[D] What makes for a good spectator eSport? - Page 2
| Forum Index > SC2 General |
|
graNite
Germany4434 Posts
| ||
|
MrInocence
United States172 Posts
On July 13 2013 22:19 Aelfric wrote: Suggesting impossible to happen changes is useless. Blizzard won't remove already established unit with a big impact in the game. They can only maybe change it or tone it down to create more space for new units in vol. Instead of removing the collosus, why not just make the collossus the micro robo unit? Maybe add an ability to aim and shoot reaver scarabs on command (fire a delayed missile attack to a small targeted area), but the scarabs also do friendly fire. Now for a really crazy idea- to discourage collossus deathballing, make the collosus hurt/kill any units it steps on top of. Imagine a collosus stomping zerglings and stalkers! | ||
|
Rassy
Netherlands2308 Posts
This for me is a strong point for sc, i was able to understand and enjoy the games from the first game i saw and before ever having played a game, this contrary to dota or lol games.I tried to watch them a few times and they did not make sense at all to me, i had no clue what was going on despite the commentators giving their comments. I think you need to have detailed knowledge of all the heros and their posibilities to follow and enjoy thoose games, this isnt needed for sc. | ||
|
Sapphire.lux
Romania2620 Posts
| ||
|
Big J
Austria16289 Posts
No viewer is interested in "good macro" and basically every proplayer has reasonable macro. What a good esports RTS game needs instead is a thousand different tricks/opportunities to control units differently. So that while marineking splits incredibly well, Mvp instead prefers perfect focus fire against banelings, while MMA is a show off who always let's his units jump over them in the last second. Meanwhile, Life just sidesteps every shot, Leenock burrows under every shot, and Jaedongs banelings are somehow always faster. ![]() And of course: Hellbats! | ||
|
YyapSsap
New Zealand1511 Posts
On July 13 2013 22:11 MrInocence wrote: Blizzard probably won't remove the boring units, even though it would be much better for the game. Another interesting point is that one-dimensional use is very boring-- reapers harass/suicide scout, oracles earlygame harass, and do basically nothing else. Changing unit pathing could be VERY interesting. This would make fights based more on positioning than unit comp. SPEAKING OF UNIT COMP, making the right mix of units was more important than any micro in WoL, a BIG pitfall in game design for WoL. The bolded bit... is one of the worst moves blizzard has done. Unit composition being far too important due to their countering system makes this game so one dimensional at times. Thinking about it, having units with projectile based animations (thats somewhat at a moderate speed) would be more interesting (so you could try to dodge the attack by dropping/boarding etc and more pleasing to the eye). You know what! they need to bring the move and shoot mechanic. I always thought clumped up wraiths single shot-ing enemy units was cool. Makes air to air battles more interesting instead of the 1a into 1a. | ||
|
laegoose
Russian Federation325 Posts
Oh I'm in Internet argument again. | ||
|
algue
France1436 Posts
| ||
|
mostevil
United Kingdom611 Posts
On July 13 2013 22:00 YyapSsap wrote: We need several things that would really entertain spectators and make this game much more deep than it its current form. 1) Need to do something to boring units either by changing its functions and/or look e.g. colossus/corrupters. Even if they have a single one dimensional purpose in the game, at least make the graphical animations look more pleasing to the eye.. like what if corrupters had a 3D attack animation similiar to the BW devourer? 2) Bring back the high ground mechanic. This way we can actually see positioning taken to a new level (now its about securing bases for economy AND high ground so that you dont get cut off or suffocated) instead of the old "dancing" with the opponent til you get the right concave.. This could potentially break up the deathball and lead to more multi engagements through the game which is WAY more exciting to watch. It really shows who the better player is. 3) Need to do something to the economy. Too many workers = less units in the field, too many workers = worker harasses are much more impactful, too many workers = no need for going above 3 bases.. There needs to be an incentive to get more bases or you simply lose out and on top of that this game emphasizes way too much on worker harass. This emphasis needs to be spread around so that its just not about killing workers to win. 4) This game needs more zone control/positional units and no more harass/offensive units. Creates more interesting engagements than the basic flanks and better concaves. And a careful use of these units along with high ground could lay steps of comeback games.. 5) Even if blizzard who "apparently" tested the unit spacing so that you don't literally blob up.. should implement it because it simply looks much more natural. Why not just add it if doesn't add to the gameplay but it does so visually i.e. better for the spectators? 6) Bring back some of the hard but high reward mechanics. E.g. removing smart cast on offensive AOE spells while buffing those spells. Bring back the holy shit storm moments when the progamer literally pulls off something thats insanely hard to do (like clicking on individual HTs to cast storms off during a battle). HOTS compared to WoL was a huge improvement but... the devs aren't willing to admit and tackle the real problems which I see no problems in why they shouldn't. Everyone wants the game to be deep (hence why theres so many excellent TL articles/posts done by users who go the extra mile and explain/analyse all the gameplay issues in SC2) and surpass BW yet they refuse to come down from that really high horse of theres... Tempted to agree with much of this but its effectively a completely different game you're asking for. I'm especially coming around on high ground, all it does is requires vision, which isn't hard to get in SC2, concaves and flanks are tactically a little too simplistic too keep it interesting. At the minute ramps are almost more useful as chokes than because of a high/low ground factor. I agree on the workers, it takes too many workers give saturation which means you never need to defend more than 3 bases at any one time, reducing harrasment potential. Lots of interesting possibilities are shut down by this. This like a lot of the bad design calls harks back to the initial WoL dev teams idea to keep the maps small for people who like rush play..... Thankfully the games grown out of that. Smart cast I don't think is the devil its made out to be, I think its part of the bring back unit selection limits crazyness. A lot of what you want in terms of micro needs the game to be played at a lower speed than it is (which I'd be fine with), A big part of the dullness of the deathball clashes aside from the ugly clumping is that even for the top pro's, battles are over too quickly, there's not enough time to properly micro a big army on faster speed. | ||
|
NEEDZMOAR
Sweden1277 Posts
A lot of multitasking, definitely not micro, micro makes the game boring (my opinion). diversity, players hitting certain timings and casters pointing out those timings. Different units used rather than hellbats and tanks in mech or MMMM in every matchup. | ||
|
imperator-xy
Germany1377 Posts
clicking a button to make your ships move faster isnt hard to master. using the engine to make your flying units stack and then letting them attack and retreat and attack and retreat while managing your awfully hard macro is. | ||
|
MrInocence
United States172 Posts
On July 13 2013 23:26 NEEDZMOAR wrote: more grand strategical moves such as defense lines in mech with PFs Turrets and whatnot or aggresive ways to zone out a player (tanks outside a base or Swarmhosts poking while the other player is trying to break through with drops or WP) casters that highlight the strategic mind and the plan a player is working from. A lot of multitasking, definitely not micro, micro makes the game boring (my opinion). diversity, players hitting certain timings and casters pointing out those timings. Different units used rather than hellbats and tanks in mech or MMMM in every matchup. Micro makes the game boring?? Wow, the reason why I started playing SC in the first place was because I watched a BW PvP goon shuttle reaver battle, and the positioning and kiting was so cool haha | ||
|
Big J
Austria16289 Posts
On July 13 2013 23:36 MrInocence wrote: Micro makes the game boring?? Wow, the reason why I started playing SC in the first place was because I watched a BW PvP goon shuttle reaver battle, and the positioning and kiting was so cool haha I disagree with his point that micro is a problem, but I can where he is coming from. There is nothing special in seeing (most) micromoves, as they are repetetive and always the same. Meanwhile, when you watch sports, there is always something different. I think that's where micro has to go. Instead of against banelings --> split against tanks --> targetfire against zealots --> kite stuff, that gets figured out fast and then is just always the same, just with tiny differences in execution. Then you look at football and watch Messi and it's like against a single opponent in a certain situation --> pass or outrun or trick1 or trick3 or trick7 against two opponents in a certain situation --> pass or outrun or trick2 or trick3 ... You always find yourself questioning "what does player X do next and how will his opponent react?" - in microterms! Right now we only have this interaction in strategy and even there it is very set, though I believe this is more of a balancing problem (not enough viable strategies). It makes the games less predictable and introduces more uncertainity for the viewer in any situation (while not being random!). And most of all, it introduces style. Messi and Ronaldo and Neymar are all different players that play differently but all of them are successful if they play their unique style right. On the flipside, a Protoss that does not blink properly will not be successful, not matter what he does with his attention instead. But I believe such a game would have to be built completely differently. With less macrorequirements (more time to use your micropotential, less fatality from making mistakes at home) and less unittypes (every unit in itself should have interesting relations with every other unit) | ||
|
MrInocence
United States172 Posts
On July 13 2013 23:47 Big J wrote: I disagree with his point that micro is a problem, but I can where he is coming from. There is nothing special in seeing (most) micromoves, as they are repetetive and always the same. Meanwhile, when you watch sports, there is always something different. I think that's where micro has to go. Instead of against banelings --> split against tanks --> targetfire against zealots --> kite stuff, that gets figured out fast and then is just always the same, just with tiny differences in execution. Then you look at football and watch Messi and it's like against a single opponent in a certain situation --> pass or outrun or trick1 or trick3 or trick7 against two opponents in a certain situation --> pass or outrun or trick2 or trick3 ... You always find yourself questioning "what does player X do next and how will his opponent react?" - in microterms! Right now we only have this interaction in strategy and even there it is very set, though I believe this is more of a balancing problem (not enough viable strategies). It makes the games less predictable and introduces more uncertainity for the viewer in any situation (while not being random!). And most of all, it introduces style. Messi and Ronaldo and Neymar are all different players that play differently but all of them are successful if they play their unique style right. On the flipside, a Protoss that does not blink properly will not be successful, not matter what he does with his attention instead. But I believe such a game would have to be built completely differently. With less macrorequirements (more time to use your micropotential, less fatality from making mistakes at home) and less unittypes (every unit in itself should have interesting relations with every other unit) Rather than "micro/micromoves" as in splitting and blinking per se, I'm referring to "positioning"-- AoE, flanks, making and breaking soft-contains, splitting up your army. Basically any micro that requires decision making, not just mechanics. This is especially apparent in TvT, much less so in the other mirror matchups. For example, ZvZ is mostly a brute force fest than a positional war. | ||
|
goody153
44313 Posts
On July 13 2013 22:00 YyapSsap wrote: We need several things that would really entertain spectators and make this game much more deep than it its current form. 1) Need to do something to boring units either by changing its functions and/or look e.g. colossus/corrupters. Even if they have a single one dimensional purpose in the game, at least make the graphical animations look more pleasing to the eye.. like what if corrupters had a 3D attack animation similiar to the BW devourer? 2) Bring back the high ground mechanic. This way we can actually see positioning taken to a new level (now its about securing bases for economy AND high ground so that you dont get cut off or suffocated) instead of the old "dancing" with the opponent til you get the right concave.. This could potentially break up the deathball and lead to more multi engagements through the game which is WAY more exciting to watch. It really shows who the better player is. 3) Need to do something to the economy. Too many workers = less units in the field, too many workers = worker harasses are much more impactful, too many workers = no need for going above 3 bases.. There needs to be an incentive to get more bases or you simply lose out and on top of that this game emphasizes way too much on worker harass. This emphasis needs to be spread around so that its just not about killing workers to win. 4) This game needs more zone control/positional units and no more harass/offensive units. Creates more interesting engagements than the basic flanks and better concaves. And a careful use of these units along with high ground could lay steps of comeback games.. 5) Even if blizzard who "apparently" tested the unit spacing so that you don't literally blob up.. should implement it because it simply looks much more natural. Why not just add it if doesn't add to the gameplay but it does so visually i.e. better for the spectators? 6) Bring back some of the hard but high reward mechanics. E.g. removing smart cast on offensive AOE spells while buffing those spells. Bring back the holy shit storm moments when the progamer literally pulls off something thats insanely hard to do (like clicking on individual HTs to cast storms off during a battle). HOTS compared to WoL was a huge improvement but... the devs aren't willing to admit and tackle the real problems which I see no problems in why they shouldn't. Everyone wants the game to be deep (hence why theres so many excellent TL articles/posts done by users who go the extra mile and explain/analyse all the gameplay issues in SC2) and surpass BW yet they refuse to come down from that really high horse of theres... i agree on 1,4 ! #1 it could be possible to make the boring one dimensional units more microable , more micro means more entertainment .right? #4 many players will most likely scream .. IMBA IMBA .. with the more space control .. but space control sort of forces tactics and draws line between players who are good and bad making the game a little harder would not hurt at all just not making it imbalanced of course | ||
|
goody153
44313 Posts
On July 14 2013 00:03 MrInocence wrote: Rather than "micro/micromoves" as in splitting and blinking per se, I'm referring to "positioning"-- AoE, flanks, making and breaking soft-contains, splitting up your army. Basically any micro that requires decision making, not just mechanics. This is especially apparent in TvT, much less so in the other mirror matchups. For example, ZvZ is mostly a brute force fest than a positional war. the positional wars is very minimal in sc2 and it should be as viable as microwars .. but micro wars is also very entertaining to watch .. like zvz lingblingwars(only) its fun to watch probably not play it if sc2 could make positionalwars as viable as the microwars then it would be good change | ||
|
Coffeeling
Finland250 Posts
On July 13 2013 22:34 Rassy wrote: More micro doesnt neccesarely make the game more entertaining to watch i think,and to much micro might work confusing.Casual people and gamers should be able to follow what is going on. This for me is a strong point for sc, i was able to understand and enjoy the games from the first game i saw and before ever having played a game, this contrary to dota or lol games.I tried to watch them a few times and they did not make sense at all to me, i had no clue what was going on despite the commentators giving their comments. I think you need to have detailed knowledge of all the heros and their posibilities to follow and enjoy thoose games, this isnt needed for sc. This is a very important point. Lotsa spellcasting mayhem is good, and has it's place, but that place is in a MOBA or such, not an RTS. Spells ought to be simple, relatively few and define playstyles. Mostly the first two though. The more activated abilities and such you add, the more opaque the game becomes. See a screenshot of Starcraft, you know what is a good idea. See one of LoL, no chance in Hell. Furthermore, more micro won't, at some point, make the game more impressive anymore (Then again, some people do enjoy watching other people run). Furthermore, this game is too damn fast and high DPS already, it's often optimal to just leave things up to the AI or you lose too much DPS. This explosiveness also helps the game become even more coinflippy and BO-based. Most of what YyapSsap wrote on Page 1 is spot on. I don't agree with making stuff more difficult to do just because, but the rest is great. The most important ones being high ground advantage and fixing the economy. Right now, SC2 for the most part lacks the natural counter to few-base turtling, namely expand-to-all-the-places Sauron play. It can be simulated via unit and faction design quirks, but on a strategic, mechanic level the natural counter isn't there. Smaller average army sizes (probably partially via lowered supply costs, but also just slower economy) and some saturation dynamics fixes would restore this capability. Besides, don't we all want tons of Marines/Lings in the meat grinder? Because I sure do. The lack of high ground advantage makes chokes and whatever sort of vision barriers basically the only meaningful parts of terrain. A base isn't safer on a hill, it needs a choke. Hello, sentrybombing. Just having a high ground mechanic would do wonders for the game. I can't help but agree with the plea for better zoning units.Things like tanks help claim territory and also cause actual commitment to positions. Mind you, when I say zoning, I mean proper zoning. This means stuff that makes other stuff go boom, not stupid gimps like Fungal, let alone the instant map editor that is Forcefield. I can't imagine anything more heinously anti-fundamentals than literally crafting a position to suddenly be good for you. Storms and Tank deployments are the good stuff. They say "I dare you" and leave the judgment to the opponent. Actually we just need more things that move and make stuff go boom. The less a unit is pigeonholed by weird abilities like Entomb, the more likely it can be used creatively. As an example, say, Hellions/Banshees/Mutas as army units when their main role is harassment. (Also kill Warpgates plz. I forgot they were also heinously anti-fundamentals and screw with a crapton of the fundamental assumptions of the genre) | ||
|
Arceus
Vietnam8333 Posts
On July 13 2013 22:00 YyapSsap wrote: + Show Spoiler + We need several things that would really entertain spectators and make this game much more deep than it its current form. 1) Need to do something to boring units either by changing its functions and/or look e.g. colossus/corrupters. Even if they have a single one dimensional purpose in the game, at least make the graphical animations look more pleasing to the eye.. like what if corrupters had a 3D attack animation similiar to the BW devourer? 2) Bring back the high ground mechanic. This way we can actually see positioning taken to a new level (now its about securing bases for economy AND high ground so that you dont get cut off or suffocated) instead of the old "dancing" with the opponent til you get the right concave.. This could potentially break up the deathball and lead to more multi engagements through the game which is WAY more exciting to watch. It really shows who the better player is. 3) Need to do something to the economy. Too many workers = less units in the field, too many workers = worker harasses are much more impactful, too many workers = no need for going above 3 bases.. There needs to be an incentive to get more bases or you simply lose out and on top of that this game emphasizes way too much on worker harass. This emphasis needs to be spread around so that its just not about killing workers to win. 4) This game needs more zone control/positional units and no more harass/offensive units. Creates more interesting engagements than the basic flanks and better concaves. And a careful use of these units along with high ground could lay steps of comeback games.. 5) Even if blizzard who "apparently" tested the unit spacing so that you don't literally blob up.. should implement it because it simply looks much more natural. Why not just add it if doesn't add to the gameplay but it does so visually i.e. better for the spectators? 6) Bring back some of the hard but high reward mechanics. E.g. removing smart cast on offensive AOE spells while buffing those spells. Bring back the holy shit storm moments when the progamer literally pulls off something thats insanely hard to do (like clicking on individual HTs to cast storms off during a battle). HOTS compared to WoL was a huge improvement but... the devs aren't willing to admit and tackle the real problems which I see no problems in why they shouldn't. Everyone wants the game to be deep (hence why theres so many excellent TL articles/posts done by users who go the extra mile and explain/analyse all the gameplay issues in SC2) and surpass BW yet they refuse to come down from that really high horse of theres... sadly I dont think Blizz would ever try even one of your suggestions. Why? They just wont admit design failure in sc2 not like no one has ever spoken about these for years | ||
|
TRaFFiC
Canada1448 Posts
Also, many things which make sc2 fun for a spectator are not fun for the player such as coin flip build orders in the meta game. | ||
|
aka_star
United Kingdom1546 Posts
I for one didn't buy HotS because I thought it was an overpriced DLC with too similar units (burrowed brood lord, burrowed tank) the viper alone wasn't going to cut it for me. HotS never addressed the unit clumping which was a huge deal breaker mix that in with more fuking protoss laser and I feel less interested in spectating the blobs smash into one another these days. The game is missing some strategic elements that BW had due to the rewards for macro play and splash damage is highly reward. | ||
| ||
