|
United States1654 Posts
|
wow! still reading make more please
|
|
Maybe not the most productive feedback, but your characters tend to look incredibly flat. Your backgrounds and mostly everything else looks nice, the outlines are very well done, and the pictures you do shade seem fine.
Examples of what I mean are the full figure shot in page five and the last picture on page seven. I think part of the problem might be the contrast between rich background and low detail on the character. Ironically, the flatness would look better if the backgrounds weren't so beautifully done.
Also, Astrid and Valerie look maybe a bit too similar, but this might be hard to avoid with your realistic though not hyper-detailed style.
Sorry about focusing on where I think you could improve. Aside from what I mentioned, I feel it looks professional.
|
I like it, keep going.
|
Personally, I don't like reading this sort of style (I've grown up reading manga rather than American comics, so my taste is just different). That being said, I still do think that your artwork its self is awesome! Not being able to actually draw myself, I always feel so envious . Keep it up!
|
On June 13 2013 04:35 Darkwhite wrote: Maybe not the most productive feedback, but your characters tend to look incredibly flat. Your backgrounds and mostly everything else looks nice, the outlines are very well done, and the pictures you do shade seem fine.
Examples of what I mean are the full figure shot in page five and the last picture on page seven. I think part of the problem might be the contrast between rich background and low detail on the character. Ironically, the flatness would look better if the backgrounds weren't so beautifully done.
Also, Astrid and Valerie look maybe a bit too similar, but this might be hard to avoid with your realistic though not hyper-detailed style.
Sorry about focusing on where I think you could improve. Aside from what I mentioned, I feel it looks professional. darkwhite makes a good point, i believe you are focusing a lot more on design rather than form. that being said, your grasp on character design seems pretty advanced, so i would take some time looking into adding some volume and depth to your figures.
edit: really well done figure in page 2, panel 2 and page 12, panel 1. really nice sense of shape, weight, and scale. i'd really like to see you do more poses like that!
overall though, this is a really great comic!! i'm working on comics myself at the moment and it can be hard to appreciate just how much time and work goes into making them without trying it yourself, so i really admire your effort here. glad that you're enjoying yourself! keep it up! :D
|
Woot a comic with a promise of a good story!
|
Amazing work! I will definitely keep reading and if I someday have some funds I would gladly give you a little support in your efforts. Keep at it!
|
United States1654 Posts
Thanks for the comments guys!
@Darkwhite and megapants- I actually intended to make my characters look very simple and flat for time's sake, as I wanted to do a style that I could draw quickly and consistently- I normally don't draw like this. With the more complex backgrounds, I was hoping for a contrast that would make the simpler outlined characters stand out more, but I do see what you guys mean. Perhaps I'll tone the backgrounds down a bit next time. Thanks again!
|
Definitely enjoying these, especially now that the plot is clearer haha . Keep it up dude!
|
Damnit Sigrun this is good stuff, keep up the amazing work man.
|
Nice talent, hanging out for Part 3
|
great job, I love it, gotta read the first one now
|
United States1654 Posts
Thanks! I don't have an ETA on part 3 for the time being, but just a heads up- there will be a lot of talking.
|
|
|
|