EPTJust a thought.
Impromptu vs Preparation
| Blogs > Kenpachi |
|
Kenpachi
United States9908 Posts
Just a thought. | ||
jrkirby
United States1510 Posts
| ||
|
DarkPlasmaBall
United States45360 Posts
I can be spontaneous, but I'd rather have knowledge ahead of time. | ||
|
Jerubaal
United States7684 Posts
More on topic, what particular scenarios are you thinking of? In important discussions, I think it's important to go very slowly. | ||
|
Kenpachi
United States9908 Posts
On October 17 2013 11:38 jrkirby wrote: All of my piano playing is impromptu. I want to get to that level! Yeah, I guess it can also be argued that impromptu skills develop in a way if you prepare enough, right? Assuming you've practiced to be able to do that >> On October 17 2013 12:00 Jerubaal wrote: Once in a high school, I had to give a speech to be nominated for a state club office (HOSA, if you've heard of it). I was unopposed and it was a pretty Mickey Mouse scenario so I thought I'd give some bullshit speech modeled after Creon's first speech in Antigone (some crap about the ship of state). I didn't really prepare though and for my hubris I lost my train of thought and muttered 'oh shit' in front of about 60 other people. There were some titters but I wrapped it up and no one ever brought it up again. More on topic, what particular scenarios are you thinking of? In important discussions, I think it's important to go very slowly. The thought arose when I was thinking about how I have piss poor conversational skills sometimes. I just blabber something that implies other things (Freudian slips :x). | ||
|
jrkirby
United States1510 Posts
On October 17 2013 12:13 Kenpachi wrote: I want to get to that level! Yeah, I guess it can also be argued that impromptu skills develop in a way if you prepare enough, right? Assuming you've practiced to be able to do that >> Well, when I first started playing piano, I was forced to take lessons and read sheet music and all that. Then I stopped playing because I didn't enjoy it, and my parents would let me stop. After that I took a music theory course, and started to understand why songs were written the way they were with key sigatures and all that. I started playing a bit again, but this time instead of reading music I just sort of played whatever I felt like. After a while whatever I felt like playing started actually sounding pretty good. Now I play piano whenever I get the chance, and it's all entirely impromptu. | ||
|
13th Marine
United States344 Posts
| ||
|
hp.Shell
United States2527 Posts
Edit: I have bad conversational skills too, even to the point of unintended double entendres, that sometimes makes stuff with friends super awkward. Sometimes I don't even realize that there even was a double entendre in what I said until days later, so I can't imagine what other people are thinking when I say something like that. I have had people think I'm gay before, and that is probably the major reason. So I'm definitely trying to improve my conversation skills so that others don't get the wrong impression. I'd love to get to a conversational level where I was able to use double entendres with women, though.  | ||
|
doubleupgradeobbies!
Australia1220 Posts
Obviously, you can't prepare for every situation (probably not even most situations you expect to encounter in life), but when you are sufficiently prepared you almost invariably perform better than by improvising on the spot. You simply need to be able to do both. The good thing is, the ability to do things impromptu makes the process preparation/practice much easier and more effective, you able to arrive at the optimal way to do things more intuitively and faster, the rest is just practice to iron out the details. Preparation also helps you improvise, every decision, action, skill that you have prepared will be another tool in your arsenal for improvisation, something you can quickly integrate into your skillset because you have already trod down that path and worked at it. The general rule, for just about everything, but especially for important things is: be prepared whenever you can, but be prepared to have to perform impromptu where there is a preparation shortfalls (a shortfall which realistically will happen far more often than you being fully prepared for most things you do). | ||
|
BirdKiller
United States428 Posts
| ||
|
biology]major
United States2253 Posts
| ||
|
mizU
United States12125 Posts
You need the basic skills and knowledge down before you can start to improvise anything. But yes, non-rehearsed performances or presentations are the most genuine, but are normally backed by a ton of preparation. | ||
| ||
