath wrote:
And of course there are plenty of crap anime out there, no denying that. Just as with everything else. Not a reason to call them "kiddy-cartoons".
On October 25 2013 01:37 Steveling wrote:
Except the OP who is clueless about the subject noone else said that all anime are childish crap.
Heh, the title was just intended to draw attention  I didn't expect it to be taken so seriously. I've watched some animes throughout the years.
Gintama, Monster, Madoka, Stein's Gate, Psycho Pass, Mushishi, Logh
Thanks, will check out.
This blog was mostly selfish ranting, but thanks for the helpful responses.
|
On October 25 2013 02:34 T.O.P. wrote:
Code Geass is the greatest anime of all time. All Hail Britiannia!
I bet you are all Sword Art Online haters too.
Not really, I just stopped watching after 30 seconds.
|
Nobody so far has mentioned Attack On Titan, so I'll just throw that into the pot.
|
On October 25 2013 05:32 ninazerg wrote:
Nobody so far has mentioned Attack On Titan, so I'll just throw that into the pot.
A japanese bloke I met in Kyoto recommended me that anime! Hopefully it lives up to his excitement so that I can thank him when next time I see him
|
On October 25 2013 05:32 ninazerg wrote:
Nobody so far has mentioned Attack On Titan, so I'll just throw that into the pot.
That's pretty much THE most overhyped anime I could think of. I don't know the manga; maybe that one deserves the fame, but the anime... no idea what people like about it. I watched the whole thing just to maybe get it, but to no avail.
|
Watch Utena instead of Madoka :D
also Attack on Titan is ok for what it is.
Might as well ask the TL anime thread for their thoughts -- I mean they have that link breaks down what anime to watch -- which for the most part is really nice.
|
code geass isn't a chilren's anime. Doraemon is
|
On October 25 2013 06:42 Leeoku wrote:
code geass isn't a chilren's anime. Doraemon is
yeah I'm pretty sure Code Geass isn't for kids. What would they think of the table scene?
|
On October 25 2013 06:54 Zhang wrote:Show nested quote +On October 25 2013 06:42 Leeoku wrote:
code geass isn't a chilren's anime. Doraemon is yeah I'm pretty sure Code Geass isn't for kids. What would they think of the table scene?
She just had an itch yo.
|
why isn't this on the general anime thread?
Since we're ranting about anime, here's my contribution:
I don't understand how some anime can get so repetitive. Last week I was watching this attack on titan, and it couldn't go 5 minutes without a throwing flashback to my face. And to make it worse, they even use the same scenes from 3 episodes ago.
So you end up with only 10 minutes of actual plot and 15 minutes of OP/ED and flashbacks with repetition of the same scenes. This is why I stopped watching most of the seinen I started to watch. Steins gate, although very slow plot-wise, was watchable.
For now I'll just stick to finger rolls and palmtop tigers.
+ Show Spoiler +
|
On October 25 2013 05:56 spinesheath wrote:Show nested quote +On October 25 2013 05:32 ninazerg wrote:
Nobody so far has mentioned Attack On Titan, so I'll just throw that into the pot. That's pretty much THE most overhyped anime I could think of. I don't know the manga; maybe that one deserves the fame, but the anime... no idea what people like about it. I watched the whole thing just to maybe get it, but to no avail.
The Titan anime is pretty much Neon Genesis Evengelion set in Berserk setting meeting Dragon Ball Z where you anticipate which character to have their super saiyan mode next.
Watch School Days though, you'll love it!
|
On October 25 2013 02:34 T.O.P. wrote:
Code Geass is the greatest anime of all time. All Hail Britiannia!
I bet you are all Sword Art Online haters too.
And you would be correct >;D
|
On October 25 2013 05:32 ninazerg wrote:
Nobody so far has mentioned Attack On Titan, so I'll just throw that into the pot.
Because that's totally not a kiddie show.
|
ALLEYCAT BLUES50120 Posts
On October 24 2013 22:07 TOCHMY wrote:Anpanman? Anime is not for everyone. I don't know what you like but I can recommend you check out Gintama.
NEO AMSTRONG CYCLONE JET AMSTRONG CANNON!
Gintama is one of the best animes I have ever watched.
|
Code Geass is definitely not a kid's anime. Given you've only watched the first episode, I'll say that I think that Code geass is one of the animes with one of the stronger plots/stories and character developments in terms of anime.
|
On October 24 2013 23:25 itsjustatank wrote:
welcome to bad, but popular, anime
top ten of all time*
On October 25 2013 05:32 ninazerg wrote:
That's pretty much THE most overhyped anime I could think of. I don't know the manga; maybe that one deserves the fame, but the anime... no idea what people like about it. I watched the whole thing just to maybe get it, but to no avail.
the standard hipster talk "I hate this (anime) because it's overhyped." It's pretty good hater
|
On October 25 2013 05:56 spinesheath wrote:Show nested quote +On October 25 2013 05:32 ninazerg wrote:
Nobody so far has mentioned Attack On Titan, so I'll just throw that into the pot. That's pretty much THE most overhyped anime I could think of. I don't know the manga; maybe that one deserves the fame, but the anime... no idea what people like about it. I watched the whole thing just to maybe get it, but to no avail.
As a person who read the manga but haven't seen the anime. I think it's terrible but definitely not the worst.
|
On October 25 2013 13:14 asdfOu wrote:Show nested quote +On October 24 2013 23:25 itsjustatank wrote:
welcome to bad, but popular, anime top ten of all time* Show nested quote +On October 25 2013 05:32 ninazerg wrote:
That's pretty much THE most overhyped anime I could think of. I don't know the manga; maybe that one deserves the fame, but the anime... no idea what people like about it. I watched the whole thing just to maybe get it, but to no avail. the standard hipster talk "I hate this (anime) because it's overhyped." It's pretty good hater
No where did he say he hated it. That projection......
|
On October 25 2013 13:14 asdfOu wrote:Show nested quote +On October 24 2013 23:25 itsjustatank wrote:
welcome to bad, but popular, anime top ten of all time* Show nested quote +On October 25 2013 05:32 ninazerg wrote:
That's pretty much THE most overhyped anime I could think of. I don't know the manga; maybe that one deserves the fame, but the anime... no idea what people like about it. I watched the whole thing just to maybe get it, but to no avail. the standard hipster talk "I hate this (anime) because it's overhyped." It's pretty good hater
I watched it. Both seasons. I have an informed opinion on this anime.
In short: They spent 25 episodes and still haven't gotten any story done yet. The plot is random and without a purpose. They constantly go around saying "this guy is so awesome for his skills in xyz" and then they try to prove that somehow, but it always ends up being stupid.+ Show Spoiler +And did they really think killing the main character had any impact? It was obvious that he would be back. None of the other characters was able to carry any plot whatsoever.
|
Code Geass is ok-ish anime, I didn't like it that much. It got popular mostly because the character design was attractive and it has robots and stuff.
It's basically gundam seed type of anime.
rahxephon imo is wayyyyyyy better in every way, proper romance, story line, music etc
|
Code Geass made me really hungry for Pizza Hut.
|
Hong Kong9154 Posts
On October 25 2013 15:08 ETisME wrote:
It got popular mostly because the character design was attractive and it has robots and stuff.
attractive character design? do you feel that human beings should have triangles for chins and faces and have abnormally long limbs?
On October 25 2013 15:08 ETisME wrote:
It's basically gundam seed type of anime.
Yep.
http://www.infinitelooper.com/?v=AevLXJ-_mOg&p=n#/430;435
|
I don't like the over the top animes like bleach and berserker. Making a character too much of a bad ass just makes it annoying. I liked monster but on a second viewing the plot just develops too slow and the characters gasp too much. I know it's weird and it's probably very normal in Japan but it annoys me for some reason.
|
ALLEYCAT BLUES50120 Posts
On October 25 2013 23:02 B.I.G. wrote:
I don't like the over the top animes like bleach and berserker. Making a character too much of a bad ass just makes it annoying. I liked monster but on a second viewing the plot just develops too slow and the characters gasp too much. I know it's weird and it's probably very normal in Japan but it annoys me for some reason.
don't lump bleach and berserk together, Guts earned his badassery.
|
|
|
avoid long-running shounen series like bleach and naruto, they are dumb and filled with countless fillers
avoid moe/harem crap, they are superficial and annoying
shows aired on noitaminA are usually good as they are more unique and tend not to contain shows filled with stereotypes
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Noitamina
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT![[image loading]](http://i.imgur.com/mJcnmMQ.gif)
