EPTMy Top 10 RPG's of All Time - Page 4
| Blogs > zerglingsfolife |
|
Scooter
United States747 Posts
| ||
|
onewingedmoogle
Canada434 Posts
 nice list :D | ||
|
Caphe
Vietnam10817 Posts
On March 14 2010 19:15 Scooter wrote: I would've tried to fit Xenogears and Persona 3/4 in there somewhere, but good list! Loved Persona 3, havent played 4 yet but i will when i can manage my time | ||
|
RoyW
Ireland270 Posts
| ||
|
LoStYouRSkiLLS
Australia223 Posts
You should really try out FFX, absolutely brilliant game and by the looks of your list it fits your preferences perfectly. | ||
Boblion
France8043 Posts
On March 14 2010 15:47 zerglingsfolife wrote: I intentionally left out all western RPG's because they are so different from Japanese RPGs So why you didn't name your blog "Top 10 all time JRPG" ? That's like making a "Top 10 all time songs" with only K-Pop huhu | ||
|
SleepSheep
Canada344 Posts
On March 14 2010 18:42 {88}iNcontroL wrote: secret of mana tops my list personally FF3/6 is amazing though. So is chrono trigger. ya that game was amazing playing it with someone makes it even better | ||
|
zerglingsfolife
United States1694 Posts
On March 15 2010 00:21 Boblion wrote: So why you didn't name your blog "Top 10 all time JRPG" ? That's like making a "Top 10 all time songs" with only K-Pop huhu I realized it after I published it. Obviously if I made a list KOTOR1,maybe 2, Fallout1,2,3 Oblivion, Mass Effect1,2, Dragon Age, Baldurs Gate would probably be on there. I'd never even heard of the persona series before making this list, I'll have to try and check it out. I never personally liked SoM. I know a lot of people did, but I never got into it for some reason. I've never played Xenogears, but from peoples posts I'm going to try to get my hands on it. It sounds pretty good. | ||
Chill
Calgary25989 Posts
That being said, I gave Lost Odyssey 2 hours and then shut it down. Is it worth trying? | ||
|
zerglingsfolife
United States1694 Posts
On March 15 2010 04:35 Chill wrote: Wow your tastes seem to align with mine exactly. It's scary how similar they are actually... That being said, I gave Lost Odyssey 2 hours and then shut it down. Is it worth trying? Lost Odyssey is a very standard JRPG. I think it does get much better later into the game when it opens up. There is a world map/hidden cities and sidequests and stuff towards the end. Also a super hard dungeon at the end where battles are very hard. There is also somewhat of an arena. I liked the dreams aspect of it, some were pretty good. I also love any rpgs where you have to time buttons with attacks to do more damage because it keeps it interactive. Later in the game you can start customizing rings to start doing serious damage. I can't even remember the beginning of the game to be honest. I'd try it for a few more hours, and if you still don't like it then don't waste your time. | ||
|
yesplz
United States295 Posts
On March 14 2010 19:13 Lightswarm wrote: Any1 ever heard of Golden Sun? It's for gameboy but a sick RPG nonetheless Yea, golden sun 2 should definitely be on that list, it was an amazing game. | ||
|
fOrQQ
Hong Kong321 Posts
Definitely Golden Sun 1 or 2 is a good choice for the list as well :p | ||
|
Myrmidon
United States9452 Posts
On March 14 2010 15:08 SpiritoftheTunA wrote: Totally agree with Lufia 2. That game was fricken amazing.... the 100-level random dungeon with the slime at the end... revolutionary for its time, really (not that I played it during its time, I just assume it was revolutionary because it was fricken awesome). The Ancient Cave is pretty much a Roguelike, which is a really old genre of game. Granted, it's probably better (as a sidequest dungeon to Lufia 2) than most full standalone games of the genre. -_-;; Lufia 2's a really nice game on the whole though, other than being so easy--especially as soon as you get the second healing spell (Stronger). About the OP's list, I agree with most of the listings actually, if you're just counting traditional turn-based RPGs! But I think it's a little strange to list Terranigma, unless you're including strategy RPGs and action RPGs too (and then I think your list indicates that none of those subgenres make the top 10, which I would respectfully disagree with). The biggest difference with my list would be Breath of Fire 5, which I would put at the top. Also I'd probably have 3 and 4 somewhere in there as well, displacing things like Lost Odyssey and maybe FF7. Golden Sun games I liked to an extent, but their lack of difficulty both in fights and especially puzzles kind of put them out of top 10 contention IMHO. Also, I would consider some Grandia games and maybe Lunar games instead of maybe SMRPG and Earthbound, and some of the SNES FF games? No Dragon Quest love, I see. I guess most Western gamers including me haven't played enough of them. edit -- or SMT (and Persona) love. For a while, the only game in the series I had personally tried was Persona 1 on PSX, and I thought it was one of the most boring games I had played in years. I recently decided to give SMT: DS a try, and it's been good so far. Including action RPGs, I would also put a bunch of Tri-Ace games on the list. Most traditional RPGs are just not as deep strategically as good action RPGs, as you don't have to worry about positioning, avoiding damage rather than curing damage, time management, which character to control manually, offense/defense tradeoffs, etc. to the same extent. Bad action RPGs definitely degenerate into mindless button mashing though. Though Vagrant Story's battles are not that interesting, maybe it would deserve a mention too for story, presentation, and dungeon/puzzle design? Anyhow, these games are more similar to the other games you mentioned than Terranigma is. edit: About SOM1 and SOM2, I used to really recommend these as well. But upon some reflection, I think that my experience with them was good mostly because I was able to play them multiplayer. Movement and fighting is pretty simplistic, and having to go through the menu to cast spells (which is what mages should be doing all the time) slows down the pace a lot. Bosses are especially bland, since most of them just sit in the same place most of the time, whereupon you just keep mashing attacks at them. If you also included strategy RPGs, then that'd be a whole different story. I like Tactics Ogre and Ogre Battle (the first ones), as well as Langrisser 2 and 4, and maybe some Fire Emblems. Then, I'd have no idea where to order stuff. | ||
|
PhailSoBaller
United States281 Posts
Also I love Legend of the dragoon. I know alot of people think of it as bland. But i think that it is a wonderful game. And i saw someone bring up tactics ogre, if you bring up that can i bring up fire emblem? And last golden sun 3 is coming out sometime ORGASM | ||
|
Nytefish
United Kingdom4282 Posts
 Final Fantasy Tactics and Front Mission are much better than FF4/5 imo. | ||
|
MountainDewJunkie
United States10344 Posts
| ||
|
ironchef
Canada1350 Posts
 (minus lost oddysey only bc I havent played, so I cant claim its good) | ||
TheYango
United States47024 Posts
On March 15 2010 03:54 zerglingsfolife wrote: I realized it after I published it. Obviously if I made a list KOTOR1,maybe 2, Fallout1,2,3 Oblivion, Mass Effect1,2, Dragon Age, Baldurs Gate would probably be on there. I can't agree with any list that cuts Morrowind for Oblivion, Baldur's Gate II for any other Bioware game, and Planescape Torment for anything. | ||
|
Cloud
Sexico5880 Posts
| ||
|
eMbrace
United States1300 Posts
| ||
| ||
